Framber Valdez stands atop the pitching class and is arguably the offseason’s last marquee free agent. He and Zac Gallen are the two remaining players who declined qualifying offers. Those two pitchers and Eugenio Suárez are the three unsigned players who ranked among MLBTR’s Top 20 free agents entering the winter.
Suárez was always going to be capped to two or three years by his age. Gallen is coming off a down season and is a candidate for a pillow contract with an opt-out. On the other hand, Valdez came into the winter as arguably the best available pitcher. His age and middling second half performance — plus the bizarre cross up incident with catcher César Salazar that could lead to some questions from teams — meant he hit the market on a bit of a down note himself. Valdez is nevertheless coming off a 3.66 ERA showing with an above-average 23.3% strikeout rate and massive 58.6% grounder percentage across 192 innings. It’s his fourth straight full season and sixth year in a row with a sub-4.00 earned run average.
Valdez’s age (32) made a six-year deal a stretch. A five-year contract seemed more plausible, with a strong four-year pact appearing to be the floor. There hasn’t been much about Valdez’s market or whether his camp would target a shorter deal with opt-outs as Spring Training approaches. Valdez clearly hasn’t found a deal to his liking, yet he’s probably the last top-of-the-rotation starter who’ll change teams this offseason.
A Tarik Skubal trade has always felt like a long shot. Freddy Peralta, MacKenzie Gore, Edward Cabrera and Shane Baz are off the trade market. Dylan Cease landed with the Blue Jays on a seven-year deal within the first couple weeks of the offseason. The market didn’t value NPB righty Tatsuya Imai as a top-of-the-rotation arm. Valdez has higher upside than any of the other remaining starters in free agency (e.g. Gallen, Lucas Giolito, Chris Bassitt, Justin Verlander).
Valdez has most frequently been linked to the Orioles. They entered the offseason needing a top-end starter, and president of baseball operations Mike Elias has ties to the southpaw from his days in the Houston front office. The O’s acquired Baz in a trade to address the rotation and signed Pete Alonso to a five-year, $155MM free agent deal. There’s reportedly still room in the budget, but another $30MM+ annual salary for Valdez would cap a much bigger offseason than usual for the Orioles.
The Mets, Blue Jays and Red Sox are all known to have met with Valdez around the Winter Meetings. They’ve each added a different marquee pitcher (Peralta, Cease and Ranger Suárez, respectively). The Astros have never seemed inclined to bring Valdez back. The Giants also met with the two-time All-Star, but they’ve consistently downplayed their desire to sign anyone long term.
Where does that leave Valdez? Will Baltimore or San Francisco get aggressive, or does the long wait open up the opportunity for a mystery team?

Not sure why, but I’m feeling the Padres here.
Same here
If they can make an arrangement with Darvish the Padres probably definitely swoop in here
Same. Especially if Darvish officially retires…
A team could build a nice front end to a rotation with Valdez and Gallen, only weeks short of camps opening.
if the dbacks couldve added bregman, surely they will sign one of the top 3 remaining of gallen and suarez (more likely), or even valdez (burnes -> az happened so ?)
It makes too much sense for my O’s to sign the man. Not that Gallen is a bad consolation signing if you miss out on Valdez. I wish we could swing a deal for the likes of Skubal but its literally a snowball’s chance in hell of that happening. Just get someone who can slot into that 1 to 3 slot in the rotation between Bradish and Rogers and we can call the offseason a job well done. All the more so if you compare it to last offseason holy moly.
Gallen is better
There’s literally nothing that points to Gallen being better than Framber
Theyre both great options, but Framber is clearly the better pitcher
Hate to say it, but it feels too good to be true as an O’s fan. Getting Alonso AND Valdez would be a pretty unprecedented offseason. Waiting for that one dark horse team to swoop in with that unexpected, mammoth offer so Elias can say “we tried” and then settle for Gallen or Bassitt. That’s the Orioles Way.
“Settle” for Gallen. Gallen is better than Valdez. I’d live either for the Os but Gallen IS THE BETTER FIT and has better stuff!
Not knocking Gallen. I think he’s a really good pitcher and due for a bounceback season. That’s EXACTLY the kind of bargains the O’s shop for. So, I wouldn’t be shocked. But Valdez is pretty damn consistent and is better overall, in my opinion. Gallen’s ERA has risen for the past four seasons. That’s a serious red flag.
I think the dark horse here could actually be COL. They have the money, and if nobody else wants to extend a 4 or 5 year deal, there’s no reason not to for them.
It will come down to salary and local food offerings. A Chicago team, Texas team, or California team. Kansas City would fit the food but not the salary; Cincy, Cleveland, St. Louis, and Pittsburgh are out on both accounts.
Not that I’m one to talk about random as anything poster names but, you may in fact take the cake on that front. Food wise, KC is tough to beat, Baltimore got the seafood though, one of the few things I miss now that I reside in Idaho lol.
Gotta keep’em guessing. Assumed you lived in the 60652, since that was always mcgruff turf.
Bmore and KC do have great food. PNW also has amazing seafood, but we all know Seattle isn’t signing Framber. Never been to Idaho besides driving through, but I feel like they should have perfected potato dishes by now. Latkes, pierogies, gnocchi, hashbrowns, etc. the versatility of potatoes is endless.
We have really good crabcakes in Baltimore. And Natty Boh as well.
Crab cakes 100%, but natty bohs are like Pittsburgh’s IC light. The local nostalgia doesn’t make it taste good.
Awesome mascot though. Pringle’s guy tried to steal the aura.
Natty Bohs are so nasty. Then again you really don’t want your players drinking anyways.
I’d take a roster full of Wade Boggs’
Idaho have potatoe tho have you tried the chip
Too bad KC won’t spend the money. Framber isn’t going to give Salvy any attitude that’s for sure…
A team that likes a grumpy pitcher that’s on the decline.
So naturally… the Cardinals, who never met a 30-something “innings eater” they didn’t convince themselves was still an ace.
“on the decline” What a stupid comment.
“Valdez is nevertheless coming off a 3.66 ERA showing with an above-average 23.3% strikeout rate and massive 58.6% grounder percentage across 192 innings. It’s his fourth straight full season and sixth year in a row with a sub-4.00 earned run average.”
did you watch him bean his catcher though?
I’m not sure why the Mets are on second on this poll right now. They would need to trade someone away to fit him. Peralta, McLean, Senga, Manaea, Peterson, Holmes will probably be the six man rotation with Christian Scott and Tong as reinforcements. Maybe they pull off a Senga and/or Peterson trade but that’s a lot of moving parts just to add Framber.
Valdez to the O’s. Gallen to the Braves. That’s how it will work out.
The Braves could use any of Valdez/Gallen/Bassit/Giolito, so could the Orioles. It’s almost spring training, time to get these guys signed
I know a lot of people voted Giants here but as a Giants fan, I am not rooting for him to sign. The video of him crossing up his catcher disqualified him. I can’t imagine Posey ever going for a pitcher like that. I got to see Gallen pitch regularly as a division rival and he is an excellent pitcher. Even if he had an off year and loses velo at this stage, I predict he will adapt similar to Greinke.
My guess is blue jays since they missed out on Tucker and Bichette but Mets can also sweep in
Where did the Yankees and their wallet go?
I think if the Orioles cannot get Framber by Groundhog’s Day, they are going to pivot to Zac Gallen.
But I expect Valdez to be signed before the 2nd.
The opt outs are probably holding up the deal. He just isn’t quite front load the money and then I opt out kind of pitcher.
I picked Angels just to give myself a laugh.
Baltimore has seemed like the obvious fit from day one.
I don’t want the Giants to give him $15oM+ because that’s elite ace money and he’s.. not.
But I don’t want the Giants to give him a short-term deal with opt-outs, because you risk losing a high draft pick (2nd round for SF, I think) for one year of Framber.
So basically I don’t want the Giants to sign him for any contract he’s likely to accept.
Also I believe in Hayden Birdsong and want him to get a real shot.
Hate the opt-outs.
Posey should toss out a 3/100 if he hasn’t signed by the start of ST. Might get lucky.
No one knows. Not even Framber
Some people will guess right
I picked Angels because that team needs some pitching(and hitting).