Yankees GM Brian Cashman took his turn breaking down the club’s 2016 season and previewing the offseason that lies ahead. Jack Curry of the YES Network was among those on hand, and all links below are to his Twitter feed:
- When asked about the possibility of dealing for a top-line starter such as Chris Sale, Cashman said he’d be “hard-pressed” to part with the haul of young talent needed to pull off such a deal. He indicated that it would be a “dangerous approach” to chase that kind of acquisition, especially given that his club is more than one piece away from pushing for a championship
- Dellin Betances is in line to remain the Yankees’ closer, though Cashman held out the possibiity that the club will “do something different.” Curry notes that his own expectation is the team will chase lefty Aroldis Chapman, who is heading onto the open market after spending part of 2016 in New York (prior to his mid-season trade to the Cubs).
- In other pitching news, intriguing young righty Luis Severino won’t come into camp with a rotation job locked up, Cashman said. Instead, he’ll need to prove himself in camp, with Cashman saying that he hopes Severino “can regain starter ceiling status” after a tough 2016 campaign. Though he contributed only 71 major league frames with a 5.83 ERA last year, Severino is only 22 years of age and threw well at the Triple-A level in 2016.
- Meanwhile, veteran lefty CC Sabathia is headed for a clean-up procedure for his knee. It’s said to be a “routine” operation, which presumably won’t prevent the 36-year-old from a full spring build-up. Sabathia is an important part of the Yankees’ pitching mix after his $25MM option vested. He contributed 179 2/3 innings of 3.91 ERA pitching last year, making for a rather promising showing.
- New York will still presumably make an effort to bolster its rotation from the outside. Indeed, Cashman said the team will be on the lookout for opportunities to add arms. While the free agent picture is rather bleak, there are a few useful starters available as well as plenty of trade possibilities — even if chasing an ace likely isn’t in the cards.
- The Yankees have never asked catcher Brian McCann to waive his no-trade clause, which Cashman says represents an indication of how much the team values the veteran. McCann’s name has come up quite a bit in trade chatter with Gary Sanchez expected to take over primary duties behind the dish. But it’s certainly still plausible to imagine both players holding down important roles. Alternatively, with a lot of demand for catchers around the game, McCann could be moved to address another need.
- Meanwhile, the current plan is for Greg Bird and Tyler Austin to battle for playing time at first base while choosing from among Aaron Judge, Aaron Hicks, and Rob Refsnyder in right field. It’s likely the club will stay with its internal options in those areas, Cashman said, though he added that there is some uncertainty as to whether that mix will be sufficient.
- While he probably won’t be an option early in the year, hyped prospect Jorge Mateo could play his way into the team’s plans if he can turn things around after a rough 2016 at the High-A level. The 21-year-old, a shortstop by trade, is being exposed to center field in instructional league action this fall in a bid to increase his versatility.
- Cashman also addressed a few broader points. The organization still hopes to get under the luxury tax threshold at some point, which would reset the team’s rising tax figure. Both Cashman and skipper Joe Girardi will go year to year on their contracts rather than receiving any long-term assurances. And all coaches except Larry Rothschild are under contract, with the Yanks set to work on a new deal with their pitching coach.
Dookie Howser, MD
Any mention of all the money coming off the books by 2017?
Bluesman
Sabathia is a poster child for what’s wrong with giving insane amounts of money to pitchers! All sports need to adopt a “pay for play” policy, whereby ALL players are paid based on their ACTUAL production, not on potential
Dookie Howser, MD
See the previous post about how badly minor league players get screwed over in the pay scale or Burke’s post about how few major leaguers make it Free Agency. These guys getting paid crazy amounts of money are the top 1% and are being paid as much for what they have already done on team friendly deals as they are for future production.
Bluesman
My proposal would take care of that, because ALL players would get the same base salary. Then money would be added on for each home run hit, each strikeout by a pitcher, each catch and/or putout, etc. On the flip side, money would be deducted for each error, each walk/hit allowed by a pitcher, etc. All quantifiable stats would have a positive/negative value assigned to them, thereby providing ALL players with a paycheck based on ACTUAL results. In fact, a side benefit would be getting rid of agents that unnecessarily drive up salaries, and take 20%, or whatever, of what the players make. It would be the most fair form of compensation, since it would be based on production, or lack thereof, and the players wouldn’t become complacent.
Deke
You do realize that whether one agrees with your commission based approach or not. The players union would never let this happen. Plus just to poke a hole in this. A hitter would never want to play for a team in a pitcher friendly park. Because it would affect their salary. Therefore that team wouldn’t be able to attract the best hitters who will all go to play in hitter friendly parks leaving the worse hitters to play for the other teams.
I think you need to tweak your model.
Deke
Also. Ummm isn’t that kinda like how communism works? Just messing with you 🙂
mike156
This is a capitalist’s dream–an incredibly lucrative business subsidized in several ways by the taxpayers, and all the talent paid as pieceworkers.
I’m assuming that there would no longer be a major league minimum….might encourage loafing or even dependency.
hotdoug5638
Yea I can see the union agree to that.
mike156
Through 2014, Mike Trout had made about $2M combined, and had, in that time, won rookie of the year, was twice 2nd in MVP, won it outright his third full season, and had amassed 28.7 bWAR. He’s also led the league in runs three straight years, SB, RBI, BB, and TB once each.
Do I think CC is overpaid? Of course. Now, tell me how you pay fairly in a system that gives all the leverage to the team in the player’s younger and more productive years.
eilexx
perhaps that fact that baseball players are forced to play longer before they get paid big time–as opposed to NBA/NFL players—is a big part of the reason why fewer MLB players end up bankrupt. Perhaps the system actually benefits the players long-term. So they can’t buy the $500K Ferrari when they’re 21…they’re not on the streets when they’re 50
theo2016
You forgot to mention he was a millionaire before ever playing in the bigs. 1.2 mil dollar signing bonus from the draft.
mike156
Yes, so that makes $3.2 Million for an MVP and 2 second place finishes, Very reasonable deal for the Angels.
eilexx
Why should players not seek guaranteed contracts? It is their right, one that they have fought for. Do the owners give back ticket money when the team loses? Do they return cable TV money, and then in turn does the cable company refund its customers? No. contracts are guaranteed. that’s how baseball is. You get paid.
petrie000
so that when rebuilding teams want to save money they can order the manager to limit the playing time of anybody who might possibly earn a a raise in order to save money?
yeah, that’s a system that would work…
big market teams don’t need even more incentives to outspend everyone else, and they sure as heck don’t need protections against their own unwise spending practices. ‘buyer beware’ is a great equalizer for baseball
Bluesman
(Here’s the rest of what I wrote that somehow disappeared…lol.)
or expectations. It makes too much sense to be adopted, even though it would level the playing field, not only for the players, but for the teams as well.
davidimondi
LOVE seeing Mateo getting work in CF. With Didi and Castro entrenched up the middle and the likelihood that Torres gets moved to 3B, you have to make a guy like that as versatile as you can and if he can maybe turn himself into an above average CF, a future outfield of Frazier, Mateo and Judge is beyond intriguing. I look at what the Nats did with Trea Turner this year as to what the Yanks should do with Mateo.
Texan 2
Yanks should trade Mateo for starting pitching. Jake Cave, Dustin Fowler, and eventually Blake Rutherford are blocking him in CF.
dobsonel
Jake Cave isn’t blocking anyone. He was lost once already and given back. I’ll be surprised if he’s still on the team next year. Fowler and Rutherford have bright futures but are still a ways away.
dobsonel
And Rutherford is being scouted as a future right fielder.
connorreed
“Blocked” usually means there’s a player already producing at the major league level in that spot.
Not a fringy player who’s a future left fielder anyway, a decent prospect who just moved to AA this season, and a teenager who’s probably a few years behind Mateo anyway.
Not to mention the fact that Mateo might not even be able to handle center anyways.
slider32
It might be too early to trade Mateo, I think the Yanks try and trade McCann, Gardner, and Headley to try and get young top line pitching first.
galihaaben 2
They have other prospect pieces that have done well in the minors to trade for #4 or #5 pitching. Not possible for a Mateo trade for #2 or 3 pitching because he’s still underdeveloped. Plus, Fowler and Cave are more likely to be dealt before they hit MLB levels because of the quality competition for the RF position, as well as the occupied LF and CF positions that have actually been healthy for one full season. (Pausing here for a minute because I can’t believe that Ellsbury and Gardner were one of several durable Yankees of the season.) Not to mention a great prospect bat, Clint Frazier that will likely to take over Gardner position. (I believe that Gardner is likely to be dealt within the next two seasons.)
connorreed
I still see a lot of Yankee fans that want to deal for Sale.
They’d be insane to go after him. Assuming they wouldn’t part with Sanchez, you would need Frazier, Torres, and Mateo headlining that package, plus a few more.
chitownsox11
Not saying that the Yankees would be willing to move sanchez, but I doubt you get sale without him. If I am the White Sox Frazier, Torres, and Mateo do not excite me enough to be headliners of a Sale trade.
MurderersRow27
So what you’re saying is, that 3 top 20 prospects aren’t exciting enough to be the headliners for Sale? If the Yankees were to offer Sanchez in a trade for Sale, it would be a 1 for 1 or maybe Sanchez and a B prospect for Sale, especially what he showed in his 2 months with the team. I’d think 3 top 20 prospects would actually be an overpay for even Sale, let alone Sanchez plus any of them.
chitownsox11
Yes I am saying none of them excite me. Mateo and Torres are 19 and 21 years old, and still pretty far away from contributing at the major league level. Frazier is the only one that is major league ready, and nothing really stands out as special to me.
All indications are if the Sox are going to rebuild they want major league ready players. And the thought that Chris Sale would get traded for Sanchez, who has played all of 53 major league games, straight up just shows how delusional you are.
We will see what happens with Sale this winter, but my guess is if they trade him it is for an absolute haul.
MurderersRow27
I’m not delusional 1 bit. It was reported that before the deadline the Yankees and Sox had conversations involving Sale, but the White Sox wanted Sanchez plus plus plus plus… Fast forward to his call up and subsequent 53 games played, add in what he produced in those games (offensively and throwing out about 41% of would be base stealers, 13/32), and the fact that people around the game have even reported it would be closer to a 1 for 1 now or Sanchez and another lesser piece or 2, and that’s where it’s at.. If I can find the article I will link it later. In the end, the Yankees most likely won’t overpay for any pitcher this off-season, even if it is Sale.
chitownsox11
You cannot honestly think there would ever be a trade for Sale that would ever be a one for one. And I would love to see who is writing that Sale could be had for Sanchez straight up. Sanchez played amazing in his short time up, but no one is ever trading a perennial Cy Young candidate for a player who has 53 major league games under their belt.
connorreed
Compared to what other teams would likely be willing to offer, it’s not a very exciting package.
As chitownsox11 stated, Mateo and Torres have yet to reach the AA level, and Frazier still hasn’t played a major league game yet, either. I doubt all three of top 20 prospects. And they’re very good prospects but not GREAT – none really come close to breaking the top ten.
When you consider what other teams would *probably* be willing to offer, I would take most of these packages of those three any day
Cubs: Kyle Schwarber, Jorge Soler, Eloy Jimenez
Rangers: Joey Gallo, Jurickson Profar, Yohander Mendez
Nats: Lucas Giolito, Michael Taylor, Reynaldo Lopez
Red Sox: JBJ, Rafael Devers, E-Rod
Dodgers: Julio Urias, Willie Calhoun, Gavin Lux
slider32
I don’t see the Yanks trading for a top line pitcher this year, Sale will be a free agent when the Yanks are going to contend in 2018.
ctguy
The Yanks are far better off holding onto Sanchez. Sale would be a nice addition but not if Sanchez is included in the deal.
jd396
Seriously, some financial recourse for players with major injuries or underperformance might make baseball just a TINY bit more like the real world. I don’t think it needs to be severe but baseball is a bit ridiculous when you can sign enormous contracts and completely fail to perform and not lose so much as a penny in the process.
slider32
Cashman is smart, he will stay on task, and try and move McCann to the Braves for pitchers like Newcomb, Allard, and Fried, move Gardner to Astros for Whitley or Paulino or to the Nats for Fedde and Glover. This will give the Yanks a good pitching base moving forward. I think they will wait until 2018 to make big free agent moves.
dobsonel
I like where you’re heads at with McCann for a young pitcher. I would add Mike Sorka to that list. Not sure the Braves want to part with either Newcomb or Allard though. As for Gardner, I think he would bring back more than most people think. Everone says he’s washed up but his numbers are still good and he’s relatively cheap.
galihaaben 2
If the Yankees want to maximize their trade value for McCann, they could trade him at the end of the season. But if they want to take the risk to try to increase his trade value at the 2017 trade deadline, they could do that too (I doubt the Yankees will be in contention next year because this years FA lacks a lot plus only DH bats are the primary feature for this years offseason [Trumbo, Encarnacion] that will demand money and more importantly, years, that the Yankees cannot become attracted to (save up for 2018/2019). It is imperative that they let their younger, future of the franchise players develop further (Gregorius, Sanchez, Judge, Severino, Bird) for at least 2018 when the rest of the youth movement comes in (Torres, Mateo, Frazier, Kaprielian).
galihaaben 2
How about this for offseason plans and notes:
– Have Sanchez work on his English and his development behind the plate blocking those wild pitches/ passed balls. (Makes every baseball fan cringe when they see a pitch pass by the catcher)
– Headley trade? Please? Then maybe Gregorius or Castro can shift to third? (Anyone remember Yangervis Solarte? I loved him when he was with the Yankees and I hated it when the Yankees traded him; still keep tabs on him here and there and he’s done well for the Padres. Can we do a retrade please?)
– Bullpen? Probably more young Triple-A guys coming up. Another season of an overused Betances. Ladies and Gentlemen we’re in for another rough bullpen season. At least we won’t have to see Anthony Swarzak right? RIGHT?!?
– CC Sabathia. Hey, he pitched well this season. If he pitches well again next season, the Yankees will pull a Kuroda on him and sign him to one-year contracts season after season until he’s 40.
– Another offseason of Gardner trade rumors? *Turns off notifications*
– Play the younger guys a lot more? Even if it means to trade the vets like Gardner, Headley and McCann. These veterans had enogh playing time and proved a lot of bad in clutch, RISP situations (cough HEADLEY cough).
– Billy Butler. Hmm, probably don’t see the Yankees resigning him with all the RH bats they have.. .
– Can’t wait to see Chad Green again. Cessa to pen please. His stuff belongs in the pen. More Severino.