The Brewers announced this morning that they’ve optioned right-hander Tobias Myers to Triple-A. Righty Elvis Peguero was recalled to the major league roster in his place.
It’s a surprising move for Milwaukee given that Myers was a key cog in the club’s rotation not only this year but also in 2024. The righty broke out last season as a rookie with the Brewers, posting a phenomenal 3.00 ERA (138 ERA+) in 138 innings of work spread between 25 starts and two relief outings. He’s followed that up with a 3.86 ERA across 16 1/3 innings across four starts and one relief appearance. Those solid top-level run prevention numbers are belied somewhat by less impressive peripherals, however. Last year, Myers posted a 3.91 FIP thanks in part to a relatively pedestrian 22.3% strikeout rate and an elevated home run rate, though his tidy 6.3% walk rate made up for it somewhat.
Things have taken a turn for the worse on the peripheral side of things this year, however. Myers has watched his strikeout rate dip to just 14.7% while his walk rate has crept up to 13.3%. That’s a walk rate that can prove untenable for even elite strikeout artists in a rotation role, and when paired with Myers’s paltry strikeout numbers from this year it’s easy to see why the Brewers may be concerned about his ability to continue providing quality production. Just 5.0% of Myers’s fly balls have left the yard for home runs this year, down from 11.3% last season. If that number were to normalize, his solid enough ERA would surely spike to a level closer to his 4.59 FIP or perhaps even his ugly 5.61 SIERA.
To this point in the season, the Brewers have had little choice besides simply sticking with Myers in a rotation role and hoping he gets right thanks to the bevy of rotation injuries they’ve been forced to navigate. Six starting rotation options are currently on the 15- or 60-day injured list in Milwaukee, a situation that forced them to sign Jose Quintana and trade for Quinn Priester just to keep a full rotation on the roster. That’s set to change in the relatively near future, however. Brandon Woodruff is poised to make what’s expected to be his final rehab start today, which would put him on track to return to the Brewers rotation as soon as next weekend. Aaron Civale and Aaron Ashby are expected to be ready to rejoin the club later this month as well.
Those incoming reinforcements on their own likely wouldn’t be enough to convince Milwaukee to pull the trigger on optioning Myers, but the club also has a day off this coming Thursday. That means the club can simply skip Myers’s next turn in the rotation without needing to lock Woodruff into Friday’s start against Minnesota, as today’s projected starter Chad Patrick will also be available on full rest that day. Optioning Myers now affords the Brewers an additional bullpen arm for their next few games while offering Myers the opportunity to sort out whatever issue may be causing his lack of strikeouts and uptick in walks this season in a lower-pressure environment.
Sensible as it may be, it’s an aggressive move that shows how uncharacteristically uncomfortable Milwaukee is this year. The Brewers are just 19-21 so far this year and have fallen to fourth place in the NL Central, four games back of the Cubs for the division lead. That’s certainly not an insurmountable gap for the club with more than four months to go in the regular season, but for a team coming off a run of six playoff appearances (and four NL Central titles) in seven years, it’s been quite some time since they were firmly on the outside of the playoff picture in the NL.
Replacing Myers on the roster for the time being is Peguero. The 28-year-old has struggled to a 5.68 ERA in five appearances this year but has generally been a quality relief options for Milwaukee since joining the organization ahead of the 2023 season, with a 3.20 ERA in 112 2/3 innings of work over the past two seasons. He’ll likely join struggling righty Joel Payamps in a lower leverage role for the time being given the success right-handed arms like Abner Uribe, Nick Mears, and Grant Anderson have found to this point in the 2025 campaign.
Booo
He was averaging not even 4 innings a start this year, not very good. He’ll go to Nashville for a month or 2 and figure things out hopefully
So one of their better starters walks a couple extra people over his first five games and they demote him? Let’s demote Chourio because his peripheral strike out rate is up. That would make about as much sense.
Wow! Would love for the Padres to try to buy low on him. Tobias is solid.
Makes sense when you read the rest of the article. They have guys coming back and can afford to send him down and let him work out his issues.
Woodruff returns. This can give Myers a few skips in starts. You never know, maybe there’s an arm fatigue.
Watching Myers this season I’ve been surprised how much more he’s focused on throwing four seamers up in the zone. He’s done that 49% of the time and he’s throwing his curve and change at a much lower rate than last season. He may be trying to avoid pain by cutting back on his secondary stuff but if fully healthy he needs to adjust his pitch selection.
Now they’re just making up guys
“Sensible as it may be” is NOT PROPER ENGLISH. You can’t just leave “as” out to begin the sentence. It’s not optional! Grammar is not optional when you’re being paid to write.