2:26 pm: The Giants and Rockies remain engaged on Story with a little more than a half hour to go before the deadline, reports Feinsand.
1:03 pm: With just under two hours before the deadline, the Rockies have lowered their asking price on Story, one executive tells Sherman. That person suggests it’s now more likely than not that Story will be traded.
12:03 pm: There’s little traction between the Rockies and either of Tampa Bay or Toronto on a Story deal at the moment, hears Patrick Saunders of the Denver Post. Of course, the Jays just parted with a pair of top prospects to land José Berríos from the Twins, so it’s possible they might be disinclined to continue to mine the farm system for Story.
11:29 am: Some rival executives think the Rays and Blue Jays are the main contenders to land Rockies shortstop Trevor Story before this afternoon’s trade deadline, reports Joel Sherman of the New York Post (Twitter link). Bob Nightengale of USA Today adds that the Rays, in particular, are making a “hard push” to land Story. Mark Feinsand of MLB.com suggests the Giants also have interest, while Thomas Harding of MLB.com indicates the Rockies have had discussions regarding Story with the Cardinals as well.
Of course, that’s only if Story winds up traded at all, which Sherman confirms is far from a lock. The Rockies have expressed comfort with holding onto Story for weeks. While that could just be public posturing, it seems Colorado’s planning to hang onto fellow impending free agent Jon Gray past the deadline.
The end game there, however, is to try to hammer out a long-term deal with Gray. Story, on the other hand, isn’t seen as especially likely to sign an extension. The Rockies instead would be more likely to make him a qualifying offer and receive a compensatory draft choice if/when he rejects and signs elsewhere in free agency.
Of course, Story’s play this season has complicated matters. While he looked like an obvious trade candidate coming into the year on the heels of a .293/.361/.544 performance from 2019-20, he’s struggled to produce at the plate this season. The 28-year-old has a below-average .240/.312/.429 line (84 wRC+) over 375 plate appearances. That’s surely depressing the caliber of prospect teams are willing to part with, so there’s some sense for Colorado in recouping a high 2022 draft choice if rivals aren’t putting forth especially strong offers.
The Rays, Jays, Giants and Cardinals are all new reported entrants into the Story market. Sherman adds that the Mets — who have been linked to Story for a while — are still on the periphery but that the Rockies shortstop doesn’t seem to be their top priority at this time. The Yankees, Brewers and White Sox have also all been tied to Story in the past but seem less likely after adding to their infield in other ways (Anthony Rizzo, Eduardo Escobar and César Hernández, respectively).
Sideline Redwine
Sounds like the Rays are just in on everyone now…maybe they missed out on the target they thought they would snag. No need for a rental on Story. This is getting ridiculous.
Get some pitching!!!
tux249
Same with my blue jays
Francys01
Trevor Story, story continues. We shall see which team acquire him.
Chief Two Hands
And whether he will make difference, which seems unlikely. Great talent, but he needed to get out of Colorado a while ago.
17dizzy
I guess I’m confused about the new trade deadline rules.
Such as the Cardinals and Rockies in discussion about a Trevor Story —- during the deadline——????
In the past —— the teams had until 12:00 midnight (eastern time), to complete the deal.
Is that still true?????
seamaholic 2
You’re suggesting the Rays need pitching? This is the organization that manufactures pitching to order every year, and usually makes a surplus that they can sell for other stuff. It’s like saying a farmer needs to acquire some corn.
GASoxFan
There’s no such thing as too much pitching.
luclusciano
Or too much corn
Eatdust666
Or too much caramel
Speak da Truth
You kilt it…
Francys01
I would have like the Cardinals to acquire Story, but I’m not sure that we a chance to win the division. We are 9.5 games back from first place. The wild card game can be ruled out for us because it’s going to be between two teams from
The NL West the super team Dodgers, Giants or Padres.
Chief Two Hands
I’ll put your mind at rest…the Cards will not win the division this season. No need to be unsure about it anymore.
Francys01
Chief Two Hands – Lol. You might be right. Who knows?
sirandrews
As a Brewers fan, I’ve learned to never doubt the Cardinals.
You guys are always in the mix.
CuddyFox
All the Brewers need to do is to go to the west coast and play against the Dodgers with Max, Kershaw and Bueller and then the Cards will be 7 games back. I still think that the Dodgers are trying to buy another championship, if they do, people will be pissed off of baseball, again.
justacubsfan
Maybe the rays should’ve held onto adames for a bit longer… or they’re trying to drive up the price.
kc38
They traded him for two lights out relivers and don’t have to overpay for some nobody in this market now…
StPeteStingRays
Walls and Franco say hello!
watup0100
How do former Rockies shortstops normally perform in Toronto?
vbcbpt
That’s awesome and true. lol
tux249
The MLB app does it too
seamaholic 2
Better than he did in Colorado. People forget that Tulo completely stunk in his last half season in Colorado. He was physically gone. Blue Jays took a chance and he actually did OK in Toronto, but he was never gonna be a superstar again after his multiple hip surgeries.
Raps902420
Of course the blue Jays are interested. I’m starting to think the mlbtraderumors staff is just adding the blue Jays into every article now, just because.
AKAINU
Blue Jays? what?
vbcbpt
Not sure why the Jays would want him especially as a rental. Makes no sense to me.
seamaholic 2
Because their starting SS has a 676 OPS and sucks on defense? I think that’s fairly obvious.
Also they just got Berrios, so they’re good on the pitching side.
TBJ12
What are you talking about? Our starting SS is Bo Bichette. I’m guessing Story would play 3B.
Deleted User
Who are you talking about? Bichette is a stud.
Astros2017&22Champs
Bichette is a stud hitter. His defense is atrocious
Ted
Cavan Biggio is not the starting SS.
solaris602
Agreed. TOR is good to go on offense, and even though they just acquired Hand and Berrios, they still need to see what they can get on the pitching market.
ABCD
Cardinals?
Win Cor
That is the perfect destination for both teams…
tbone0816
Trade DeJong, Knitzer and prospect for Story
tombenton
NOT Kizner!
hiflew
I wouldn’t mind that deal for the Rox. Better than the Arenado deal.
Chief Two Hands
The Story speculation becomes more uninteresting every day. Thankfully, it will be over soon.
FloridaSportsGuy
A Neverending kind of speculation, if you will.
Win Cor
I heard the Cardinals have awoken! Trever Story is the perfect fit.
baseballguy_128
What about the Reds
Altuves Buzzer
Jays would be a good fit for a run with him. Perhaps is would mean Beau goes to 3b…..19 errors at SS on the season so far can’t be ignored.
Aoe3
AL east and Nl west building super teams? Nyy, Tor, Bos Looking like it..
Yes Houston and Milwaukee are very good too.
Rsox
This isn’t the NBA. The “super team” means nothing in MLB
tominco
Reunite Trevor and Nolan.
tstats
Trade them both to the Giants?
holecamels35
It would be so like the Rockies to sit on their hands and do nothing yet again.
Joel Peterson
Summer is a tough time a year for the Rockies higher ups. Especially now with the pandemic. Have you tried to fly international lately? If you want to escape to your summer home in Italy good luck. It’s just the worst……
Chief Two Hands
No need to meet in person. No need to meet with the Rockies FO at all. Just request a proposal via email and let the legal teams take over. The Rockies are too stupid to be smart. Should have moved Story a long time ago…now his value is just diminishing by the minute.
Joel Peterson
It’s always been diminishing by the minute. That’s what makes them so dumb. That they don’t understand that…..
Noel1982
Both New York teams should call and offer their pu pu plater package Yankees.: Clint Frazier and Miguel andujar
Mets : jd davis and dom smith
tstats
Rockies would really be sweating on that decision
Camden453
Jays better be careful and not blow their rebuild
JoeBrady
Sounds like a BS story, planted by the Rox, to drum up interest in a guy they waited a full year too long to trade. Where would Story possibly play in TO? Grichuk is providing a 1.1 WAR this year. Nobody is giving up prospects in the hope that Story can provide a material upgrade AND changing positions.
Joel Peterson
You are giving the Rockies far too much credit. That kind of idea would require creative outside the box thinking.
Story should have been dealt in the off-season. Should be dealt today. Probably won’t be…..
sports101
He would play SS… Bo has been atrocious in the field this season, and would allow the jays the flexibility to move Lourdes/Grichuk, or just have an extra bench bat for the playoffs/Jansen, Story’s added 1.6 WAR this season with only the potential to dramatically increase. That’s an upgrade anyway you slice it
Darthyen
Toronto don’t want more overrated Colorado inflated numbers garbage. Don’t care what the numbers say he is Tulo (the most overrated player in MLB history) 2.0. No Thank You. Let someone else be disappointed on an overpay for an overrated player..
tstats
Overrated?? Jeters defense gives em a run for his money
angt222
Probably fits best with Cincy. Wouldn’t be surprised if they enter the chat.
hiflew
Have you seen how great Kyle Farmer has been playing recently? The Reds already have a pretty good SS, just without all the hype.
Not a clever name
Not sure why the giants would be interested in story as a rental at all.Crawford comes back today and I would think story is a downgrade from Crawford. Maybe as a 3B to rest longo? Or as a DH if they make the series?
Arnold Ziffel
Trade Story, sign Gray as Gray wants to stay there and handles Coors well.
Get a bag of baseballs for Cron.
cwsOverhaul
Rockies are probably overplaying their hand big time for an expensive rental that is struggling this year for whatever reason. If they pay his salary, maybe they can get a decent prospect that’s worth a bit more than the compensatory pick. Doubt anyone caves with an elite one.
Win Cor
The Cardinals and Rockies are the perfect fit . Arenado and Story belong together. They both have the players to make the deal happen, that is mutually beneficial for sure.
dmarcus15
DeJong, Carp cash and a couple prospects for Story.
dmarcus15
Story for DeJong and a couple of prospects.
Joe It All
The Reds are going to swoop in and give them 3 bullpen guys they’re about to DFA
BrewersMVP08
Rockies holding out to take the head cheerleader to prom. As prom approaches, they are now willing to take the band geek
Joe It All
Plot twist: The band geek already found a date
BrewersMVP08
Now they have to take the weird girl who barks at people in the hall.
Well played Rockies
Rsox
If the Reds are truly interested in making a run this is a no-brainer. Story going anywhere else to play positions he’s never played is going to turn out bad.
bhambrave
Bring Story to Atlanta. Pederson in right, Duvall in center and Riley in left. Move Story to third.
Metsin777
Story is having a mediocre season. If Im the Mets, I offer Vientos straight up for Story. If the Rockies decline, Mets trade Veintos, JD Davis, and Drew Smith for Kris Bryant and Craig Kimbrel.
Oldschoolandthemets1980
Kimbrell going to white Sox, but I would rather have Baez over Bryant, we need a bat yes,but Baez can play more infield positions than Bryant plus he is a gold glove candidate every year.
MyWifeLeftMeForWadeBoggs
Let’s all laugh at the Rockies FO
hiflew
The Rockies don’t have a front office anymore, you might as well laugh at the nearest wall.
Grade_1_teacher
Story is having a down year, so how much could they ask for him by himself anyway? Best would be to package him with a controllable guy like Marquez and then the offers should be pouring in.
hiflew
This has just been a bad trade deadline for the Rockies, but it’s not necessarily all their fault. They didn’t know Trevor Story was going to have such a down year AND not want to sign an extension. If they did, they would have moved him this past offseason. They also didn’t know that just about every contender was set at shortstop. There is almost always 1-2 teams that NEED a shortstop, but not really this year. Especially since the Brewers picked up Adames early on.
The Rockies have been their usual brand of inept, but in fairness to them, everything not in their control that could have gone wrong in this situation, did go wrong.
hiflew
To be honest, I would be happy with Luke Voit and a prospect at this point.
Oldschoolandthemets1980
If and it’s a big if. If voit,s body could ever hold up he would rake in Coors.
TDM
Phillies should be in SELL mode, but if not, Story and Gray.
Chief Two Hands
Of course, this is after Story lowered the asking price on his own due to a relatively substandard year so far. In typical Rockies fashion they waited too long to move him.
alwaysgo4two
As a Rays fan I’m hoping for Story also. Wander isn’t quite ready and Walls bat is lacking. A couple of prospects amd Denver throwing in $$$…it’ll work.
Monfort needs to go
Don’t you even think about trading him to the Giants. I will get rid of every Rockies thing I have.
atuck_sfg
I’d rather have KB, he can play outfield
sugoi51
A neverending Trevor Story…
LaFlamaBlanca
How sick would it be if the Giants pulloff Bryant and Story.
powerslave777
I just threw up in my mouth
dodgerfan
Story to SF doesn’t make any sense to me but I’ve been wrong on most of today’s activity.
angt222
Story staying in Colorado.
Tcsbaseball
Are the Rockies really so inept as a franchise that they didn’t trade any of their impending free agents ? Lol
bravesfan
How the Rockies don’t trade story blow my freaking mind…. Dumb
WarrenSpahn
Is the Rockies FO really as dysfunctional as they appear?
It’s like there is no one answering the phone…