Six seasons have elapsed since Daniel Bard threw his last pitch in a Major League game, but the 34-year-old righty threw in front of scouts recently and is hoping to make a comeback, Pete Abraham of the Boston Globe reports (via Twitter).
Bard, for those who don’t recall or have only begun following baseball in recent seasons, at one point looked to be a high-end closer in the making. Selected with the 28th overall pick in 2006, Bard debuted for the Red Sox in 2009 and went on to post a 2.88 ERA with 9.7 K/9 against 3.5 BB/9 and 0.7 HR/9 in his first 197 innings at the MLB level. Were it not for Jonathan Papelbon’s presence in the Boston bullpen, he’d surely have been afforded more save opportunities in the early stages of his career.
The 2012 season was an ugly one for Bard, however, as he was blown up for a 6.22 ERA through 59 1/3 innings. A sudden deterioration of his ability to locate the ball was the chief culprit, as Bard averaged 6.5 BB/9 and hit eight batters in 59 1/3 frames that season. Bard missed more than two months of the 2013 season with an abdominal strain and only tossed one inning in the Majors plus another 15 1/3 frames in the minors; he walked 27 batters in that time.
Winter ball in the 2013-14 offseason and a brief stint with the Rangers in 2014 only confirmed that Bard’s control had completely evaporated. Call it the Yips, Steve Blass disease or whatever moniker you prefer — Bard walked 18 of the 31 hitters he faced between the Puerto Rican Winter League and his quick run with the Rangers’ Class-A club. He embarked on comeback attempts with the Cardinals and Mets in 2016-17 but was met with similarly disheartening results.
Since calling it quits before the 2018 season, Bard has been working in as a “minor league player mentor” with the D-backs organization, where GM Mike Hazen and assistant GMs Amiel Sawdaye and Jared Porter know him well from their time in the Red Sox’ front office. Expectations on another comeback attempt should be measured, of course, given the long layoff and Bard’s prior, unsuccessful attempts. Still, it’s hard not to root for the 34-year-old. A successful renaissance after this much time off the radar would make for a wonderful story to follow and surefire Comeback Player of the Year favorite.
bballblk
Still not as random as when Brian Wilson tried coming back as a knuckleballer
A'sfaninLondonUK
Brian Wilson from the Beach Boys, yeah that was a surprise…
nowheredan
God only knows if he could have made it.
astrosfansince1974
I see what you did there! One of the best songs of all time by anyone IMO.
carlos15
Wouldn’t it be nice if he made it?
TeddyBallgameYazJimEd
But…Wouldn’t It Be Nice
WARrior
And he threw inside! outside! B-O-B
Inside! Outside! H-B-P
Daniel Bard’s gone throwin’, throwin’ mlb
smrtbusnisman04a
Didn’t he already attempt a comeback with the Pirates organization in 2018?
Anyways. I’ll be rooting for him.
looiebelongsinthehall
I’ve been as hard on him as any based on his painful it was to watch his lack of control during his last season with Boston. America though loves come back stories and second chances so I’ll also be rooting for him.
uvmfiji
What if he signs with the Jays? Do the Canadians love coneback stories as well?
deweybelongsinthehall
No idea but tongue in cheek here. How about requiring all 2017 Houston Astros batters having to stand in the batters box his first time back on the mound.
mlb1225
It was 2016, but yea. I remember they signed him to a minor league deal, but he was injured for the entierity of it and never appeared in a pro-game for the big league club, or minor league club.
DarkSide830
“Renaissance?” like the pun of sorts Steve.
agentx
I missed that initially but agree. Fun seeing Steve have fun with such word play.
PaulM
His arm is a cannon.
AtlSoxFan
Sounds like the guy you use as an opener against the astros.
GaryWarriorsRedSoxx
Atl.. FUNNY !! 2 thumbs up
Cam
He just has no clue where it’s firing
rangerslegend34107
Dude had a thunderbolt for an arm. Chalk it up to another potential great reliever whose career was ruined when the team (Red Sox in this case) tried to use him as a starter. The Rangers had a terrific trio they ruined (Neftali Feliz, Alexi Ogando, and Tanner Scheppers) trying to turn them into starters when they had an electric bullpen with them. Joba Chamberlain suffered a similar fate. I know I’m leaving off several others. Hopefully teams have learned their lesson, especially in today’s game, where relivers have such high value.
DarkSide830
Matt Strahm might fit here
butch779988
If I remember correctly, HE was the one that asked to be a starter., and Cherington supported it. Valentine was dead against it.
Senioreditor
Relieves values are pretty low compared to high end starters and that’s why an attempt to convert is often implemented. If you don’t believe me look at what high end starters signed for this past off season vs high end relievers. It’s not even close.
Boston2AZ
Actually, it was Bard who wanted to be a starter because they make more money than relievers. The Sox just gave in to his request.
bostonglobe.com/sports/2011/12/06/sox-bard-prefers…
Northeasternskier
Funny that the author of this article didn’t mention that Bard first pooped the bed while starting, not relieving. Huge oversight.
Remember dreading this move. Ain’t broke don’t fix it.
agentx
If I recall correctly, Bard’s peripherals had already been taking a turn for the worst toward the end of the prior season. I don’t believe the Bard-as-starter experiment was completely to blame for his unraveling.
Goku the Knowledgable One
The shelf life is short on setup men who overpower their way through early parts of their career.
Lots of them break down. Betances, Zumaya, Madsen, on and on
Goku the Knowledgable One
The shelf life is short on setup men who overpower their way through early parts of their career.
Lots of them break down. Betances, Zumaya, Madsen, on and on
Jack Marshall
Wrong. Bard wanted to be a starter in 2012,. He had already been ruined when Francona over-worked him down the stretch in 2011, even though something obviously wasn’t right.. Bard was a big factor in the Sox late season collapse.. His confidence was shot, and maybe something in his mechanics too.
AtlSoxFan
In addition to Bard requesting the change to starter, you have to remember ALL of this relates back to his battery mate Justin Masterson going from set-up man in a similar role with the red sox to being lights out for a couple seasons with Cleveland following a trade.
Bard likely figured if Justin could make the switch, earn bigger paychecks, why not him.
It wasn’t exactly an out of nowhere idea, there were reasons why some within the organization supported the request.
Mlb1971
Bard was a starter in the minors with an average of around 6 walks per 9 innings. He became a reliever because he failed as a starter. Back as a starter his average mph on the fastball dropped by two mph, so he got hit hard with a lot of runners on base……
looiebelongsinthehall
Why blame the team? If he hurt his arm, that would be a different story. As a pro, it’s on the player to adjust.
astrosfansince1974
IIRC Bard himself wanted to be a starter so don’t blame the dirty Sox for that.
Moleyrussell’swart
The Red Sox ownership is notorious for ruining pitchers.
amcguire72
I”m not sure I would take it that far. Most clubs would love to have had the pleasure of pitchers like Clemens, Hurst, Martinez, Sele, Sale, Wakefield, Beckett, Lester, Papelbon, Buchholz, Lackey, Price, etc. Now, they don’t really have that standout closer or reliever, but those guys I noted were pretty serviceable starters, love ’em or otherwise.
amcguire72
Oh, and dare I disrespect the one and only Oil Can Boyd! 😉
dman07
Why not. This guy had some heat!
JKB7394
The Red Sox should have never experimented with him as a starter.
Senioreditor
Why not, he’s more valuable as a starter and there’s no guarantee that he wouldn’t have broken down as a reliever. There’s no shortage of hard throwing righthanders and they just moved on. Sadly cheap minor leaguers is a commodity that most teams have.
cmanson
maybe he can learn to hit and become the next Rick Ankiel
stubby66
Hey isnt Rick Ankiel making a pitching comeback?
BuyBuyMets
Ankiel learned to hit?
Must have been after his time in the big leagues.
amcguire72
Ha – didn’t realize Ankiel was mentioned already. And whether or not he could hit is subjective. His average over the course of his tenure looks more like a weight loss program readout.
Cam
He did. His ’07 and ’08 seasons were comfortably above average.
mikedickinson
Red Sox ruined him when they attempted to make him a starter.
astrosfansince1974
I believe it was at Bard’s request.
BaseballBrian
He could sell Avon and become the Bard of Avon.
MoRivera 1999
I would rather THE Bard made a comeback.
hatlessmanus
Hopefully, the absence of juiced baseballs aids his comeback attempt!
srechter
Daniel Bard’s 2014 minor league numbers with Texas are some of the most fascinating you will ever see in this sport. .2 innings pitched, no hits, 99.99 era, nine walks, SEVEN hbp.
I mean… it’s almost remarkable they let it continue.
Strike Four
Whoever that manager was probably said “get me 3 outs no matter what”
GaryWarriorsRedSoxx
They were experimenting with the minimum number of batters rule. Hit the first few guys, keep him in there. Thank goodness they settled on three or we might see more of this in the future.
astrosfansince1974
Sounds like Trevor Rosenthal this year.
Android Dawesome
In his absence he has been secretly removing and re-hiding the treasure of Oak Island.
bigbadjohnny
Yahoo / Reuters just said Tony Fernandez is still alive……on life support……….now he should win COMEBACK OF THE YEAR award !
Strike Four
It’s simply bizarre to watch someone who no doubt has been pitching since they were a small child, who has been doing it for decades at that point, go from a perfectly-fine 3.0 BB/9 rate in 2011 to never being able to throw a strike consistently ever again. Mental health is so huge in this game.
Coal tender
Since he has never had any arm injuries, except for a strain abdomen, I think he is physically ready to try it again! Now if he can just get over the “Yips” which is no small hurdle.
amcguire72
The “Vaughn” syndrome is an odd one for sure. Ankiel is the one that comes to mind immediately. He couldn’t hit the broad side of a barn much less get it over a 43cm slab of rubber with some semblance of vertical accuracy sprinkled in. Hope he can get it squared away – but whether he dipped his toe in the starting rotation or not is more of a question for what is in the best interest of the club and athlete. Being a Brewer fan, I’m pretty sure Hader would get lit up brighter than the Rockefeller Christmas Tree if he tried to be a starter. Three inning saves? If the pen were depleted and it were the playoffs, I’m sure he would give it a roll and do just fine, but it wouldn’t be in his personal best interest I doubt.
elscorchot
“Oh, gooood for you. And how’d that work out for you? I hope it was good, cause it’s ruined now isn’t it?”
whyhayzee
I remember him pitching when the yankees had that guy in the stands signaling the pitches and he still struck everyone out.
google.com/amp/keitholbermann.mlblogs.com/2011/04/…
whyhayzee
The thing that amplifies this strange saga is history. In the ’70s and ’80s the Yankees and MLB were frequently at odds over an “Eye In The Sky” – an innovation by the late George Steinbrenner in which a Yankee employee (beginning, I believe, with Gene Michael, and lasting so long that the last one may have been Buck Showalter) worked from the press box level and was in communication with the dugout during games, relaying goodness knows what. The Commissioner’s Office frowned on this and monitored it regularly.
whyhayzee
In the realm of baseball espionage, this was about as low-tech as it gets: A fan with a good view of the catcher and a strong set of lungs.
That was all it took on Tuesday night for that fan to be ejected from Yankee Stadium for yelling out information on pitch location to the Yankees’ Gary Sanchez while he was hitting in the eighth inning of his team’s 6-1 victory over the Tampa Bay Rays.
gorav114
I wish him luck but I doubt even the Tigers or Orioles would be willing to give him a minor league invite at this point.