Headlines

  • Yordan Alvarez Shut Down Due To Setback With Hand Injury
  • Giants Exercise 2026 Option On Manager Bob Melvin
  • Astros Place Jeremy Peña On Injured List With Fractured Rib
  • Tucker Barnhart To Retire
  • Tyler Mahle To Be Sidelined Beyond Trade Deadline
  • Reds Release Jeimer Candelario
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2025 Trade Deadline Outlook Series
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

MLBTR Poll: Grading Recent Extensions

By Jeff Todd | March 22, 2017 at 9:10am CDT

As usual, the offseason has brought a few fairly significant long-term deals. Though we haven’t seen any nine-figure strikes — yet, at least — teams have staked a variety of interesting long-term bets on players who weren’t particularly close to free agency.

Since the start of February, in particular, three players with multiple years of control remaining have received guarantees that secure their financial future. But how wise were these investments? While it’s easy to like most early-career extensions — they are typically reached with young players who have played well at the game’s highest level, after all — they don’t all work out. The budgetary impact will never be as large as a pact to keep a top star off the market (or to bring one in), but even these early-career deals turn non-obligatory control rights into massive financial commitments that can hinder organizational flexibility.

Here are the most recent deals, with polls for each asking you to grade the merit of the investment:

Carlos Martinez, SP, Cardinals: five years, $51MM with two options ($17MM, $18MM): The first-time arb-eligible righty could be on the cusp of blooming into an established, top-of-the-rotation arm at 25 years of age. This deal extends the club’s control span over Martinez by four years, so there’s clear upside here. But it also comes with a hefty up-front promise and passes the risks inherent to pitching on to the Cards. The closest comp to this agreement, Matt Harrison’s $55MM deal with the Rangers, shows that there’s downside as well.

(Poll link for app users.)

Kevin Kiermaier, CF, Rays: six years, $53.5MM with one option ($13MM): Kiermaier was a Super Two player, so this deal boosts Tampa Bay’s control by three seasons. Only one of those is left to the team’s discretion, leaving the organization fairly firmly committed to the defensive whiz. While his glove gives him a lofty floor, that’s also dependent upon maintained athleticism. And Kiermaier hasn’t yet shown he’s more than an average hitter. If he can do that and keep tracking down just about everything hit in his general direction, he could be a star.

(Poll link for app users.)

Tim Anderson, SS, White Sox: six years, $25MM with two options ($12.5MM, $14MM): Announced just yesterday, this deal is quite a bit different than the others. Anderson hasn’t even completed a full season in the majors, and remains a highly variable player despite the evident talent. Understandably, he could only secure about half the guarantee of the other players, though he did easily beat the prior record for a sub-1 MLB service extension (Chris Archer, $20MM). Notably, this contract only promises to pay Anderson through his arbitration-eligible seasons (assuming he’s able to remain in the majors from this point forward), meaning the South Siders only extended their control rights by two years but also didn’t have to promise to pay Anderson too far out.

(Poll link for app users.)

Share 0 Retweet 6 Send via email0

MLBTR Polls

Straight From The Heart: The Signing Of Ted Lilly
Main
Minor MLB Transactions: 3/22/17
View Comments (22)
Post a Comment

22 Comments

  1. Matt Rox

    8 years ago

    Carlos Martinez deal——-: A-
    Kevin Kiermaier Deal——-: B-
    Tim Anderson deal:——-A+

    The way I see it, the Martinez deal was a great bargain at the time that panned out so far.
    The Kiermaier deal might be good, but Rays could’ve done better.
    The Tim Anderson deal IMO is the best extension on paper at the time, I also think it might be one of the best deals in history, if it pans out. Very little downside.

    All 3 deals look good for the team more-so than the player. But I like Anderson’s the most, from the White Sox standpoint. Giving a former 1st round pick who mastered the minors and just had a very strong Rookie year this deal, which buys out some FA years, is just WOW. This could be like the Evan Longoria and Bumgarner deals all over again.

    1
    Reply
    • Vedder80

      8 years ago

      How was the Martinez deal a “bargain at the time that panned out so far?” He hasn’t thrown a single pitch in a single season since signing the deal.

      4
      Reply
      • Hiro

        8 years ago

        Probably meant track record…

        1
        Reply
        • chesteraarthur

          8 years ago

          That still doesn’t make any sense

          1
          Reply
        • jdackleyjd

          8 years ago

          Maybe he meant track record for the Dominican team?

          Reply
        • Matt Rox

          8 years ago

          Sorry. I actually thought Martinez signed that deal after the 2015 season. I should’ve looked it up.

          1
          Reply
    • higuys

      8 years ago

      The Anderson deal does not buy out an FA years, just arbitration.

      1
      Reply
      • Matt Rox

        8 years ago

        Really? I thought I heard otherwise. Therefore I guess I should be double checking my ” facts”

        Reply
        • Priggs89

          8 years ago

          The guaranteed portion only covers his pre-arb/arb years, but the two team options cover what would be his first two FA years at $12.5M and $14M.

          Reply
  2. Kayrall

    8 years ago

    I loved the Martinez and Kiermaier deals, but not so much the Anderson contract. The Cards acquired controllable years for a TOR pitcher for multiple years into free agency at what could be significantly below market value. The Rays, in my mind, put Kiermaier in the exact mold of Adam Eaton. The Sox, although I agree with what they have done this offseason took a gamble on a guy that has decent floor because of his defense, but lower upside because of red flags in his offense.

    3
    Reply
    • AidanVega123

      8 years ago

      Exactly what I was thinking regarding Anderson. He had a nice average last year but his OBP wasn’t really that good and there’s always the possibility that he regresses.

      1
      Reply
      • lesterdnightfly

        8 years ago

        Exactly. Low OBP + unsustainable BABIP looks like he likely regresses some. Anderson looks like good floor, iffy ceiling.

        1
        Reply
    • sunshipballoons

      8 years ago

      If Anderson ends up a .270 with no walks, that’s still not a bad deal for the White Sox over five years. I think he looks more like Jean Segura with good defense, though. So if he ends up more like .300, he’s a huge bargain.

      2
      Reply
      • therealryan

        8 years ago

        Do you realize that if Jean Segura is healthy and productive this season, he will earn around $20 million for his first 6 years. Brandon Crawford will earn less than $19 million for his first 6 years. The White Sox just guaranteed Anderson $25 million for his first 6 seasons and he has some large red flags with his strike zone judgement. Over the last 50 years, his BB/K is the worst all time for any rookie with over 400 PA. I’m happy for Anderson, but unless he takes some large steps forward this extension could be a wash or worse.

        Reply
  3. redsfan48

    8 years ago

    Anderson’s deal, because of his very limited experience, gets an “incomplete”

    2
    Reply
  4. jumsy

    8 years ago

    The Martinez deal is the best deal of the 3. Anderson has never shown consistent ability to take a walk, so his OBP will always be driven on average alone. Kiermaier seems to be Peter Bourjos with a better bat, which is pretty good (5.5 WAR), but I question his ability to continue to hit consistently..
    Martinez is a top of the rotation arm at age 25 where the Cardinals will be getting his prime years and just coming off a 5.9 WAR season. He is the staff ace and was the staff ace last season as well. His comp is Matt Harrison, who was never considered to be a staff ace (due to his low K numbers), but was still paid more than what Martinez is getting..

    Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      8 years ago

      Where are you getting 5.9?

      2
      Reply
    • prufrock88

      8 years ago

      low K numbers as an evidently major determining factor for “staff ace”? is this new? somewhere, Jamie Moyer is smiling…

      Reply
  5. Dookie Howser, MD

    8 years ago

    Lets grade contracts that are ending! 20/20 hindsight is fun!

    2
    Reply
  6. jdgoat

    8 years ago

    Kiermaiers is the best but Martinez is a close second. Andersons was good but not in the same way the other two were

    2
    Reply
  7. CelticSentinel314

    8 years ago

    Why isn’t the Odubel Herrera deal here? Had an 8 WAR over 2 seasons. If he only has half of that each season of the 5 year deal, that’s a total of 18 WAR. That has to merit at least consideration.

    Reply
  8. SFgiantsUK

    8 years ago

    Martinez:
    For the Player FAIR
    For the Team FAIR

    He is a good pitcher, he isn’t an ace, and he isn’t being paid for being an ace.

    Kiermaier
    For the Player AMAZING
    For the Team FAIR

    For that money the Team has him locked, he isn’t great and he won’t ever be great, that’s why he isn’t getting great money comparatively to a Cespedes. The team is getting what they are paying for, Kiermaier won’t get that money in Japan or in Korea.

    Anderson
    For the Player FAIR
    For the Team AMAZING

    He is getting paid for what he has shown thus far. And the team is locking him up, for a long time at a team friendly deal. He should have waited.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

    Top Stories

    Yordan Alvarez Shut Down Due To Setback With Hand Injury

    Giants Exercise 2026 Option On Manager Bob Melvin

    Astros Place Jeremy Peña On Injured List With Fractured Rib

    Tucker Barnhart To Retire

    Tyler Mahle To Be Sidelined Beyond Trade Deadline

    Reds Release Jeimer Candelario

    Dave Parker Passes Away

    Griffin Canning Diagnosed With Ruptured Achilles

    Pirates Reportedly Have Very Few Untouchable Players At Trade Deadline

    Griffin Canning Believed To Have Suffered Achilles Injury

    Mariners Looking For Corner Infield Bats; Ownership Willing To Bump Payroll

    Wander Franco Found Guilty Of Sexual Abuse

    Mariners Place Rowdy Tellez On Release Waivers

    Max Meyer To Undergo Season-Ending Hip Surgery

    Whit Merrifield Announces Retirement

    White Sox Sign Noah Syndergaard To Minor League Deal

    Corbin Carroll Placed On IL With Wrist Fracture

    Hoops Rumors Has The Latest On NBA Draft, Free Agency

    Mets Option Francisco Alvarez

    Reds To Promote Chase Burns For MLB Debut

    Recent

    Trey Mancini Opts Out Of D-Backs Deal

    Padres To Select Eduarniel Nunez

    Brewers’ Connor Thomas To Undergo Elbow Surgery

    Yordan Alvarez Shut Down Due To Setback With Hand Injury

    Jorge Mateo To Miss 8 To 12 Weeks With Hamstring Strain

    Reds To Sign Buck Farmer To Minor League Deal

    Pirates Trade Hunter Stratton To Braves

    Rockies Designate Sam Hilliard For Assignment, Select Austin Nola

    Orioles Select Jacob Stallings, Designate Emmanuel Rivera For Assignment

    Rangers Select Billy McKinney, Transfer Tyler Mahle To 60-Day IL

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Sandy Alcantara Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Alex Bregman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android App Store Google Play

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • Trade Deadline Outlook Series
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    Do not Sell or Share My Personal Information

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version