MLB Rumors - MLB Trade Rumors
Subscribe to MLB Trade Rumors using RSS
Home     Contact     About     Advertise     Archives     Widget     Twitter      RSS Usage

« The Mitchell Report | Main | Nationals Sign Mackowiak, Harris »

Mitchell Report Names

Here are some new active players brought to light as users of performance-enhancing drugs by the Mitchell Report.  By the way, they did talk to Jose Canseco.  Note that I left out some of the more public/obvious steroid busts we already know about.

Larry Bigbie (confessed)
Brian Roberts (based on an admission to Bigbie)
Jack Cust (based on an admission to Bigbie)
Rondell White (Kirk Radomski)
Roger Clemens (Brian McNamee)
Andy Pettitte (Brian McNamee)
Gregg Zaun (Kirk Radomski)
Ron Villone (Kirk Radomski)
Miguel Tejada (performance-enhancers provided to Tejada by teammate Adam Piatt)
Mike Stanton (Kirk Radomski)
Stephen Randolph (Kirk Radomski)
Paul Lo Duca (Kirk Radomski)
Eric Gagne (Kirk Radomski)
Matt Herges (Kirk Radomski)
Gary Bennett (Kirk Radomski)
Brendan Donnelly (Kirk Radomski)
Howie Clark (Kirk Radomski)
Nook Logan (Kirk Radomski)
Alex Cabrera (Commissioner's Office, DEA, clubhouse attendant)


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515b9a69e2010534b4d704970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Mitchell Report Names:

Comments

Only a handful of good players.

ahh crap i thought Santana talks had alot of posts...this will take the cake for sure! lol...by the way..did Zaun get riods when he played for the O's..do u know tim?

Barry's clean!! YEAH!!!

Hahah

If Matt Herges did roids, he needs his money back!!

Zito Mitchell just said on ESPN that he had recived them

Just skimmed through the report... names mainly came out in the second half of the report.

I'm sorta disappointed that more bigger and newer names didn't come out. Good to get some confirmation on rumored names, but still. Quite a lot of players linked to the Blue Jays, damn McNamee, haha.

Brenden Donnelly, makes sense. He was in the Minors forever. Then one day he learned how to pitch and be succesful.

This Kirk Radomski guy seems to be a bigtime drug dealer.

Oh, and guys like Gary Matthews Jr and Troy Glaus were also mentioned... but the report mentioned how MLB thought there wasn't enough sufficient evidence of their roles. Only name that sorta surprised me was Gregg Zaun

Wow... was there anything Brendan Donnelly didn't do?

i can't believe ed wade was stupid enough to trade for tejada the day before this came out. any other time may have been ok, but this is an embarassment for the stros

his timing is incredible in this

I'm so glad the Nats fired Logan last night...just wish they'd release Lo Duca now...pity too, I really thought he'd be a good addition to the team, but now I cannot root for him at all.

I just knew Kevin Brown was on Riods...remeber that time he punched the wall and was out for a bit when he was with the Yanks i think...i just knew it

I hate all of you that posted that list with Bagwell on it, dont you know I have enough angst over the Astros trading for Tejada?!

I dont need any my childhood hero going down too! =P

We can has Brian Roberts for free nowz?

i'll be the first to say it.....what a convenient lack of red sox on this list.

My hero, Tim Laker, was also included in the report. It makes for a fascinating 409 page read.

Whoever released that first bogus list with all those big names on it should be crucified.

John Minko on WFAN rattled out a bunch of names including Pudge Rodriguez, who I myself couldn't find after looking through the report.
Tim, is this one of the names "we already knew about" or did you not see his name either?
Also Chuck Knoblach, David Justice I found in the report might be worth mentioning.

and while the list does lack a significant amount of red sox, look at Donnelly and Gagne, both on the list. Red Sox brass thought htey might have been on steroids or HGH and STILL acquired them!!

So Dan Duquette is vindicated. Stupid Rocket, another childhood idol crushed.

Where's Varitek ???...we all knows he's in the report. And no doubt he was jacked up on 'roids when he attacked A-Rod

Cody McKay? Seriously.

im glad there were no red sox on this list, for the exceptions of the ones nobody really cares about around Boston (i.e donnelly and gagne)

What i want to know is if Clemens was doping when he was with the sox, that will be important to find out

We need to come up with a nickname for the Brewers bullpen. Turnbow, Mota and now Gagne, lol.

I know there are many more players out there that are taking steroids. One is probably Albert Pujols.

Your bias is showing

I doubt Pujols took steroids, but I really doubt he is now. He has just as good chance as anyone in the MLB.

haha Rick Ankiel left off list? he is the most obvious. how does a shitty pitcher with no power go to a star outfielder crankin homeruns all the time in 3 years?

also love this -- no Cubs on there.

so much for the plan to pick up Jack Cust in the late rounds of my draft next year..

The way the report reads Clemens was not using steriods while he was on the Red Sox.

Ankiel, I figured was public knowledge.

I just did a Ctrl-F in the report for Varitek and nothing came up.

So what's next for Jim Hendry now that Brian Roberts is included in the report?

Turnbow only tested positive for andro, you know.

Glenallen Hill.. that makes sense. He hit the longest homerun I have ever seen. When he was with the cubs he hit one across Waveland that hit about 5 feet below the roof. It was over 500 feet. Shortly after that he was traded to the Yankees..... :-)

Manny Alexander
Chad Allen
Rick Ankiel

Mike Bell
David Bell
Marvin Benard
Gary Bennett Jr.
Larry Bigbie
Barry Bonds
Ricky Bones
Kevin Brown
Paul Byrd

Alex Cabrera
Ken Caminiti
Jose Canseco
Mark Carreon
Jason Christianson
Howie Clark
Roger Clemens
Paxton Crawford
Jack Cust

Brendon Donnelly
Chris Donnels
Lenny Dykstra

Bobby Estellela
Matt Franco
Ryan Franklin

Eric Gagne
Jason Giambi
Jeremy Giambi
Jay Gibbons
Troy Glaus
Juan Gonzalez
Jason Grimsley
Jose Guillen

Jerry Hairston Jr.
Matt Herges
Phil Hiatt
Glenallen Hill
Darren Holmes
Todd Hundley

David Justice

Chuck Knoblauch

Tim Laker
Mike Lansing
Paul Lo Duca
Nook Logan

Josias Manzanillo
Cody McKay
Kent Mercker
Bart Miadich
Hal Morris

Daniel Naulty
Denny Neagle

Rafael Palmeiro
Jim Parque
Luis Perez
Andy Pettitte
Adam Piatt
Todd Pratt

Stephen Randolph
Adam Riggs
Armando Rios
Brian Roberts
John Rocker

FP Santangelo
Benito Santiago
Scott Schoeneweis
David Segui
Mike Stanton

Miguel Tejada

Ismail Valdez
Mo Vaughn
Randy Velarde
Ron Villone
Fernando Vina

Rondell White
Todd Williams
Jeff Williams
Steve Woodard

Kevin Young

Gregg Zaun

I hope the no cubs thing was sarcastic. There is about 2 pages in the report about the cubs injecting at spring training and also during the season. Apparently several cubs players were seen injecting each other. Check out the matt karchner section of the report.

What is shocking about this list to me is the size. It is so SMALL.

What we have here is a sampling of actual abusers. When you realize that most of the information provided came from just a handful of sources you can see how widespread this really could become. If another trainer or coach flipped there might be an additional 20-30 names on this report. Additionally, what about those players that engaged in the activity without the aid of another. Buying steroids through others and administering the drug yourself or having a close friend do it would be simple and undetectable through the methods used by the Mitchell report.

I chalk these guys up as idiots who got caught. I bet there is a much larger population of the smart ones.

Rick Ankeil went to the same high school as Nomar Garciaparra. Nomar set all the batting records Ankiel broke them.

Several players have been quoted that around 50 percent of players were on some sort of performance enhancer. This list just scratches the contacts of basically two suppliers.

For the questions on Clemens, it says he took steroids in the second half of '98, '00, and '01. I think it was '00 were he briefly tried HGH but decided he didn't like it. It also claims he couldn't stand to inject himself and always had his trainer do it. It also gives the impression that Clemens knew nothing about steroids when he first used them in '98.

Basically, he used them to stay strong in the second half. Which fits the pattern we've seen in recent years of him not lasting for an entire season.

Oh, and it also contradicts the theory that his revival in 97 being due to steroids.

The Mitchell report is like a storybook filled with little interesting short stories. This is Christmas come early.

Agreed with the last few posters... this barely scratches the surface. Just the fact that Brady Anderson and Brett Boone weren't named in it is enough to prove that.

Hopefully this does bring some sort of closure on the topic. It will obviously continue to be talked about for months, and brought up for years/decades... but maybe now we can focus on baseball again and the great sport that it is.

ha glenallen hill, i guess normal people do not hit homeruns on top of roofs across the street

No David Eckstein!!! I bet he'll sleep easy tonight.

Why is it that there is no mention of international use. I mean most of this stuff is legal in other countries why is there nothing in this report about a detailed investigation into distribution of other countries. It's tough that the only players to come out will be ones that got their stuff from the good old USA. I have to imagine that if I was Vlad and I lived in a on bedroom shack with 9 brothers and sisters and steroids were legal were I lived I would do it too. Be dirt poor or a millionaire, tough choice!!!!

"i'll be the first to say it.....what a convenient lack of red sox on this list.

Posted by: Nj_Intimidator | December 13, 2007 at 02:08 PM"

Player (Years with Boston):
Manny Alexander (2000)
Kevin Brown (2002)
Jose Conseco (1995-1996)
Roger Clemens (1984-1996)
Paxton Crawford (2000-2001)
Brendon Donelly (2007)
Chris Donnels (1995)
Eric Gagne (2007)
Jeremy Giambi (2003)
Mike Lansing (2000-2001)
Josias Manzanillo (1991)
Kent Mercker (1999)
Mike Stanton (1996, 2005)
Mo Vaughn (1991-1998)
Steve Woodard (2003)

Now shush.

You know, if i actually cared what other people put in their bodies I'd be really upset about Clemens and Mo Vaughn right now. Alas, i actually know how overexagerated the negative effects of roids are. Booze are much worse for you, as are cigs.

Oh and before anyone says anything i haven't taken roids. That comment was based on MANY comparative studies I've read that were trying to figure out a legitimate way of ranking drugs (for the purposes of prosecution mostly). Marijuana is a schedule I drug in the USA while, cocaine is schedule II and alchohol is legal?? HA.

I am surprised Klesko and Pudge didn't get mentioned, off the top of my head. These are lumbering guys who magically started hitting for more power and stealing lots of bases. And then lost 20 lbs each "to run faster in the outfield" (Klesko) or "get in better shape for the long season (Pudge). Yeah, right.

what about luis gonzalez??!?!?!? he went from being in the same boat as sosa and mcguire and being in homerun derbys to being a nobody who hits like 8 HRs a year

Keep in mind, these are not the only people that did/do steroids. As for the red Sox they could easily just have a supplier that hasn't been discovered yet or whatever. I do find it funny tho that the Red Sox competition was named a lot ie Yankee's O's and Blue Jays and like Rays tho I have not looked for former rays on the list.

Will people let the stupid Mitchell conspiracy theories go. The only reason the list has any sort of "NY bias" is that the main source of info was headquartered in NY.

To the anonymous poster talking about players who were on the Red Sox:
Kevin Brown was never on the Red Sox.

The sports media is so funny, they all talk like MLB is now finished and fans are going to stop paying attention and going to games.... I DON'T CARE! Does anybody on here really see this report and now view baseball differently and don't like it as much?

how many red sox are mention?

This from Rotoworld:

Agent Randy Hendricks sent out a statement saying Roger Clemens "vehemently denies allegations in the Mitchell Report that he used performance-enhancing steroids."
Hendricks's release says that Clemens "is outraged that his name is included in the report based on uncorroborated allegations of a troubled man threatened with federal criminal prosecution."

What a fvcking loser.

Def some guys missing on that list:

Curt Schilling
Gabe Kapler


I do find the list a bit biased. I don't see how Clemens can be his age and still be pitching good because of steroids, but fat actress Schilling who is also over 40 is apparently clean. Doesn't make sense.

david ortiz went from a so-so hitter in minn. to a very good hitter in boston???????

Looks like the only people getting caught are the dumb bastards who wrote checks.

The ones getting away with it are the ones who made the checks out to "CASH."

Yeah, writing a check for dope is not all that smart. I think a football player was busted a while back for writing a check to his supplier and putting 'cocaine' in the memo on the check.

...If steroids is a HUGE problem, it's just hard to believe that it's basically confined to the As, Mets, Yanks, and Orioles...and mostly names of former players...there are 26 other teams out there and it's hard for me to believe this list is anything but comprehensive...

...just consider the span of 10 or so years these players on the list represent, and the several thousand players who have played in the bigs during that span...it's hard to believ it's just 80 or so...you gotta think that this is the best list that can be gathered from following this trail cooperative sources...current players who don't use roids have every reason NOT to cooperate or else be silently ostracized by the player community...until MLB installs penalties for NOT cooperating, it won't get players to be upfront and honest...

...IMO we need lifetime bans on your first strike...a 0 tolerance rule and no opportunity for the Hall of Fame...and records set by proven roids users should be omitted completely...

Where's Ecksteins name ???

I heard that before that in the mid-ninties he was actually the guy who played mini-me in the Austen powers movies. And then all of a sudden he's like 5'5 and playing baseball.

Something's up

Don't understand why this Mitchell thing is a big deal. If you didn't know most of these guy were on steroids or some sort of now-illegal performance enhancing drugs then you weren't paying attention. And for the people talking about Hendry and Roberts, how does this affect his trade value at all? Roberts was already mentioned in the Grimsley files and if you read the Mitchell report for Roberts, there isn't even factual proof he did them.

Roberts is one of the guys on here who shouldn't even be in this report if this report is supposed to be of steroid abusers. He wasn't an abuser even if what Bigbie said was true. And again, this was 4 years ago.

And the Tejada thing. Give me a break. I would have bet my life on it that Tejada was in this report. It was pretty much a given to the baseball world with everything that happened with Palmeiro and Grimsley. But now since it's being brought up again and it's in the all mighty "George Mitchell Report" he's a terrible person? You guys gotta remember that these players are being publically punished by the media and fans for something that wasn't illegal in the MLB at the time.

"something that wasn't illegal in the MLB at the time"

-that might be the most hilarious quote in the history of this cite.

Biggest deal to me is pg 124. Aug 2002 -Giants trainer Stan Conte informs Giant's GM Brian Sabean that a player told him he could get steroids from Greg Anderson. Sabean didn't act on it for a number of reasons. So there's concrete proof of one MLB GM who was complicit. I don't wanna hear this bulls*** no one in ownership knew what was going on.

"Barry's clean!! YEAH!!!

Hahah"


Barry Bonds was named countless times and is one of the main guys in the report...Barry Bonds did steroids...period. This report wasn't even necessary to prove that, it's already been proven, this report is just another source that proves it.

"haha Rick Ankiel left off list? he is the most obvious. how does a shitty pitcher with no power go to a star outfielder crankin homeruns all the time in 3 years?"

I actually personally looked through quite a bit of the report, Ankiel is in the report and did use steroids.

Wow, some of these names were very surprising, the most was Gregg Zaun.

Everyone is so worried about IF instead of WHAT. It's not IF they used steroids or something like it. The real question is, WHAT is the benefit...

The benefit is quicker healing, increased endurance, less injuries...

False presumptions about steroids:
You don't hit the ball farther.
You don't hit for a higher average.
You don't run faster.
You don't throw any harder You don't gain any more accuracy with your throws.

Steroids make you bigger but they don't make you stronger, typically the ridiculous strength is gained from the unreasonable amount of time you must stay in the gym. If you don't work out EVERY day for HOURS on end you gain FAT not MUSCLE.

That's why steroid users are so much stronger because of their longer workouts. All it is doing is making the same muscle fibers swell to the point that they look bigger. It is bad for your body because it puts undue strain on your muscles when you get off of it as they are now over expanded like a rubberband that has been held in a stretched out position for a long period of time.

Hitting is about hand-eye coordination and size only makes it look more impressive to us, it doesn't change the effect. A homerun by Bonds the last few years just went farther it didn't happen more frequently. McGwire hit 49 HRs his rookie season at 6'5" and 180lbs. far from his steroid days, so I don't want to hear that it makes these guys superior.

Please educate yourself on these topics before spouting off crap you heard on a media source like t.v. or radio. These people are trying to build ratings and realize you'll only listen to their nonsense if they take the pessimist perspective, if it wasn't an issue there would be nothing to talk about and you wouldn't give a crap about their show. Do the math, this is truly a non-issue and we shouldn't give it any more credence.

Again, steroids helps heal muscles, increase endurance, and decreases injury, nothing more. Everything else you hear is a bunch of crap it only makes you look bigger, it doesn't actually effect your strength and by the way baseball is loving this, don't lie to yourself. Any ratings are good ratings. The eye is on baseball more than any other sport right now and they have been cashing in at the stadiums since the drug style witch hunt began. Become informed and don't listen to the hype! So what if they did them, it didn't make them better! Did Aaron hit 755 HRs weighing less than 200lbs. at roughly 6' tall?! So you think Bonds at a natural 6'3" and 210lbs. can't hit 762 in hitters park after hitters park, don't make yourself look stupid, vote no on whether this steroids issue matters.

"-that might be the most hilarious quote in the history of this cite."

Ok. Would you have rather me put it that taking steroids at the time had basically no risk because the steroid policy was terrible at the time? Up until 2004, using steroids and even getting caught had no implications whatsoever. And don't think like the head honchos of the MLB didn't know it was going on. They could have easily starting doing something about it in the late 90's.

They actually implemented a plan in 2002 where first time offenders of the new steroid policy wouldn't even have the name released and all they had to do was get "treatment". That shouldn't even be considered a punishment.

"A homerun by Bonds the last few years just went farther it didn't happen more frequently."


Um yeah, so it makes the ball go farther, which turns some non-home runs that would just be warning track outs into home runs, thus making it more frequent...you are wrong and contradicted yourself in this statement.

I went through the whole list of names in the report and clicked the wrong Kevin Brown. Wasn't thinking that deeply at the time or i'd have caught it. So sue me :p

As for '"something that wasn't illegal in the MLB at the time"

-that might be the most hilarious quote in the history of this cite.'

It WAS'T illegal in the MLB at the time. US Govt=/MLB.

I still don't understand why people are so up in arms about all of this. Do any of you have any idea about how many performance enhancing drugs are still legal?

First steroids were made illegal and then they came out with prohormones that were essentially derivatives of steroids. Then they make prohormones illegal and now you can find products that inhibit the estrogen-negative-feedback-loop and the androgen-negative-feedback-loop . Essentially what that means is that it prevents testosterone in your body from decaying into estrogen and also reacts with the bonding sites in your hypothalmus making your body THINK your testosterone levels lower. As a result your body pumps out more testosterone and less of that testosterone is then converted into estrogen. They all have the same effect. Are you gonna ban them too even tho they haven't been shown to have any serious side effects? People like to ban these things without knowing anything about them :p

Oh and a little food for thought. Broccoli contains a chemical indole-3-carbinol (also known as DIM). The chemical in the long run decreases the concentration of estradiol (strongest form of estrogen in the body) and as a result increases testosterone. If people were to engineer strains with a higher concentration are we going to start banning them as well?

What about actual dietary consumption of hormones (not just chemicals that affect the ratios in your body but the hormones themselves). You do all realize how much you get from all the meat you eat as well as phytoestrogens from plants like soy (not sure if phytotestosterone exists...). Anyways, the point i'm trying to make with this LONG rant is that rather than condemning people for the use of substances that affect their body chemistry, people should simply concern themselves with their own body chemistry and make the right choice for themselves. Feel free to educate others on the subject (as well as yourself whenever you can get the chance), but why bother passing judgement on someone trying to make the most of their human form.

Most of these athletes are much more aware of what they're putting into their bodies than the average poster on here. At the very least they pay someone to have a clue for them :p

BaseballGuru, you're the one who is talking out of your ass here.

I would agree with your comments about ineffectivity in the context of HGH, but you are dead wrong when it comes to Nandrolone and Stanozolol. Both of these substances stimulate lean muscle growth, and do so WITHOUT the need to increase workout regimens. In short, these two substances will, all other things constant, make an athlete stronger, and faster, completely contradictory to your assertion.

>> All it is doing is making the same muscle fibers swell to the point that they look bigger.

Well, when you go to the gym and workout, you are doing the exact same thing. Muscle tone is NOT an increase in the number of muscle cells, but rather it is the existing cells taking up more volume due to the workload they are carrying. Nandrolone, in particular, increses muscle cell turnover, which is an obvious enhancement to overall strength in and of itself.

This whole thing kind of makes me wonder what will come of Larry Bigbie. He was still an active player, I believe in the Braves farm system, in 2007 and he still went out and outed former teammates. I gained some respect for the guy for coming out and doing this, but I'd have to imagine his career is over.

jpmvp20

I believe Bigbie's on the Las Vegas 51's, which is the Dodgers AAA team i think.

Baseballguru while i agree with the general tone of your post, you do have a few of your facts wrong. First off steroids will NEVER make you gain more fat than if you weren't on them. That's an utter fallacy and one i've definitely heard muttered too many times on the internet. "A friend of a friend took roids and just sat around and ate and he got REALLY fat!!" Yah that might have seemed to actually happen, but likely it was just that the guy either got a ripped off and got some kind of saline solution or something or he just ate like a pig and expected all the calories would go to muscle. All other variables equal steroids will always help with the ratio muscle/fat you gain, but they aren't a cureall. You still need to eat well and exercise to take full advantage.

Anyways i don't remember where the exact article was but check the articles by Author Rea (author is actually his first name) on bodybuilding.com. He talks about how your body each year breaks down some obscene amount of muscle and rebuilds a comparable obscene amount. I know that's really vague, but it was at the very least enough for all the muscle in your body hundreds of times over. If you've ever taken any kind of chemistry class you should be familiar with the concept of equilibrium. What it means is that a chemical reaction is happening simultaneously in both directions. For some reactions it may occur much more rapidly in one direction than the other until it reaches almost completion. In the human body, however, catabolic (breaking down muscle) and anabolic (building muscle) reactions are balanced out fairly evenly over the course of the year. When it comes to testosterone and other androgens, whether they are naturally produced, injected, or ingested, they will shift the rate at which muscle is built while decreasing the rate at which it is broke down. Spread that out over a long period of time and even a TINY little shift will add up to lots of muscle :)

Again, i just want to reiterate, i've never taken steroids, i just like to read (and i'm a chem major so i like to look at all the structures and reaction mechanisms and such).

Oh and also. Muscle is muscle...well actually it depends on the kind of muscle fiber whether it be slow twitch of fast twitch but that has nothing to do with what we're saying. If you increase the amount of muscle you have you will get stronger and faster (in general). Steroids don't just "puff up" your muscles like you seem to be suggesting. Well actually they do increase the size of the individual cells (where as HGH would instead causes your body to create more muscle cells), but it's not simply an aesthetic change. The muscle is fully functional. This isn't some kind of video game where the big character is powerful but slow. Speed=power in the real world (well assuming he's not big, fat and powerful :p).

Anyways, sorry i rambled a few places in there :)

Any steroid taken during the season means you can manage the 162 game schedule easier. Just like being able to work out with more frequency. No they don't make you a better player skill wise but they make overly easy to be 100% or near for the whole season. Sore arms and legs become less bothersome because the steroids help your muscles heal.

My argument isn't that they don't help. My argument is "why do we have to label them as 'cheating?'" Who cares? There are other similar things that are legal anyways.

Anything that effects the outcome of a game unfairly or gives someone an unfair advantage over another (not every player uses steroids) is cheating. Players throwing games, corking bats, and scuffing balls are all forms of cheating. I really don't see how someone injecting designer drugs into their body in effort to give them a physical edge over the rest aren't cheaters.

"False presumptions about steroids:
You don't hit the ball farther.
You don't hit for a higher average.
You don't run faster.
You don't throw any harder You don't gain any more accuracy with your throws"

Then why do they do steroids? Because they want to look good at the beach? That is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard in my life. He tells US to get our facts straight, hilarious.

Steroids will make your body break down much faster whereas HGH does not. HGH and steroids are not the same thing and people need to realize that. HGH has many beneficial health attributes and I think HGH should be a manditory part of injury recovery. Anyone found using when they aren't injured are gone for three years without chance of appeal. Don't make everyone else suffer because one person wants to abuse the privledge. Everyone who could benefit from HGH replacement therapy have to suffer because these guys want to use it to cheat.

Yeah, and who cares if they cheat. That means anyone else who doesn't use that has their job stolen by someone using steroids must also risk his health and use steroids if he wants to keep his job and that is BS. Everyone should be on an even playing ground and we don't need to be shortening players lives by allowing steroids to continue to manifest in the game. Steroids are damaging to the body even when used as directed, but who cares if they use it and end up dying before they are fifty. There are other things that are legal that aren't deadly or so damaging to the body. Glutamine and Arginine are both great with this. I personally use them and they work great and have no side effects or long term damage whatsoever. At least give the players something that isn't going to kill them or shorten their lives/careers. How f'd up do you have to be to say "who cares"?

By the way, corking a bat is actually counterproductive. Less weight = less mass and that means the ball doesn't travel as far. They did this on Mythbusters some time ago and a corked bat absorbs half the impact, literally half. There is something to be said for the potential psychosomatic effect though.

I remember this one time at band camp we had this tuba player. He was pretty small and had a hard time marching with that Tuba, he just wasn't strong enough. Well the next year he was huge but when he marched he moved too quickly and couldn't keep in step. He was angry all the time too. He finally got kicked out and I heard he started playing baseball. I wonder what happened to him.....

Too funny BB.

If the day job doesn't work out, you could always take Dave Berry's old spot...

Okay, Ankiel is on the list, but why was some left off the list, when leaked through reports had them on it. I think for baseball, and Bubba Selig, they were left off, and some $$$$ paid to leave them off. Albert Pujols is one, it pisses me off!!!

Pujols might now becoming clean though. His numbers were down last year, and he doesn't look as buffed up as he used to look. With all this stuff going on, we will see what kind of offensive numbers Poohole will have next year.

First off, I did not contradict myself by saying the ball goes farther but doesn't leave the yard more often... The players as I stated work out more because of the steroids and as a result their workouts cause them to hit the ball further than when they depended on their natural build to get them by.

In the case of Bonds, you can see a steep rise to his production, but he also was training religiously starting about 6-7 years ago, before he admitted that he took the offseason as a break from athletics in general and he has always been on a Hall of Fame pace.

My general point is that where do you seperate the competitive advantage?! Should guys like David Ortiz be forced to lose 40lbs. because he has an unfair advantage in terms of power over guys like Eckstein who will never be big enough to hit 30 HRs?! What about guys like Rickey Henderson that workout year round like animals, he was stated as having the best body in the clubhouse when he was a Mariner at age 43 or so. Should we limit the amount of hours that a player can lift weights or run to compensate for those that don't train as hard?! What about intelligence, should we make the strike zone smaller for pitchers like Schilling and Moyer that take a rediculous number of notes on batters. I mean it's unfair that they do research and prepare better than their oppositions' pitcher, right?!

My final argument is about history and stats. Can you verify that players in the 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s, and 70s didn't take steroids?! Those guys were on average much smaller and played in more challenging environments like Ebbets and Crosby Fields. We can't back track and say that this player or that wasn't taking steroids, we have no way to know. Also, what about technology?! We have all sorts of instruments to correct swings and arm motion now that were unavailable to players half a decade ago and before WWII it was considered stupid to workout or you would lose speed, agility, and flexibility. You can't compare the eras of baseball objectively and to try and play on a level playing field in crazy. You can't make the world perfect and you must accept it for what it is and nothing more.

A side note about steroids, when I was a freshman in H.S. years ago, my whole team was on steroids and we lost almost every game. We had some amazing NATURAL athletes that when we played Little League Football led us to league championships against the same kids we played in H.S., but a sport always finds it's own level like with water. Parity exists when we finally stop screwing with the system and just let it play. Notice baseball players say do this, do that, but no one is bitching about the on the field results. No one is complaining about Bonds breaking records or teams like the Yankees winning championships, the only people complaining are the fans who echo the sentiment of the media like lemmings.

No my football team wasn't on steroids when they won league championships. Also, I have seen people first hand taking steroids as I said above and there were some that thought they didn't need to lift and as a result, they got FAT! I am informed about supplements and steroids and have worked out for 15 years since I was 11 years old. I'm a "below-average" guy at 5'7" and 190lbs., but yet I move more weight than anyone in my Gold's Gym. I'm not on steroids, but there are guys I know that shoot up in the locker room and can't move the weight I can and they are as big as 6'4" and 260lbs. Hopefully you all keep this in perspective and recognize what the motivating factors are in the things you see around you in the media, there is always a twist whether you see it or not.

Oh and to further breakdown my comment about farther but not more frequently.

One, only Brady Anderson, Luis Gonzalez, and Henry Rodriguez woke up one morning and decided to double their HR output or in some cases triple it. Aside from those guys there is no rise in slugging percentage by current athletes that is any more eye-catching than 40-50 years ago, players have up and down years and three guys in the last 20 years happened to have their best year at the plate when their swing was projecting the balls appropriately to clear the fence.

Two, a player can hit the ball as hard as they want, but if they don't have the right angle to their swing then they won't hit the ball out of the yard. Pentland with the Mariners worked with Ibanez a couple years ago on his "swing plain" and figured that if he added just a little more uppercut to his stroke he would hit 10-15 HRs more and magically it happened in 2006. There is not always a battle of good or evil, sometimes it's just about ratings and money.

This whole thing makes me appreciate Greg Maddux that much more.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment


Top Stories



Search MLBTR

Lijit Search

MLBTR Features



Recent Posts


MLBTR Mailing List

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Rumors By Team



Monthly Archives


Live Chats


Tuesdays at 2 p.m. CST



Site Map     Contact     About     Advertise     Privacy Policy     Widget     Twitter     Rss Feed


MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com.