Email a copy of 'AL Central Notes: Infante, Tigers, Indians' to a friend
Loading ...
By charliewilmoth | at
Email a copy of 'AL Central Notes: Infante, Tigers, Indians' to a friend
MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com
hide arrows scroll to top
stymeedone
The Tigers have done a decent job of filling the holes this off season. They have acquired 2 starting pitchers (Zimmermann and Pelfrey), a closer (K-Rod), 2 late inning set up guys (Lowe and Justin Wilson), an OF (Maybin), a backup catcher (Saltalamachia), and a utility player (Aviles). All while dealing with in a restrained payroll. For a first year GM, Mr. Avila has been more active than I anticipated.
As to the quality, I am extremely happy getting Zimmermann and K-Rod, especially at the cost. At a time when the prices for premium starters and relievers was going thru the roof, in retrospect, both were acquired very affordably.
Why the Yankees wanted to move Wilson, I don’t know. I am just glad he came out way. It has been too long since the team had a reliable lefty in the pen. Lowe is a good gamble, and should at least be better than Al Al.
At this time, I will give the benefit of the doubt to both Pelfrey and Maybin. Hopefully, Avila knows something that the numbers don’t show. Neither has been impressive at any point of their careers. Maybin may have been an opportunistic acquisition (who knew Kroll had any type of value?). Pelfrey, he went after! He signed him to a multi year contract at 8MM per. It seemed like it was too early in the off season to settle for someone, who on many levels, did not pitch as well as Randall Simon did.
The Tiger fans are hoping for one more OF acquisition (Cespedes), but I believe he will require a contact beyond their comfort zone. I am hoping for a legitimate leadoff hitter to be on base in front of Miggy and company. I’d be fine with Clippard, too.
bobbleheadguru
Great thoughts! Thanks for sharing.
I think the RP is now a strength of the team and Avila outflanked DD but getting 3 guys for the trade/salary collective price of just KImbrel. None of the three are as good and Kimbrel, but the Tigers got three innings of coverage instead of one. And three guys to spread the injury risk across.
tigerfan4ever
I’m thinking you meant Alfredo Simon rather than Randall, even though at times one would think AS pitched worse than RS would have if he were a pitcher! LOL
tuner49
Great assessment of Avila’s off season. I remember reading that some,(or one), of Detroit’s scouts have had lots of info on Pelfrey and felt he would be a good fit for Detroit as a back end starter. I sense Maybin was a high upside/low cost on a short contract pickup that they felt would not hurt them in CF or LF. He does not fill either the lead off or power hitter role they needed.
I am still lost as to what a “complementary piece” means for Detroit’s OF. Maybin has upside but is at best an average pickup with Collins,Gose, and Aviles as his “complementary piece”. Why would they add a “complementary piece” for a complimentary piece? Anyone that is not better than those three options will not work and an upgrade would be a replacement piece. Collins can be shipped back to Toledo in 2016 but they lose the LHB with pop he would provide off the bench.It seems Gose is the benchmark for who ever they get as a starter or his “complementary piece”.
They still could be just waiting in the weeds for a big LF signing and keep Maybin in center.They want to lock in J.D. for several years. But if they can’t get a deal done, going big now could be their best option.
tigerfan4ever
Everybody pitched better than Randall Simon, but few worse than Alfredo Simon.
tigerfan4ever
I’m sure Pelfrey could actually outpitch Randall Simon but not so sure if he could be better than Alfredo. LOL
stymeedone
I could see a platoon of Gose and Maybin in CF with the Complimentary piece being someone to platoon with Collins. I would think they would want someone decent defensively, with some pop. If Steve Pierce could field, he would be a nice fit.