Headlines

  • Brewers To Promote Jacob Misiorowski
  • Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony
  • Craig Kimbrel Elects Free Agency
  • Marlins Place Ryan Weathers On 60-Day IL With Lat Strain
  • White Sox To Promote Grant Taylor
  • Mariners Designate Leody Taveras For Assignment, Outright Casey Lawrence
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Extension Faceoff: Odubel Herrera vs. Ender Inciarte

By Jeff Todd | December 27, 2016 at 11:00pm CDT

The Phillies and Braves have been on remarkably similar paths this winter, seeking to boost near-term performance without jeopardizing their long-term rebuilding plans. Most notably, that has involved collecting veteran pieces (especially starters) on expensive, one-year deals.

While neither of the N.L. East rivals appear to be ready to add truly significant, long-term pieces via free agency, both were willing to make targeted investments to enhance their control over their own players this winter. Specifically, Philadelphia and Atlanta found common ground with their young center fielders, Odubel Herrera, who turns 25 on Thursday, and Ender Inciarte, who just turned 26.

It’s probably not entirely coincidental that the two pacts — struck within about a week of one another — were structured so similarly. Both players are in the 2+ service class, meaning they each already had four years of team control to go, though Inciarte had qualified as a Super Two. Instead, each player committed at least one would-be free-agent year to his team, in exchange for nearly identical guarantees: Herrera gets $30.5MM, Inciarte $30.525MM. The only meaningful difference came on the option front. The Phils can control Herrera for two more seasons (at $11.5MM and $12.5MM), while the Braves only get one additional year of control over Inciarte, but need pay him only $9MM to utilize it.

Of course, the two are hardly identical players. Herrera possesses a bigger bat, having produced at a 111 wRC+ rate over his first two MLB seasons, while Inciarte is more of a league-average hitter. Though both add value with their legs and gloves, the latter is the more accomplished in both regards. All things considered, both have established themselves as solidly above-average regulars and appear set to provide plenty of value to their respective employers over the duration of their new contracts.

Herrera arguably comes with greater upside, given the increasing power (and improved walk rate) he demonstrated last year. But you could also reasonably suggest that Inciarte’s superior value in other aspects of the game makes him a surer bet to remain a quality center fielder into his early thirties. So, just for fun, which player’s contract looks like the better bet? (Those using the Trade Rumors mobile app can weigh in here.)

Share 0 Retweet 8 Send via email0

Atlanta Braves MLBTR Originals MLBTR Polls Philadelphia Phillies

Pirates Re-Sign Ivan Nova
Main
Extension Candidate: Jake Arrieta
View Comments (73)
Post a Comment

73 Comments

  1. Diablo 2

    8 years ago

    Give me Herrera

    Reply
    • slimjones92

      8 years ago

      Exactly

      Reply
    • highlander

      8 years ago

      HERRERA – OFFENSIVE
      INCIARTE- DEFENSIVE + INTELLIGENCE
      I stay with INCIARTE

      Reply
      • jlv3gem

        8 years ago

        Guess you’re a braves fan. He’s so intelligent; he figured he’d try to transfer some of that intelligence to his girlfriend with the ‘fist to face’ method.

        I’ll take Odubel either way

        Reply
        • brandons-3

          8 years ago

          What the hell are you talking about? Ender Inciarte has NEVER been associated with domestic violence. It’s asinine and downright disgraceful to utter such nonsense.

          You’re referring to the scum Hector Olivera, who never played another game for Atlanta after his arrest. Olivera was eventually traded to San Diego for Matt Kemp and subsequently released, having stole 62.5 million dollars from three MLB teams. He’s likely done playing MLB.

          Reply
  2. lonestardodger

    8 years ago

    It’s tough to pick. Inciarte’s option is cheaper, but Herrera has two.

    Reply
  3. rouschpuppy

    8 years ago

    Herrara, because bat flips and shenanigans.

    Reply
  4. WAH1447

    8 years ago

    Inciarte all day

    Reply
    • slimjones92

      8 years ago

      Na

      Reply
      • kbarr888

        8 years ago

        If you want Offense…..You like Herrera

        If you treasure defense / speed…..you like Inciarte

        Reply
    • vacommish

      8 years ago

      I’m with you. Intangibles are wins. And weren’t the Phillies just shopping Herrera?

      Reply
      • rsmlbtr

        8 years ago

        They said they would consider trading him but I don’t recall anything that said they were actively shopping him

        Reply
  5. MB923

    8 years ago

    Tough one. I’ll lean towards Herrera due to the extra year of control. But I’d also lean with Herrera if we are to assume each players stats will continue to trend in the directions they’re going in, both at the plate and in the field. Thus far Herrera has been a good hitter and above average fielder whereas Inciarte has been a below average hitter and a great fielder. I would take good at the plate and above average D over subpar at the plate and great fielding.

    Yes Inciarte hits for a high average but he has a low OBP for someone with a high average, and he has zero power.

    I don’t think you can go wrong with either one though.

    Reply
    • HammySosa

      8 years ago

      Herrera isn’t an above average fielder.

      Reply
      • HammySosa

        8 years ago

        Although I’d take Herrera as well.

        Reply
      • MB923

        8 years ago

        I will admit I’ve seen very little of him play so I can’t say I use the eye test , but UZR/150 has him at 6.4 which is above average. He’s also 16 in DRS.

        Reply
        • MB923

          8 years ago

          Apparently the app doesn’t let me use the Plus sign. That should be Plus 6.4 UZR/150 and Plus 16 DRS.

          Reply
        • aceofrainbows

          8 years ago

          It also doesn’t take fancy and signs, which I know because I’m a Giants fan and AT and T park is annoying to type. I like herrera more

          Reply
        • kbarr888

          8 years ago

          Herrera was almost benched this past summer because of a problem with his defense……….He’s adequate on D…….but much better at the plate…..IMHO

          Reply
        • MB923

          8 years ago

          Not saying you’re wrong, but if you’re right, I wonder why he’s a Plus in UZR and DRS.

          Reply
        • El Duderino

          8 years ago

          As someone who watched all the Phillies games, it was sometimes painful to watch Herrera in the field. He makes things harder on himself with bad route running. Hopefully it improves.

          Reply
        • jlv3gem

          8 years ago

          What are you even saying right now? Speak English

          Reply
        • MB923

          8 years ago

          Jlv3gem, what’s confusing about what I said?

          Reply
    • blueagleace1

      8 years ago

      Inciarte just had a season in which he recorded a .351 OBP so how is that low? 56th best in baseball, higher than CarGo, Cano, Kinsler, Rendon, Adrian Gonzalez, Machado, McCutchen, and Justin Turner to name a few.

      Reply
      • MB923

        8 years ago

        I was looking at Career. Not 2016. But good catch. Likely due to his slight increase in BB% which certainly is always a good thing.

        Nevertheless , he still ranks behind Herrera in OBP and is below average in wOBA and wRC

        Reply
        • blueagleace1

          8 years ago

          You’re exactly right and I agree Herrera is the better offensive player but Inciarte is a better baserunner and far superior defender.

          Reply
        • MB923

          8 years ago

          No doubt that he’s a better baserunner and defender too.

          Reply
  6. chesteraarthur

    8 years ago

    herra because of how arb works

    Reply
    • Travis’ Wood

      8 years ago

      These players won’t be going through arb. You mean since Herrera would’ve made more had he gone through arb?

      Reply
      • chesteraarthur

        8 years ago

        Yeah. It is a better extension because philly is saving more because they would have had to pay him more than the braves would have to pay ender during their respective arbitration years. I thought that was clear enough

        Reply
        • sidewinder11

          8 years ago

          Ender is a super 2 player though, so he would have had 4 years of arbitration while Herrera would only have 3. Based on that, you could argue that Ender would have made more money through the arbitration process than Herrera had they not signed extensions.

          Reply
  7. cmancoley

    8 years ago

    Herrera. Just my preference with the power and high OBP. Also, I think another aspect that many people don’t think about is team chemistry. Nothing against Inciarte, but Herrera just brings a swagger and attitude that can motivate all his teammates to do better play with a spark under their butts. Love players that can do this just because they’re so rare. Other examples of this are Hosmer, JD Martinez, and Torii Hunter types.

    Reply
    • blueagleace1

      8 years ago

      You obviously haven’t watched Ender play much then…

      Reply
    • RunDMC

      8 years ago

      Swagger and attitude…lol…that’s not Inciarte — deke’ing guys and stealing game-winning HRs from Cespedes. In the words of Michael Irvin, “C’mon man!”

      Reply
  8. lesterdnightfly

    8 years ago

    Neither one causes a blip on the Richter Scale.

    Reply
    • aceofrainbows

      8 years ago

      In philly and atlanta of all places.

      Reply
  9. ahale224

    8 years ago

    With the exception of one year with Bourne, the Braves have needed a lead off guy forever. Inciarte is an important piece for them going forward. No knock on his counterpart in this argument, I’d just say it’s a better deal because it’s been a need that hasn’t had a long term answer for so long.

    Reply
  10. gmflores27

    8 years ago

    Inciarte is overrated

    Reply
    • blueagleace1

      8 years ago

      Please explain how?

      Reply
      • pukelit

        8 years ago

        Because he said so

        Reply
  11. atlbirdsnbraves

    8 years ago

    Inciarte is my pick, but, I am admittedly a braves fan. I do get to watch them both, and believe over the long hall, Herrera will produce more power, but more swing and miss. Defense during our run was so important in center. Andrew Jones was the only offensive superstar we had there. Herrera does have a swagger, but that can wear thin when your team is not performing. Inciarte has more of an even temperament, and is a better over all leader to me. My preference is Inciarte’s leadership and plus defense. he also seems to to have 15 he potential, which would make him more valuable when combined with his drs pace. Pretty even debate though. Good question really.

    Reply
  12. bravesfan82

    8 years ago

    Hard to believe Herrera was a Rule 5 pick infielder who the phillies put in CF. Great job by them…and I am a braves fan. Makes we wish we could have gotten both

    Reply
    • blueagleace1

      8 years ago

      Inciarte was actually a Rule V pick as well by the Phillies but was returned to Arizona.

      Reply
      • bravesfan82

        8 years ago

        Wow, great job by them. Imagine if they had both guys patrolling the OF

        Reply
        • pukelit

          8 years ago

          I’m a Phillies fan and still kinda pissed about that haha

          Reply
        • Christopher Guzman

          8 years ago

          Phillies have been pretty good with their Rule V picks. Herrera, Inciarte, Victorino, even Goeddel looked decent in his limited playing time.

          Reply
    • kbarr888

      8 years ago

      Dan Uggla was a Rule 5 pick up by the Marlins…….and he went on to have an excellent run for several years with them (prior to his decline). “There are some diamonds to be found in that draft”…..lol

      I tend to choose hitters over speed guys, because I am inclined to be a “Bat 1st” guy……….we each like what we like, right?

      Reply
      • RunDMC

        8 years ago

        Uggla is not a good example of Rule 5 picks making extensions look good. Yes, he came from relative obscurity into historic HR numbers for a 2B, but his extension with ATL was a joke – not to totally blame him (but also former GM Frank Wren).

        Reply
        • biasisrelitive

          8 years ago

          here’s a good example of a Rule 5 pick but not an extension

          Reply
        • brandons-3

          8 years ago

          His extension with Atlanta wasn’t a joke at the time. Maybe the fifth year. During his Marlin years he was consistent as they come. To this day I’ll never understand how far he fell

          Reply
  13. raykraft88

    8 years ago

    I’m a Braves fan, and I’d give a slight edge on Herrera.

    Reply
  14. braves2

    8 years ago

    Really? Inciarte is way more than an avg hitter and is better than herrera. Herrera may hit a few more HR but that is pretty much negated by his Ks which he does about twice as many times as inciarte who has a higher avg, more triples, equal doubles. Throw in his GG fielding Id take Ender any day of the week and twice on sunday over herrera

    Reply
    • sngehl01

      8 years ago

      Inciarte is absolutely just an “average” hitter in terms of where he ranks in the league.

      Herrera is also, IMO, but I definitely prefer him at the plate as opposed to Inciarte.

      Herrera per 162 games : .291 BA, 12 HR, 27 2B, 5 3B, 22 SB, 48 BB, 139 K, .353 OBP, .419 SLG

      Inciarte per 162 games : .292 BA, 6 HR, 29 2B, 6 2B, 24 SB, 41 BB, 76 K, .337 OBP, .385 SLG

      It’s pretty clear who the better offensive player is. It’s not by leaps and bounds, but Herrera is also still developing offensive. In 3 years from Inciarte, we haven’t really seen much of a change in his hit tool across the years. Still young enough to grow into a little more, though.

      Herrera only took a slight step forward in terms of SLG/OPS, but the BB rate climb was nice to see, as well as the drop in K rate. He may very well end up a .290 hitter with 20 HR pop and a .350+ OBP to boot.

      Herrera has a little thicker build, so he may well be able to up some HR’s and sustain it. I do think it was a bit fluky he hit 15 HR to 21 2B this year, where he hit 8 hr to 30 2B last year.

      Inciarte definitely better on defense. I guess it depends on what you value and/or need. I learn Herrera, but it’s not like it’s by a lot.

      Reply
    • Jeff Todd

      8 years ago

      Well, Herrera has clearly been a more productive batter than Inciarte, who has been like exactly a league-average hitter over the past two years. So, yeah, really, that’s what their track records suggest.

      Reply
  15. chieftoto

    8 years ago

    Definitely Inciarte

    Reply
  16. bush1

    8 years ago

    Another reminder of the historically bad Shelby Miller trade, as we discuss a “complimentary piece” extension.

    Reply
  17. urban schocker

    8 years ago

    How fun for Braves and Phillies fans to watch these two teams rebuild and compete over the next several years. Seeing these two talented CF demonstrate their abilities over the same time will be one more element of the rivalry. Go Braves, but we all win here.

    Reply
  18. baseball10

    8 years ago

    Inciarte struggled with the bat and injuries the first half of the year and still ended with that batting line. Herrera definitely has more power but you need to factor in the little league park he plays in for his offensive numbers.

    People like us will always choose the best “fantasy” guy and forget all that matters is the player’s value to help his team put wins on the board

    Reply
    • therealryan

      8 years ago

      Well wRC+ does take park factors into consideration. Herrera has 111 wRC+ and 110 wRC+ the last two seasons, compared to Inciarte’s 100 wRC+ and 97 wRC+. This also includes one season of Inciarte playing in hitter friendly AZ. Overall, I think the 2 players are very similar and both will help their teams win, but if I had to choose, I’ll take the younger player with an extra year of control in Herrera.

      Reply
    • Braves4Ever2025

      8 years ago

      This pretty much sums it up with the fantasy comment

      How many of you in here commenting play fantasy? Probably more than not. Deep down you’re going to have some bias ingrained in you.

      This isn’t as tough a question as some of you think. Not knocking Herrera, but Inciarte wins this comparison with room to spare.

      Reply
      • aff10

        8 years ago

        Idk. I think Herrera’s is more favorable from a baseball perspective. He’s had a higher OBP and SLG in each of his last two years, he’s a year younger, and Philadelphia grabbed an extra option year. He’s probably higher-risk too, since his spike in walk rate and power dwarfs anything he’s ever done in the minors, and he has had some maturity concerns. On the flip side, he’s a higher-upside play than Inciarte. I’d rather have the upside in this case than the floor that Inciarte’s defense and average bat provide

        Reply
    • Christopher Guzman

      8 years ago

      I’m going to debunk your home park advantage for Herrera hitting. He split pretty much even on the road and home. Similar across the board in his two years. Inciarte (at least by average) had been a better home hitter but better power on the road where Herrera is pretty even across the board.

      Reply
  19. therealryan

    8 years ago

    The real question here is, can the Rays come to agreement with Kiermaier on a similar extension? He is also a 2+ service time CF with a similar age and a blending of their two skill sets. Time to lock him up Rays.

    Reply
    • bigpapijuicer

      8 years ago

      Kiermaier will cost more.

      Reply
  20. ABK99

    8 years ago

    I like Inciarte a little bit more as a player, but not enough to make up for the extra year of potential control for Herrera.

    Reply
  21. MatthewBaltimore23

    8 years ago

    I would go with Herrera. He has a better offensive output, though Inciarte is a better defender and has more speed. Herrera does come with the extra year of control, though.

    Reply
  22. Bob Knob

    8 years ago

    Inciarte.
    Leadoff hitter ?
    Ranked 60th in OBP…..(400ab+)
    60th !
    Not particularly good at his primary role.

    Reply
  23. basilisk4

    8 years ago

    Both are nice players and both teams did well to lock them up.

    One thing I wonder about with Herrrera — he had 15 HR in 656 p[ate appearances in 2016, compared to a total of 13 HR in his entire minor-league career (2,597 PA). While he’s just 24 and a lot of guys start to hit for more power as they get a little older (versus when they are teenagers), that’s still a pretty huge jump. It makes me wonder whether the power is real or whether that number will come back down.

    Reply
  24. cardfan2011

    8 years ago

    I don’t think there’s necessarily a right answer here, it’s all opinion; both bring a strength to their respective clubs, so both are good extensions

    Reply
  25. money

    8 years ago

    I like both players,but I think Herrera going to be the better of the two.
    He’s a year younger has more power potential and as far as fielding he’s only been in CF two years. Prior to that he only played second base.
    You can’t defense him. He slashes the ball all over the field. He’s strikes out too much,but I think he will cut down on that .He gets his share of infield hits,but also hits the ball hard a lot.
    If the Phillies can get some more bats to drive him in then he’d be a more exciting ballplayer .

    Reply
  26. JDSchneck

    8 years ago

    Inciarte all the way. The guy hit freakin .410 against left handers in the 2nd half and he’s left handed!!! Inciarte had the best glove in CF and probably top 5 arm in CF. the guy has wheels too. Enders power could improve in the new park, as well as having better protection, similar to Freeman’s blossom with the addition of Kemp. Having Swanson for an entire year will boost Inciartes performance, no doubt.

    Reply
  27. Z-A 2

    8 years ago

    Odubel – 4, Ender – 1, Tie – 2.

    Defense – Ender – 2016
    Baserunning – Push – Career 1% difference
    Power – Odubel – Career
    OBP – Odubel – Career
    BA – Push – Career .001 difference
    WAR – Odubel – 2015-2016
    Years of Control – Odubel

    Reply
  28. RBI

    8 years ago

    Inciarte because he makes the players around him better, both in the field and offensively. Ender being on base gets more fastballs for the hitters behind him and his speed is a distraction for the opposing pitchers and fielders. His better defense helps his pitching staff tremendously.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Brewers To Promote Jacob Misiorowski

    Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony

    Craig Kimbrel Elects Free Agency

    Marlins Place Ryan Weathers On 60-Day IL With Lat Strain

    White Sox To Promote Grant Taylor

    Mariners Designate Leody Taveras For Assignment, Outright Casey Lawrence

    Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.

    Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Braves Select Craig Kimbrel

    Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox

    White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel

    Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!

    Pablo Lopez To Miss Multiple Months With Teres Major Strain

    MLB To Propose Automatic Ball-Strike Challenge System For 2026

    Giants Designate LaMonte Wade Jr., Sign Dominic Smith

    Reds Sign Wade Miley, Place Hunter Greene On Injured List

    Padres Interested In Jarren Duran

    Royals Promote Jac Caglianone

    Mariners Promote Cole Young, Activate Bryce Miller

    2025-26 MLB Free Agent Power Rankings: May Edition

    Recent

    Rangers To Sign Craig Kimbrel To Minor League Deal

    Akil Baddoo Accepts Outright Assignment With Tigers

    Dodgers Recall Matt Sauer, DFA José Ureña

    Chris Stratton Elects Free Agency

    Aaron Nola To Be Shut Down For Two Weeks With Stress Reaction In Rib Cage

    Mets Sign Travis Jankowski To Minor League Deal

    Poll: Can Drew Rasmussen Keep Pitching Like An Ace?

    White Sox Designate Bryse Wilson For Assignment

    Nationals Claim Ryan Loutos

    Brewers To Promote Jacob Misiorowski

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version