Headlines

  • Orioles To Decline Five-Year Lease Extension At Camden Yards, Seeking Longer-Term Agreement With Maryland Stadium Authority
  • Blue Jays Sign Chad Green
  • Rays Extend Yandy Diaz
  • Dexter Fowler Announces Retirement
  • Mets Sign Jeff McNeil To Four-Year Extension
  • Red Sox, Marlins Swap Matt Barnes For Richard Bleier
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2022-23 MLB Free Agent List
    • Top 50 Free Agents
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2023
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Arbitration Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Mariners Acquire Mark Trumbo In Six-Player Deal

By Steve Adams | June 3, 2015 at 6:34pm CDT

With an offense that is again struggling to score runs in Seattle and a logjam of corner outfield types in Arizona, the Diamondbacks and Mariners have agreed to a rare, significant early-June trade that will send Mark Trumbo from Arizona to Seattle, the teams announced. Left-hander Vidal Nuno is also heading to the Mariners, who will send catcher Welington Castillo, right-hander Dominic Leone and prospects Gabby Guerrero and Jack Reinheimer to the D-Backs.

Mark  Trumbo

From the Mariners’ perspective, Trumbo will add significant power to a lineup that has struggled to score runs, as they rank 28th in the Majors with 191 runs. However, Seattle has thrived as a collective unit against left-handed pitching, which is where Trumbo does most of his damage. The 29-year-old is a lifetime .263/.311/.528 hitter against southpaws but owns a more pedestrian .242/.293/.444 line against same-handed pitching. Despite questionable OBP skills and his so-so numbers against right-handed pitching, Trumbo does figure to make the Mariners’ offense more formidable, though it may come at the cost of some defensive value. The acquisition of Trumbo also forces the team to either displace Logan Morrison at first base or utilize one of Trumbo or Nelson Cruz in the corner outfield, where both are regarded as defensive liabilities. Trumbo, who is earning $6.9MM in 2015 and is under team control through 2016 via the arbitration process.

Looking at the trade from Arizona’s perspective, it’s not difficult to see why the team felt the need to move Trumbo. The signing of Yasmany Tomas this offseason gave them a pair of slow-footed corner outfielders whose most appealing asset was right-handed pop. The D-Backs have been playing Tomas at third base while highly regarded prospect Jake Lamb is on the disabled list, but Lamb is nearing a return, and Tomas’ defensive work in the infield has not been particularly strong. With this move, Tomas can shift to right field in Trumbo’s place, joining A.J. Pollock and a combination of Ender Inciarte and David Peralta in the outfield. The move also saves the D-Backs some significant money; Trumbo is owed $4.68MM for the remainder of the 2015 season, compared to Castillo’s $1.43MM, making for a total savings of about $3.25MM.

Nuno has been told that he will be joining the Mariners’ rotation, the lefty himself told reporters, including MLB.com’s Steve Gilbert (Twitter link). The 27-year-old has struggled throughout his brief MLB career as a starter, but he’s pitched quite well in a long relief capacity for Arizona this season, posting a 1.88 ERA with a 19-to-5 K/BB ratio in 14 1/3 innings. Of course, that small sample consists of just three appearances, and Nuno’s larger body of work is relatively suspect. He’s tallied 196 innings at the Major League level between the Yankees and Diamondbacks, posting a 4.13 ERA with 7.2 K/9, 2.6 BB/9 and a 38.1 percent ground-ball rate.

As a fly-ball pitcher, his first stint in an expansive, pitcher-friendly environment figures to benefit Nuno, but his peripheral profile doesn’t exactly indicate that he’s been the recipient of much poor luck. Metrics such as FIP (4.36), xFIP (4.15) and SIERA (3.97) all feel that Nuno’s ERA are more or less reflective of his talent level. The Mariners will hope that he can produce improved results in a more favorable setting, however, and if not, he seems like he could at least be a useful bullpen piece. Nuno has stifled opposing lefties to this point in his career, yielding just .191/.271/.317 batting line in 190 plate appearances. The Mariners will be able to control him through the 2019 season.

Castillo is the most established player headed back to Arizona in the trade, and he will pair with Jarrod Saltalamacchia behind the dish to form the D-Backs’ new catching tandem. That’s a far more established duo than Tuffy Gosewisch and Jordan Pacheco, who have handled the bulk of Arizona’s catching duties this season. Arizona GM Dave Stewart stated on multiple occasions this offseason that he had no intent of adding a catcher, and he held to his word through Opening Day, but he’s since seen Gosewisch go down for the year due to a torn ACL, while a back injury has ended veteran Gerald Laird’s season. Rule 5 pickup Oscar Hernandez is on the shelf as well, creating an even larger dearth of catching options for the Diamondbacks.

Arizona values prospect Peter O’Brien’s bat quite a bit, but scouts have long questioned whether or not he can handle catching from a defensive standpoint. Late in Spring Training, those questions became even more pronounced when O’Brien developed an issue throwing the ball back to the mound. He’s seen more time in the corner outfield this season at Triple-A than he has behind the plate.

Therefore, Castillo and Saltalamacchia give the Diamondbacks a more experienced tandem without forcing them to try O’Brien at catcher before he is ready (if he ever is). Castillo is a career .250/.316/.392 hitter that posted a combined 105 OPS+ from 2012-13 before taking a step back in 2014. All told, his bat has been about five percent below the league average over the course of his career, which is solid offensive output from a catcher. Castillo has also caught an above-average 30 percent of attempted base stealers in his career, though like Saltalamacchia, he does not grade out well in terms of pitch-framing metrics. Castillo is under team control through the 2017 season.

In Leone, the Diamondbacks will acquire a 23-year-old reliever who was dominant in his 2014 rookie campaign but has struggled to repeat that success. Leone emerged from out of nowhere in 2014 to post a 2.17 ERA with 9.5 K/9, 3.4 BB/9 and a 54.7 percent ground-ball rate in 66 1/3 innings for the Mariners. Both FIP and xFIP pegged him at 3.07, while SIERA was more bullish at 2.81. Entering the 2015 season, Leone looked like a potential long-term bullpen cog. However, he’s seen his control erode dramatically, issuing nine walks in 11 1/3 innings against just seven strikeouts. The 94.6 mph he averaged on his heater in 2014 has dropped to 93.3 mph, leading to further cause for concern. His ERA to this point is a sky-high 6.35, while ERA estimators peg him for a mark in the 5.40 to 5.80 range. Put simply, Leone is a reclamation project for the Diamondbacks, but if he can return to anything close to his 2014 output, he’d be one of the most effective pieces in Arizona’s relief corps, if not the most effective piece.

Guerrero, 21, is the best prospect in the deal, despite a rough year at Double-A so far (.215/.262/.305). The nephew of famed slugger Vladimir Guerrero, Gabby has ranked among the Mariners’ Top 15 prospects in each of the past three offseasons, topping out at seventh this past winter. In their most recent scouting report, BA noted that Guerrero has plus-plus raw power, a plus-plus arm in right field (sound familiar?) and plus range as well, but he’s overly aggressive at the plate and swings too hard too often. Guerrero has baseball in his genes and is a high-risk, high-reward type of prospect; BA and other outlets such as MLB.com (where he ranks fifth among Mariners prospects) and Fangraphs (eighth) all feel that he could ultimately be an everyday right fielder, but the likelihood isn’t great without adjustments to his approach.

The 22-year-old Reinheimer reached Double-A for the first time this season and has slashed .277/.323/.351 thus far. Ranked as Seattle’s No. 17 prospect by BA, he also ranks 19th per Fangraphs and 14th per MLB.com. Jonathan Mayo and Jim Callis at MLB.com call Reinheimer a singles hitter at the moment, noting that he has above-average speed and the range/arm to handle shortstop defensively. Kiley McDaniel of Fangraphs agrees for the most part and comps him to Mariners shortstop Chris Taylor, noting that there’s very little power and a utility player might be the ultimate outcome.

Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports first reported that Trumbo and Nuno had been traded to Seattle in exchange for Castillo, Leone and two prospects (Twitter links). 

Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.

Share 199 Retweet 189 Send via email0

Arizona Diamondbacks Newsstand Seattle Mariners Transactions Dominic Leone Gabby Guerrero Jack Reinheimer Mark Trumbo Vidal Nuno Welington Castillo

Reds Release Donald Lutz
Main
AL East Notes: De Aza, Tanaka, Schultz, Rays
View Comments (184)

Comments

  1. CT Cubs Fan

    8 years ago

    AZ must of been blown away with the M’s offer. Didn’t the GM just say they weren’t looking to trade him? Possibly Walker to AZ?

    Reply
    • James Attwood

      8 years ago

      Walker would be criminal overpay. I’ll take it!

      Reply
      • CT Cubs Fan

        8 years ago

        Never know. Doubtful, but I can’t think of who else they’d get back.

        Reply
        • James Attwood

          8 years ago

          If it is anyone from the organization top-15, I would be somewhat surprised, though Hultzen fits exactly the risk/reward profile Stewart has been targeting. I still think Hultzen is probably considered too much though.

    • Fred

      8 years ago

      Dude…

      Reply
    • Paul Michaels

      8 years ago

      If the Dbacks got Walker for Trumbo, someone needs to call the police cause the Mariners got robbed.

      Reply
      • Patrick Simcock

        8 years ago

        Where does it say that?

        Reply
        • Paul Michaels

          8 years ago

          Read said comment that my comment was aimed at.

    • pete peterson

      8 years ago

      From MLBTR, June 1: For his latest notes column, Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports spoke with Diamondbacks GM Dave Stewart about the possibility of trading Mark Trumbo this summer — a notion which Stewart seems to strongly oppose. “We know there’s interest in Trumbo,” said Stewart. “…With all of our players, if you overwhelm me with something, I’ve got to listen. I guess most people would say the trade deadline is where we’ll find the best value. But at this moment, Mark Trumbo is my guy. He gives us something in our lineup that none of our other guys do other than Goldschmidt – a guy who can hit the ball out of the ballpark.”

      –Oh, that foxy Dave Stewart. The guy could throw smoke, but now throws smokescreens.

      Reply
  2. James Attwood

    8 years ago

    This trade has been waiting to happen for six months now. The match-up of needs to personnel, both ways, just makes so much sense that I assumed that the baseball gods would just prevent this.

    Reply
    • DMZ

      8 years ago

      Good timing sell high. Make room for Lamb and Tomas. Hopefully get something decent in return. Can’t wait to find out about the transaction.

      Reply
    • stymeedone

      8 years ago

      6 months? Seattle didn’t have a C to trade until they got Castillo.

      Reply
      • James Attwood

        8 years ago

        Trumbo to Seattle made sense going all the way back to the winter meetings. Back then, the Diamondbacks weren’t looking for a catcher, they were looking for lottery tickets. Seattle has plenty of those. The only reason they went catcher now is because of the Gosewisch injury.

        Reply
        • stymeedone

          8 years ago

          A poor defensive OF with no OBA, going to one of the more spacious ballparks, on a team that struggled to get on base, before they acquired him, “made sense going all the way back to the winter meetings.” You, sir, have a different way of solving problems than I do.

  3. DerekJeterDan

    8 years ago

    Leave it to Jack Z to always go for the
    1st Base / DH Types. When will he learn?

    Reply
    • James Attwood

      8 years ago

      At least Trumbo plays slightly above average at 1B and is a better bat than what the Mariners have there right now.

      Reply
      • harmony55

        8 years ago

        Since the start of the 2014 season Mark Trumbo has an OPS+ of 101 while current Seattle first baseman Logan Morrison has an OPS+ of 109 over the same period.

        Reply
        • Edgar4evar

          8 years ago

          That’s why I believe this trade is designed to fix LF. Ackley and Weeks are the ones who will lose AB’s. And our pitching staff will lose outs Ackley would have made in the outfield.

  4. Marvin Marshall

    8 years ago

    No surprise to Dback fans. With O’Brien’s bat ready in Reno & Tomas needing time in LF when Lamb gets back in the next week or so, this needed to happen.

    I hope it is a good return.

    Reply
  5. Joe

    8 years ago

    Nice move by the M’s. Getting Cruz was big, but adding another RHed hitting power bat will balance the lineup even more. Only problem is, does Ackley or Morrison lose playing time?

    Reply
    • theo in 2016

      8 years ago

      Ackley obviously

      Reply
  6. Brixton

    8 years ago

    A bad month and a half, what an awful 10 year contract!

    Reply
  7. Jo JoAnne

    8 years ago

    Stewart doesn’t bluff very well.. Just about everyone saw Trumbo getting traded soon.. Plus, he wasn’t in the lineup today..

    Reply
    • Marvin Marshall

      8 years ago

      Him not being in the lineup meant nothing. They had a 4 man weave going on in the OF with Trumbo sitting out 1-2 games per week.

      Reply
  8. Marvin Marshall

    8 years ago

    Hopefully some catching talent comes back as part of the return.

    Reply
    • Brixton

      8 years ago

      the Mariners did just acquire Wellington, plus they had Zunino.
      Maybe something like Castillo and Edwin Diaz for Trumbo?

      Reply
    • James Attwood

      8 years ago

      Seattle is short on that. Besides, the Diamondbacks have catching coming up here shortly.

      Reply
  9. joshb600

    8 years ago

    I don’t know why but I’ve always liked Trumbo. He’s got an awesome swing. For some reason it’s one of my favorite swings to watch in MLB.

    Reply
    • Seamaholic

      8 years ago

      Certainly one of the hardest … it’s a man’s swing for sure.

      Reply
      • joshb600

        8 years ago

        Definitely. But not even that. It’s just a swing thats fun to watch.

        Reply
  10. Evan Wallace

    8 years ago

    Remember the Bedard trade….

    Reply
    • King Kyle

      8 years ago

      And how this trade is not even remotely similar?

      Reply
  11. Jo JoAnne

    8 years ago

    Cano’s bat will heat up sooner or later.. That contract won’t be regrettable for another 4 years or so..

    Reply
  12. cxz

    8 years ago

    Apparently it’s Trumbo and Nuno for Castillo,Leone, and “2 prospects”.

    Reply
    • DerekJeterDan

      8 years ago

      When I die. I want Vidal Nuno to lower my casket so he can let me down one final time.

      Reply
      • citizen

        8 years ago

        thats a cleveland browns joke.

        Reply
      • cxz

        8 years ago

        This still doesn’t have the number of upvotes it deserves.

        Reply
  13. iliekcereal

    8 years ago

    Rosenthal: Castillo, Leone, 2 prospects for Trumbo and Nuno

    Reply
  14. Daniel Morairity

    8 years ago

    They get vidal nuno from them too and I dont know who the mariners traded to get trumbo and nuno maybe walker and and prospect

    Reply
    • Joe

      8 years ago

      Leone, Castillo and “2 prospects”. Don’t know who they are at this point.

      Reply
    • King Kyle

      8 years ago

      Even though we know who is going at this point, how could anyone have reasonably expected Taijuan Walker to be in this deal?

      Reply
  15. JacobyWanKenobi

    8 years ago

    Cruz and Trumbo both playing OF in Safeco, yikes.

    Reply
    • joshb600

      8 years ago

      Why can’t Cruz and Trumbo split OF/DH?

      Reply
      • MFFeLtman27

        8 years ago

        they could. Seth Smith is also in the mix. not like Seattle has a Papi or V-Mart that actually warrants permanently filling the DH spot.

        Reply
    • cxz

      8 years ago

      I would hope they play Trumbo at 1st. Otherwise, super yikes

      Reply
      • joshb600

        8 years ago

        I think it’ll either be him at 1st, or him and Cruz splitting OF/DH duties.

        Reply
  16. Marvin Marshall

    8 years ago

    Dbacks acquire C Wellington Castillo, P Dominic Leone, INF Jack Reinheimer, OF Gabby Guerrero from Sea for Trumbo & Nuño.

    Reply
    • MFFeLtman27

      8 years ago

      Guerrero was my guess.

      Reply
    • Brixton

      8 years ago

      I kinda like the deal for the Mariners. Nothing of real value going back to the D’Backs.

      Reply
      • stl_cards16

        8 years ago

        Castillo is a good catcher. This is an immediate upgrade to the Dbacks team, not that it really matters for this season.

        Reply
        • Brixton

          8 years ago

          Yeah, but hes not THAT valuable. The Mariners got him for a reliever with control issues.

        • stl_cards16

          8 years ago

          Neither is Trumbo, especially to a team in the NL with a great 1B and better OF options available.

          Fun fact: Welington Castillo has a higher career fWAR (6.3) than Trumbo (5.5) in 1,000 fewer PA. You are either greatly over valuing Trumbo or under valuing Castillo.

        • jb226

          8 years ago

          I think a lot of people are down on Castillo because of his pitch framing. He’s an above-average bat and at least an average defender in terms of blocking pitches and throwing out runners. He’s a nice piece.

        • theo in 2016

          8 years ago

          He has a cannon

        • davbee

          8 years ago

          People aren’t over valuing Trumbo. It’s just that he’s a first baseman playing mostly out of position which diminishes his value.

      • stymeedone

        8 years ago

        Seems fair then. Nothing of real value going to the Mariners either.

        Reply
        • Brixton

          8 years ago

          Power is value.
          See Evan Gattis

        • stymeedone

          8 years ago

          So is catching.

        • Brixton

          8 years ago

          not when you’re a below average defensive catcher.

        • theo in 2016

          8 years ago

          Hes not. Just framing. Good blocker, great arm quick release

        • stymeedone

          8 years ago

          Good thing Castillo is not a below average defensive catcher. Only area in question is a subjective one, pitch framing.

  17. Snoochies8

    8 years ago

    This is just great, keep being you Zdurencik

    Reply
  18. Draven Moss

    8 years ago

    I like this deal for the D’backs. They got rid of a guy they didn’t really need and in return, got a capable catcher, a nice young reliever in Leone, and 2 “prospects”. Nuno isn’t that valuable IMO.

    Reply
    • Seamaholic

      8 years ago

      Nuno is value-less. AAAA type. M’s will eventually move him on.

      Reply
      • Edgar4evar

        8 years ago

        He’s absolutely murdering lefties as a reliever. I think the mistake is converting him to starter where he’s been average at best.

        Reply
        • davbee

          8 years ago

          The Oliver Perez syndrome, and the Ms put him in the bullpen to mostly good results there for a couple of years. Nuno also gets to go to a ballpark that is more forgiving to flyball pitchers.

  19. MFFeLtman27

    8 years ago

    the dumbest part of this trade was trading Adam Eaton and Tyler Skaggs for Trumbo in the first place

    Reply
    • letsgogiants

      8 years ago

      Thanks Kevin Towers!

      Reply
      • Brixton

        8 years ago

        While Im not gonna defend Towers, Eaton is hitting like .230 and Skaggs has a career ERA of 4.72 and just had TJ, while Trumbo is still a pretty good hitter.

        Reply
      • BK

        8 years ago

        Angel fan here, no it wasnt.

        Reply
      • JoeCB91

        8 years ago

        I do not miss that grit loving fool

        Reply
    • Seamaholic

      8 years ago

      This is an old, and by now pretty close to false, assessment. Eaton isn’t doing much and Skaggs is hurt, while Trumbo is still trumboing. It continues to be a weird trade, but it turned out not particularly unbalanced.

      Reply
      • stl_cards16

        8 years ago

        A NL team with a great 1B trading for Trumbo is a bad decision.

        Reply
        • William

          8 years ago

          Agree !

      • theo in 2016

        8 years ago

        2 months of a bad eaton and u think hes done? Hes still young and cheap for years

        Reply
  20. Jo JoAnne

    8 years ago

    Wow, Castillo is taking quite a tour of the majors.. I guess Stewart finally realized that O’Brien will never be their catcher of the future but he will be a nice OF bat..

    Reply
  21. RedSox040713

    8 years ago

    Did this trade just come completely out of the blue, or is this my East Coast Bias showing?

    Reply
    • Edgar4evar

      8 years ago

      The Mariners almost never leak info on pending deals, so it’s never a surprise to us when one shows up out of the blue. I mean, the trade is a surprise, but we’re not surprised that we were surprised.

      Reply
  22. Mark D

    8 years ago

    Really bad deal for AZ – the prospects are nothing special and Trumbo could have brought back a lot more.

    Reply
    • Seamaholic

      8 years ago

      Leone can be very good, and Castillo is a starting caliber C. That seems pretty close to fair for a DH type. What’s odder is that Trumbo is basically a poor man’s Cruz. Not sure what the M’s are thinking here.

      Reply
      • Mark D

        8 years ago

        It will indeed be funny if they play him in LF and Cruz in RF and wonder why suddenly their pitchers ERAs skyrocket.

        Reply
        • Bernard Middlebrook

          8 years ago

          Nice, Mark. You took nearly an entire tweet from Dave Cameron @ FanGraphs and repeated it here as your own. Did you not think anyone would notice?

        • Mark D

          8 years ago

          I thought I wrote it as if we all saw it by stating “It will indeed be funny…” – sorry

      • dt

        8 years ago

        Poor man Cruz is not a bad thing for their offense. Defense however…

        Reply
    • Kyle Cotton

      8 years ago

      Hell they would of heard something from the astros at some point if Carter started struggling again.

      Reply
    • Mark Firkus

      8 years ago

      We were having Salty as our starting catcher…. Castillo is an upgrade

      Reply
      • davbee

        8 years ago

        Wait til you see him try to hit.

        Reply
  23. Jeffy25

    8 years ago

    Good in terms of exchanging of needs

    Reply
  24. ChuckMorris36

    8 years ago

    Wow Castillo 3 teams in 3 months lol and trumbo’s power numbers might go down.

    Reply
  25. cxz

    8 years ago

    I suppose this was a mutually beneficial deal, though I don’t love the Trumbo to Seattle fit as an answer for lacking offense. D-Backs make a clear spot for Tomas and add another catcher while taking in a few prospects,and the Mariners add a pitcher and try to get some offense. I like it a little more for Arizona, but when it comes down to it they’re both having their needs met.

    Reply
  26. theo in 2016

    8 years ago

    Called this last week

    Reply
  27. dt

    8 years ago

    Only prospect Seattle gave up that might be worth something is Gabby but from what I heard he is bouncing around from A and AA. Still young though.

    Reply
  28. Brandon Stubbs Calvert

    8 years ago

    Well there goes Goldrumbo, I liked trumbo but just sooo many outfield options, and we can put lamb back at third for a nice lefty in the lineup. Not a great package in my opinion but im assuming Sea is taking the rest of trumbos money?

    Reply
  29. LiveFastCyYoung

    8 years ago

    @Dbacks: #Dbacks acquire C Wellington Castillo, RHP Dominic Leone, INF Jack Reinheimer & OF Gabby Guerrero from Mariners for Mark Trumbo & Vidal Nuño

    Reply
  30. nauchwc

    8 years ago

    if gabby guerrero is involved in the deal then the dbacks win this trade. imo.

    Reply
    • nauchwc

      8 years ago

      *and it appears so.

      Reply
    • harmony55

      8 years ago

      Gabby Guerrero is a 21-year-old outfielder who has posted a .215/.262/.305/.567 line in 191 plate appearances this year at Double A Jackson. Vlad’s nephew had posted strong numbers last year in the extremely hitter-friendly California League.

      Reply
      • sdsuphilip

        8 years ago

        Gabby has only really hit in a extreme hitting environment in A+ and even then his numbers weren’t that great, seems like he has a lot of raw power that doesn’t play in games

        Reply
  31. stl_cards16

    8 years ago

    Seems like a good trade for both teams. Trumbo can get some time at DH/1B, the Dbacks clear up a logjam and get a nice upgrade behind the plate.

    Reply
  32. HoopDreams

    8 years ago

    Guess their patience ran out with LoMo.

    Reply
    • Robert_Risteen

      8 years ago

      Ackley

      Reply
    • algionfriddo

      8 years ago

      LoMo has been playing rather well after a rough luck start, and he looks especially strong on defense. Ackley has been pretty awful with an occasional blip of ability. I’ve seen softball girls with better arms.

      Reply
      • James Attwood

        8 years ago

        Trumbo’s defense in the OF is horrid. At first, it is slightly above average. He should play well there if LoMo struggles.

        Reply
  33. skrockij89

    8 years ago

    Gabby will be tough to lose. Leone was pitching horrible this year. Needs help with his control and he’ll return to forum. Gave up Medina for a one month rental in Castillo, just to trade him.

    Reply
    • Edgar4evar

      8 years ago

      If you get something when you trade a guy he wasn’t a rental. I may not agree that Trumbo is the guy we needed, but he has value and he’s a Mariner because we traded Medina.

      Reply
  34. ConstructionBoy

    8 years ago

    .298 lifetime onbase

    I hate this era of baseball because of the type of players we overvalue for a slugging percentage

    Reply
    • Mark D

      8 years ago

      Trumbo didn’t exactly bring in anything of value though.

      Reply
    • Ray Ray

      8 years ago

      Don’t worry because before too long we will start overvaluing players for a completely different reason and sluggers will be undervalued.

      Reply
    • theo in 2016

      8 years ago

      A homer produces a run in itself. Anything else requires a sequence oc multiple events. And they have players with that obp and slugging in their lineup. Hes a legit 800 ops guy for a couple years.

      Reply
  35. BILLY THE CURSED GOAT

    8 years ago

    This circus show just keeps getting better and better. M’s have a .298 OBP…Don’t they realize they need to fix this? How can you not bench Ackley who has a .227 OBP? Insanity….

    Reply
    • Wayne

      8 years ago

      They might just bench him. It’s not like the M’s have no outfielders.

      Reply
    • MisterQuigley

      8 years ago

      It’s clearly Jack Z’s ego. Jesus, Jack, DFA him already. We forgive you for blowing the number 2 pick, everyone would have made that pick. Move on, let’s start winning again…

      Reply
      • Red_Line_9

        8 years ago

        The Mariners, are reportedly only one of three teams to have Mike Trout #2 on their draft board behind the consensus #1 Strasburg. Jack Z tossed out his own scouting dept to take Ackley. But I’ll say at the time Ackley was legit. He’s having a Mark Teahen career arc now. The other teams have Trout #2 were the Angels and Yankees

        Reply
  36. kentwa

    8 years ago

    everybody looks good until they get to Seattle..then they fall apart !

    Reply
    • sdsuphilip

      8 years ago

      I mean Trumbo’s going to do worse by OPS, going from chase to Safeco is a huge difference

      Reply
      • Jaysfan1994

        8 years ago

        Trumbo made a career of hitting gigantic homers in a place where both Pujols and Hamilton saw massive declines in power. I think Trumbo will be fine homer wise. He just needs to stay healthy.

        Reply
  37. kentwa

    8 years ago

    spells the end for Ackley in the OF..Amen!! he becomes the super utility guy now since we can also play 1st and 2nd…yeah!!!

    Reply
    • Red_Line_9

      8 years ago

      How many super utility types do the M’s need…. Ackley likely gets non tendered in the off season

      Reply
      • Bernard Middlebrook

        8 years ago

        He might well be released tomorrow!

        Reply
  38. We.Need.More.Grit

    8 years ago

    Well, glad our OF depth is being shortened however the fact still stands. We dealt Skaggs and Eaton for Trumbo which then in turn, we got back Castillo, a reliever, and two prospects, whom I’m guessing aren’t near a Skaggs or Eaton level of production at the ML level. If anyone has info on them and would spare me the time of searching, that would be appreciated.

    Still can’t wrap my mind around dealing a pretty darn good CF and 2/3 slot lefty for a somewhat platoon catcher, a reliever and two prospects. Glad KT is gone from that front office to say the least.

    Reply
    • Marvin Marshall

      8 years ago

      Eaton is not doing so well & Skaggs was mediocre & now on the shelf with TJ. With Pollock being the better player, Eaton had to be moved.

      Reply
      • We.Need.More.Grit

        8 years ago

        Hilarious.

        Adam Eaton for 2014:
        wrc+ 115
        .300 average
        .362 OBP which is above league average.
        .340 wOBA which is once again, above league average.
        K% of 15.4 Which is oh, again, above average.
        BB% of 8%, league average.
        Totaling a WAR of 2.9.

        Tyler Skaggs for 2014:
        4.30 ERA in which FIP and xFIP projected he was due for some positive movement as they sat at 3.55 and 3.65.
        K/9 of 6.85 Which is just below league average.
        BB/9 of 2.39 Which any walk rate between 2.3 and 2.8 is considered ‘Great’.
        A .72 HR per nine speak for itself as well as a BABIP of .293.
        Skaggs totaled a WAR of 1.7.

        While they both are not superstars, I’d rather have Eaton in LF and not waste 68 something Mil on Tomas who will most likely be worse than that of the mentioned Eaton. Skaggs, would most likely, lead that staff and save us from paying for Jeremy f****** Hellickson.

        Just because Eaton is pressing and or hiding an injury doesn’t mean that trade wasn’t a disaster. In turn, we dealt away two young would be core pieces for a man we moved for spare parts and two high risk high reward prospects who could very well be absolutely nothing more than depth.

        Reply
        • Marvin Marshall

          8 years ago

          Eaton & Skaggs are both overrated. Neither was going to lead this team. Eaton has returned down to earth & Skaggs may never be more than a mid to back of the rotation arm.

        • We.Need.More.Grit

          8 years ago

          So we trade two USEFUL MLB pieces for a backup catcher, reliever and two unknowns. Genius. Why aren’t you a GM, dude? Oh wait, we already had a KT era.

        • We.Need.More.Grit

          8 years ago

          So smart. Oh boy, where oh where do I start. A PLAYER DOESN’T NEED TO BE A SUPERSTAR TO BE A PART OF A WINNING CLUB. Eaton + a free 68 million is far greater than Tomas. Skaggs, would be the ace of a horrid rotation and supply an upside mid-rotation arm we so dearly need.

          Fact still stands, trading for Trumbo in the first place was the stupidest decision by KT. Well, perhaps that and trading Upton for a bunch of nothing.

    • I WILL FINE HIM

      8 years ago

      D’Backs had a terrible GM that made that trade.

      Reply
      • Gersh

        8 years ago

        I think he realizes that as he mentions it in the last sentence.

        Reply
        • I WILL FINE HIM

          8 years ago

          Lol, I missed the last sentence.

      • We.Need.More.Grit

        8 years ago

        Not particularly fond of the current regime either, but at least he understands that talent and youth are needed and not just guys who enjoy being covered in dirt. The dark ages are over, but the light is still years off.

        Reply
        • I WILL FINE HIM

          8 years ago

          I don’t know much about the new regime there, but it must be a relief compared to last year. I think KT would have literally traded all of the D’Backs young talent if he stayed much longer. Trumbo trade was terrible to begin with and was made worse with having Goldschmidt already at 1st.

  39. Will

    8 years ago

    O’Brien didn’t have a problem throwing back to the Pitcher from what I heard, he had problems throwing out runners. He decided recently he wants to go OF full time.

    Reply
    • Marvin Marshall

      8 years ago

      No, he seriously couldn’t throw the ball back to the pitcher in spring training. It came out of no where & made the Dbacks put him in RF to start the season in Reno.

      Now that he has gotten used to & played well in RF while continuing to rake, he decided to he wanted to stay there permanently.

      Reply
      • Mark Firkus

        8 years ago

        but Stewart has said that report was false, and the org has not decided a perm position

        Reply
        • Marvin Marshall

          8 years ago

          I watched multiple games in the spring in which he was having issues. I saw it with my own eyes.

  40. GameMusic3

    8 years ago

    Mariners’ recent philosophy, collect EVERY DH.

    Reply
    • Cam Hodgson-Dwyer

      8 years ago

      Cornering the market.

      Reply
    • harmony55

      8 years ago

      Since last year the Mariners have jettisoned Kendrys Morales, Justin Smoak and Corey Hart while harboring Jesus Montero in the minors.

      Reply
      • Jaysfan1994

        8 years ago

        They pick up RBI men, Jack Z’s philosophy in action.

        Reply
        • Red_Line_9

          8 years ago

          And that works maybe unless you keep batting Ackley in a prime top of the order slot. For awhile Cruz was on pace to hit 70 HR and not even drive in 100

    • Ray Ray

      8 years ago

      Why not? The Red Sox are collecting corner outfielders and the Dodgers are collecting relievers. Some team needed to collect DHs.

      Reply
  41. FrankRoo

    8 years ago

    I wonder if the Cubs could have gotten a better deal if they dealt directly with Arizona. The Dbacks obviously wanted Castillo for a while, but never offered anything the Cubs wanted.

    Reply
    • stymeedone

      8 years ago

      Arizona’s C wasn’t injured until after the Cubs had traded Castillo, so probably not.

      Reply
      • Jaysfan1994

        8 years ago

        Yup, everyone needs a starting catcher with a .540OPS. If Arizona wasn’t looking for upgrades until after he got hurt, they have problems.

        Reply
        • theo in 2016

          8 years ago

          He said they were targettjng navarro but hes hurt as well. Think they liked tuffys d and catcher is a tough spot to really upgrade.

        • Jaysfan1994

          8 years ago

          He’s back now.

        • stymeedone

          8 years ago

          Its Arizona. Yeah. They do have problems. They really were satisfied until he got hurt. Whether they should have been satisfied is another question.

  42. Lefty_Orioles_Fan

    8 years ago

    I like Trumbo a lot, but where is he going to play?
    If he can do it, 1st base would be a good spot.
    Cruz is a bit rough defensively, but he is hitting. So…

    Reply
    • harmony55

      8 years ago

      Why can’t Mark Trumbo serve as a designated hitter in his return to the American League?

      Nelson Cruz won’t win a Gold Glove, but his alarming -.36.0 UZR/150 so far this year should regress toward his career UZR/150 of +1.4 (or his 2014 UZR/150 of +3.8).

      Reply
      • Jaysfan1994

        8 years ago

        Nelson Cruz’s 2014 UZR is a pretty small sample size. He also didn’t have much ground to cover in those small A.L East ballparks. His career UZR over the past 3-4 years is more indicative of how Cruz is probably going to play going forward and it isn’t very pretty when adding on age.

        Trumbo should be the 1B against LHP. I’d want him to be the everyday 1B but Logan Morrison is probably going to split time with him at 1B on some days vs RHP.

        Reply
        • theo in 2016

          8 years ago

          Uzr also takes a ridiculously long time to stabalize. Drs is better

    • James Attwood

      8 years ago

      Trumbo is slightly above average at first. He could also play LF in a pinch if the Mariners really wanted LoMo, Smith, Cruz, and Trumbo all in the lineup.

      Reply
  43. JoeCB91

    8 years ago

    Great news, Trumbo was a poor fit as an outfielder for an NL team. Now we can play Lamb and Tomas together too!

    Reply
  44. Red_Line_9

    8 years ago

    Not exactly sure what M’s are doing. They need another starter…Castillo also helped rest Zunino. I guess it’s not a bad deal

    Reply
  45. desertdawg

    8 years ago

    According to AZ Sports Radio, catching was a top priority, plus D’Backs outfield was way to crowded, and Trumbo contract. With the trade it now fixes the outfield, Tomas is a better fit in the outfield and with Jake Lamb coming off the DL to play everyday at 3rd. Trumbo was the odd man out. I was surprise it happen this quick, kinda expected the Trumbo trade at the deadline.

    Reply
  46. Aaron

    8 years ago

    Kinda figured Castillo would end up in Arizona anyway. I was surprised when they traded him to Seattle, and I did like the return. Now it seems that the Mariners are cashing in on him.

    Reply
  47. Daniel Morairity

    8 years ago

    So the mariner lineup looks like this

    Austin Jackson
    Dustin Ackely
    Robinson Cano
    Nelson Cruz
    Kyle Seagar
    Mark Trumbo
    Mike Zunino
    Logan Morrison
    Brad Miller

    Thats still alot of left handers in that lineup. Five of them to be exact

    Reply
    • MadThespian

      8 years ago

      I really think Ackley loses playing time, not Smith. He and Zunino are the two dead spots in the lineup, and the bench offers no help. Hopefully this might also lead to the end of the Rickie Weeks experiment.

      Reply
    • Arndt Miles

      8 years ago

      i see it more like
      jackson cf
      cano 2b
      cruz dh
      seager 3b
      trumbo lf
      lomo 1b
      smith rf
      zunino c
      miller ss

      Reply
    • docmilo5

      8 years ago

      Ackley shouldn’t be getting many ABs. Jackson will likely leadoff vs lefties and Smith should be leading off vs righties, or LoMo? LoMo does have the best OBP vs RHP at this point so I could see him staying there. I do like the idea of moving Cano to the 2 hole and everyone up a spot.

      Smith/Jackson
      Cano
      Cruz
      Seager
      Trumbo
      LoMo
      Jackson/Ruggiano
      Zunino
      Miller

      Smith/Ruggs get the LF platoon. Ackley can get the occasional start in CF vs tough righties.

      Reply
      • Red_Line_9

        8 years ago

        Agree….I want Cano presumably batting near norms in that 2 hole

        Reply
        • Lanidrac

          8 years ago

          Your best overall hitter should usually bat 3rd. That way he can drive in the two guys ahead of him and get on base for the guys behind him. I can understand it though if Seattle just doesn’t have any other good OBP guys to bat 2nd.

        • Red_Line_9

          8 years ago

          I’ll get all stat wonk for a second and say optimal lineup efficiency places most importance on the 1,2,4 hitters. But all in all the difference between setting a lineup and just drawing it at random is only a few runs a season.

    • Red_Line_9

      8 years ago

      It’s also an incredibly good slow pitch softball team! Its mystifying if the Mariners bat Ackley #2. Thats possibly the most important slot in the order. I’d bury him 8 or 9 and move everyone up

      Reply
  48. NickinIthaca

    8 years ago

    I remember when Dave Stewart said there was no chance he’d trade Trumbo. Aaaahhh, those were the days….

    Reply
    • vonjunk

      8 years ago

      It’s a good way to set up trades: create value and pretend to not be all that interested in trading a player. The best way to maximize their value.
      As opposed to the previous GM Towers who would say the player had to go and usually when their value was lowest. Putting himself in the position of lowering their value and forcing a trade (Justin Upton is a prime example).

      I like how Stewart works, but I suspect LaRussa is guiding the trades.
      The Diamondbacks saved over $3m, landed their starting catcher, a possible plus bullpen arm and Vlad Guerro 2 (maybe, very much worth a gamble) for an expensive slugger who had no place to play. Somehow Trumbo won his arbitration hearing despite not playing that much last year and underperforming when he did. Goes to show, chicks and arbitrators dig the long ball.

      This trade the Diamondbacks did very well!

      Reply
      • DMZ

        8 years ago

        Landed their starting catcher? If they wanted Castillo they would have got him in the Montero deal. Tuffy has not lost his job to any of Laird, Castillo, or Salty. Oscar Hernandez when ready but until then Tuffy has the lead unless another move is made before Tuffy is ready or Oscar…

        Reply
      • Red_Line_9

        8 years ago

        The beat way to maximize value, according to Sandy Alderson, is to not talk at all. Almost any talk is a tell.

        Reply
  49. Joe Goldberg

    8 years ago

    Do the Diamondbacks have ANY idea what they’re doing? There doesn’t appear to be a plan and everything is done impulsively. Last year, Trumbo was the big acquisition and worth a top young pitcher. This year, it’s spend big on Tomas and trade Trumbo for a backup catcher.

    Reply
  50. Red_Line_9

    8 years ago

    They also have 4 utility players on the roster. Flexibility really hasn’t been the issue. They have Ackley, Taylor, Miller, and Weeks

    Reply
    • davbee

      8 years ago

      Taylor is back in Triple-A

      Reply
      • Red_Line_9

        8 years ago

        I was more referring to their roster capabilities…but true..and he’s also covering for an injury.

        Reply
  51. Red_Line_9

    8 years ago

    What DH are they carrying other than Cruz? Morrison plays 1B

    Reply
    • theo in 2016

      8 years ago

      Well trumbo now. One of cruz or trumbo has to play the field. Although morrison will most likely sit vs lefties

      Reply
      • Red_Line_9

        8 years ago

        I see Trumbo playing some first. Morrison is nothing special. What this might signal to me though… And it’s ominous…That Jack Z is bolstering the offense because they might not feel they can acquire a decent starting pitcher…which is where the teams overall long range season flaw might be. Felix is Felix, but Paxton is out…Roenis might not keep it up and Walker is all over the place. Imamura has been injured. Its really a big ? After Hernandez

        Reply
        • Red_Line_9

          8 years ago

          Who out there has a back end #4-#5 starter that’s dependable and expendable for either Trumbo or Morrison? My thinking is that the M’s need is stability in the rotation. It certainly wasn’t adding Trumbo exactly. I’m thinking maybe this was yo add pieces or make them available to add that arm over the next couple of months.

        • theo in 2016

          8 years ago

          They would trade prospects before a hitter with how bad there offense is

        • Red_Line_9

          8 years ago

          Prospects seem to be way down the pipe. The offense has been down below norms…they were without Austin Jackson, and Cano was drastically down. Just a normal bounce back would reset the top of the order. Its not like the lineup was projected to be weak.

        • theo in 2016

          8 years ago

          Jackson is basically what his statline is. He is a bad fit for their ballpark.

        • Red_Line_9

          8 years ago

          Jack Z is just good enough as a GM to be extremely frustrating. I get the big swing approach… But he’s built a solo homer profile because no one gets on base…

  52. WhoKilledTheRallyMonkey

    8 years ago

    Dont the D’Backs know the Angels traded Trumbo to Arizona so they wouldn’t have to see him anymore. Atleast its not as back as the Mike Napoli catastrophe.

    Reply
  53. Edgar4evar

    8 years ago

    Hopefully Trumbo essentially replaces Ackley/Weeks. He and Cruz split DH/OF and the other corner is played by Smith/Ruggiano who’ve both performed as expected in their roles (Ruggiano has had to face a lot of righties so his overall line is poor…but he’s been good against lefties).

    Now they need to add a left handed option for CF. They moved Leon Landry up to Tacoma and he’s been hitting well there. I wonder if we won’t see him before long.

    Reply
  54. Kevin McClintock

    8 years ago

    Damn – was hoping Trumbo could come to the Cards.

    Reply
  55. Eduardo Cuadras

    8 years ago

    Agree

    Reply
  56. Eduardo Cuadras

    8 years ago

    So let me see if I understand… The team gets rid of another veteran player to rely on a young but unproven core of players??? What do Inciarte, Peralta, Lamb, Tomas, Ahmed and Owings have in common?? None of them have more than two years in the majors and they are now suddenly the solution to ARI problems. Even I understand what happened with Trumbo and why he was sent to Seattle, I don’t get how quick Arizona changes philosophies. Miley was sent to another team, Montero, Trumbo etc. I understand this is a business but sometimes you have to spend money, not ridiculously, to have some better talent. The team is not going to find Paul Goldschmidt deals every year. We lack a front line starter now but a few years ago we sent Kennedy to Padres, Hudson is not an SP anymore and we (Arizona fan) seem to be doing just non-sense things over and over again.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.
Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Orioles To Decline Five-Year Lease Extension At Camden Yards, Seeking Longer-Term Agreement With Maryland Stadium Authority

    Blue Jays Sign Chad Green

    Rays Extend Yandy Diaz

    Dexter Fowler Announces Retirement

    Mets Sign Jeff McNeil To Four-Year Extension

    Red Sox, Marlins Swap Matt Barnes For Richard Bleier

    Darren O’Day Announces Retirement

    Royals To Re-Sign Zack Greinke

    Braves Extend Manager Brian Snitker Through 2025

    Rays Sign Pete Fairbanks To Extension

    Royals Sign Aroldis Chapman To One-Year Deal

    Athletics Sign Jesús Aguilar

    Orioles Acquire Cole Irvin From A’s

    Astros Name Dana Brown General Manager

    Rays Extend Jeffrey Springs

    Royals, Red Sox Swap Adalberto Mondesi For Josh Taylor

    Red Sox Designate Matt Barnes For Assignment

    Scott Rolen Elected Into Baseball Hall Of Fame

    Red Sox Sign Adam Duvall

    Brad Ausmus Reportedly Among Astros’ GM Finalists

    Recent

    Cal Raleigh Underwent Offseason Thumb Surgery

    Orioles To Decline Five-Year Lease Extension At Camden Yards, Seeking Longer-Term Agreement With Maryland Stadium Authority

    Red Sox Notes: Barnes, Bleier, Paxton, Bello, Pivetta

    Extension Candidate: Dylan Cease

    Mariners Win Arbitration Case Against Diego Castillo

    Mariners, Kyle Tyler Agree To Minor League Contract

    Dodgers Move Danny Lehmann To Bench Coach

    MLBTR Chat Transcript

    Reds Sign Jason Vosler To Minor League Deal

    Braves Sign Yolmer Sanchez To Minor League Deal

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Offseason Outlook Series
    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Go Ad-Free
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2023
    • 2022-23 MLB Free Agent List
    • MLB Player Chats
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • Feeds by Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrowsFOX Sports Engage Network scroll to top
    Close

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version