White Sox Planning More Consistent Roles For Dominic Fletcher, Miguel Vargas

The White Sox have gutted their roster over the past season as their rebuild has gone into full swing, but they’ll aim for some more consistency down the stretch in 2024. Outfielder Dominic Fletcher and infielder/outfielder Miguel Vargas will have more solidified roles down the stretch. James Fegan of Sox Machine tweeted recently that interim manager Grady Sizemore wants to give Vargas a consistent role (something he’s previously not had with the Dodgers), so he’ll play primarily at third base. Sizemore also said he plans to deploy Fletcher in a near-everyday role after he’s been heavily platooned prior to this point (X link via Daryl Van Schouwen of the Chicago Sun-Times).

Fletcher, 26, came to the Sox in an offseason deal that sent pitching prospect Cristian Mena to the Diamondbacks. His plus contact skills and solid glovework seemingly give him a high floor in the outfield corners, but Fletcher floundered through 66 plate appearances in the White Sox’ first 23 games and found himself quickly optioned to Triple-A Charlotte. He returned in mid-May, collected one hit in 18 plate appearances, and then hit the injured list with a shoulder strain.

The Sox sent Fletcher on a rehab assignment and optioned him afterward. He hit well in his last run with Triple-A Charlotte, was recalled to the big leagues the evening prior to the trade deadline, and now stands to log an everyday role down the stretch. He’s making the most of it in his tiny sample thus far; after hitting .283/.345/.377 in 53 Triple-A trips to the plate following his rehab stint, he’s tallied 27 plate appearances in the big leagues and gone 9-for-26 with a double, a walk and only three strikeouts. It’s a minuscule set of games, of course, but it’s still the most encouraging run Fletcher has had since landing in Chicago.

“I love Dom’s game,” Sizemore told the Sox beat (via Van Schouwen). “He’s a good all-around player, especially the defense.”

Fletcher hasn’t shown that yet with the South Siders, but he did slash .301/.350/.441 in 102 plate appearances with the Diamondbacks in 2023’s MLB debut. He’s also a lifetime .293/.376/.462 hitter in 889 turns at the plate in Triple-A, where he’s fanned in a lower-than-average 18.6% of his plate appearances and drawn walks at a stout 10.6% rate.

Fletcher has also drawn strong defensive marks in limited time. He’s played only 487 innings in the outfield in his big league career but been credited with plus marks in Defensive Runs Saved (7) and Outs Above Average (3). When looking at only his corner work (200 innings), both DRS (5) and OAA (5) feel he’s been even stronger. Again, it’s not a big sample, but scouting reports on Fletcher have been bullish on his glove for some time now. Prior to the season, Baseball America called him a potential plus defender at all three positions, noting that his “great reads and above-average routes … and above-average arm strength” all help to offset his roughly average speed.

As for Vargas, his time with the Sox has gotten out to a rough start after being acquired in the Erick Fedde/Michael Kopech deal. Recently fired skipper Pedro Grifol has played him at third base, designated hitter and in left field, but Sizemore seems keen to keep him at the hot corner moving forward. Still just 24 and only a season removed from ranking among the sport’s top 40 overall prospects, Vargas has batted .116/.240/.209 in 50 plate appearances. He’s at least shown good strike zone recognition, drawing seven walks (14%) and chasing only 19.8% of pitches off the plate — way shy of the 28.5% league average. Earlier this season, it didn’t take a much longer slump than this for the Sox to option Fletcher earlier, but it seems they’re understandably intent on giving Vargas some more time to work through his big league struggles.

After all, there’s little left for Vargas to prove in the minors. He’s a .297/.412/.512 hitter in 997 Triple-A plate appearances, including a huge .290/.440/.556 batting line there in 2024. The White Sox already know Vargas can clobber upper-minors pitching, and the focus will now shift on coaxing improvements from the talented youngster at the MLB level. With the Dodgers, they bounced Vargas from third base, to second base, to first base, to left field in an effort to get his touted minor league bat into a veteran-laden lineup where Vargas was largely blocked from a regular role. He’ll have a much clearer runway to playing time at Guaranteed Rate Field — and at his natural position, no less.

There’s minimal competition for either player at the moment. In the outfield, Fletcher has been lining up in right field alongside center fielder Luis Robert Jr. and left fielder Andrew Benintendi. Oscar Colas hasn’t hit well in Triple-A or the majors this season. Corey Julks hasn’t hit much in the majors, either. Zach DeLoach, acquired from the Mariners in the Gregory Santos deal, has roughly league-average numbers in Triple-A.

It’s a similar story for Vargas at third base. Former top prospect Nick Senzel hasn’t hit with the Nationals or White Sox this season and will likely be non-tendered in the offseason. Lenyn Sosa has seen some time at third base but is a utility player in a best-case scenario. Bryan Ramos, who entered the season as one of Chicago’s top prospects, has taken a huge step back in 2024 after a breakout 2023 season in Double-A. With a strong finish, both Fletcher and Vargas could essentially stake their claim to regular jobs on what should be a largely wide-open White Sox roster in 2025.