Baltimore moved on from Brandon Hyde during the 2025 season, but they’ll replace him this year with another former catcher. New manager Craig Albernaz was a backstop for nine seasons in the minors. After his playing career wrapped up, he entered the coaching ranks. Albernaz’s first gig at the major-league level was as a catching instructor and bench coach with the Giants.
Albernaz’s lengthy catching experience as a player and coach could come in handy with Baltimore. Adley Rutschman and Samuel Basallo are two of the club’s key players, both for 2026 and beyond.
“I’m excited,” Albernaz told reporters earlier this month, including Roch Kubatko of MASN Sports. “Adley and Basallo both have a ton of talent. Obviously, Basallo coming in, relatively not a lot of experience at the big league level, but you just see the talent jump right at you. And Adley, even before he got to the big leagues, and his pedigree behind the plate.”
The trade of Alex Jackson on Friday could increase Baltimore’s reliance on Rutschman and Basallo. Jackson has mostly been a backup in his career, but he had the second-most plate appearances at catcher for Baltimore last season. There was a chance the team would carry all three catchers next year. Basallo started 20 games behind the plate, but also made a pair of starts at first base and spent time at DH. Scouting reports aren’t glowing about his defensive capabilities, outside of a strong arm. FanGraphs gave him a 30 scouting grade for his current fielding ability and a 40 future grade. MLB.com was more generous, though a 45 fielding grade still isn’t ideal.
Rutschman had 18 appearances at DH in 2025, though oblique issues limited him to a career-low 90 games. He had at least 45 DH appearances in both 2023 and 2024. Rutschman is a solid defender, but injuries have limited his offensive production in back-to-back seasons. The backstop took a ball off the hand midway through the 2024 season. He didn’t go on the IL, but hit just .200 over the final three months of the season. Rutschman strained both his left and his right obliques this past season. He managed just 365 plate appearances, his fewest since his first professional season in 2019.
Albernaz has worked with some strong options behind the plate in his coaching career. Buster Posey’s final year in San Francisco was Albernaz’s first full season as catching instructor. Albernaz’s final season with the team saw Patrick Bailey emerge as an everyday option. Bailey hasn’t been much of an offensive contributor, but he’s been elite at pitching framing and controlling the running game. He’s a two-time Gold Glove winner. Rutschman might not be Posey and Basallo probably won’t be Bailey, but figuring out how to utilize both players will be key for Albernaz.
“I’m biased toward catching, having a great tandem behind the plate should help us win a lot of games in itself, and with those two guys, I’m going to lean on them a lot,” Albernaz said. “I’m going to give them a lot of information as far as how to help lead this team, our pitching staff, and also hold the coaches accountable. Because a high-functioning team, those catchers are involved in a lot of the process.”
Photo courtesy of Daniel Kucin Jr., Imagn Images.
Hopefully he can get some consistency for holding runners/catching base stealers. Basallo had a really good percentage of cs% at 38% in a small sample size. Adley definitely needs to pick it up in that area at 22% for his career. It doesn’t have to be some crazy high percentage of caught stealing, but both the pitchers and catchers do need to be more consistent at keeping runners honest. Sounds like Albernaz is definitely going to make it a point to nail down how his catchers handle things.
Based on the eye test, Rutsch throws the ball into the outfield as often as he catches the runner. I remember his pop time being hailed when he was in the minors, but I never expected his throwing to be so scattershot
I remember looking at his pop time somewhat recently and seeing it still be pretty good. But based on percentages its either on the pitcher being late to the plate or just not good throws.
Basallo outperformed Adley in controlling the running game in the minors. Actually he outperformed everyone.
True, I think he just needs to familiarize himself with the pitching staff. I remember he and kremer were crossed up at one point and kremer kinda laid into him a bit and it was caught on camera on the way back to the dugout. Which wasn’t a good look but basallo does look like the better defensive option at the very least against the run game.
This needs to be a big bounce back year for Adley now that he’s been on a little bit of a decline over the last year and a half. Injuries have much to do with it I’m sure, so hopefully he comes into camp ready and healthy and stays that way throughout the season.
It seems like his breakup with his girlfriend last summer when she moved to the west coast of Canada really messed up his head.
@ChickenMan: Love….. it’s a MFer, eh?
It’s going to be interesting how framing evolves with the new rules. I’m sure it will still be involved but less likely in high leverage situations. I hope Albernaz can help with the catching situation in Baltimore.
I hope he does more than help with catching. CLE guys had a lot of respect for him. Wish him well
Good luck in Baltimore Albie, we will miss you in SF, you were great!
He hasn’t been in SF since 2023
They both need to have a healthy year. Their catching prospects are very thin. Their top catching prospect was in A-ball last year and their 2nd was in AA.
Can’t afford Adley so might as well trade him before he moves to NY a la Mussin