Headlines

  • Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment
  • Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery
  • Braves Select Craig Kimbrel
  • Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox
  • White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel
  • Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Blue Jays Acquire Francisco Liriano, Two Prospects For Drew Hutchison

By charliewilmoth | August 1, 2016 at 3:57pm CDT

The Pirates have announced that they’ve received righty Drew Hutchison from the Blue Jays in exchange for lefty Francisco Liriano, outfielder Harold Ramirez and catcher Reese McGuire. The deal comes as a shock, as the Bucs gave up two legitimate prospects in exchange for a marginal rotation option and relief from the approximately $18MM remaining on Liriano’s contract.

[Related: Updated Pittsburgh Pirates and Toronto Blue Jays Depth Charts]

Liriano was a top performer in the Pirates’ rotation in 2013 through 2015, but he has struggled badly in 2016, with a 5.46 ERA and a league-leading 69 walks. The Bucs, much-praised for their reputations for fixing struggling pitchers, evidently felt they wouldn’t be able to fix Liriano, who is making $13MM both this year and next.

Hutchison, formerly a regular in the back end of the Jays’ rotation, has spent most of the 2016 season with Triple-A Buffalo, where he’s posted a 3.26 ERA, 9.7 K/9 and 3.1 BB/9. He’s had considerably less success in his four-year big-league career, with a 4.92 ERA, although with a reasonable 8.3 K/9 and 2.8 BB/9. He’s making $2.2MM this season. He’s eligible for arbitration for two more years after this one, should the Pirates choose to keep him.

The 21-year-old Ramirez was batting .306/.354/.401 for Double-A Altoona. He has a stocky build and hasn’t yet developed much home-run power, but is relatively close to the Majors at a young age and has always hit well for average. MLB.com ranks him the Pirates’ ninth-best prospect.

Ramirez’s inclusion in the deal was surprising enough, but the inclusion of McGuire is downright strange — McGuire’s bat hasn’t developed, but he’s a very highly regarded defensive catcher who rated as the Pirates’ No. 8 prospect. MLB.com notes that his plus defense makes him a likely future regular, with potential to be more than just a defensive-minded player depending on how his bat develops. The 21-year-old has batted .259/.337/.346 for Altoona this season.

Overall, the deal is reminiscent of the Diamondbacks’ 2015 trade of Bronson Arroyo and top prospect Touki Toussaint to the Braves for Phil Gosselin and relief from Arroyo’s salary. The Diamondbacks’ end of that trade was harshly criticized by most analysts, and the Pirates’ end of this deal seems likely to suffer a similar fate.

Robert Murray of Fan Rag was first to tweet that a deal had been struck.  Shi Davidi of Sportsnet.ca tweeted that the Jays would receive two prospects. Gideon Turk of BP Toronto tweeted that Hutchison was involved, with Stephen J. Nesbitt of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette noting Ramirez’s involvement.

Share 208 Retweet 15 Send via email0

Newsstand Pittsburgh Pirates Toronto Blue Jays Transactions Drew Hutchison Francisco Liriano Harold Ramirez Reese McGuire

Mets Acquire Jay Bruce
Main
Rangers Acquire Jonathan Lucroy, Jeremy Jeffress
View Comments (122)
Post a Comment

122 Comments

  1. The Man 38

    9 years ago

    For a second I read Francisco Lindor

    Reply
    • movaughn

      9 years ago

      I wish it was Frank Francisco…one of the best 9th innings guys Jays ever had

      Reply
      • exhibitionstadium

        9 years ago

        And here I finally completely forgot about that guy and you had to go ahead and bring him up again. Thanks, man.

        Reply
        • The Morning After Pillar

          9 years ago

          Those old wounds are brought back to the surface lol

          Reply
        • movaughn

          9 years ago

          Sorry but it’s either him or Francisco Cordero. Take your pick.

          Reply
  2. TWolvesFan

    9 years ago

    Right before the buzzer

    Reply
  3. Cotton Walsh

    9 years ago

    Wow

    Reply
  4. pirates937

    9 years ago

    Finally

    Reply
  5. clutchcutch22

    9 years ago

    Sweet! What do we get??

    Reply
  6. Thronson5

    9 years ago

    I thought the deadline ended an hour ago? Maybe I was wrong and it just ended now? Or was this trade done and just not reported until now?

    Reply
    • EndinStealth

      9 years ago

      I imagine it just now got reported.

      Reply
    • Pit2ODU16

      9 years ago

      Trades can take place if they were in the works around 4pm until 5pm or 6pm. Morse and Happ were acquired at 5:30 last season.

      Reply
  7. marco 5

    9 years ago

    There is a god!!!!!!!!!

    Reply
  8. EndinStealth

    9 years ago

    Not a good place for him to pitch. Bullpen?

    Reply
    • jimmyz

      9 years ago

      Doubt Liriano goes to the bullpen considering he’s never pitched out of the bullpen and has had control issues his whole career. I do think this will improve the Jays bullpen though cuz i see this as a move to replace Sanchez’s spot in the rotation down the stretch so his innings can be managed as a set-up man for Osuna.

      Reply
      • EndinStealth

        9 years ago

        You’re probably right, but I don’t think he will stay there. His high walk total will hurt more with Toronto being a hitters park.

        Reply
  9. chuckyboy1217

    9 years ago

    Pirates reportedly acquiring 3B Josh Donaldson, P Aaron Sanchez, P Roberto Osuna, and 2B Devon Travis. According to multiple sources.

    Reply
    • steelparrot 3

      9 years ago

      YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!! i dont even care what we got back, this is a win for the pirates!

      Reply
    • Ravens_Last_Place

      9 years ago

      Liriano for Donaldson is fair only if you throw in Jose Bautista, with Toronto eating most of their salaries.

      Hey, Joey Bats’ longtime gf is a Pittsburgh girl. Well, sort of. If you consider her tiny town 90 minutes away to be Pittsburgh.

      Reply
      • Logjammer D"Baggagecling

        9 years ago

        Joey bats was a scrawny kid when he was on the pirates. He drank some bonds and A-Rod juice

        Reply
        • stormie

          9 years ago

          Are you serious? He’s not even big. He’s had nowhere near the body transformation that guys like Bonds and McGwire had. Any weight or muscle he’s put on since his early days with the Pirates is nothing out of the ordinary.

          Reply
    • Atlanta Braves Fan 4 Life

      9 years ago

      Reply
    • Pit2ODU16

      9 years ago

      Who is your source cause all I’m hearing is Drew Hutchinson maybe some others. No way they give up Josh Donaldson. Sanchez is moving to Jays BP.

      Reply
    • chuckyboy1217

      9 years ago

      I’m joking btw hahaha

      Reply
      • pirates937

        9 years ago

        I can’t believe they took that seriously

        Reply
  10. Robertowannabe

    9 years ago

    May be a good deal for the Bucs. Liriano seems to have lost his edge so maybe another scenery change will work and looks like Pirates got at least a decent pitcher back. Any comment from Jay’s fans as to what Hutchinson is all about??

    Reply
    • Ted

      9 years ago

      Hutchison (no “n”) is one of those guys who is a great 6-7th starter on your depth chart. He’s capable of pitching a major league game without killing you, but he’s maddeningly inconsistent as a regular rotation member. He was actually the opening day starter last year, but fell into an ugly rut of every-other-start being excellent or terrible. If he can ever get it right he’ll be a solid starter though.

      Reply
      • Robertowannabe

        9 years ago

        Thanks for the info. He appears to be what Liriano is without the experience.. Frankie has been the same way this year. Ugly one game and pitches like Cy Young into the 6th the next game then gives up a run or two and gets pulled.

        Reply
      • theeterps

        9 years ago

        Great! Another Jeff Locke!

        Reply
      • ThePriceWasRight

        9 years ago

        hutch will be as good as Cole at home and as good as Niese on the road. he is truly jekyll and Hyde

        Reply
        • stormie

          9 years ago

          Hutchison could easily be a 4th or 5th starter on many teams and is only 25, cheap and controllable. Honestly, I think it’s a good pickup for the Pirates. We’ll see what the final deal looks like though.

          Reply
    • andrey c.

      9 years ago

      In 2015 Hutchison had a 2.91 era and 1.1 ratio in 90 innings at home. On the road he had a 9.83 era and 2.08 ratio in 60 innings.
      The road starts can be further broken down into 3 starts at Boston and 2 at Baltimore where he gave up 30 earned runs in 15 innings.
      Just getting him out of the AL East is a good start at fixing him. The road era still seems impossibly bad, Tipping pitches in road starts? Figure out that issue and he could be a good starter.

      Reply
  11. EndinStealth

    9 years ago

    As much as he has done for the Bucs in the past I’m shocked at how many people are trashing him so hard.

    Reply
    • Robertowannabe

      9 years ago

      Pgh Fans seem to parrot the local talking heads and they all have been bashing him this season. Gets people to call in or post on the articles. Did great for the Bucs but just seemed to lose the edge this year and was just off a shade and could not get guys to chase his stuff much.

      Reply
    • Pit2ODU16

      9 years ago

      He’s 5-11 with a 5.68 ERA this season has had like one good start every so often but he’s horrible this year. Has had at tops one great season for us. 16-8 year. But nothing since then. Hopefully Bucs get more than Hutchinson back.

      Reply
    • Monkey’s Uncle

      9 years ago

      He’s very frustrating. He will go through stretches where he is unhittable, then stretches where he can’t throw it over the plate, then stretches where he throws every pitch down the middle. All of these stretches can occur in the same game. He seems to keep tinkering with his delivery, placement on the rubber, etc. and not surprisingly this affects his consistency. He is a fierce competitor, but he sometimes (to me) looks complacent; maybe some think he doesn’t care, though I don’t think that’s the case.

      Reply
      • bobveale

        9 years ago

        I would say the inconsistency was early season. Since then he is just bad. 2 QS out of last 14 starts. Giving up Ramirez seems excessive but probably the cost of Tor paying all of Liriano 2017 salary. Hutchison only 25, possible 4-5 starter. Regardless, that’s 13 M to be used for ??

        Reply
        • Monkey’s Uncle

          9 years ago

          Giving up Ramirez seems excessive. Giving up both Ramirez and McGuire is just inexplicable.

          Reply
  12. tylerall5

    9 years ago

    We better be getting more than this if Ramirez is involved.

    Reply
  13. Robertowannabe

    9 years ago

    The big Ah!!! for the trade seems yet to be announced. If Harold went too, something else is coming back to the Pirates. Pirates Prospects had a couple of unnamed prospects leaving with Frankie so………..

    Reply
    • Raf25

      9 years ago

      Liriano

      Reply
  14. mp9

    9 years ago

    Good pick up for the Pirates i think Hutchison can be at least a decent #3 in the rotation!

    Reply
    • Hank Murphy

      9 years ago

      He’s way better than Lirano. The Buc’s totally fleeced Toronto.

      Reply
      • MB923

        9 years ago

        Uhh. Exact opposite actually. Liriano is better (though not better in 2016) but better over the past several seasons, and Toronto fleeced Pittsbrgh by not only getting a better overall pitcher, but also getting prospects.

        Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      9 years ago

      Be a decent number 3 based on what, exactly?

      Reply
  15. parkdog

    9 years ago

    Hutch is the big winner in this deal. He needed a change of scenery. Hopefully Ray Searage can work his miracles with him. I can’t say I’m sad to see him go. Good live arm, but too many walks and way too much hard contact. All goes well, he’s a back of the rotation guy. Good luck

    Reply
  16. letsgobucs

    9 years ago

    There has to be more to this deal. I get the salary dump aspect of Liriano, but its not like he’s Mike Hampton or something. If we seriously gave away Harold Ramirez to make the deal and only got back a never-was 25-year old starter, I’m going to be pissed.

    Reply
    • 66TheNumberOfTheBest

      9 years ago

      Yeah, I’m a pretty big NH fan, but if this is it, it’s the worst trade he’s ever made.

      I was pushing for the idea of dumping Liriano even, but NOT paying someone to take him.

      This is a terrible deal unless something else is coming to PGH.

      Reply
      • letsgobucs

        9 years ago

        It’s a joke. Stack up Huntington’s trades since day one, there is no way to defend his track record. Free agent signings? Sure. Drafts? Sure.

        Trades? The Pirates are the lackey, constantly getting taken advantage of. If I was the owner, Huntington wouldn’t have a phone or internet access in his office.

        Reply
        • stormie

          9 years ago

          If you thought it was bad before, the fact they also gave up Reese McGuire is going to make your head explode.

          Reply
        • ecat72

          9 years ago

          Yea that AJ Burnett trade was awful. So was that Cervelli trade. The Marlon Byrd trade, terrible. Don’t even get me started on the dumpster fire that was the JA Happ trade. Getting Hanrahan, trading Hanrahan for Melancon just dumb moves. Early moves were made to try and get a large quantity of prospects into a barren farm system. Later moves have been much better. Liriano is done. He’ll get murdered pitching in Toronto. Ramirez is Tabata 2.0 and Reese McGuire can’t hit. So they sold them for 18 million dollars that the Pirates can try and reallocate this offseason. JA Happ would look really good in a Pirates uniform right now, wouldn’t he? Now they can at least attempt to find a new pitcher in the offseaon with that money. They gave themselves options and it cost two prospects that would never see the light of day in Pittsburgh. So many moronic Pirates fans here in the burgh.

          Reply
        • A'sfaninUK

          9 years ago

          Hey guess what: literally every other fan of every other team thinks this of their front office, except maybe St. Louis.

          Reply
        • southi

          9 years ago

          While you are correct that McGuire probably won’t be a great hitter in the majors and that he is blocked from starting in Pittsburgh by Cervelli, there are other things in play with McGuire that makes almost everyone call his inclusion in this deal strange and puzzling. There is absolutely no question that Reese McGuire can be a quality defensive catcher in the big leagues. The only real question about McGuire is if he will hit enough to be a starting catcher. He seldom strikes out and walks in fact more than he fans. He is also slightly young for his league’s age. There are more than enough organizations who would had loved to acquire a prospect like McGuire and would had paid more on the market for him than lumping him into a salary dump. I think that is most people’s main gripe, the fact that Huntington seems not to have maximized McGuire’s value.

          Don’t forget just because the Pirates have Cervelli extended doesn’t mean that he will catch every inning of every game. The pirates need a back up catcher just like every other team does. There is definite value in quality defensive catchers.

          Reply
        • User 2997803866

          9 years ago

          THIS POST. Love it.

          Reply
        • wkkortas

          9 years ago

          I agree; if you asked someone in April “Hey, should the Bucs trade two of their top ten prospects for Drew Hutchison?” You would have politely answered…OK, you would not have been polite. Awful, awful trade–maybe the worst the club has made since the original Ramirez trade.

          Reply
        • ecat72

          9 years ago

          Thats what Diaz is for

          Reply
    • Ray Ray

      9 years ago

      If that’s it, I would have loved for the Rockies to have traded Jordan Lyles for Liriano and Ramirez. Lyles is at least comparable to Hutchison.

      Reply
  17. Gwynning's Anal Lover

    9 years ago

    The Pirates typically overpay with their prospects. That’s probably it of the deal.

    Reply
    • Robertowannabe

      9 years ago

      Not lately….. have trade none of the top prospects for years.. Back in the 90’s yeah, they gave away prospects by the bus load for older players but picked the wrong ones to get with the prospects

      Reply
  18. The Morning After Pillar

    9 years ago

    Liriano has a 2.92 era in 33 starts with Russ Martin catching him. So maybe that familiarity will help the Jays

    Reply
    • johnnywalker

      9 years ago

      Now….that’s the ticket!

      Reply
    • smelliott00

      9 years ago

      Great point. Didn’t even think about him reuniting with Martin

      Reply
  19. letsgobucs

    9 years ago

    Huntington is dead to me. Who gives up the #9 prospect in your system in a salary dump?

    Add another crap deal to the resume of Neil Huntington.

    Reply
    • OB1792

      9 years ago

      #8 and #9 prospects with McGuire involved

      Reply
    • Ray Ray

      9 years ago

      The same guy that also gave up the #8 prospect in the same deal.

      Reply
    • gobraves46

      9 years ago

      Dave Stewart… i.e. Touki Toussaint (thanks Dave!)

      Reply
  20. OB1792

    9 years ago

    I see reports that it’s Harold Ramirez AND Reese McGuire along with Liriano for only Hutchison. That’s insane

    Reply
  21. Clutchp

    9 years ago

    Neil what you do. I mean, including Ramirez was surprising but I guess he was blocked by Marte and Polanco, but McGuire?!

    Reply
    • Ray Ray

      9 years ago

      He was blocked by Cervelli as well. Still seems to be a horrible trade, but not crushing for the Pirates by any means.

      Reply
      • jimmyz

        9 years ago

        If he stayed in the Bucs system he likely would have been Very replacement as he likely would have started next year in AA and moved up to AAA at some point and get called up after super 2 in 2018 providing an opportunity to trade Cervelli in the offseason or at the deadline of his final year.

        Reply
      • ecat72

        9 years ago

        And Diaz

        Reply
      • Clutchp

        9 years ago

        Yeah they were both blocked, I just don’t like this because they easily could’ve gotten someone better for the two of them.

        Reply
  22. steelerbravenation

    9 years ago

    This is such a strange deal but is there anyway the Blue Jays would be willing to flip Reese to the Braves ?

    Reply
  23. steelerbravenation

    9 years ago

    Why were the Braves not in on this deal ? We had money to eat Liriano’s contract for those 2 prospects. There coulda been our catcher of the future right there. And Ramirez numbers are very good. Man Coppy u dropped the ball on that one.

    Reply
  24. steelerbravenation

    9 years ago

    I woulda gave up Blair for that package.

    Reply
  25. The Ghost of Bobby Bonilla

    9 years ago

    If Huntington really did also include McGuire in this deal, he needs to have his office cleaned out tonight. That would be an idiotic, 1990’s/2000’s Pirates move similar to dumping Jose Bautista for nothing.

    I hope these rumors are false, otherwise, say hello to 1,000 fan per game attendance for the rest of the season.

    I liked Huntington alot too until this season. He’s really gone all A.J. Preller this season.

    Reply
    • stormie

      9 years ago

      That’s the confirmed deal.

      Reply
  26. stormie

    9 years ago

    Wow, 2 borderline top-100 prospects for Hutchison and getting rid of Liriano’s contract. Definitely looks like a steal for the Blue Jays. I will say that Hutchison has good stuff though and has breakout potential. He’s only 25 and finished 8th in the AL in strikeouts in 2014. He should be a solid back-end arm for the Pirates for years, with mid-rotation upside. I think a lot of people judging this trade will underrate Hutchison’s value as far as how the Jays and obviously the Pirates valued him.

    Reply
  27. tylerall5

    9 years ago

    I usually stand by NH, but this deal is just absurd. Liriano for Hutchinson should have been enough, but Harold and Reese also? This deal honestly could have been enough to get NH fired. Ridiculous over payment and honestly, I could care less what happens to the Pirates this season because of this trade. I really hope that this deal is a hoax but I don’t believe it is

    Reply
    • Cedric Lee

      9 years ago

      who would trade hutch for liriano straight up right now? you’d be getting the same results but paying a lot more money to roster liriano for this year and next year.

      Reply
    • stormie

      9 years ago

      Liriano would not have been enough for Hutchison, the Jays would have no logical reason to make that deal when Hutch could give them the same level of performance (or better), but one of the prospects should’ve been enough to even it out. Both was definitely an overpay.

      Reply
  28. jaysfan77

    9 years ago

    Love this trade, build the farm and the rotation for the next couple seasons in one swing. Awesome, the Jays new front office has shown a lot of savvy this season, great work!!

    Reply
  29. Mike 25

    9 years ago

    Yet another terrible move for Neal Huntington, when will it be time to fire him. Absolutely horrible trade! Two top ten prospects from the pirates for Drew Hutchison?!? Terrible.. This guy needs to find a new job immediately

    Reply
  30. thatdank1

    9 years ago

    If those 2 kids are included in this deal this is a huge get for the Blue Jays. Jays call looking for a starter and end up with 2 promising prospects (love the potential of McGuire) along with the starter at the same asking price. WTF Huntington. Even if Hutchinson turns out to be something decent (best case) it still was a massive overpay. No one was competing with you to acquire him. Could have added those kids in a deal w the ChiSox for a legit starter…. shesh

    Reply
  31. southi

    9 years ago

    Strange deal for the bucs for sure. I am really shocked that they gave up Reese McGuire in this. I’m quite sure that several teams would had been willing to pay more for him if the news was broadcast they were looking to deal him.

    Definitely a steal for the Blue Jays. The Pirates may very well look for a new GM after the season is over. That deal is horrible.

    Reply
    • szielinski 2

      9 years ago

      Huntington will remain the GM. This trade, along with the Morton trade, was a salary dump. Both Coonley and Nutting had to guy ave signed off on it. Since the Pirates went cheap this past winter, dumping Walker, Bastardo and Morton, the Liriano trade reflects that strategy. It’s not just that they wanted to rid themselves of Liriano’s contract, they used two players that had already cost them millions to acquire to accomplish the salary dump. Moreover, these players had considerable present value, and this value must be added to the money the Pirates spent to acquire them a few years ago.

      Hutchison may become a quality ML starter. But the Pirates traded Liriano to save money.

      Reply
  32. letsgobucs

    9 years ago

    Your welcome, Blue Jays!

    Signed,

    Neil Huntington

    Reply
  33. SupremeZeus

    9 years ago

    This has to be a misprint. Surely Dave Stewart made this trade. All Jolly Rogers are ordered to half-staff today.

    Reply
  34. Cam

    9 years ago

    Wrap a bow on that mofo – Huntington bought Xmas early to Toronto.

    Reply
  35. Ray Ray

    9 years ago

    Between this trade and the lackluster return for Melancon, I think this moves the Pirates slightly ahead of the Reds for worst trade deadline performance. I can’t really think of any other team that just jumps to the forefront in that discussion.

    Reply
  36. graysondecker

    9 years ago

    I first looked at this deal when it said Liriano for Hutchison, and two prospects. I thought “Yes!”. We dumped his contract, let’s go spend it all on Encarnacion this offseason.

    Then I saw Ramirez and McGuire were involved, and had slightly more mixed feelings. But how in the world does Huntington think dumping 17 million and a (maybe) back-of-the-rotation/long reliever is worth two of our best prospects that are borderline top 100?

    I guess he just doesn’t like his job, and wants demoted to water cooler filler. There isn’t even a really crappy metaphor for this trade. It just sucks. The Blue Jays are throwing parties over this deal. John Gibbons should get a 10 year extension, he sure played us

    Reply
  37. st1300b 2

    9 years ago

    Recall Huntington used to work for Toronto GM so this looks like a little giveaway to me. Fire NH today

    Reply
  38. bucsfan

    9 years ago

    This is simply awful. I’ve advocated moving Ramirez and McGuire as they seem to be blocked, but to give them to a team along with a potential #2 if he is right is insane. NH has some explaining to do

    Reply
  39. tigers1968

    9 years ago

    A big surprise since the new Jay management has been so careful with their spending. Perhaps the Jays will go to six starters to reduce the load on everyone especially Sanchez. Dickey has been awful for several weeks so not sure what happens if Dickey continues to under perform.

    Reply
  40. KermitJagger

    9 years ago

    Tough to be a bucs fan today. This is a pure salary dump in the realm of ARam. Liriano, no problem but those are high quality prospects for a pure salary dump. Hoping there is more to this.

    Reply
  41. Hank Murphy

    9 years ago

    Awwwwww crap. The Blue Jays are going to take Sanchez out of the rotation and replace him with a guy worse than Hutchinson. Lovely. Kiss the post season good bye.. Only 2 good starters is not enough to get you to the playoffs.. Let’s be honest, Stroman is having a sophmore slump and is pretty poor most starts and Dickey is Dickey; neither are any good, now we have a pitcher who is far worse. Good news for Boston and Baltimore.

    Reply
  42. clutchcutch22

    9 years ago

    Absolutey horrible….this trade could be one of the worst I’ve ever seen. There is no way you give up two solid prospects for a guy like Hutchison! They’re way too valuable to just “give” away like that! Beyond stunned!

    Reply
  43. Monkey’s Uncle

    9 years ago

    This is reminiscent of the Dave Littlefield era, and the Aramis Ramirez salary dump to the Cubs which turned out to be one of the worst trades in recent Pirate memory. There is absolutely no good explanation for including Harold Ramirez and McGuire in this deal. None. Liriano’s contract wasn’t that much of an albatross.

    Reply
  44. nalieh

    9 years ago

    I thought there were rules against selling prospects. If Ramirez and McGuire are going, this is a prospect sale, not a trade. I’d bet just about any team in baseball would take McGuire and Ramirez. Just think what these two would be worth if they were coming from Cuba!!!

    Waiting to see if there’s more to this, and it seems to violate MLB rules.

    Reply
  45. graysondecker

    9 years ago

    I don’t think Neal Huntington got the memo. He is supposed to help us win, now and in the future. This deal does neither. Sure, we dumped Liriano’s salary, but we traded away two future regulars in the majors, for… what? This deal reminds me of the one the Pirates made for Matt Morris 10 years ago. Except Matt Morris actually had a good reputation, and declined from what he was. Drew Hutchison was never more than an okay back-of-the-rotation player. He’s not even that anymore. I don’t understand why Huntington thought this trade was a good idea in the first place.

    Reply
  46. ChiSoxCity

    9 years ago

    The Jays add yet another mediocre pitching arm… it’s a shame all that position talent getting wasted like that.

    Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      9 years ago

      This isn’t about adding Liriano.

      Reply
      • stormie

        9 years ago

        Agreed. I”m sure they’re hopeful he can rediscover himself with Martin and a new coaching staff’s eyes on him, but Liriano is even less reliable as a 5th starter at this point than Hutch would’ve been. They didn’t make this move with the expectation of getting better now, they made it for the possibility of getting better but primarily for the prospects.

        Reply
    • terrymesmer

      9 years ago

      > The Jays add yet another mediocre pitching arm

      You do know that the Jays are #1 in MLB in ERA (after August 4 games)?

      Reply
  47. mike156

    9 years ago

    Odd trade. Love to hear a coherent explanation for it from the Pirates side.

    Reply
  48. 66TheNumberOfTheBest

    9 years ago

    Yeah. this is the worst trade I’ve seen in a long, long, long time.

    They gave away two legit prospects to save a few bucks.

    I sincerely hope the fans PUNISH the Pirates badly for this with a steep drop off in walk up sales.

    Make it cost them more. This is inexcusable.

    Reply
  49. A'sfaninUK

    9 years ago

    McGuire can’t hit, and Harold Ramirez has a decent tool and not much else. A couple of really overrated prospects right there. I like it for Pittsburgh’s salary budget and Hutchison is kind of exactly the kind of player who responds to Ray Searage. Hutchison still has a mid-rotation ceiling IMO, and Toronto get an upgrade for a postseason race.

    Reply
  50. smrtbusnisman04a

    9 years ago

    Prospects? I can understand Ramirez but if they give up McGuire, the jAys better be taking all of Liriamos salary.

    Reply
  51. LumberJerk9Billion

    9 years ago

    Simmer down people and allow me to be the voice of reason here. I’ve watched these two quite a bit as I live near Bradenton and attend many of their games.
    Reese McGuire has a long way to go with the bat before he can become a major leaguer. Yes, his defense is solid but he’s ticketed for a reserve role if the hit tool never materializes. I compare his future to a Chris Stewart.
    Harold Ramirez on the other hand has the effort and a good bat. His issues, I believe, will be covering enough of the plate in the majors where the pitchers are much better at changing speeds and locating pitches. I comp’d him as a Rajai Davis.

    TL;DR- I don’t think anyone would be calling for Huntington’s head if the trade was our number 4 starter(with $18mm left on the contract), Rajai Davis, and Chris Stewart for a number 4 starter in the AL East with 2 years of arbitration left.

    Reply
    • stormie

      9 years ago

      You’re trying to make a point by already declaring what they’ll become, as if there’s no debate on that front. Obviously not everyone agrees with your assessments, so people have different views of the trade.

      And while Davis’ minors numbers look similar to Ramirez’s, he was significantly older than Ramirez at every stop. He didn’t even reach AA until he was 24; Ramirez is already hitting .306 there at 21.

      Reply
      • LumberJerk9Billion

        9 years ago

        I can’t do anything but agree with you on that. In fact, there’s nothing anyone can do until we see what becomes of all the players involved. Certainly my assessments could be wrong, I’m no paid scout, but I watched these players quite a bit and it seems like I’m the only one not jumping up and down calling for Huntington to be fired. I’m not just looking at the prospects list and deeming it bad, I’m offering a first hand look at these players, and they remind me very much of a 4th outfielder and backup catcher. Useful pieces, sure, but not something to dismiss a GM over.

        Reply
  52. ericl

    9 years ago

    I’m stunned that the Jays got this much for Drew Hutchison. I don’t even mind Liriano’s salary. He’s been a solid pitcher as recently as last year. Maybe he can turn it around in Toronto. However, to also get the Ramirez & McGuire in the deal is unreal. Hutchison has been nothing but inconsistent. He’s struggled on the road & has been struggling in AAA recently (16 runs in his last 3 starts). The Jays did quite well in this trade

    Reply
  53. dempsey77

    9 years ago

    Wow…this is an awful deal by NH! This is old school Pirates thinking. This trade was 110% FINANCIALLY driven, NOT baseball driven! And that really ticks me off. I don’t mind dealing Liriano and I don’t mind dealing Harold Ramirez (Because although he is a talented prospect on the offensive side of things, he defensive metrics are a bit Shakey AND more importantly than anything, he is BIGTIME blocked on the depth chart…HOWEVER, to include prospect like Reese McGuire in a deal that your ONLY return is a guy of Drew Hutchinson’s caliber and value is 110% IDIOTIC. REESE IS A TOP 100 PROSPECT FFS! This is a deplorable move on the Pirates end. The Blue Jay’s should be laughing the entire way to the podium to announce this deal… ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE in every way, shape, and form!

    Reply
  54. chesteraarthur

    9 years ago

    This seems like an awful, awful trade for the pirates

    Reply
  55. Darth Alru

    9 years ago

    And now I really like REALLY want to hear how good GM NH is and how many great smart basebal deals he made. Liriano and two top-10 prospects for a very mediocre starter? HOW IS THAT BS EVEN POSSIBLE? How stupid you should be to do that? Wow!

    Reply
  56. Kyle Jennison

    9 years ago

    One subplot: Pirates’ Neal Huntington was a longtime assistant for Blue Jays’ Mark Shapiro when they were both in Cleveland.

    Reply
    • szielinski 2

      9 years ago

      I have tinfoil hats for sale — cheap.

      Reply
  57. bucsfan32

    9 years ago

    Clearly, the Bucs are all about the buck$$$. The Pirates wo 92 games last year. NH did some off season shopping that provided some depth but the glaring weakness was starting pitching. Glasgow and company could not provide what was needed. As a fan, I am disappointed at the organization for not going about business as the other teams in town do. I agree that Liriano was struggling and considerations needed to made regarding him BUT… I had to read the article closely to make sure NH didn’t somehow ship Sydney Crosby north as well. Mr. Nutting, please give the Bucs more $$$$ so we can make it to Buctober.

    Reply
  58. TC06

    9 years ago

    This trade is a joke! NH and Nutting say their committed to winning? Right! They are committed to winning if it doesn’t cost more than 80-85 million in payroll a year! What a joke! Please sell the team Nutting!!

    Reply
  59. stratcrowder

    9 years ago

    Yep

    Reply
  60. rmwrmwrmw

    9 years ago

    Clearly the Pirates see a mechanical flaw in Hutchisons delivery that they think they can fix. It is known that the pitching coaches are well known to do that. Don’t forget Hutchison won 13 or 14 games in 2014 and was the Jays opening day pitcher last year.
    Ironically the Coaching staff in Pittsburgh was able to materially imorove JA Happs pitching performance to the point that the Jays brought him back as opposed to signing David Price, the choice of the braying masses. Looks to be a good move now.
    So the Pittsburgh fans should give allowances for the expertise of their coaching staff which appears to be exceptional

    Reply
  61. bsteady powers

    9 years ago

    It’s still an overpay for salary relief. Hands down a bad move. If they only added 1 prospect I could see it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment

    Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Braves Select Craig Kimbrel

    Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox

    White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel

    Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!

    Pablo Lopez To Miss Multiple Months With Teres Major Strain

    MLB To Propose Automatic Ball-Strike Challenge System For 2026

    Giants Designate LaMonte Wade Jr., Sign Dominic Smith

    Reds Sign Wade Miley, Place Hunter Greene On Injured List

    Padres Interested In Jarren Duran

    Royals Promote Jac Caglianone

    Mariners Promote Cole Young, Activate Bryce Miller

    2025-26 MLB Free Agent Power Rankings: May Edition

    Evan Phillips To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    AJ Smith-Shawver Diagnosed With Torn UCL

    Reds Trade Alexis Díaz To Dodgers

    Rockies Sign Orlando Arcia

    Ronel Blanco To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Joc Pederson Suffers Right Hand Fracture

    Recent

    Blue Jays Recall Spencer Turnbull For Season Debut

    Orioles Notes: Westburg, Mullins, O’Neill

    Tigers Notes: Vierling, Olson, Urquidy, Boyd

    Twins Place Zebby Matthews On 15-Day IL, Reinstate Danny Coulombe

    Yankees Claim CJ Alexander

    Phillies Claim Ryan Cusick, Designate Kyle Tyler

    Brewers Claim Drew Avans

    White Sox Sign Tyler Alexander, Place Jared Shuster On 15-Day IL

    Orioles Designate Matt Bowman For Assignment

    Diamondbacks Select Kyle Backhus, Designate Aramis Garcia

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version