Brendan Rodgers is in big league camp with the Red Sox this spring, hoping to win a spot in Boston’s infield alongside former Rockies teammate Trevor Story. A right shoulder injury suffered in late February put any such hopes on hold, and the latest update from skipper Alex Cora may have dashed them entirely. Via the Boston Herald’s Mac Cerullo, Cora said Tuesday that Rodgers is “most likely” going to require shoulder surgery. Rodgers already underwent a CT scan and MRI on his shoulder, and Cora has previously stated that the results from those tests “didn’t look great.” Rodgers is headed for another opinion from renowned surgeon Dr. Neal ElAttrache to confirm his outlook.
The injury occurred early in camp. Playing second base, Rodgers dove to his left for a hard line drive off the bat of Twins shortstop Brooks Lee (video link via MLB.com). He briefly snow-coned the liner, but the ball popped out of his glove upon a hard impact with the ground. Rodgers was in clear, immediate pain and left the field with the Red Sox training staff.
Rodgers, 29, has already undergone one surgery on each of his shoulders. He suffered a torn labrum during his rookie season back in 2019 and underwent surgery that July. In 2023, he suffered what was originally termed a dislocated left shoulder during spring training. Additional testing revealed some tearing in his left shoulder’s labrum, requiring surgery, though Rodgers was able to make it back to the field for the final couple months of that season.
Formerly the No. 3 overall pick in the draft and a consensus top prospect, Rodgers’ career hasn’t played out as hoped. He’s a lifetime .261/.313/.401 hitter and has only thrice played 100 games in a season. He’s never topped 137 games played or 581 plate appearances and only has two big league seasons with 500-plus trips to the plate. After spending the 2019-24 seasons in Denver, Rodgers signed with Houston on a minor league pact last winter and made the roster. However, he went on to bat just .191/.266/.278 (55 wRC+) in 128 plate appearances as an Astro.
The infield mix in Boston is relatively unsettled. The Sox traded Rafael Devers to the Giants last June and watched Alex Bregman sign with the Cubs in free agency. They’ve traded for the Cardinals Willson Contreras and the Brewers’ Caleb Durbin this winter. Contreras slots in at first base, while Durbin will fill either second base or third base alongside the aforementioned Story.
Top prospect Marcelo Mayer is the favorite to hold down whichever spot isn’t occupied by Durbin, but the Red Sox also have Andruw Monasterio (acquired alongside Durbin), Isiah Kiner-Falefa (signed in free agency), Tsung-Che Cheng (claimed off waivers) and holdovers Nick Sogard and Nate Eaton on the 40-man roster. Former top prospect Kristian Campbell, who signed an eight-year extension early last year, is being viewed primarily as an outfielder moving forward.
That stinks for both him and the Sox.
Given the situation, it sucks worse for Rodgers. There was a possible path to the roster with Romy out but i feel like that just cleared a path for Eaton to make the team as a backup IF/OF option
Eaton, Sogard, maybe even Romero – although he is having back issues or something. Plenty of JAG utility guys.
Rsox – I don’t see the path to which you’re referring.
Unless someone gets released or traded, they have 4 healthy infielders ahead of him for 6 spots.
Durbin
Story
IKF
Contreras
I think Monasterio, Mayer, and Eaton would have had a better shot at the two spots than Rodgers.
You don’t have to squint to see Mayer falling into a career arc like Rodgers though…
Im hoping the 2026 will be his first complete season playing in pro ball not ending on the IL list.
GaSox – He reminds me of another young shortstop from California who averaged only 94 games with the Sox because he couldn’t stay healthy …. Glenn Hoffman was his name.
Fever, and here i thought you were going to think of Alberto Mondesi.
That would be combining layers ceiling defensively with his health floor.
Really theres a lot of various comps. Just keeping Mayer healthy and off the IL will be a huge positive.
GaSox – Well let’s hope Duran is okay after that nasty brawl tonight with Canada.
Romero is healthy as far as I know.
Never like to read shoulders. Bad news them.
Thx Yoda, but I do agree shoulder injuries are the worst.
The one stolen base in 24 looks impressive on his resume. That’s a shame 🤣
he negated it the following season.
Yuck. That infield is awful
Deke – 26th best infield in MLB!
Needless to say, their outfield and pitching staff is their strength.
Your takes are awful.
Rogers is basically roster filler at this point. This injury has just blown his last chance to see more of the field for a team. IF he ain’t DFA’d and comes back after injury to BOS I will be surprised.
Yesterday per Ian Cundall on X:
Red Sox OF Justin Gonzales lined a 117.3 mph exit velocity single in today’s game Toronto. His max exit velocity in 2025 was 113.1 mph.
His single today was the 5th hardest batted ball by a Red Sox batter ever recorded by statcast, spring, reg season, or postseason.
x.com/IanCundall/status/2028590770874183797?ref_sr…
He is here on a minor league deal isn’t he? I hope the surgery goes well. Good luck wherever you land. After 3 shoulder surgeries it might be time to hang up your cleats.
Not if you’re still getting paid to play baseball.
He’s on a minor league deal so the pay is not great and the last few years his job has been rehab.