Cardinals Notes: Donovan, Wetherholt, Winn, Herrera

Brendan Donovan’s name has been mentioned in trade rumors for a couple of years now, but with the Cardinals moving into a full-on rebuild mode this winter, it has seemed like only a matter of time before the versatile All-Star is dealt.  That said, it isn’t a guarantee that another club will meet what is reportedly a high asking price on the Cards’ part, and Donovan won’t necessarily remain on the market forever.

Cardinals president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom naturally didn’t share many details on the trade talks when speaking with reporters (including Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch) this weekend at the Cards’ Winter Warm-Up fan event, but Bloom would “I think ideally” like to see Donovan’s situation settled one way or other by the start of Spring Training.  This is certainly a lot less concrete than Diamondbacks GM Mike Hazen firmly declaring the end to the Ketel Marte trade negotiations, but it is some indication that Bloom might have some kind of loose deadline in mind.

This could be a way of putting a bit more pressure on Donovan’s suitors to up their offers, or it could reflection the simple fact that Donovan and the Cardinals have a season to prepare for, and constant trade buzz will continue to be a distraction.  While the hot stove won’t entirely cool until a deal actually happens, Donovan would surely prefer to just focus on baseball during Grapefruit League action.  Having rumors weigh on Donovan to the point that it impacts his play isn’t helpful for Donovan, the Cardinals, or the team’s efforts to command a high return on the trade market.

Since Donovan is arbitration-controlled through the next two seasons, there isn’t any immediate reason St. Louis needs to trade him this offseason.  The situation also got a little less pressing when Nolan Arenado was dealt to the Diamondbacks, thus opening up the Cardinals’ third base spot and creating less need for Donovan to be moved out of second base.

Moving some of Arenado’s salary was certainly a factor in his trade, but from a pure baseball standpoint, the rebuilding Cardinals wanted as much runway as possible for their younger players to get regular at-bats.  Nolan Gorman and Thomas Saggese should benefit from more available third base playing time, but both Bloom and manager Oliver Marmol reiterated this weekend (to Gould and other media) that top prospect JJ Wetherholt has a chance to make the Cards’ Opening Day roster.

Baseball America ranked Wetherholt fourth on its updated August list of the top 100 prospects in baseball, and MLB Pipeline has Wetherholt fifth on its current list.  The 23-year-old infielder is sure to occupy another top-shelf ranking when the 2026 prospect lists are released, as Wetherholt excelled in his first full pro season — he hit .300/.425/.466 over 275 plate appearances for Double-A Springfield, and then hit .314/.416/562 over 221 PA after an in-season promotion to Triple-A ball.

Wetherholt totaled 17 homers and 23 steals (out of 26 chances) over the full 496 PA and 109 total games while playing primarily at shortstop, but he made 20 appearances as a second baseman and 12 appearances at third base.  The Cardinals aren’t going to rush things with their prized prospect, and if the hot corner is likely going to be Wetherholt’s entry point into his big league career, his fielding development may be the deciding factor in whether or not he can break camp.  However, both evaluators and the Cardinals themselves have a high opinion of Wetherholt’s glovework, and feel he can adapt anywhere.

“There is a versatility there.  His mindset will allow him, in my opinion, to excel at any of those [positions],” Marmol said.  “It’s a special mindset.  It’s one I continue to be impressed with.”

The shortstop position might not open for Wetherholt as long as Masyn Winn is there, as Winn is one of the game’s top defenders.  Winn won his first Gold Glove in 2025 despite playing through a martial meniscus tear during the second half of the season, and he underwent an arthroscopic knee surgery in late September to correct the issue.

The relatively minor procedure wasn’t expected to impact Winn’s readiness for Spring Training, and Bloom confirmed as much to reporters (including Daniel Guerrero of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch) this weekend.  Winn is “not even in rehab mode.  He’s just preparing for the season at this point,” Bloom said.

Ivan Herrera is also making good progress in his recovery from October surgery to remove a bone spur from his throwing arm.  Bloom said Herrera has started his throwing program, and his offseason prep over the next week will include the start of his hitting work, as well as blocking and receiving work behind the plate.  Herrera acted mostly as a DH during an injury-marred 2025 season, as he played in only 107 games.  While his bat certainly didn’t suffer (19 homers and a .284/.373/.464 slash line in 452 PA), Herrera is eager to return to catching in 2026.

Defense was seen as a question mark for Herrera even before his health issues cropped up, so his future as a catcher is far from settled.  Spring Training will provide some answers on Herrera’s recovery and development, but “I think it’s hard to evaluate strictly in spring,” Marmol said.  “When you think about what pitchers are doing in spring, they’re working on a specific pitch.  You’re not game-planning against a hitter.  There are certain things we’ll be able to continue to address and improve upon during spring.  But I think that’s a tough ask.”

As Goold notes, Herrera’s ability to catch impacts the Cardinals’ wider roster decisions.  If Herrera will again be a primary DH, the Cards will need to roster two proper catchers — Pedro Pages, and one of Yohel Pozo or Jimmy Crooks.  If the Cardinals feel good enough about Herrera’s defense to make him a part-time backstop, that probably means Pozo and Crooks will start the season in Triple-A, or one of them could possibly be trade fodder.