Headlines

Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Sonny Gray Trade Rumors: Sunday

By | at

Sonny Gray’s scheduled Sunday start has already been pushed back to Monday, and as of yesterday, the Yankees were widely rumored to be the favorite to land the Oakland ace. Generally, though, the state of play does not appear to have changed all that much much as of this afternoon. Still, there will be plenty of rumors on Gray flying around from this point forward, and we’ll track them all in this post…

  • Indications from this morning are that the Yankees remain focused on pursuing Gray rather than a rental arm, as Jon Heyman of Fan Rag writes. New York has added lefty Jaime Garcia from the Twins, of course, but that acquisition reportedly will not deter their pursuit of Gray — who’d likely bump Garcia to the pen if he’s added.
  • At this point, though, talks between the Yanks and A’s are at something of a stalemate, according to Joel Sherman of the New York Post. There are suggestions on both sides that the teams will stick to their valuations even with the pressure of the deadline. And that means there’s somewhat “less optimism” that there’ll be a deal sending Gray to the Bronx. Indeed, per Sherman, there hasn’t been much new dialogue of note between New York and Oakland over the last day.
  • Meanwhile, the Dodgers are still talking with the A’s about Gray, MLB.com’s Jon Morosi tweets. But it’s also possible, he notes, that the ongoing dialogue is as much about maintaining leverage as it is due to serious, mutual interest.
newest oldest

Comments

    • Not a chance. More like Florial, Abreu, Park, and Acevedo. Can’t get Florial and Torres in the same deal.

    • No way in hell do the Yanks give up Torres. Mateo or Florial, Abreu and Acevedo.

      • So if no top prospects are on the table for Gray just be pleased with getting garcia.

        4

        • “Just because they aren’t the top 10 Yankees prospects, doesn’t mean they won’t be #2 or #3 in the A’s system.” -Vinny from the Bronx.

          1

        • #3 in A’s system – Matt Chapman (Top Prospect #91)

          #5 in Yankees system – Estevan Florial (Top Prospect #90)

          Yankees #5 is barely better than A’s #3 (according to MLB … his defense has been AWESOME, also hit 6 HR over 26 games), so ‘Vinny from the Bronx’ is full of crap.

          3

        • Texas will want at least 1 top 10 prospect since they can QO Darvish and get a 1st round draft choice.

        • Be prepared to give up the same level of talent. Rangers not just giving Darvish away, even if a rental.

        • What’s your definition of top prospects? Mateo and Florial are top 100 guy.

        • I don’t think Mateo is, but I read he is basically top 110 (if that means much)

        • “What’s your definition of top prospects?”

          The MLB Top 100 Prospect List (already updated with recent trades), that’s what.

        • According to Baseball America mid-season top 100

          Athletics
          #26 Baretto
          #27 Puk
          #94 Chapman

          Yankees
          #3 Torress
          #36 Rutherford (traded)
          #49 Frazier
          #56 Adams
          #71 Florial
          #73 Sheffield
          #89 Fowler

          Things done changed. Yanks prospects 3-7 would be ahead of your #3. Of course it’s all subjective but I think you get the point.

    • Torres isn’t going I’d bet my life. Yankees have best GM in baseball

      • I wish I could fail most of the last 5 years despite having the most resources and be considered the best at my job

        3

      • The importance of this trade is pretty immense for the A’s. They have small handful of young players/ prospects that look like they will be future All Stars (Chapman, Barreto, Manea, Healy……) Beane should not give in at all for a lesser package. Quintana was acquired for Jimenez and he is the #7 prospect in the league. I

        I don’t want Frazier. Give the Yanks Gray, Alonso and a top 10 A’s prospect and get Torres and Florial and some low end prospects. Don’t go for quantity like some of the trades in the past but go for quality.

        Basically, If the A’s get Torres & Florial the A’s rebuild last 1.5 years and not 3 Years.

        • Couldn’t agree with you more. Quintana’s ERA was over 4 and he had the Windy City to help his stats. And white six still landed eloy?! Billy better get something better. Sonny could outpitch quintana any day of the week.

    • I like it. Best pen ever. Trade for Darvish too and make him long relief. Lol

  3. I think you you meant bump Garcia to the pen not Grey. I dont see Grey coming out of the pen anytime soon

    1

  7. I think he meant “Bump Montgomery to the pen” he’s reaching his limit in innings

  9. Sounds more like Cashman is just doing this for show and say on Monday he couldn’t let go of his top prospects. Media and fans will praise him as being tough. If Cashman truly wanted Gray he would be in pin stripes already. From what has been said Cashman has only offered 1 of his top 10 prospects for Gray and a bunch of low minor nobodies. Sounds like this is all for show.

    1

      • Beane told clubs what he wants for Gray so he made it clear. B=rewers passed when asked for Brinson. Cashman knows the cost so sounds like he has passed too.

        1

        • Which I’m still confused over. Brinson is batting .112 and just got re-called from triple-a last week because he couldn’t hit big league pitching. And brewers still won’t give him up for sonny?! I hope cubs blow right past them and brewers regret not making the trade for sonny.

    • I guess fans read what they want and dismiss the rest…from this site:

      “The two sides are currently discussing other players and still have not reached an agreement. In fact, Morosi tweets that the A’s prefer another Yankees prospect, Estevan Florial, to Frazier because of his center field defense”.

      and..

      “ival clubs believe that most teams have informed the Athletics which centerpieces they’re willing to part with in a potential trade for right-hander with Sonny Gray, adding that the Yankees are believed to be the front-runners”.

      The A’s want Florial and others. Yanks feel like their offer is the best on the table. Why bid against yourself?

      2

  10. A’s dont have to trade by the deadline. 2 years club control left. Yanks don’t want to pay then they have the free agent market to buy from.

    3

    • They don’t have too but now or never. Yanks are in the lead. Dodgers never give up prospects. Cashman set to win this

      • “Dodgers never give up prospects.”

        Except for Cotton, Montas, and Holmes.

        For two rentals.

        4

        • None of whom were in the top echelon of their prospects. Holmes had dropped and the other two never were.

        • And de Leon and Headley. At the deadline last year, de Leon was ranked the dodgers 2nd best prospect and Holmes their third, they have traded both since then. No they didn’t trade Urias, largely because he was MLB ready, showed by him helping them down the stretch.

          1

    • You Red Sox need a GM Dombroski is stupid and Price is a punk. You can’t win with that clubhouse.

  12. I’m already happy with the yanks this year . I don’t want to trade any of the kids for at least another year. We need to find out how their minor league pitchers are . I think Gray has too many injuries to take a chance now .

    1

    • He hasn’t been the beacon of health but it’s been way over blown. He has has missed like 15 starts in his career and 95% came in 2016. I get that it’s fresh in people’s mind but he is healthy now and pitching like the boarderline ace he is. He would easily slot as the Yankees #1. I get the not wanting the Yanks to trade Torres or Fraizer, but Sonny Gray comes with 2.2 years of control and will be your team’s #1 starter.

      2

      • Time will tell. Houston has been mediocre the last 2 weeks. Injuries will have a lot to do with it. Its all about being healthy. Yankees had a lot of injuries early on, ( and now) and Houston has been bitten recently. McCullers has been awful as the #2 starter lately.

      • I bet people said the same thing about the 2001 mariners. Since the wild card era the teams to get to the WS the majority did not have the best record in the league. 09 Yankees and 16 cubs being the most recent examples. Once you get to the playoffs everything is a toss up of whoever gets hot.

        1

      • If Yankees win AL East, then they likely would not face Houston (if those teams advanced) until ALCS. In all likelihood, Houston will be playing AL Wildcard winner in ALDS (which of course could be the Yankees).

  13. Yankees fans value their prospects way to much. Gleyber Torres, Clint Frazie, Mateo, and Andujar would be my untouchables in the farm.

    Florial is a single A hitter who’s whiffed 33% of the time this year. You have no clue what he will turn out to be.

    Acevedo has to show me a lot more. He’s 23 and still going through the minors and isn’t a top 5 guy in the organization. 23 is old in prospect terms.

    Not every prospect works out and usually they won’t. I’ve seen the song and dance before of holding on to guys Ian Kennedy, Joba, Phil Hughes were supposed to be 3 aces in the rotation. One is out of the league, ones career is about to be over from injury, and one turned out to be an average 3/4 starter. And average is being generous. Let’s talk the killer Bs as they were proclaimed Betances, Banuelos, Brackman were held out of so many packages. They were supposed to be the future and in the rotation. Banuelos is toiling away in the minors. Brackman retired. Betances had huge control issues and moved to bullpen which has worked out great but he was supposed to be a starter and failed at that. If his first year or two as a reliever didn’t work in the minors he probably would of been let go.
    You can’t save everyone in rule 5 draft either.

    1

    • We havent had legit prospects in forever. Thats why we value finally having a strong farm system.

    • Every team values their prospects too much, even GMs. However, don’t sit an act like it’s a Yankee thing.

      Also, it’s not just about how you value your own prospects. it’s also about how you value the player you’re trading for. Maybe the Yanks would trade those guys for a “Sale” top player and not for Gray. Gray is not elite therefore not worth 2 elite prospects. Yanks are ahead of schedule.

      1

    • Yeah, Betances never worked out as a starter. You know who else was a failed starter? Mariano Rivera, and I’d say moving him to the bullpen worked out just fine for 20 years. He’s only the all-time saves leader, a record that will probably never be broken.

      I’m not saying Betances is Mo, but when he’s on, he’s pretty damn close.

  14. The Yankees are already in the post season race. The A’s are in no position to hustle the Yankees. Sonny wont be worth anything to them after the trade deadline. Don’t want what we are offering, that’s ok, we’ll go forward with what we got.

    2

    • “The A’s are in no position to hustle the Yankees”

      Sure they are, they have someone the Yankees want.

      “Sonny wont be worth anything to them after the trade deadline”

      Two years of cheap high-level pitching is worthless?

      Sensing a lot of sour grapes suddenly.

      • darkside on wrong side of facts. Gray 2 years left after this year so his value is almost the same. More clubs in the off season need a starter than now. Cost will go up for NYY because they will need to spend 100 million to get starting pitching next year..

        1

        • I hear Cueto wants to finish his career in the AL … if he suddenly puts himself back together, gets his ERA comfortably under 4, and opts out of the 4/84 the giants still owe him.

        • If cueto opps out he wants more than a 4/84 from NYY so you end up spending over $100 million for a #3 starter.

          1

        • The cost won’t go up. If anything, the payment changes, The Yanks would rather sign Darvish to a free agent contract and keep the prospects. That gives them the best of both worlds. Cash is in abundance. High level talent and under market value isn’t.

          Let Gray hit the open market in a trade situation vs Darvish as a FA and I guarantee you they’ll be more interest in Darvish amongst teams that can afford his terms.

        • “Let Gray hit the open market in a trade situation vs Darvish as FA ”

          So, ones’ price is in prospects and the other’s is cash … stacking the deck much?

        • Darvish is injury prone more than Gray so put all your eggs in one basket and pay him $25 million a year for the next 6 years. Keep the prospects. Of course Cashman can do that but its a very big gamble on him.

        • It is what it is. The Yanks greatest resource is money. If they can build a team by keeping as many prospects as possible and then re-purposing the money coming of the books then that’s the recipe for the Yanks.

      • sour grapes for a pitcher with the letters DL instead of a number on his uniform. I don’ think so.
        If Sonny had that much value, the A’s would keep him as part of their perpetual rebuilding. We are taking a gamble he doesn’t hit the DL at any moment. The A’s have the best deal they are going to get from us. Like I said, our staff already has us in the race. The Yankees go into the off season free agent market with a load of money to spend on Pitchers.
        Let me add,,.the stats of A’s pitcher not pitching in the coliseum is not a pretty read

    • Serious Fishing Expedition going on by the A’s. Beane isn’t dumb. He is probably “setting the market” for next winter

      Sonny stays with the A’s…..

  16. Yankees will have to pay to play if they really want Gray. Will cost them one of their Top 5 prospects,one of their 15-20 ranked prospects and 1 or 2 lower level, young prospects. No reason for Oakland to trade Gray for anything less than this. He’s young, cheap and controllable. So it’s time for Cashman to either pay up or shut up.

    2

    • Bo man couldn’t have said it any better my friend! Panzy fans! Sorry Yankee fans lol

      • If I were you and Mr Bosoxwin, I would worry about your Red Sox rather than what the Yankees are doing.
        Well let’s see….you screwed up the Panda thing, and now it looks as if Price is going to tear the team apart with his attitude directed towards a Hall of Fame pitcher and good news, he’s signed for over 200 million and you’ve got him signed for years ahead. Good luck, and PS: You guys aren’t “pansy” just jerks!

        1

    • No, they will just wait until Beane gets itchy on Monday. Gray is getting moved. His value won’t be higher than right now. His injury history will become an issue in the off-season that they won’t get the value in the winter that they’d get now.

      A’s homers and apologists don’t want to hear that, though.

      1

    • So why are the A’s, a team with one of the lowest payrolls, currently in last place and having immense problems with the health of performance of their own SP staff so willing to move this productive and relatively cheap asset again?

      A’s seem highly motivated to move Gray my friend. Why? He’s affordable for them right? They have 4 guys who’ve pitched 10 games or more and 3 are on the DL and 3 have an ERA above 5. Why don’t the A’s just keep him and let him be there ace for the next 2 seasons?

      Please stop telling me the As can keep him. Yes they can. Obviously they don;t want to.

      • A’s goal is not contending now but in 2 years when Gray will be leaving so trade him now before his value goes low in the walk year. they want good young impact prospects to help them during their championship run. There goal is not to collect as many prospects as they can and hope they will be legit players. they want more sure thing young impact players. A’s have enough young players at each position but want above average players.
        Obvious Beane is not desperate to trade Gray or he would have already done so. Why do you think he wanted Brinson from Brewers? Impact player. Florial is a good defensive CF with no power. Mateo is a poor defensive player that can hit. So obviously they are not impact players. That is why Cashman is highly motivated to move them but not Torres or Frazier. A’s only trade chip right now is Gray. The others players couldn’t bring in a impact prospect. So why should he settle than wait for the right player the team needs.

  18. Beane and Cashman know by now what Gray is worth, we don’t! The A’s don’t have to trade Gray if they don’t like the offer, but i do believe from all reports the Yanks have the best offer on the table. Good GMs will wait until the last minute to get the best offer, but it could backfire on the A’s if Cashman decides to go after Lynn or Darvish. Either way the Yanks will be in the playoffs and the A’s will continue to rebuild their team.

    • It doesn’t backfire because he can still be traded later. If Gray was a FA at the end of the season it would be stupid for Beane to insist on a better deal.

      1

    • How can it back fire??? They get him for another 2 years and pretty cheap!

      1

      • It Can backfire if gray gets injured or struggles down the stretch it will cause him to lose value

    • Dude there’s nothing written in stone about playoffs. This team is super streaky and being in first on July 30 means absolutely nothing. The Red Sox are slumping and could easily win 9 out of ten and be up by 4 or 5 the second week of August. Yankee fans please stop counting your chickens by being so smug with these statements. Please also stop with coveting these prospects like they’re stepping in this year or even the next three to make a difference. If they get Gray then the playoffs may well happen,but none of these pitching prospects are making the difference. Florial,Mateo,Sheffield,and a lower prospect hopefully get it done.

      1

  19. Would love to know where the line in the sand has been drawn. None of us really know. If the A’s want Adams or Sheffield I would do it. If they still want Torres or Frazier (or Bird) I would not.

    • I think if Beane still wanted Torres and Frazier they would have moved on by now. I think that either Adams or Sheffield is the sticking point right now.

  20. Something I havent heard too much talk about, due to Alonso’s market restrictions limited to the Yanks and whoever has a big injury from now til September, the July deadline actually doesnt mean much in his case, right?

  21. Something tells me gray is going to be s dodger i think the signing of garcia and the dodger , A’s connection

  23. A’s don’t have to trade Gray now…can wait till the winter meetings. He won’t lose any value.
    ESPN gave Rick Hahn a “F” for not trading Sale at the deadline last year, even though best offer came at winter meetings. Hahn also got criticized for not trading Q before this season started.
    Beanie isn’t trying to win the World Series now… he can wait.

    • I agree. Cashman should just pull his offer and look elsewhere. Gray is a good pitcher but there are other alternatives out there.

      • Best other (non-rental) starting pitcher on the market is Verlander, who is arguably better, but comes with a HEFTY contract and is probably past his prime.

  24. Trolls aside. It’s looks like Cash and Beane will hold firm and fans of A’s and Yanks agree. No deal is best deal in this case.

    1

  25. In the end, Cashman will have to give in to get Gray.

    Final Trade Result:
    Yankees get Sonny & Alonso
    A’s get Torres, Florial, Abreu & Perez

    • Yanks don’t need Alonso & they aren’t trading Torres. Other than that it looks good.

      2

      • If Billy accepts trade without Torres, I can see it looking like this:

        Yanks get Sonny & Alonso
        A’s get Florial, Mateo, Abreu, Perez & McKinney

        *Yanks must take Alonso in trade to get it done.

        1

    • Cashman isn’t trading Torres. He’s already stated this over and over again. If he wasn’t offering Torres for Quintana, what makes you think he’ll all of a sudden change his tune and offer him for Gray? Let’s be serious here.

      2

  26. As I’ve said for the past month and continually got ridiculed about it. I do t think the A’s will trade Gray. They are putting to high of a value on him and they do not need to trade him right now. They could do it this summer or even a year from now

  28. The Braves are too desperate and they have the pieces. He’s going to Atlanta.

  29. I think the braves could get it done with Albies, Maitain , Wentz or Gohara and another lower

    • That is steep, I think it is possible with Albies, Pache and Gohara/Wentz though I would happily take Maitan :D

Leave a Reply

MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

hide arrowsFOX Sports Engage Network scroll to top