The Major League Baseball Players Association has announced that Bruce Meyer has been unanimously elected the interim executive director of the union. Previously the deputy director, Meyer will take over for Tony Clark, who surprisingly resigned yesterday as news emerged that he had an “inappropriate” relationship with his sister-in-law, who was working for the MLBPA. Matt Nussbaum is now the interim deputy director. Jeff Passan of ESPN reported Meyer’s election prior to the official announcement.
Meyer will continue to act as the MLBPA’s chief negotiator through the upcoming collective bargaining agreement talks, with the current CBA set to expire December 1st. Another lockout is widely expected and the last one dragged into March, so it seems Meyer is positioned to potentially lead the union for a year or more, despite the interim tag.
Ever since the Clark scandal emerged yesterday, it seemed likely that the union would pivot to Meyer. He has been the MLBPA’s clear #2 and top negotiator for years. With the season about to begin and the big CBA deadline less than a year away, maintaining stability seemed like an easier path than undergoing a lengthy search for a replacement. Left-hander Brent Suter, a member of the union’s eight-player executive subcommittee, framed it that way yesterday. “We’re going to have an interim [director] and keep everything as stable as we can this year,” Suter said.
Clark took over the job in December of 2013 after the death of Michael Weiner. Clark was the first former player to hold the job, as the previous executive directors had been career union officials or attorneys.
The 2017-2021 CBA, the first under Clark, was generally viewed as poor for the players. The base threshold of the competitive balance tax barely moved, going from $189MM in 2016 to $195MM in 2017. That number would creep up over the course of the CBA but two extra tiers of increased taxation were added at $20MM increments above the base threshold. The 2016 minimum salary of $507.5K nudged up to $535K in 2017.
Meyer was hired in 2018 to serve as the union’s lead negotiator, with Clark staying on as executive director. At that time, Meyer had three decades of experience working with the player unions of the NBA, NHL and NFL. The next round of MLB CBA negotiations proved to be more contentious. The league instituted a lockout in December of 2021, the first work stoppage since the 1994-95 strike. That lockout lasted 99 days and was resolved in March, just in time to still play a 162-game schedule in 2022.
That CBA was viewed by some as better than the previous agreement. The base CBT threshold jumped from $210MM in 2021 to $230MM in 2022, though a fourth tier of the tax was added, another $20MM over the previous high. The minimum salary went from $555K in 2021 to $700K in 2022, with $20K increases in each year. It also added a new feature, a $50MM bonus pool paid for by all teams and to be distributed annually to pre-arbitration players based upon a version of wins above replacement agreed upon by both MLB and the MLBPA.
The agreement didn’t lead to perfect harmony within the union, however. In March of 2024, an attempt was made to replace Meyer, an event often referred to as an attempted coup. Some players tried to pressure Clark to replace Meyer with Harry Marino. The latter was previously the head of Advocates For Minor Leaguers and helped unionize minor leaguers under the MLBPA umbrella. A minor league CBA was negotiated with the league in 2023. Meyer and Marino both worked for the MLBPA at that time and reportedly had a strained relationship.
The attempted coup eventually flamed out, with Clark and Meyer staying in their positions. The players reportedly connected to the coup were voted off the executive subcommittee in December of 2024.
More trouble emerged this year with Clark coming under the microscope of federal investigations that alleged he had given himself equity in organizations funded by MLBPA licensing money. The union hired a law firm to conduct an internal investigation in response to those allegations. That internal probe reportedly uncovered messages between Clark and his sister-in-law, which led the union to seek his resignation.
Meyer will now take the reins and try to keep the players united at a significant time. Financial imbalances in the game have led to owners and many fans calling for the league to implement a salary cap. The union has long been opposed to such a measure, with Clark and Meyer both frequently speaking out against it. As mentioned, the CBA expires December 1st and another is widely expected. MLB commissioner Rob Manfred spoke positively about the effect of lockouts about this time last year.
With the interim tag on Meyer, it’s unknown how things will proceed after the upcoming CBA negotiations. Presumably, his interest in staying in the job more permanently will depend upon how things develop in the coming year, as would the players’ interest in keeping him in the gig.
Nussbaum has worked for the MLBPA since 2011. He was promoted to deputy general counsel in 2017 and then general counsel in 2023. Prior to joining the MLBPA, he had worked for the NHLPA.
Photo courtesy of Greg Lovett, Imagn Images
