This is the latest entry in MLBTR’s 2017-18 Offseason In Review series. Click here to read the other completed reviews from around the league.
The Orioles saved their biggest spending for a much-needed rotation fix, while relying on some familiar faces and young arms to augment the back end of the roster at a low cost.
Major League Signings
- Alex Cobb, SP: Four years, $57MM ($20MM deferred without interest)
- Andrew Cashner, SP: Two years, $16MM (plus $10MM club option for 2020 that can either vest or become a player option with at least 340 IP over 2018-19)
- Chris Tillman, SP: One year, $3MM
- Michael Kelly, RHP: Major League contract, minimum salary (Kelly has since been designated for assignment)
- Total spend: $76.545MM
Trades And Claims
- Acquired C Andrew Susac from the Brewers for cash or a player to be named later
- Acquired IF Engelb Vielma from the Giants for cash or a player to be named later
- Acquired OF Jaycob Brugman from the Athletics for RP Jake Bray
- Acquired RHP Konner Wade from the Rockies for $500K in international bonus pool money
- Selected RHP Pedro Araujo from the Cubs, and LHP Nestor Cortes Jr. and RHP Jose Mesa Jr. from the Yankees in the Rule 5 Draft (Mesa has since been returned to the Yankees)
Notable Minor League Signings
- Colby Rasmus, Pedro Alvarez, Danny Valencia, Craig Gentry, Jhan Marinez, Alex Presley, Joely Rodriguez, Ruben Tejada, Josh Edgin, Luis Sardinas, Asher Wojciechowski, Ryan O’Rourke, Jeff Ferrell, Jayson Aquino, Tim Melville, Andrew Faulkner, Perci Garner (note: the Orioles selected the contracts of Rasmus, Alvarez, Valencia, and Gentry, adding $6.1MM in guaranteed salary to the payroll)
- J.J. Hardy, Ubaldo Jimenez, Welington Castillo, Wade Miley, Jeremy Hellickson, Ryan Flaherty, Seth Smith
Orioles 25-Man Roster & Minor League Depth Chart; Orioles Payroll Overview
If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, then Orioles executive VP of baseball operations Dan Duquette could take Major League Baseball’s offseason as a compliment. Since taking over Baltimore’s front office, Duquette’s signature move has been to wait until late in the offseason to pursue free agents whose markets had stalled or even collapsed, in order to sign the players at a discounted price.
This winter, however, seemingly every team in baseball adopted Duquette’s strategy, leading to an unprecedented chill in free agent activity and leaving O’s fans increasingly agitated about their team’s lack of action. While the Orioles were filling some holes via minor league contracts, the club’s most glaring need was being left unfilled — three spots in the team’s starting rotation.
The first domino fell in mid-February, when Andrew Cashner was signed to a two-year, $16MM deal. Next came a one-year, $3MM reunion with Chris Tillman, the longtime O’s workhorse and former ace whose value cratered after a nightmarish 2017 season. While these two signings addressed the back of the rotation, however, Baltimore still seemed in clear need of a more prominent arm to join with Dylan Bundy and Kevin Gausman as the team’s frontline starters.
The O’s weren’t in particularly strong pursuit of Alex Cobb as recently as early February, though the urgency to address that pitching need continued to build, especially once Lance Lynn joined the Twins on a one-year deal even though the Orioles may have been willing to offer multiple seasons. The time had come for the Orioles to take a plunge to solidify their pitching staff, and the result was bringing Cobb into the fold on the largest pitching contract in franchise history.
Cobb has yet to entirely recapture the form he showed prior to his May 2015 Tommy John surgery, returning from rehab to make five ugly starts in 2016 and then posting a solid-but-unspectacular 3.66 ERA, 6.4 K/9, and 2.91 K/BB rate over 179 1/3 innings for the Rays last season. Cobb did gradually pitch better as the season developed, however, and answered some of the questions about his durability by setting a new personal best for innings. It should be noted that even if Cobb’s 2017 numbers end up representing his new normal, his performance last year still represents an enormous upgrade for the Baltimore rotation. Cobb posted 2.4 fWAR and rWAR last season, putting him almost on par with Bundy (2.7) and Gausman (2.5 fWAR, 2.0 rWAR), and far surpasses the numbers posted by Jimenez, Tillman, Wade Miley, or Jeremy Hellickson.
The signing was an aggressive and somewhat unexpected move from Baltimore, especially given their previous record-high pitching contract (Jimenez’s four-year, $50MM deal) only just came off the books and was a significant bust for the team. Still, it was clearly a risk the Orioles felt comfortable in taking, as since 2018 could be something of a win-now season with so many star players hitting free agency next winter, the four-year length of Cobb’s contract indicates that the O’s still intend to be competitive over the long term.
The shorter-term fixes came in the form of some former Orioles brought back on minor league contracts. Pedro Alvarez, Craig Gentry, and Danny Valencia all returned for another stint in Baltimore, while Colby Rasmus (rumored as an O’s target for a couple of years now) joined both the team and baseball itself, after he put his career on hiatus last summer to spend time with his family and newborn child.
Mark Trumbo’s season-opening DL stint and the Orioles’ desire for Austin Hays to get everyday minor league work resulted in Alvarez, Gentry, Valencia, and Rasmus all having their contracts purchased for Opening Day. Rasmus and Gentry look to form a lefty/righty platoon in right field, with Alvarez and Valencia doing the same at DH, with Valencia also available to back up first and possibly third base.
Cobb’s injury history is surely a concern to the O’s, though barring any further health issues, he should clearly help the rotation. It’s anyone’s guess as to how Tillman can (or will) rebound, though at a cost of just $3MM and with shoulder problems potentially the culprit behind his 2017 struggles, he represents at worst a low-risk option for the fifth starter role. If Tillman’s shoulder is feeling better, he stands out as a major bargain for the Orioles at anything resembling his old form. (Tillman can earn up to $7MM more via incentives, though if he reaches a significant portion of that number, it’ll likely be because he’s pitching well enough to make it money well spent for Baltimore.)
Cashner, however, is more of a concern, with a checkered injury history of his own as well as some fairly questionable numbers last season. His 3.40 ERA over 166 2/3 innings for the Rangers looked great on paper, though advanced metrics (4.61 FIP, 5.30 xFIP, 5.52 SIERA) painted a much more dire picture of Cashner’s performance. Never much of a strikeout pitcher, Cashner posted only a 4.64 K/9 last year, the second-lowest total of any qualified starter in the game. Combine that stat with the lowest swinging-strike rate (6.1%) of any qualified starter, and Cashner’s .266 BABIP and 74% strand rate suddenly look like much larger factors in his 2017 success.
There’s also the fact that Cortes and Castro could be needed in the bullpen, which took a big hit when closer Zach Britton suffered a ruptured Achilles tendon over the offseason. Britton is said to be making good progress and could perhaps even be a bit ahead of schedule if he returns by early June or even late May, but obviously it’s a major setback for a pitcher who was already looking to bounce back from an injury-hampered 2017 season.
Brad Brach, Darren O’Day, and Mychal Givens will share the late-game duties with Britton out, and the Orioles’ top plan for bullpen reinforcement seems to be Cortes and Pedro Araujo, both selected in the Rule 5 Draft and required to be on Baltimore’s 25-man roster all season if the team wants to keep them in the organization. Cortes and Araujo both have live arms and either one would be an intriguing addition to the bullpen — going with both for a full season is somewhat risky, due to the sheer lack of experience.
The O’s didn’t have many holes around the diamond, and they gained a bit more left-handed hitting depth in the form of Rasmus, Alvarez, and top prospect Chance Sisco. None are everyday options, though Sisco likely will be at some point. Deploying the veterans in pure platoon roles makes sense on paper, though there is a lack of infield depth on the bench, as Valencia isn’t an ideal defensive choice at anything besides first base at this point in his career. Luis Sardinas and Engelb Vielma are on hand as defense-only infield options in the minors and could eventually get the call once Trumbo returns and the O’s have to engage in some roster shuffling.
The infield question stands out since it isn’t clear if Tim Beckham is a reliable everyday option, though the Orioles are now wondering if Beckham can be a starting third baseman as opposed to a starting shortstop. In a much-publicized position switch, Manny Machado is returning to shortstop after spending the bulk of his MLB career as one of baseball’s best defensive third basemen. It’s a move that carries some risk for Baltimore (in an “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” sense), though Machado’s defense doesn’t appear to have been much affected, and if there is any worry about the position change impacting Machado’s bat, it could be noted that Machado really has nowhere to go but up after a disappointing year at the plate.
Machado hit .259/.310/.471 over 690 PA in 2017, still displaying big power with 33 homers but falling behind in the average and OBP departments — the latter being particularly harmful on a team that struggled as a whole to reach base. With Adam Jones also going through a bit of an off-year by his standards and Davis and Trumbo just having flat-out mediocre seasons, the Orioles’ biggest need may simply be for these lineup cornerstones to get back on track.
There is even more pressure on Machado and Jones for turnaround years since both players will be free agents next offseason. A big contract year could be particularly important for Jones, who turns 33 in June and is entering a free agent market that has become increasingly unfavorable to veteran position players with marginal OBPs over the past two winters. Machado is going to score a huge deal even if he repeats his 2017 numbers, though if he proves that last year was just a fluke, he’ll again be on track for a massive contract that could crack the $300MM barrier.
Whether that next contract could come from the Orioles is beginning to seem increasingly unlikely, as the team and its star shortstop seemed to barely touch base on extension negotiations this winter. Of much more intrigue was the fact that the O’s actively explored trading Machado, opening the floor to offers from any team willing to meet a gigantic asking price. Teams like the Diamondbacks, White Sox, Yankees, Phillies, Giants, and Cardinals were all involved in the talks but, ultimately, Machado was still wearing the orange-and-black on Opening Day.
It’s possible that Machado could again be shopped at the trade deadline if Baltimore falls out of the postseason race. Owner Peter Angelos has traditionally been hesitant about unloading stars at midseason, though with his sons taking an increased role in the franchise’s operations — they reportedly pushed for the Cobb signing, for instance — perhaps Angelos could be convinced that dealing free agents like Machado, Jones, Britton, or Brach would be in the team’s best interest for a quick reload to contend in 2019.
Given how some of the veteran hitters struggled last year, it would be rather painfully ironic for the Orioles if they finally overhauled their rotation only to see their lineup fall apart. The O’s took steps to address their pitching weaknesses, but they’re still putting a lot of faith that the core of their lineup can bring them back to their 2012-16 success. The Orioles did shave around $18MM off the payroll from their season-ending $170MM figure, so there is room to spend at the deadline if they decide to be buyers rather than sellers, but it remains to be seen if Baltimore can hang around in the tough AL East long enough to make that decision.
What’s your take on the Orioles’ winter? (Link to poll for app users)
Photos courtesy of USA Today Sports Images
It doesn’t get much more mediocre than this. Duquette’s continued failure as GM keeps the team treading water.
Britton should have been moved last offseason. Machado should have been moved this offseason. Our two best trade pieces of the past decade wasted.
Schoop should have been extended. Bundy should have been extended. After another solid season from each, both will likely wait to test the FA market, capping their long-term value to the team.
Duquette has brought a level of respectability to the O’s over the past few seasons, getting us to the playoffs a few times, but I think he’s taken us as far as he can. Ever since the debacle with Toronto, I haven’t been impressed. His mind is elsewhere, let him go.
Could not have said it any better dorf
While i agree with almost everything you said i think a lot of it also comes from Angelos himself and the fact he isn’t really willing to spend the money it takes to build a winning team. I think Duquette has done about all he could with the money he was giving to spend but i do believe its probably time to make some changes to the front office. Honestly Brady Anderson is one of the main reasons the team has probably done as well as it has. He is responsible for most of not all of the better moves we have made yet gets none of the spot light for it. I could see him taking over as GM but this team won’t go to far with Angelos as the owner. Either way i will never give up on my team.
Is responsible for most if not all the moves*
I think it’s hard to give credit to a guy who’s position is so undefined and nebulous. As a life-long O’s fan, I like Brady a lot, and while I think a lot of our dysfunction starts with Angelos, the Brady/Duquette dynamic is so weird that it can’t help things.
Since you actually are spouting unchecked cliches re Angelos and his refusal to spend, perhaps you can substantiate your claims.
I’ll check back in a bit.
Angelos is easily a top 10 worst owner in pro sports
The Cobb signing raised their grade from a D to a C in my opinion. I try to convince myself the O’s will still be in it in July, but with so many question marks remaining in that rotation coupled with the fact that they have to face the Yankees and Red Sox so often, I think at best they’ll battle it out with TOR for 3rd place in the division. Difficult to imagine Angelos agreeing to sell at the deadline, so Duquette will have his work cut out for him this season, and it’s a walk year for him and Showalter as well.
.500 for this bunch, literally. 81-81.
that was the longest garbage article on a garbage team that no one cares about…….what a waste of time….
They do that for every team. What so many of us like about this site is that they talk about EVERYBODY, not just the same two teams and five players over and over again.
Underwhelming off season. Lots of needs, but few of them addressed to the level they should have been.
Their acquisitions were half measures at best. The silver lining, I suppose, was that the longest contract they gave out was just 3 years. Would the Red Sox or Yankees have acquired any of these guys? Maybe Cobb but none of the rest of the motley crew BAL acquired that clearly no other team wanted.
Should be a fairly mediocre season for the Orioles. I do think the pick ups of Cashner and Cobb will help over the next couple of seasons in stabilizing the rotation. Last year was entirely lost on the rotation.
I rated the offseason as a solid “B.”
Hopefully, the leadership of the team sees the value in moving Manny, Britton, Brach, and anyone else they can get good prospects for. At this point, I’m guessing Adam Jones demands a trade by July too. His comments about playing for a contender a few months ago were telling.
All this sets up the move of Buck to GM, hiring a new manager (and hopefully batting coach), and letting Duquette transition to another team. Of course, as all Oriole fans know, the greatest help to the entire team will be a transition of majority ownership.
Not signing Markakis seems like the start of the downfall. There’s been a constant hole in the outfield ever since. Markakis was and is Mr consistent, which is something the Orioles offense needs. Signing Davis to that huge contract was a mistake. They’ll likely get little to nothing for Machado and schoop seems to be headed toward the same direction. And where is the pitching development? Matusz, Bundy, Gausman are all too 10 picks if I’m not mistaken and only Bundy has somewhat (finally) developed, but not to what people thought he’d be. Guys like Tyler Wilson, mike Wright, brad bergesen, and arrieta never developed. Something is wrong within either scouting or coaching of pitchers within the organization.
Markakis is the definition of mediocre. Him leaving did not create a hole, but if it did, Nelson Cruz filled it beyond all expectations the year after Markakis left.
Speaking as someone who has a framed autographed Markakis jersey hanging on the wall in my house, I do not miss him.
As for everything else in your post, I agree 100%.
Markakis was still on the team in 2014 the one year Cruz was there.
My bad, although that doesn’t change my outlook that Markakis being here nor there doesn’t move the needle.
On the other hand, former Orioles prospects around the league include Zach Davies, Eduardo Rodriguez, Josh Hader, even Jake Arrieta if you want to reach back, and serviceable back end guys like Parker Bridwell, Andrew Triggs, and Ariel Miranda. The group they’ve given up is almost as good, if not better, than their current 5. I don’t know if the answer is the O’s not being able to develop these arms or if they just don’t know who to hold on to, but something seems broken.
I’m a lifelong O’s fan and it is killing me to watch such a hopeless franchise. There are two basic problems with the Orioles. #1 ownership will not allow the rebuild that is desperately needed. Trading key members of the bullpen last year and sadly even Machado since it is clear that he almost certainly won’t be returning could bring back a group of prospects that could refill a barren farm system.
Unfortunately, that leads directly to problem #2. The O’s are not very good at developing young hitters and can’t develop pitchers at all. Far too many “top prospects” in the Orioles system end up as either busts or replacement level players. Currently, with the possible exceptions of Hays and Sisco there are no Orioles prospects projected to be above average MLB players. Even more telling is the list of above average pitchers that the Orioles successfully developed in the farm system. Zach Britton is home grown, but before him I go back to Armando Benitez and Mike Mussina to find an above average pitcher developed in house. The last 20 years are littered with pitchers like Jake Arietta who were not really successful until they left the Orioles, and pitchers like Adam Lowen, Josh Towers, and John Maine who were all organizational top pitching prospects and never amounted to anything at all. Based on what we have heard from Jake Arietta, it is clear that at least a big chunk of the problem is with the coaching. How much of the problem is related to scouting and analytics as well, I don’t know but they won’t develop pitching until they correct the problems in the system.
Couple the inability to develop pitchers with the fact that free agent pitchers don’t like to pick Baltimore and the results are predictable and depressing. If we are honest, with the possible exception of Dylan Bundy no Orioles starter could crack the 5 man rotation on any of the teams expected to make the playoffs this year.
Bottom line, the Orioles aren’t going to win this year and will continue to scrape along as a mediocre team until they learn to develop pitchers.
No reason to spend on good players when your game plan is for the season to be over at the All Star break. I pray for new ownership who actually cares about the quality of the team.