Headlines

  • Orioles Acquire Cole Irvin From A’s
  • Astros Name Dana Brown General Manager
  • Rays Extend Jeffrey Springs
  • Royals, Red Sox Swap Adalberto Mondesi For Josh Taylor
  • Red Sox Designate Matt Barnes For Assignment
  • Scott Rolen Elected Into Baseball Hall Of Fame
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2022-23 MLB Free Agent List
    • Top 50 Free Agents
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2023
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Arbitration Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Blue Jays To Sign Yusei Kikuchi

By Darragh McDonald | March 12, 2022 at 1:58pm CDT

The Blue Jays are signing left-handed pitcher Yusei Kikuchi, per Jon Heyman of MLB Network. It’s a three-year, $36MM contract. (Twitter links) The deal is frontloaded, per Bob Nightengale of USA Today, with Kikuchi earning a salary of $16MM in 2022, followed by $10MM in each of 2023 and 2024.

Starting pitching has been a hot commodity this offseason, with most of the top names signing before the lockout. Now that the transactions freeze has thawed, the market has picked up right where it left off. The top two free agent hurlers that lingered on the market through the lockout, Clayton Kershaw and Carlos Rodon, signed on the first full day after the lockout ended. That left Kikuchi and Zack Greinke as the only healthy starters remaining from MLBTR’s list of Top 50 Free Agents. With the Jays scooping up Kikuchi, that leaves Greinke as the last man standing.

Kikuchi has been one of the more difficult pitchers to evaluate since coming over from Japan prior to the 2019 season. In his first MLB season, he made 32 starts for the Mariners, throwing 161 2/3 innings with an ERA of 5.46 and a strikeout rate of just 16.1%. In the shortened 2020 campaign, he made nine starts and still had a high ERA of 5.11, but made huge strides in the strikeout department, bumping his rate up to 24.2%.

2021 was a tale of two seasons for Kikuchi, as the first half his campaign was excellent. At the start of July, MLBTR’s Steve Adams wrote about Kikuchi’s season around the midway point, when Kikuchi had made 15 starts and was sitting on an ERA of 3.18, strikeout rate of 25.4%, walk rate of 8.5% and ground-ball rate of 53.8%. But things went completely in the opposite direction in the second half of the season, as Kikuchi threw 63 2/3 innings from that point on, with a 6.22 ERA, 23.3% strikeout rate, 10.3% walk rate and 41.7% ground-ball rate.

As part of the unusual structure of Kikuchi’s contract, at the end of the season, the Mariners then had to decide whether or not to execute a series of four one-year options valued at $16.5MM each, effectively a four-year, $66MM extension that would cover the 2022-25 seasons. After they declined, then Kikuchi could have selected a one-year, $13MM player option for the 2022. Though it seemed there was a chance he would accept that deal after his poor performance down the stretch, he ultimately declined and tested the free agent market. That has now proven to be a wise decision on his part, as he has earned himself a new contract at that exact rate but three times as long.

The Blue Jays were evidently encouraged enough by Kikuchi’s strengths to overlook his weaknesses, much like they were with Robbie Ray and Steven Matz. Although those two pitchers had serious flaws on their respective resumes, they both went on to have excellent campaigns with the Jays in 2021, with Ray earning the American League Cy Young award. Although Ray and Matz will both be wearing new uniforms this year, Kikuchi is still going to be joining a strong rotation. The club also added Kevin Gausman prior to the lockout, joining Jose Berrios, Hyun Jin Ryu and Alek Manoah. That is likely to be the club’s front five, but they also have Ross Stripling on hand, who could function either as a starter or long-man out of the bullpen. Nate Pearson could potentially join the rotation at some point, though he has durability concerns after throwing just 18 innings in 2020 and just 45 2/3 in 2021.

After the lockout, the 2022 season is going to feature a condensed Spring Training and a regular season with added double-headers to make up for the delayed start to the campaign. Those factors, combined with the dwindling options in the free agent market, led the Jays to take a risk by bolstering their depth with a pitcher who has had flashes of excellence but also definite concerns.

As for the structure of the deal, it’s worth pointing out that the Blue Jays also front-loaded their contract with George Springer. This seems to be a way of taking advantage of the fact that most of the club’s core players are still working their way through arbitration and will only get increasingly expensive in the coming years. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is arbitration eligible for the first time this year as a Super Two player. Teoscar Hernandez will be playing his second of three arbitration seasons in 2022. Bo Bichette and Jordan Romano won’t be arbitration eligible until next year. By paying Springer and Kikuchi more now, the club will have a little bit extra wiggle room to weather the increasing salaries of those players in the coming seasons.

Image courtesy of USA Today Sports.

Share 0 Retweet 11 Send via email0

Newsstand Toronto Blue Jays Transactions Yusei Kikuchi

Twins Acquire Isiah Kiner-Falefa For Mitch Garver
Main
Angels To Re-Sign Kurt Suzuki
View Comments (215)

Comments

  1. Tacoshells

    11 months ago

    Wth!

    Reply
  2. The Baseball Fan (Doesn’t like the Cubs)

    11 months ago

    Nice! That rotation is one of the best in baseball

    Reply
    • 48-team MLB

      11 months ago

      By far the best in all of Canada

      Reply
      • Pete LaCock

        11 months ago

        Lol, nice

        Reply
        • WillSmith

          11 months ago

          Pete , your last name excites me.

        • bobtillman

          11 months ago

          Kind of a Square name, in a Hollywood sort of way.

        • DonnyDownvote

          11 months ago

          Circle gets the square.

    • jimmertee

      11 months ago

      NO this rotation is not by far the best in baseball. It thankfully has quality depth but it doesn’t have an alpha front of the roation starter.

      It has a #2 {Berrios}, two 3’s [Gausman and Ryu], a #4 in Manoah who will get better, and the rest are unknowns or #5’s. {Kikuchi, Stripling, Garcia).

      Kay and Pearson are NOT starters. Give that one a rest. They are both relievers. Kay is a one inning max effort 7th inning guy and Pearson could be a closer if someone in the Jays gets their head on right and teaches him to relax and pitch rather than throw.

      Reply
      • Akakak

        11 months ago

        Ryu alternates between being a high end fourth and a low end ace each year. This should be an ace year lol

        Reply
      • Braves Fan 138

        11 months ago

        Manoah a number 4# starter bro what are you smoking I want some!

        Reply
        • tad2b13

          11 months ago

          Braves Fan 138:

          I know right? I wish my team had a #4 guy that posted a 136 ERA+ in his first year as a 23 year-old.

        • TalkSomeSense

          11 months ago

          Jimmer doesn’t smoke he uses mushrooms lol.

      • rovssss

        11 months ago

        Jimmer, Gausman is a #1-2. He’s really good. Kikuchi a wild card, Manoah hopefully is a 3. So Gausman (#2), Berrios (#2), Ryu (#3), Manoah (#3). That’s your playoff rotation.

        And then you have options for 5th starter and BP (Kay, Pearson, Kikuchi, Hatch).

        I don’t really understand the Kikuchi add, but I always felt he’d be dynamite as a reliever. So we’ll see if the Jays get creative and get the most out of him. He’s got a live arm, just his pitch mix is kind of not great for a starter.

        Reply
      • gwa500

        11 months ago

        This is a terrible take

        Reply
        • GareBear

          11 months ago

          That’s the only kind of takes jimmer ever has.

      • Mystery Team

        11 months ago

        Manoah is the best number 4 of all time lol. He’s probably the best pitcher in that rotation. It’s a good rotation.

        Reply
    • Hammer please quit 30 words or less

      11 months ago

      what kind of brownies did u bake?

      Reply
    • dsett75

      11 months ago

      Still falls way short of Milwaukee’s, imho. But I know, you said “one” of the better. I agree.

      Reply
  3. Pete LaCock

    11 months ago

    Overpay much for a guy whos never seen an ERA below 4.41? Could see him being a decent pickup, but still an overpay if you ask me.

    Reply
    • IjustloveBaseball

      11 months ago

      Think the consensus is that Kikuchi could have some untapped potential in the tank — likely ran up his price a bit.

      Reply
      • rovssss

        11 months ago

        Kikuchi has a very live arm but can’t spin a breaking ball or a changeup for the life of him. Maybe there’s some Pete Walker magic there.

        Reply
    • falconsball1993

      11 months ago

      $10mil is about average for that production now.

      Reply
      • Pete LaCock

        11 months ago

        It’s still crazy to me to know that, even in MLB’s economy, that’s true.

        Reply
        • YankeesBleacherCreature

          11 months ago

          That’s the cost of competing in the AL East. He’s a steady pitcher; won’t win a CYA. Jays are also getting his prime years.

    • WillSmith

      11 months ago

      Pete , your last name excites me.

      Reply
      • wvpirate

        11 months ago

        If you were old enough you would have remembered Pete LaCock from the Chicago Cubs. Son of Peter Marshall, from the Hollywood Squares.

        Reply
        • Halo11Fan

          11 months ago

          I remember him with the Royals.

        • Hammer please quit 30 words or less

          11 months ago

          My mom told me stories about him. said I resemble him and the mailman.

        • DonnyDownvote

          11 months ago

          Peter Marshall or Pierre LaCock is still kicking. 94 years old. So is Bob Barker. He’s 98. Johnny Gilbert is still announcing for Jeopardy. He’s 98.

        • goob

          11 months ago

          @Hammer please quit 30 words or less

          Stop it! 🙂

    • Omarj

      11 months ago

      In 2020 in he had a 5.17 ERA but a 3.30 FIP. I do believe there’s potential with this guy and I do believe Toronto has superior defense so quality signing in my book

      Reply
      • seamaholic 2

        11 months ago

        Don’t read anything into 2020 stats.

        Reply
        • Pete LaCock

          11 months ago

          Its his 2019 and 2021 stats I really look at. He looked good first half of the year, but folded as the season went. The guy is very homer prone, not gonna bode well for him in the AL East. His only saving grace is the one team from that division he wont have to play is the Jays.

        • Dustyslambchops23

          11 months ago

          If I recall correctly he had a really good start agains the jays last year

    • Dutch Vander Linde

      11 months ago

      I think 3/25 mil would’ve done it.

      Reply
      • goob

        11 months ago

        I doubt it. I think the Jays probably paid (approximately) the going-rate.

        Reply
  4. Ha-Seong Kim

    11 months ago

    Lfg, open the floodgates!

    Reply
  5. Jaysfan1981

    11 months ago

    Nice, Stripling goes back to a spot start swing role, Pearson is in the BP or AAA

    Reply
  6. 48-team MLB

    11 months ago

    I still predict a Blue Jays/Giants World Series this decade.

    Reply
    • Tacoshells

      11 months ago

      Let’s goooo!!!!!

      Reply
      • 48-team MLB

        11 months ago

        I also predict Braves/White Sox, Padres/Red Sox, Dodgers/Rangers and Yankees/Brewers.

        Reply
        • stevecohenMVP

          11 months ago

          None of those will happen. Good try

        • YankeesBleacherCreature

          11 months ago

          Pittsburgh/Baltimore

        • 48-team MLB

          11 months ago

          The Mets won’t be champions anytime soon.

        • Alexburnshred

          11 months ago

          Marlins/Orioles

        • 48-team MLB

          11 months ago

          Cardinals/Angels at the end of the decade

        • stevecohenMVP

          11 months ago

          Mets will be before brewers, Padres or rangers, you neophyte

        • 48-team MLB

          11 months ago

          Incorrect. The Mets are cursed.

        • stevecohenMVP

          11 months ago

          Your life is cursed.

        • 48-team MLB

          11 months ago

          False. My team just won a championship four months ago and they went through both the Dodgers and the Astros in the process.

        • stevecohenMVP

          11 months ago

          I don’t care at all

        • BobGibsonFan

          11 months ago

          You don’t care at all about World Championships? Must be a Mets fan.

        • goob

          11 months ago

          @48

          I’d predict that you have predictions that you haven’t even thought of yet. 🙂

        • RandalGrichuksStubble

          11 months ago

          HeHell’ll yeah

  7. FSF

    11 months ago

    For that kind of money, they can have him. Team ownerships crying poor and paying this kind of money out for that track record?

    Reply
    • Camden453

      11 months ago

      ‘That kind of money’? 12 million?

      Reply
      • ellisburks

        11 months ago

        the 3 year commitment is the big thing. This guy in the AL East will get lit up.

        Reply
        • cjmask

          11 months ago

          Same thing everyone said about Robbie Ray when the Jays signed him.

        • Akakak

          11 months ago

          Pete walker will take that bet.

        • Ducky Buckin Fent

          11 months ago

          In 2019 he would’ve been. Depends upon which baseball is used this year.

        • FSF

          11 months ago

          @cjmask

          What??? First off Robbie Ray had a better and longer track record, was younger and signed a $8M, 1-year deal. Where do you see any analogy to Ray?

      • FSF

        11 months ago

        Yes, This is the kind of player would have gotten a $6-8M one year deal with a team option for $8-10, with maybe a $1M buyout. He’s someone who’s had years that one can only describe as very bad to horrible.

        Reply
    • GB85

      11 months ago

      This is a reasonable contract, and it has been reported for months that Rogers was going to spend this offseason to improve the team. Kikuchi may indeed be a #5 starter, but he’s an upgrade over Stripling and could very well be a lot better than a back of the rotation piece. Nice job Jays.

      Reply
      • ellisburks

        11 months ago

        He will get lit up in the AL East. one year $12 fine. Another 2 years after that? Not smart. He is 32 this year, there is not a lot of potential.

        Reply
      • MoneyBallJustWorks

        11 months ago

        move stripling in a package for jram

        Reply
        • Dustyslambchops23

          11 months ago

          Will he be driving Moreno and Groshans to Cleveland?

        • Jaysfan1981

          11 months ago

          I’ll drive all 3 of them at my expense and pay for Jrams flight to TO if we can make that official

        • dsett75

          11 months ago

          Moneyball, it’s going to take a ton to get Jose Ramirez. And Stripling probably wouldn’t even be a part of any deal. He’s a depth piece at best.

        • MikeD26

          11 months ago

          And 3 more prospects.

  8. Camden453

    11 months ago

    The Mets were ‘allegedly’ in on Kikuchi. You have to take these reports with a grain of salt

    Reply
    • 48-team MLB

      11 months ago

      @Camden453

      He probably rejected the Mets since they are cursed.

      Reply
      • stevecohenMVP

        11 months ago

        @48team You hate so hard on the Mets. It must feel good to have a micro peen, you sloppy human.

        Reply
        • neo

          11 months ago

          for how long have you been focused on talking with others about the size of their peen? can you remember the first time you felt it important to raise this topic with someone? if you can trace back the circumstances of this behavior, it may inform you about something important within yourself that you should try to understand.

      • Camden453

        11 months ago

        It’s not that they’re cursed it’s just that a losing tradition breeds losing…after a while everyone- the fans, the front office, etc gets shaky about it

        Reply
        • YankeesBleacherCreature

          11 months ago

          It’s a new regime with a reshaped front office. This take is as tiring as the Astros’ trash can banging meme.

        • stevecohenMVP

          11 months ago

          The trashtros will never get old

        • You Can Put It In The Books

          11 months ago

          They know that. The detractors are only now coming out in force because Cohen has the resources to spend $300M for the next few seasons while simultaneously investing ~$250M in building out the Mets analytics department. It’s a frightening proposition, seeing how Cohen is a brilliant, analytical, billionaire hedge fund manager and venture capitalist. He’s the most unique owner in sports. So let the haters like @MarlinsFanBase and @48-team MLB pound the same, tired drum about the Met’s past. We all know they’re internally panicking about the Mets future. It’s good to be a Mets fan, boys!

      • You Can Put It In The Books

        11 months ago

        “tHe mEtS aRe CuRsEd”

        Reply
  9. jdgoat

    11 months ago

    I feel like they could have got a fifth starter on a one year deal. Big risk here.

    Reply
    • Dustyslambchops23

      11 months ago

      I wouldnt say big risk, but a risk yes.

      Either way, the fact that they could have started the year with Stripling or Pearson at #5 but still looked to improve is a good sign.

      Reply
    • Best Screenname Ever

      11 months ago

      Lots of good starters looking to go to Canada on cheap one year deals. Sigh.

      They’re looking for a back of the rotation arm. They got a guy. Of course they overpaid, it’s Canada and no one’s going unless they pay more $ over more years. So cut them some slack. At least they’re trying. I look at it as paying 2×10 if he was going to the Sox and that’s about market.

      Reply
      • Dustyslambchops23

        11 months ago

        Yah that’s some BS.

        Toronto is top 5 place to work and live in North America, very easily. Safe, great restaurants, good schools for kids etc. With an exciting young team ready to be competitive, why would they need to overpay?

        Reply
        • Best Screenname Ever

          11 months ago

          I’m guessing Toronto may not even be top 5 in Canada, let alone In North America. But sure, lots Americqns looking to pull up stakes and move to Toronto. I think the crush at the border of people trying to move to Canada from California, Texas, New York, Mass. etc must weigh down your border guards. Must be the govt health care.

          Toronto had to give Ryu 4. Berrios 7 (!!!). Gausman 5. Springer 6.

        • MoneyBallJustWorks

          11 months ago

          tax implications vs some states is just one thought.

        • Dustyslambchops23

          11 months ago

          I’m not going to argue with the fact that 3 of the 5 guys you listed as overpays aren’t even American lol.

          Guasman would have got 5 anywhere, Springer meh, maybe a bit over pay by one year. So you have on example to back up your trash opinion.

          Should we now try the same for literally any other team in the US that has signed free agents the last few years?

        • Dustyslambchops23

          11 months ago

          Canadian tax rates don’t differ all that much from the bigger blue states in the US. So yes one can easily argue that playing in florida or texas would be more desirable vs playing in Toronto financially but you can make that case over New York and CA as well.

        • Dustyslambchops23

          11 months ago

          Of course they overpaid Cole, it’s New York! No one’s going unless they pay more money.

          Of course they overpaid Seager it’s Texas!
          No one’s going unless they pay more money.

          Of course they overpaid Rendon it’s Anaheim!
          No one’s going unless they pay more money.

          Are you going to admit that you’re wrong? Or you going to put your tail between your legs and hide like you always do when someone proves how stupid the things you say are

        • gomer33

          11 months ago

          He’s a bit butt hurt that you had the audacity to suggest that just maybe other cities in the world could possibly be as good or better than a city in “Murica.

        • neo

          11 months ago

          I’m guessing you don’t put too much thought into anything you do or say. Thinking is okay, but too much is exhausting?

        • Best Screenname Ever

          11 months ago

          What schools do you mean? That’s a big disincentive for people with young children whose employers would like them to transfer for a while to Canada. The only schools they have are the govt schools. Sorry to break it to you Dusty but the Socialist Paradise is an unappealing destination.

        • TalkSomeSense

          11 months ago

          If you think Canada is full on socialist you have been indoctrinated by the likes of Tucker Carlson. I have lived and worked all over the world and Canada is one of the most free countries in the world with one of the best standards of living and lowest crime rates. ( There is a reason Canada is consistently in the Top 5 best countries to live rankings ) As for schools why do people without a clue insist on putting their ignorance on full display online. There are tons of private schools in Canada.

        • bigdaddyt

          11 months ago

          That’s cute that you don’t think 100k a year private schools don’t exist in Canada

        • Shakermo

          11 months ago

          Your ignorance is truly breathtaking. Toronto has some of the best private schools in the world. My classmates were kids from royal families in Europe. My parents neighbor was a raptor whose two daughters loved their school.

        • Shakermo

          11 months ago

          And that raptor came back to Toronto after his playing career was over to work for the team. The city loved him and he loved the city. The Junk Yard Dog. Great guy and incredibly bright.

        • YankeesBleacherCreature

          11 months ago

          @Shakermo. Used to date a Canadian and travelled to Toronto plenty. I’d chose it over many American cities if I had to move.

        • Best Screenname Ever

          11 months ago

          I had to laugh at this one. Tucker Carlson? I don’t know if I’ve watched him more than once or twice in my life. The only people I think watch that are old folks looking for their ‘Libs Gone Wild’ daily fix, or young ‘progressives’ looking for their opposites to get mad about. But seriously thanks for the chuckle.

          I don’t think there are tons of private schools in Canada. I think it’s like sending your kids to the San Francisco School Board. Maybe worse, because in SF you could recall those clowns. Can you in Canada?

        • TalkSomeSense

          11 months ago

          See you just summed up your problem ” You think” versus taking the time to actually find out. A common ailment amongst many of you. Take the time to research something you know nothing about and you won’t look so ignorant online. Question- what countries have you actually travelled and spent time in to know about their way of life , you seem to have a very narrow distorted view of the world .

        • Best Screenname Ever

          11 months ago

          I see Villar turned down the Blue Jays. Guess he hadn’t read about all the advantages of schools and govt health care.

        • TalkSomeSense

          11 months ago

          Nothing to do with the fact he may be waiting for a 2 yr deal or more $$. Or more playing time then the Jays are offering.

          You need to travel and explore the world – might help with you becoming a more rounded human being.

      • Akakak

        11 months ago

        3 x 12 is a minor overpay. They had the dollars available to get a guy they targeted. Worst case scenario he got an extra year but the jays still picked their player and are in fact driving the market the last couple years.

        Reply
        • Best Screenname Ever

          11 months ago

          This is what I said. I actually said it wasn’t a big deal because they have to offer more years and dollars. and the locals went off because they think it’s a baseball destination.

  10. bigdaddyhacks

    11 months ago

    That dude in that ballpark. LLOOLLZZ

    Reply
  11. davidk1979

    11 months ago

    Jays rotation is stacked Berrios/Gausman/Manoah/Ryu/Kikuchi easily one of the best rotations.

    Reply
    • Jaysfan1981

      11 months ago

      Probably go Gausman,Ryu,Berrios,Kikuchi,Manoah to keep the R/L split up

      Might even swap Berrios with Gausman

      How it should probably go is Berrios Manoah Gausman Ryu Kikuchi but that doesn’t flow as well against lineups and trying to keep them off balance

      Reply
      • tstats

        11 months ago

        I think it should go Berrios Guasman Ryu Manoah Kikchui

        Reply
    • Pete'sView

      11 months ago

      Unless Gausman regresses. A two-pitch pitcher who started to struggle in last year’s second half.

      Reply
      • Dustyslambchops23

        11 months ago

        With the jays offense they don’t need sub 3 ERA guys.

        If they can put together 4-5 guys who can give them 180+ innings at around 4 ERA, they will be a good team

        Reply
        • The Natural

          11 months ago

          Exactly right..

        • subarusports

          11 months ago

          Yup, that’s a true statement right there!

  12. manos

    11 months ago

    Money is a bit high but the term is too much for me. I would have given him maybe $12M on a 1-year “prove it” deal. The guy hasn’t exactly been electric so far.

    Reply
    • tad2b13

      11 months ago

      You can’t “give” a FA, especially a pitcher in this market, what you want to pay. If you offered 1/12 to Kikuchi, you’re not going to sign him. The Jays are a better team with him than some replacement.

      Reply
      • Chester Copperpot

        11 months ago

        Meh. Tyler Anderson replaced Kikuchi in the M’s rotation last year, because Kikuchi is terrible. Anderson is still available and will probably get a one year deal under $10M.

        This move does not help the Jays rotation like you think it does.

        Reply
    • YankeesBleacherCreature

      11 months ago

      Prove what exactly? He declined a $13M ’22 option and parlayed it into a lot more. Pretty savvy of him.

      Reply
  13. TalkingBaseball

    11 months ago

    Good luck with that! Totally hated watching that guy in Seattle.

    Reply
  14. Rangers29

    11 months ago

    Blue Jays trying to be the Rangers so bad.

    Reply
    • GB85

      11 months ago

      Rangers wish they had the Jays rotation.

      Reply
      • Dustyslambchops23

        11 months ago

        And offense

        Reply
      • Rangers29

        11 months ago

        ***jokes***

        Reply
        • You Can Put It In The Books

          11 months ago

          Yes, your comment was a joke… wasn’t it?

    • C-Daddy

      11 months ago

      Why would the Jays want to emulate a perennial bottom dweller?

      Reply
  15. MoneyBallJustWorks

    11 months ago

    Kershaw 14 / Kikuchi 13. hmmmm

    Reply
    • YankeesBleacherCreature

      11 months ago

      Kershaw was 17 with incentives.

      Reply
    • goob

      11 months ago

      @Money

      Not that it’s necessarily the most important thing, but Kikuchi is about 3 and a half years younger, with a lot less mileage on his arm.

      Reply
    • JakersTaters

      11 months ago

      Kershaw is 17M and is heavily laden with incentives. He essentially is on the verge of TJ surgery and hoping to get through the year. Big difference.

      Reply
  16. myaccount2

    11 months ago

    Kikuchi is gonna get shelled in Toronto.

    Reply
  17. AlienBob

    11 months ago

    He declined his one year, $13M option with the M’s to play for less. He worn down last year and had to skip his last couple starts.

    Reply
    • downsr30

      11 months ago

      36 > 12

      Reply
    • teddyk

      11 months ago

      How is turning down $13M and signing for $36M playing for less? Seems to me he just guaranteed himself $23 Million more in his pocket. Not too shabby for a guy who has never won more than 7 games in a MLB season. He has looked decent in stretches but I think it’s risky betting 3 years on it. Good for him though, I never begrudge someone from getting paid, I just shake my head at it and thank god it isn’t my team doing it and handcuffing themselves later with bad contracts.

      Reply
      • YankeesBleacherCreature

        11 months ago

        It’s a front-loaded deal: 16/10/10. Jays can offload him easier if he doesn’t work out this year.

        Reply
        • teddyk

          11 months ago

          I guess that makes it more palatable, still glad it wasn’t my team signing him. Not the worst signing out there, just longer than I expected.

        • bigdaddyt

          11 months ago

          Or makes it easier to justify moving him to the pen in years 2-3 if it doesn’t work

      • stymeedone

        11 months ago

        Wait! I thought W’s didn’t count for anything. Now you complain he didn’t have enough of that thing that doesn’t count!

        Reply
        • teddyk

          11 months ago

          I never said wins don”t count, many do feel that way. I still think there is a ton to be said for pitchers that go deep into games and can stick around for the decisions. It is not an end all/be all stat, but it still shows value.

        • JakersTaters

          11 months ago

          Wins might be one of the more useless stats in baseball. I remember Ricky Romero had 8 or 9 wins going into the All-Star break with an ERA over 7. Wins are a measure of run prevention combined with run support, and therefore 50% of the stat is out of the hands of the pitcher. Even more if you take into account the bullpen blown saves.

  18. MoneyBallJustWorks

    11 months ago

    sorry 17 for Kershaw

    Reply
    • GB85

      11 months ago

      ….and 12 for Kukuchi.

      Reply
  19. Monkey’s Uncle

    11 months ago

    Yusei Kikuchi, I say bold move by Toronto.

    Reply
  20. HeedFrodo

    11 months ago

    Sorry about that signing. As a Mariner fan, this guy made you crazy. Gives you 7 solid innings one start and then three starts of not being able to get out of the 4th.

    Reply
    • StPeteStingRays

      11 months ago

      Sounds like Blake Snell

      Reply
    • HomerSexual

      11 months ago

      This.

      Reply
    • You Can Put It In The Books

      11 months ago

      Sounds just like Robbie Ray’s career. Bust written all over him!

      Reply
  21. downsr30

    11 months ago

    Would have rather seen them get Greinke. Kikuchi is good in spurts, but hitters adjust quickly.

    Reply
  22. Mario93

    11 months ago

    I like him, he’s got very good stuff. Powerful fastball, great curve, seems to have a changeup at 88mph, or whatever he calls it. Fastball can hit 97mph.. Pete Walker has a really nice toy to play with, with Kikuchi.

    Reply
    • HidekiMatsuimalemodel

      11 months ago

      He hit 99mph last year

      Reply
  23. stevecohenMVP

    11 months ago

    Good. Didn’t want him on Mets. Didn’t think he’d be a good fit. Better options on trade market. Good luck in Toronto. 12 mill is a lot less than the option he declined. But 36mill ain’t

    Reply
  24. VonPurpleHayes

    11 months ago

    Love the Jays rotation

    Reply
  25. winonesooner

    11 months ago

    lol at people who said he had to go to the mariners!

    Reply
  26. Camden453

    11 months ago

    Jays are the AL East favorites now

    Reply
  27. Daizydad

    11 months ago

    I wish him luck but glad he turned down the M’s option. Maybe it was just a coincidence but he completely fell off a cliff once they started checking pitchers for foreign substances.

    Reply
    • Jaysfan1981

      11 months ago

      Only foreign substance he’s going to need is Pete Walker.

      If he can make him hit his potential similar to Ray and others. Fantastic signing, If he just eats up 150 innings from the #5 slot and doesn’t lose us more games than he wins us (im not talking his win loss record you animals) then it’s still worth it.

      It only really sucks if he goes all Rick Ankeil on us and can’t throw a strike for the rest of the contract. Even then it’s only Rogers money, not exactly gonna get handcuffed by 2/24 remaining next year

      Reply
      • stymeedone

        11 months ago

        Ray and what others?

        Reply
        • Jaysfan1981

          11 months ago

          Happ. Estrada. Biagini Matz

          Happ was a journeyman before Walker

          Estrada was able to pitch mid 80s and a 65 mph changeup thanks to Walker

          Biagini enjoyed the only success of his career under Walker and was damn good out of the Pen

          Matz put it together for the most part under Walker and got himself a nice contract from St Louis because of it.

          Granted outside of Ray he didn’t get anyone else a CY but greatly improved all of those pitchers and likely earned them a few extra years and dollars

        • Best Screenname Ever

          11 months ago

          Happ was a journeyman before Toronto? New to baseball?

        • Jaysfan1981

          11 months ago

          Ya, his 2009 and 2010 seasons were the only good seasons he had, including his first run with TO he was a 4.50 Era pitcher.

          He didn’t really excel until his 2nd stint with TO when Walker got ahold of him and he was a 3era 20 win pitcher.

      • tad2b13

        11 months ago

        Agree, but the remaining is 2/20 next season, as the deal is front-loaded.

        Reply
    • bloomquist4hof

      11 months ago

      The Mariners probably wouldn’t have minded him picking up his option. They could definitely use another starter and would probably prefer to get one with only 1 year commitment unless they were young an/or good.

      Reply
  28. NostraThomas

    11 months ago

    A fly ball pitcher in the AL East? Good luck with all that. Jays look desperate here. Could have done better in the trade market.

    Reply
    • Dustyslambchops23

      11 months ago

      #5 starter.

      Reply
    • bloomquist4hof

      11 months ago

      On the flipside they front loaded it so 2/20 isn’t so bad to eat after this year if they need to and won’t prohibit further spending and they didn’t give up any talent to get him.

      Reply
      • smuzqwpdmx

        11 months ago

        The front loading makes sense if you’re a GM, but has to be irritating if you’re a Rogers accountant whose money is being flushed just because it’s there this year. Makes me wonder why more teams don’t set multi-year payrolls to give their GMs better incentives.

        Reply
    • KamKid

      11 months ago

      In terms of looking desperate, I suspect quite a few teams are going to just go get what they need rather than holding out for deals with a only a few weeks until the season. They get one of the few starters available here and use this year’s budget room to front load the deal so it’s pretty palatable after next year if he doesn’t break through. Stripling is a FA next year so Kikuchi at $10m per can move into that swing man spot start role if they want to pivot and upgrade. Or they can move it easily enough.

      Reply
  29. Jacob Cook

    11 months ago

    Wonder who signs Greinke now.

    Reply
    • Pete'sView

      11 months ago

      I hope the Giants, though the price—even for a year or two—might be too high. He’s a smart innings-eater at this stage of his career and would fill some innings that Rodon or Wood may not be able to fill.

      Reply
    • 48-team MLB

      11 months ago

      The Braves would be a good option IF he is willing to take a one-year deal.

      Reply
    • mlb1225

      11 months ago

      Ky money is on the Braves then Brewers. Braves get a veteran #4 starter who can give them a 3.80 and 180 IP. A rotation of him, Morton, Fried, Anderson, Ynoa, and eventually Soroka down the line is a strong group. Not to mention any young arms like Muller, Davidson, or Wright.

      Reply
  30. mrmackey

    11 months ago

    Seems like a Matz replacement, and probably a downgrade.

    Reply
    • Akakak

      11 months ago

      It’s going to be an interesting who would you rather kind of year: ray who the jays didn’t offer a serious contract to or gausman and matz vs kikuchi.

      Reply
      • Akakak

        11 months ago

        To add to the ray vs gausman comparison: similar age, similar career trajectory, both are two pitch guys, rays a max effort pitcher, gausman is close max effort….. really odd how this one broke down.

        Reply
  31. mookiesboy

    11 months ago

    and i thought Matz was overpaid!

    Reply
  32. crshbng

    11 months ago

    Ok with him as a backend starter. 12 mil a year isn’t terrible. Just needs to keep era undet 5.

    Reply
  33. jetpowerbass

    11 months ago

    Pete Walker, work your magic.

    Reply
  34. KcsMsFan

    11 months ago

    After they started checking for foreign substances he started getting insanely wild and spiking pitches into the dirt halfway to home plate and throwing the ball over people’s heads. Hate to say it but I think he relied on “sticky stuff” and his best days are behind him. The best part of this deal is that I don’t ever have to watch him pitch for my team every 5 days anymore.

    Reply
  35. jimmertee

    11 months ago

    NO this rotation is not by far the best in baseball. It thankfully has quality depth but it doesn’t have an alpha front of the roation starter.

    It has a #2 {Berrios}, two 3’s [Gausman and Ryu], a #4 in Manoah who will get better, and the rest are unknowns or #5’s. {Kikuchi, Stripling, Garcia).

    Kay and Pearson are NOT starters. Give that one a rest. They are both relievers. Kay is a one inning max effort 7th inning guy and Pearson could be a closer if someone in the Jays gets their head on right and teaches him to relax and pitch rather than throw.

    Reply
    • bigfatandugly

      11 months ago

      this didn’t age well the first time you posted it. must be a glutton for punishment to post it twice.

      Reply
  36. Shiatsu4U

    11 months ago

    Good luck YK!

    Reply
  37. Rsox

    11 months ago

    Kikuchi in the AL East is going to be brutal. Lots of souvenirs going to be flying out of the yard

    Reply
  38. drasco036

    11 months ago

    I love the potential but the results are not there to justify that contract.

    Reply
  39. In nurse follars

    11 months ago

    Lefty, eats innings, #4 or #5. Better than most I guess. Not a stand out sign but will add some value for Montoyo.

    Reply
  40. NWMarinerHawk

    11 months ago

    We loved Yusei but he’s a total headcase. No doubt about it. If he can find a way to just relax and pitch to his strengths consistently he can be dominant. He’s got some of the best arm talent in baseball, honestly. Last year early on when the fastball was hitting 97-98 to go with that nasty cutter, he was on a different level. He got nicked up right before the ASG and was never the same.

    Reply
  41. RobM

    11 months ago

    The way this contract is structured makes me wonder if there is an opt out after year 1.

    Kikuchi has a good arm. I do wonder if he will benefit getting away from the Mariners and working with the Jays pitching coaches, who did wonders with Ray.

    Reply
    • bloomquist4hof

      11 months ago

      Hes getting paid what they think he’s worth which if guess is a 2ish WAR pitcher that declines from here based on todays salaries. Im not surprised by this. Hes got the stuff to be a sold #2 pitcher but his track record is more like a #5 or mop up guy. So if he’s in between that which he likely is thats a #4 type that gets worse from here, which 3/36 seems to be inline what those types make anymore but seems steep to me. Basically they tacked a year on in hopes hia potential shines through. He still has a lot of variability for a 3 year veteran in his 30s though. That’s my winded got take.

      Reply
      • bloomquist4hof

        11 months ago

        Steep is an exaggeration. Slight overpay is more what I meant.

        Reply
        • NWMarinerHawk

          11 months ago

          What’s up man? SK grad here, saw the name and just wanted to shout out

        • Pete'sView

          11 months ago

          No, I think “steep” is exactly right.

    • YankeesBleacherCreature

      11 months ago

      No opt-outs reported so far. Even if he replicates last years’ production, the Jays won’t have a lot of trouble trading him to a middling team who needs an innings-eater for 2/$20.

      Reply
      • RobM

        11 months ago

        Good point. Structuring it with more up front makes him more marketable in trades if they go that route.

        Reply
  42. saluelthpops

    11 months ago

    If he can bend his front leg that way imagine the magic he can generate with a ball in his hand!

    Reply
  43. Mario93

    11 months ago

    They pay him 16 this up coming season and then an extremely fair 10 mill for each of the last two years. I think they got a bargain if anything. Pete Walker will get the best out of him, and with the stuff he has, this rotation will be one of the best in baseball imo. Every day you have a chance to win, fantastic job by the Jays brass to put this rotation together.

    Also have Ross Stripling, Nate Pearson, some more minor league depth after those guys. Injuries will always come into play at some point of the year, Jays as of now are in really solid shape.

    Try to grab a Colin Mchugh imo, and this team is ready to start the year. Trade deadline you get your 3B if one of the youngsters don’t take control of that spot.

    This Jays team right now, going into the season is very talented man.. Glad to be a Jays fan.

    Reply
    • YankeesBleacherCreature

      11 months ago

      Jays secured a ton of depth. I wish my team had this much.

      Reply
  44. Besbol

    11 months ago

    I watched every one of his starts.

    He completely lost confidence in himself after they cracked down on ball doctoring.

    Reply
    • NWMarinerHawk

      11 months ago

      My (Japanese) girlfriend and I went to 6 of his start’s across the whole year, and I’ve debated in my head how much the crackdown affected him, how much his minor injury before the break affected him, the combination of the two, or the possibility that the injury occurred BECAUSE of the crackdown.
      There’s a lot to take in there. He’s certainly worthy of another look like this, they absolutely are overpaying BUT I’m rooting for the guys arm talent to win out for him. I swear, he’s also a huge headcase and needs to relax out there. He’s in a full sweat and taking his sweet time after 5 pitches. Watching him stress himself out stresses me out

      Reply
  45. YaGottaBelieve

    11 months ago

    Good luck, Jays! As an M’s fan glad to see this frustrating guy leave. Flashes of being really good, surrounded by many more looking lost. Maybe the change of scenery will help. Came to Seattle projected as a Number Two starter, left as a fifth and MAYBE a 4th. The fact they skipped his slot while chasing the wild card last year tells the tale!

    Reply
  46. frankw

    11 months ago

    This time last year the Jays had Ryu at the top of the rotation and a lot of question marks in Ray and others. This year they are starting with a much better rotation 1-5. Berries, Gausman and Manoah are nr 2 pitchers and Ryu a nr 3 and Kikuchi a very good 5. I will take it.

    Reply
  47. Ronk325

    11 months ago

    The Blue Jays overpay for another beneficiary of a pitcher’s park out west to join the hostile AL East. This surely won’t blow up in their face

    Reply
  48. whyhayzee

    11 months ago

    But it’s Canadian money.

    Reply
    • tad2b13

      11 months ago

      Jays players are paid in US dollars.

      Reply
  49. bobtillman

    11 months ago

    It’s a good move. The AL East is far from the goliath it was a few years ago; every team has warts, nobody (IF especially) can catch the ball, and the O’s could lose 110 games. If nothing else, he provides depth, which is a BIG quality, especially this year. And the price really isn’t bad.

    Zack and BIG SEXY about the only two left.

    Reply
    • smuzqwpdmx

      11 months ago

      Uh, you’re talking about the division where 80% of the teams won 90+ games last season. It’s a better division now than it ever was before.

      Kikuchi makes approximately 0 wins difference to projections for 2022 though.

      Reply
  50. A'sfaninUK

    11 months ago

    Where’s the baseball-reference page links today? Someone miss a step?

    Reply
  51. angt222

    11 months ago

    Jays overpaid. Hopefully he has a career bump like Matz did in TOR.

    Reply
  52. whogg72

    11 months ago

    Beautiful Pete Walker project at a reasonable price.

    Reply
  53. HomerSexual

    11 months ago

    Yusei…I only hear what I want to…

    Reply
  54. Shoguneye

    11 months ago

    Although I have faith in Walkers ability to get the best out of this guy it feels like Tanner Roark redux.
    Might have to introduce him to the local cannabis culture to chill his edge.

    Reply
    • crazybaseballgal

      11 months ago

      He is easily rattled

      Reply
    • smuzqwpdmx

      11 months ago

      Roark had a better track record. But Kikuchi is younger, especially in terms of MLB experience, and at least he’s improved each season.

      Reply
  55. crazybaseballgal

    11 months ago

    As a Mariner fan I say best of luck ! He is so NOT worth the contract he got. Yusei seems like a decent guy. Thanks for Ray though!

    Reply
  56. fox471 Dave

    11 months ago

    Dodgers need Greinke!

    Reply
  57. garywang00

    11 months ago

    Paying 56mm 3 yr for a guy with Career era just under 5.00 ! Have fun and enjoy him . Thanks for taking him away from the Mets!

    Reply
    • TalkSomeSense

      11 months ago

      Where do you get 56m?

      Reply
  58. TalkSomeSense

    11 months ago

    A # 5 with #2-3 upside- if Walker can do his thing and help him reach and sustain his potential the 2-3rd years will be a steal. If not oh well it’s not like it’s 100m contract.

    Reply
  59. kenphelpsformvp

    11 months ago

    this guy is trash. usually 4/5 guys are over 30 reclamation projects commanding 1 year deals in the 10mil range. he’s on the wrong side of 30 and mlb hitters pulverize him. flush this money down the toilet.

    Reply
  60. JoeBrady

    11 months ago

    Interesting. Perez signing gets trashed, and Kikuchi gets $36M/3. Over the past three years.

    Player A 20-20 W/L 341 IPs 4.88 ERA 4.75 FIP 95 ERA+

    Player B 15-24 W/L 365 IPs 4.97 ERA 4.93 FIP 86 ERA+

    Reply
  61. Eric D

    11 months ago

    I was at Yusei Kikuchi’s first start at T-Mobile park, I think he threw five or six innings giving up a couple runs. He always showed flashes of greatness, but failed to be consistent over his time with the M’s. I often thought he threw the fastball too often, and hoped he’d have more success in Mariner blue. I wish him the best going forward, and hope he finds a new gear in Toronto.

    Reply
  62. Vmax

    11 months ago

    For the same money, they could have had Matz away better pitch. Kurt must be willing to be vaccinated..

    Reply
  63. snowyphile1

    11 months ago

    Greinke should retire.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.
Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Orioles Acquire Cole Irvin From A’s

    Astros Name Dana Brown General Manager

    Rays Extend Jeffrey Springs

    Royals, Red Sox Swap Adalberto Mondesi For Josh Taylor

    Red Sox Designate Matt Barnes For Assignment

    Scott Rolen Elected Into Baseball Hall Of Fame

    Red Sox Sign Adam Duvall

    Brad Ausmus Reportedly Among Astros’ GM Finalists

    Mike Clevinger Under Investigation For Domestic Violence Allegations

    A’s To Sign Jesús Aguilar

    Arte Moreno No Longer Pursuing Sale Of Angels

    Twins Acquire Michael A. Taylor From Royals

    Padres Sign Nelson Cruz To One-Year Deal

    Sal Bando Passes Away

    Twins, Marlins Swap Luis Arraez For Pablo Lopez In Four-Player Trade

    Marlins To Move Jazz Chisholm To Center Field

    Pirates Sign Andrew McCutchen

    Mariners Sign Tommy La Stella, Designate Justus Sheffield

    Royals To Sign Aroldis Chapman To One-Year Deal

    Twins Sign Chris Paddack To Extension

    Recent

    Orioles Acquire Cole Irvin From A’s

    Orioles Designate Darwinzon Hernandez For Assignment

    Marlins Outright Daniel Castano

    Mets To Sign Michael Perez To Minor League Deal

    Astros Name Dana Brown General Manager

    Orioles, Austin Voth Avoid Arbitration

    Dodgers Sign Wander Suero To Minor League Deal

    Pirates Outright Miguel Andujar

    Red Sox In Talks With Roberto Perez

    Read The Transcript Of Our Chat Hosted By Former MLB Pitcher Cory Wade

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Offseason Outlook Series
    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Go Ad-Free
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2023
    • 2022-23 MLB Free Agent List
    • MLB Player Chats
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • Feeds by Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrowsFOX Sports Engage Network scroll to top
    Close

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version