Headlines

  • Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment
  • Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery
  • Braves Select Craig Kimbrel
  • Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox
  • White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel
  • Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Orioles Acquire Andrew Miller

By Jeff Todd | July 31, 2014 at 2:45pm CDT

The Orioles have issued an announcement of the 1-for-1 swap of lefties. Baltimore will acquire Red Sox reliever Andrew Miller, as Jerry Crasnick of ESPN.com first reported (via Twitter).

In return, Boston has picked up left-handed pitching prospect Eduardo Rodriguez, per a tweet from Roch Kubatko of MASNsports.com. Sean McAdam of CSNNE.com (via Twitter) first reported that a young arm was included in the deal.

MLB: Boston Red Sox at Detroit Tigers

Rodriguez represents a significant return for Boston on Miller, who emerged as the most sought-after left-handed reliever but is set to reach free agency at year’s end. He had been nothing short of dominant this year, posting 14.7 K/9 against 2.8 BB/9 and generating a 52.5% groundball rate.

Miller’s excellent 2.34 ERA is actually higher than advanced metrics would suggest, as Miller owns lower marks per ERA estimators such as FIP (1.69), xFIP (1.76) and SIERA (1.42). Miller has held down both lefties (.420 OPS) and righties (.537 OPS) on the year.

Rodriguez came into the year as Baltimore’s 3rd-best overall prospect, per Baseball America. The 21-year-old has not taken a step forward at Double-A, however, as he owns a 4.79 ERA with 7.5 K/9 against 3.2 BB/9 through 82 2/3 innings on the year. Though he profiles more as a middle-of-the-rotation arm, Rodriguez had been on a fast track to the big leagues and still has plenty of value.

Share 103 Retweet 185 Send via email31

Baltimore Orioles Boston Red Sox Newsstand Transactions Andrew Miller

Mariners Acquire Chris Denorfia
Main
Nationals Acquire Asdrubal Cabrera
View Comments (190)
Post a Comment

190 Comments

  1. Ben_Cherington

    11 years ago

    Fantastic!

    Reply
  2. The_Porcupine

    11 years ago

    If you have an iffy rotation, beef up the pen. Hope the O’s didn’t overpay

    Reply
    • rovert22044

      11 years ago

      Not sure if this is a fried chicken joke…?

      Reply
    • GOOREOS

      11 years ago

      3.14 ERA over the last 45 days isn’t all that iffy

      Reply
  3. ugotrpk3113

    11 years ago

    Err… Rodriguez. Sorry, wrong name.

    Reply
    • Guest 3659

      11 years ago

      Way too much?

      Reply
      • seren1tyn0w

        11 years ago

        yes

        Reply
      • Brian 38

        11 years ago

        Perhaps. But I’ve never been on the E-Rod hype-wagon… Miller is one of, if not, the best bullpen arms available. As an O’s fan I like the deal. Probably a good deal for the Sox too.

        Reply
      • Brian 38

        11 years ago

        Perhaps. But I’ve never been on the E-Rod hype-wagon… Miller is one of, if not, the best bullpen arms available. As an O’s fan I like the deal. Probably a good deal for the Sox too.

        Reply
  4. Doms

    11 years ago

    This will give an idea of the price of interdivision trade

    Reply
    • Kevin 23

      11 years ago

      Its a rental Interdivision does not matter

      Reply
      • Doms

        11 years ago

        I think it does, no rivals want to help bolster another’s roster and help them win a WS. They got the teams #3 prospect. I think that’s a lot for a “rental”

        Reply
        • UVAguy81

          11 years ago

          Rodriguez has been awful this year in Bowie. Hitters look like they’ve adjusted and he hasn’t made the necessary changes to counter act that.

          Reply
    • Tvators

      11 years ago

      Not really since two others teams not in Sox division back out of deals bc price was too high…

      Reply
  5. Nicolas_C

    11 years ago

    The Red Sox are doing well today!

    Reply
  6. Ace2095

    11 years ago

    Is it at least a good minor league pitcher? 😛

    Reply
  7. seth

    11 years ago

    My sources tell me it is Dylan Bundy

    Reply
    • Rally Weimaraner

      11 years ago

      Yep, Red Sox made him wear Rodriquez’s jersey until he got to Boston.

      Reply
  8. GoAwayNow

    11 years ago

    Its like Christmas morning! What is in this present?

    Reply
    • Ben_Cherington

      11 years ago

      a bag of coal…merry freakin christmas. Now, goaway

      Reply
      • GoAwayNow

        11 years ago

        I’d say socks. Lots and lots of socks today.

        Reply
  9. Letsgolos

    11 years ago

    Ken Rosenthal said it’s Eduardo Rodriguez.

    Reply
  10. Theo The Gorilla

    11 years ago

    For whom?

    Reply
  11. coreybishop

    11 years ago

    What the heck man??? The Braves could have beat this offer!! Who in the world is answering a phone in Atlanta????

    Reply
    • Mike Query

      11 years ago

      Rodriguez is the 60th best prospect in baseball. I dont wanna trade Lucas Sims for 30 innings of a reliever. Huge overpay.

      Reply
      • GOOREOS

        11 years ago

        Over-rated by BBA and O’s fans because he’s a lefty who throws hard… not all that special and will be a major bust. At best he’s a left match-up man out of the pen… most likely a AAAA pitcher who bounces around for a few years.

        Reply
        • Brian 38

          11 years ago

          Not overrated by this O’s fan. You guys got shiny Etzel for a rental of one of the best bullpen arms available.

          Reply
      • GOOREOS

        11 years ago

        Don’t’ be surprised if he isn’t on that list next year.

        Reply
        • ishkabibble

          11 years ago

          Rodriguez is 21 in a league where the average pitcher is 3 to 4 years older.

          Reply
          • Yankees420

            11 years ago

            The average age of pitchers in AA is 24-25? I’m asking in earnest, do you have a source?

            Reply
    • Steve_in_MA

      11 years ago

      Not really. Lucas Sims is about the only thing you have that’s close and he’s a right hander.

      Reply
  12. MeowMeow

    11 years ago

    Middling return for Lester/Gomes, peanuts for Lackey, Orioles’ #3 prospect for Miller.

    I don’t understand anything anymore.

    Reply
    • ugotrpk3113

      11 years ago

      This is what happens when Henry and company are more worried about filling the seats. They were so worried about being bad next year that they made silly decisions.

      Reply
      • Ben_Cherington

        11 years ago

        Im a puppet.

        Reply
    • Charles Tetrick

      11 years ago

      Cespedes, Craig and Kelly are all MLB talent that will be with Boston next year with a handshake agreement to sign Lester this Offseason they Sox got alot to be competitive next year.

      Reply
      • MeowMeow

        11 years ago

        Calling Craig and Kelly “talent” right now is a blatant misuse of that word. Craig is rocking a negative WAR right now. Joe Kelly is iffy. Cespedes is alright, but only around for 2015.

        And this “handshake agreement” talk is all speculation that non-Sox fans like to talk about. I don’t buy it for a second.

        Reply
        • John Cate

          11 years ago

          You’re right. A guy with a 3.25 career ERA in 266 major-league innings isn’t good enough to be a #5 starter…

          …on the 1968 Dodgers.

          Reply
          • MeowMeow

            11 years ago

            Okay, my bad on Kelly, I was walking and was reading K/9 as ERA xD

            Reply
            • Bob Bunker

              11 years ago

              Player 1 2014 3.93 FIP, 3.72 XFIP, 6.43 K/9, .77 HR/9

              Player 2 2014 3.87 FIP, 3.83 XFIP, 5.38 K/9, 1.00 HR/9

              PLayer 1 is Joe Kelly and PLayer 2 is Doug Fister guess Fister is awful xD

              Reply
              • MeowMeow

                11 years ago

                I literally just admitted that I was reading the wrong columns

                Reply
                • Bob Bunker

                  11 years ago

                  Well earlier you said the return for Lackey was two awful players… Also, you have continuously said the the trades were no where near fair value and commented as someone that would know which column to look at on a website…

                  Reply
                  • MeowMeow

                    11 years ago

                    I was walking home from work, cut me some slack.

                    For someone who criticized my reasoning earlier, you’re pretty quick to use a brief error of attention as a strawman for my whole body of reasoning

                    Reply
                    • Bob Bunker

                      11 years ago

                      Alright fair enough. I apologize for my rudeness.

                      Reply
        • GrayhawkAZ

          11 years ago

          I was going to say Craig is 30 and was losing playing time to Tavares

          Reply
          • Brian 38

            11 years ago

            Playing time doesn’t matter. StL depth is their problem. The fact that he hasn’t been hitting this year does matter…

            Reply
        • Better

          11 years ago

          I buy it 100% and I’m a Sox fan. Reading between the line for the last 3 months leads me to believe both sides (Lester and Sox) had something up their sleeves as far as Jon coming back.

          Reply
          • Jeff Scott

            11 years ago

            Agree. Doesn’t hurt that they sent him to Oakland–a team without the resources to keep him. Red Sox will have Lester in 2015.

            Reply
            • John Cate

              11 years ago

              And if we don’t have Lester, we’ll have Scherzer or Shields or trade for someone like them. The Yankees can’t sign all of them.

              Reply
        • Bob Bunker

          11 years ago

          One season of negative WAR and Allen Craig has no talent. Guess Matt Kemp is talentless and Bryce Harper and Carlos Gonzales and lots of other players having bad years. One year doesn’t mean everything.

          Reply
        • MaineBaseball

          11 years ago

          Lester is bound to be a FA. They weren’t going to pound out an extension before the end of the year. So even if they lose him they got a whole year of Cespedes and a 2nd round pick rather than a 1st round pick for losing him. Sounds good to me. There is also the real possibility they resign Lester and have Lester AND Cespedes next year.

          Now the Lackey trade: Lackey is going to be 36 years old. Joe Kelly is 10 years younger, has a 3.25 career ERA, and could be a very nice 3 or 4 starter for the Sox. They’re sort of buying low on Craig in a way. He was a .300 hitter in 2012 and 2013 but has scuffled this year. He could easily turn it around at Fenway.

          Miller trade: They got another young arm that they could use in a package for a marquee player this offseason.

          I have no doubt in Ben and I believe that the Red Sox will have a competitive team next year. The roster will look drastically different but BE PATIENT. It’s a good day to be a Red Sox fan.

          Reply
          • Brian 38

            11 years ago

            Probably the most insightful Sox perspective comment to here.

            Reply
            • MaineBaseball

              11 years ago

              Thank you!

              Reply
          • John Cate

            11 years ago

            Thanks. A voice of reason. This is the same front office that built a 69-win team into a World Champion in one off-season. It might be a little much to expect that to happen again, but the Red Sox know what they’re doing. They just acquired a good 26-year-old pitcher with 4.5 years of club control and a power-hitting outfielder who hits 25 homers a season despite playing in one of the worst hitters’ parks in baseball. He could bust out in a big way in Fenway.

            Reply
            • Jeff Scott

              11 years ago

              Yes, I was thinking the same thing about Cespedes–Fenway is a MUCH friendlier hitter’s park.

              Reply
            • MaineBaseball

              11 years ago

              Agreed!

              Reply
        • Brian 38

          11 years ago

          I hope the Cubs sign him!

          Reply
    • Wojo

      11 years ago

      My other post got deleted, but: Please explain to me how they were awful trades? Lester was gone in 2 months, so instead of a pick we get a bonafide MLB OF ( i know he is only under contract for one year) and a pick. Lackey we get two MLB players under team control. One of which is one year removed from being an all-star. The other is a 26 year old who started game 3 of the World Series last year. So again, please explain to me how these are awful trades?

      Reply
      • MeowMeow

        11 years ago

        Sox. Should. Have. Gotten. More.

        Reply
    • MaineBaseball

      11 years ago

      I’m a Red Sox fan and I don’t understand how any Red Sox fan can dislike what the Sox have done for trades today.

      Reply
      • MeowMeow

        11 years ago

        They traded two top pitchers for pennies on the dollar?

        Reply
        • Better

          11 years ago

          They’ll get one of them back in a few months.

          Reply
    • Baseball Legend

      11 years ago

      Makes no sense whatsoever. Potentially their best return and likely most useful looking forward was obtained for a guy that just 16 months ago was banished to the south pole. I really deep down truly believe the Red Sox front office is in way over their heads. I often chuckled how much stock they put in draft picks, which when it comes down to it, that’s their strong side. Outside of that, this front office really has no business, well, doing business.

      Reply
    • Brian 38

      11 years ago

      Middling return? Cespedes through 2015 for $10.5m. Plenty of cash to resign Lester in the off-season and still have Cespedes in the middle of the order?
      The Sox wanted Lackey off the team. Period.
      E-Rod WAS the #3. He’s not even in the top 10 per MLB 2014 mid-season prospect listing.

      Reply
      • MeowMeow

        11 years ago

        Sox wanted Lackey off the team? What?

        E-Rod isn’t listed as the Orioles’ #3 anymore because he got moved to the Sox’s #10. He got traded, remember?

        Reply
        • Brian 38

          11 years ago

          Lackey is a quitter. Especially on a team that’s not contending. They wanted him off the team.
          Fine, he’s not on the O’s list anymore because he was traded. I’ll concede that point. If you’ll concede the FACT that E-Rod wasn’t in the O’s top 10 at the time of the trade (at least per the MLB 2014 mid-season prospect ranking by teams).
          (I feel like I’m arguing with my 5 year old daughter…)

          Reply
          • MeowMeow

            11 years ago

            He was though. I went to the MLB prospects page to see where he was, and he was #3. I didn’t know anything about him prior to this trade, so it’s not like I’m recalling old information.

            Also, you’re name-calling and *I’M* the one who’s like a 5-year old?

            Reply
            • Brian 38

              11 years ago

              You’re missing my point. He was #3 in the off-season. Before the trade MLB did a ‘refresh’ of the prospect ranking and E-Rod wasn’t in the O’s top 10. So, yes, you were recalling old information (just like the MLBTR article did).
              And my 5 year old comment was because she misses the point and brings up ‘he’s not #3 on the O’s list because he was traded’ type comments too.

              Reply
              • MeowMeow

                11 years ago

                I’m not going to have this argument xD When the article dropped, I was like “Who’s this guy?” I went to the page. He was listed as #3 on the Orioles prospect list. Now he’s #10 on Boston’s list.

                Also, given that he’s #10 for Boston, there’s no way he wasn’t in the top 10 for Baltimore. Boston has a much better system.

                Reply
              • MeowMeow

                11 years ago

                I’m not going to have this argument xD When the article dropped, I was like “Who’s this guy?” I went to the page. He was listed as #3 on the Orioles prospect list. Now he’s #10 on Boston’s list.

                Also, given that he’s #10 for Boston, there’s no way he wasn’t in the top 10 for Baltimore. Boston has a much better system.

                Reply
              • Bob Bunker

                11 years ago

                E-Rod was number 3 on the Os in the recently updated MLB midseason top prospects.

                Reply
          • MeowMeow

            11 years ago

            He was though. I went to the MLB prospects page to see where he was, and he was #3. I didn’t know anything about him prior to this trade, so it’s not like I’m recalling old information.

            Also, you’re name-calling and *I’M* the one who’s like a 5-year old?

            Reply
    • Rabbitov

      11 years ago

      Are you serious? I thought the Red Sox made out like bandits.

      Reply
      • MeowMeow

        11 years ago

        Like the bandits from Home Alone, maybe

        Reply
  13. Steve_in_MA

    11 years ago

    The Carabobo contingency continues.

    Reply
  14. Mochi

    11 years ago

    Eduardo Rodriguez was ranked #43 in MLB by Keith Law back in January.

    Reply
    • Kevin 23

      11 years ago

      Yeah and he has had an awful season repeating AA Bowie. He is 3-7 with a 4.79 era with blah peripherals.

      Reply
      • Damon Bowman

        11 years ago

        And he’s 21. How many 21-year olds tear it up as a starting pitcher at double-A?

        Reply
  15. ChrisSEA84

    11 years ago

    A top pitching prospect in return for 2 months of a reliever…. Wow…

    Reply
    • Fangaffes

      11 years ago

      Yeah, take a look at those “top prospect” stats. Could be a hard decade for the Os, if that’s the best they’ve got for pitching prospects.

      Reply
      • UVAguy81

        11 years ago

        I think Gausman will be fine. I just hope Dylan Bundy can recover fully from the Tommy John surgery he had last year and become the stud everyone envisioned. Still a while to go to see how Harvey pans out, even though he’s done for the year.

        Reply
        • Fangaffes

          11 years ago

          Who? I’m talking about Rodriguez. This is the Andrew Miller thread.

          Reply
          • UVAguy81

            11 years ago

            You were talking about the other prospects the O’s had and I was just listing them.

            Reply
  16. Remember92

    11 years ago

    Wonder if the Orioles try to move him back into the rotation?

    Reply
    • Bleed_Orange

      11 years ago

      Not on a two month rental

      Reply
  17. daro11

    11 years ago

    They got him for free -_-

    Reply
    • Ted

      11 years ago

      ? It’s a consensus top-75 prospect going back. Not an elite guy, sure, but a legit prospect.

      Reply
      • MeowMeow

        11 years ago

        Consensus top-75? He’s not even on MLB’s top 100 list

        Reply
        • OhthePossibilities

          11 years ago

          He was previously. Having a rough year.

          Reply
        • Ben_Cherington

          11 years ago

          I drew his name out of a hat. win some you lose some

          Reply
          • MeowMeow

            11 years ago

            That would explain a lot of today’s moves, really 😛

            Reply
        • Bleed_Orange

          11 years ago

          He’s been banged up this year which is why his numbers were so bad.

          Reply
        • Brian 38

          11 years ago

          Wait, I thought you liked E-Rod? Or are you just argumentative?

          Reply
          • MeowMeow

            11 years ago

            I liked that he was a top organizational prospect, but then I looked at his numbers.

            Reply
          • MeowMeow

            11 years ago

            I liked that he was a top organizational prospect, but then I looked at his numbers.

            Reply
        • Brian 38

          11 years ago

          Wait, I thought you liked E-Rod? Or are you just argumentative?

          Reply
        • Ted

          11 years ago

          Dunno what to tell ya. These are the numbers I got:
          Baseball America: #65
          MLB: #68
          Baseball Prospectus: #61

          Reply
          • MeowMeow

            11 years ago

            Those look like pre-season numbers?

            Reply
            • Ted

              11 years ago

              They are. I don’t really know what I’m talking about then… I thought that was all there was. I guess he’s fallen since then?

              Reply
              • MeowMeow

                11 years ago

                MLB updates their prospect list. You can go there right now like I did xD

                Reply
  18. The_Porcupine

    11 years ago

    eh…. I think it’s a bit of an overpay. Considering it is a 2 month rental for a reliever.

    Reply
    • Bleed_Orange

      11 years ago

      Huge overpay

      Reply
      • Jbruns318

        11 years ago

        I’ve never been impressed by Rodriguez, and he continues to disappoint this year, even if it is a two month rental we now have arguably the best 3 punch bullpen combo in baseball.

        Reply
        • Benjamin Rush

          11 years ago

          Agreed. Rodriguez is a soft tosser that was north of 4.00 ERA this year. Get value now to have the 7th-9th inning locked down before ERod dimishes his value even more.

          Diminished value is something that continues to happen to O’s prospects, like Britton (finally found a job), Matusz, Arrieta and Tillman to some degree. I like to see them finally get a great return for one of these “potential” players.

          Reply
          • Jbruns318

            11 years ago

            Couldn’t have put it any better. Everyone’s excuse for why this trade was bad on the O’s part is that he is only 21 years old, and they assume that he will get better, although they fail to look at what would happen if he gets worse. I’m just glad we moved him while his stock is still somewhat valuable.

            Reply
        • danistheguy

          11 years ago

          He’s extremely disappointing. His stuff is gone. 90 mph fastballs that don’t hit the corners. Seriously seriously average breaking stuff. Meh.

          Reply
  19. Phishfan52

    11 years ago

    Eduardo Rodriguez, Orioles were high on him a last year and having a rough season in Bowie AA this year.

    Reply
    • vtncsc

      11 years ago

      and Atlanta couldn’t have matched this for one of our biggest holes? Ugh.

      Reply
  20. Chris Vinnit

    11 years ago

    Of all the deals the Red Sox made today, it’s a rental reliever that nets them the best prospect? Does not compute.

    Reply
    • MeowMeow

      11 years ago

      That nets them any kind of prospect.

      Reply
      • Bob Bunker

        11 years ago

        Yeah lets throw out all years but 2014 and say Allen Craig is awful right… Makes sense. Guess Lester was a terrible player because he had a poor 2012 should have never given him a chance to rebound in 2013. Or you know Ortiz was done in 2010. Or Xander Bogaerts is an awful player because because after 450 PA in MLB he has a 89 WRC+.

        I agree with you though the best way to analyze players is on less then 400 plate appearances…

        Reply
        • MeowMeow

          11 years ago

          Yeah, Allen Craig used to be really good, and then this season he’s been awful. Maybe he’ll bounce back, and it’d be great, although who knows where his playing time will come from since his positions are all blocked by surer things.

          But as it stands, Allen Craig is terrible right now. They bought low on him. They really couldn’t do any better from team-friendly-contract Lackey than a buy-low bat and a #3-4 starter?

          Reply
          • Bob Bunker

            11 years ago

            A team friendly contract that many sources have said Lackey won’t play for in 2015??? And that if they traded Lester he would be even less likely to play in 2015 without an extension or with one.

            And for Lackey they got a guy making 24 million for his age 30-32 seasons who from 2011-2013 had a 140 WRC+ and can player corner OF/1B/DH or rotate around. Also, potentially allows them to trade Vic or Nap for pitching prospects.

            Not to many they got 4 years of Joe Kelly a guy who has a career 3.25 ERA for a total cost under 20 million most likely.

            I mean Lackey had value but not as much as you think and Craig and Kelly aren’t stars but definitely have more value then you seem to thing.

            Reply
            • MeowMeow

              11 years ago

              The MLBTR article said Lackey would honor the option. Can we finally put the Lackey might retire talk to rest?

              To say Allen Craig “can play” the OF is like saying I “can cook.”

              The Sox didn’t get enough for Lester OR for Lackey. These players would be alright, probably, if they weren’t the ONLY ones.

              Reply
              • Bob Bunker

                11 years ago

                The Lackey return was arguably better then what the Rays got for Price and the Lester return definitly was.

                Tell me what team would have given up more Major league proven ready to help the team contend in 2015 talent???

                Reply
                • MeowMeow

                  11 years ago

                  One season of Cespedes is “definitely” better than Drew Smyly through 2018 + Nick Franklin and a well regarded shortstop prospect? Are you seriously saying you don’t think the Sox could’ve at least gotten Milone too? And maybe a middling prospect?

                  That said, the return for Price was laughably low.

                  Reply
                  • Bob Bunker

                    11 years ago

                    Smyly has a lower FIP on the year then Joe Kelly and Nick Franklin has a career 82 WRC+ in 462 PA kind of like how Allen craig (part of the terrible return for Lackey according to you) has a 81 WRC+ this year in 400 PA except for the fact Craig has a career 123 WRC+ in 1800 PA.

                    Also, a Nick Franklin type player will most likely be available with the comp pick the Red Sox got.

                    Just going by your standards Cespedes who is a good player this year is the better return then Smyly and Frankling. Also, by standards in contending in 2015 Cespedes a 30 HR threat and top 30 OF in the game paying for ten million is better then Smyly and Franklin though I agree their additional years of control is nice.

                    Overall, I think the Lester, Lackey, and Price trade just shows that SP weren’t going to get as much in return as you, me, or most fans/analysts thought they were.

                    Reply
    • Bob Bunker

      11 years ago

      Maybe because the other trades weren’t for prospects but for proven MLB players…

      Reply
    • Rally Weimaraner

      11 years ago

      Cespedece>Rodriquez…. people are too high on prospect, most never play as projected

      Reply
    • Phishfan52

      11 years ago

      Not even that great of a prospect, AA numbers are terrible.

      Reply
      • snowbladerp14

        11 years ago

        he was a top 70 prospect coming into the year but yes he has struggled

        Reply
    • John Cate

      11 years ago

      The Red Sox weren’t trying to get prospects. It was pretty obvious that their goal is to build a winning team in 2015.

      If you look at their system, it makes sense anyway. They already have a ton of A and B-level prospects at AA and AAA, more than they can protect on the 40-man roster. Getting more really does them no good. Getting established major-league talent with an upside in return for veteran major-league talent makes more sense than prospects.

      Reply
    • John Cate

      11 years ago

      The Red Sox weren’t trying to get prospects. It was pretty obvious that their goal is to build a winning team in 2015.

      If you look at their system, it makes sense anyway. They already have a ton of A and B-level prospects at AA and AAA, more than they can protect on the 40-man roster. Getting more really does them no good. Getting established major-league talent with an upside in return for veteran major-league talent makes more sense than prospects.

      Reply
    • Brian 38

      11 years ago

      Because he’s not as good as the article makes him out to be…

      Reply
  21. SierraM363

    11 years ago

    Didn’t really expect Andrew Miller to have such an nice career in Boston. Win-Win for Both Miller and Cherington here.

    Reply
    • Ben_Cherington

      11 years ago

      Gracias

      Reply
  22. yawn

    11 years ago

    Orioles pitching prospect are terrible…….

    Reply
    • UVAguy81

      11 years ago

      Gausman looks like he will fare pretty well from what I’ve seen. Bundy just needs to get back in the swing of things this year after TJ surgery. Harvey is one I don’t know a lot about yet and probably won’t until next year since he is hurt and is done for the season.

      Reply
  23. William Turbeville

    11 years ago

    O’s back end of bullpen now about the best in the game. Miller has been dominant all year, and who’s to say we don’t sign him next year? Miller-O’Day- Britton. Lights out!

    Reply
    • Baloo

      11 years ago

      I hope we resign him too. The bullpen needed one more good lefty arm with Matusz stinking it up. Now it’s McFarland, Matusz, Hunter, Webb, Miller, O’Day, Britton. I really like the pen depth.

      Reply
    • UVAguy81

      11 years ago

      I do like the Miller addition but after seeing how the Rays didn’t get back nearly enough for Price (in my opinion), I would’ve liked to have seen what the O’s could’ve offered to Tampa to get him.

      Reply
  24. philpbarnes

    11 years ago

    Thats a nice return for 2 months of a relief pitcher. Miller will be a big piece for the Os too

    Reply
  25. Zach R

    11 years ago

    This is not a two month rental people. Miller is a free agent after 2015. He is arbitration-eligible at the end of this year.

    Reply
    • frogbogg

      11 years ago

      Sure… .the Andrew Miller for the Marlins. Not the one traded by the Sox.

      Reply
    • frogbogg

      11 years ago

      Sure… .the Andrew Miller for the Marlins. Not the one traded by the Sox.

      Reply
    • Dr. Balloons

      11 years ago

      You are wrong. He is a free agent. Not arb eliglible.

      Reply
      • Lefty_Orioles_Fan

        11 years ago

        First love the name and avatar.
        Anyway, at Baseball Reference Andrew Miller.

        2014 Status3rd-Year Arb Eligible, Earliest Free Agent: 2015

        Reply
        • Dr. Balloons

          11 years ago

          this coming year is free agent year 2015. Baseball ref is messed up with how they list things.

          Reply
  26. CharlieMurphy

    11 years ago

    Strange that the O’s were willing to give up their 4th best prospect (including Gausman) for Miller, but wouldn’t give up one of their top 3 or Lester… especially considering their glaring need at the front of their rotation and the fact that 2 of their 3 best prospects have elbow issues.

    Reply
    • danistheguy

      11 years ago

      For those of us O’s fans that have followed Rodriguez this year… the kid’s stuff has evaporated into thin air. We saw it in Spring Training and it’s continued into his season at Bowie.

      Reply
    • Matt_P102

      11 years ago

      Not at all. Harvey and Bundy are both top 40 prospects. E-Rod is a top 125 guy at best.

      Reply
      • snowbladerp14

        11 years ago

        going into the season he was top 70 but he has had a rough year with injurys which probably lead to his poor performance

        Reply
        • Matt_P102

          11 years ago

          He was top 70 according to some at the start of the season. Keith Law really liked him (#43 I think). But his stuff isn’t doing well in AA. It’s not just his injury that are turning people off.

          Reply
      • CharlieMurphy

        11 years ago

        Yeah obviously those guys are way above E-Rod but Lester is also a lot more valuable than Miller. Solid pickup for the O’s either way.

        Reply
    • Brian 38

      11 years ago

      There’s a huge gap between Bundy/Gausman/Harvey and E-Rod (or anyone else in the O’s minor league system). I think #4 is being generous…

      Reply
  27. CharlieMurphy

    11 years ago

    Strange that the O’s were willing to give up their 4th best prospect (including Gausman) for Miller, but wouldn’t give up one of their top 3 or Lester… especially considering their glaring need at the front of their rotation and the fact that 2 of their 3 best prospects have elbow issues.

    Reply
  28. Fangaffes

    11 years ago

    Good job, Ben. There’s still time left. Can you get rid of Drew?

    Reply
    • Dr. Balloons

      11 years ago

      They’ll be able to move him in August.

      Reply
      • John Cate

        11 years ago

        Yeah, he’ll get through waivers. We don’t have to trade him today. Although I’ll be glad when he’s gone.

        Reply
        • Dr. Balloons

          11 years ago

          I agree with much vigor.

          Reply
    • Frederick Darwin Quixote

      11 years ago

      The Fisherman’s Feast is coming up. Maybe they’d take Carp.

      Reply
    • Brian 38

      11 years ago

      🙂 Ben’s good! Can he get rid of Kelly Johnson too?

      Reply
  29. Mikenmn

    11 years ago

    Big day for the Red Sox. Monetizing assets quite well

    Reply
  30. Fred Gilmore

    11 years ago

    I called for this move over Jon Lester a couple of days ago. Andrew Miller will help more in the long run than Lester would have for a few months.

    Reply
    • Dr. Balloons

      11 years ago

      They are both only under contract for this year. There is no long run.

      Reply
      • Fred Gilmore

        11 years ago

        The O’s will be able to re-sign Andrew Miller while they wouldn’t touch having to pony up the money to re-sign Lester. This move frees up the ability to pass on Zach Britton in the offseason.

        I love this deal because the O’s got to keep all 3 of their top young pitchers, setting them up for years to come. Not selling the future for the now definitely helps in the long run.

        Reply
  31. Frederick Darwin Quixote

    11 years ago

    Third best trade Duquette has made for the Red Sox.

    Reply
    • John Cate

      11 years ago

      The guy put together most of our 2004 championship team, and as soon as he got to the O’s, they started winning for the first time in forever. He’s not a bad GM.

      Reply
      • MeowMeow

        11 years ago

        He was a bad executive at any rate.

        Reply
  32. Frederick Darwin Quixote

    11 years ago

    Third best trade Duquette has made for the Red Sox.

    Reply
  33. Aron

    11 years ago

    Worst news for a Jays fan today was this trade

    Reply
    • Baseball Legend

      11 years ago

      Wait, that’s right, I forgot about the Jays. They were in on everyone, yet landed no one..Why they do that?

      Reply
      • Aron

        11 years ago

        They always do that…

        Reply
  34. Derek 3

    11 years ago

    As an O’s fan, I’m pumped. E-Rod really didn’t look great this year, and Miller has always torn us apart. Excited to add him.

    Reply
  35. Baloo

    11 years ago

    I can dig this trade. We didn’t give up Bundy or Harvey and got some major league talent in a year we’re we are poised to win it all. With a mediocre rotation that’s just good enough to get by and a great bullpen and excellent lineup, I think we can make some 08 Phils magic work. Let’s go O’s!

    Reply
  36. Frederick Darwin Quixote

    11 years ago

    Now how do we get rid of Carp and Drew? Give them out in grab bags? As party favors? Kids Meal Toys?

    Reply
  37. Brooks Miller

    11 years ago

    Andrew Miller is not a rental! He is arbitration eligible after this year. FA in 2015

    Reply
    • Dr. Balloons

      11 years ago

      Why do people keep making this mistake? He is not arb eligible.

      Reply
    • GOOREOS

      11 years ago

      2014 is this year… 2015 is next year… he’s a free agent next year

      Reply
    • Chris Vinnit

      11 years ago

      When you click on Baseball Reference, they always list the year of free agency one year ahead of his last season under contract. So anybody listed as a “2015 free agent” becomes a free agent after this – the 2014 season – ends. I know its confusing and I don’t know why they do that but thats what they do.

      Reply
  38. James F

    11 years ago

    Oh my goodness gravy! Man, I didn’t want to see Miller traded but for this? I’m not even mad.

    Reply
  39. Jeff Scott

    11 years ago

    Red Sox have traded 20% of their 25 man roster within the last 24 hours–so far. Love it!

    Reply
  40. mauryfeldman

    11 years ago

    Huge day for the Boston Red Sox organization; they have picked up a lot of young talent.

    Reply
  41. Arthur Muldowney

    11 years ago

    A third rate prospect from a sixth rate country! Great deal Benbo. I hope that this is a flip!

    Reply
    • snowbladerp14

      11 years ago

      he was a top 70 prospect coming into the year

      Reply
  42. 123Star

    11 years ago

    Goes to show, some players get 2 comfortable with there high pay.

    Reply
  43. A=MT2

    11 years ago

    If the O’s can extend him to a 3/15mil, this will be a great get by the O’s. He has ace potential before (one of the main piece in the Miguel Cabrera trade) and now seemed to have figured things out. Don’t be surprised if he starts and do well next year!

    Reply
  44. Longdistance O'S fan

    11 years ago

    He has given up 25 hits in 42 innings pitched. Did I read that right ? Talking about Miller….GO O;S

    Reply
  45. Longdistance O'S fan

    11 years ago

    And that 0.898 whip that Miller has cannot be right…..GO O’S

    Reply
  46. Ben G.

    11 years ago

    Duquette and company have returned a great winning tradition to Baltimore. Just great to see.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment

    Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Braves Select Craig Kimbrel

    Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox

    White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel

    Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!

    Pablo Lopez To Miss Multiple Months With Teres Major Strain

    MLB To Propose Automatic Ball-Strike Challenge System For 2026

    Giants Designate LaMonte Wade Jr., Sign Dominic Smith

    Reds Sign Wade Miley, Place Hunter Greene On Injured List

    Padres Interested In Jarren Duran

    Royals Promote Jac Caglianone

    Mariners Promote Cole Young, Activate Bryce Miller

    2025-26 MLB Free Agent Power Rankings: May Edition

    Evan Phillips To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    AJ Smith-Shawver Diagnosed With Torn UCL

    Reds Trade Alexis Díaz To Dodgers

    Rockies Sign Orlando Arcia

    Ronel Blanco To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Joc Pederson Suffers Right Hand Fracture

    Recent

    Tigers Notes: Vierling, Olson, Urquidy, Boyd

    Twins Place Zebby Matthews On 15-Day IL, Reinstate Danny Coulombe

    Yankees Claim CJ Alexander

    Phillies Claim Ryan Cusick, Designate Kyle Tyler

    Brewers Claim Drew Avans

    White Sox Sign Tyler Alexander, Place Jared Shuster On 15-Day IL

    Orioles Designate Matt Bowman For Assignment

    Diamondbacks Select Kyle Backhus, Designate Aramis Garcia

    Athletics Acquire Austin Wynns

    Julio Rodriguez Helped Off Field Following Apparent Injury

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version