With several teams around the league straining to find rotation help, the Mets have been receiving early interest in righty Paul Blackburn, reports Joel Sherman of the New York Post. There’s no indication a trade is close, but there’s good reason to think the Mets might be amenable to an earlier-than-usual trade involving the veteran righty.
The Mets are currently six-deep in starters, with Blackburn the ostensible odd man out. Kodai Senga, David Peterson, Clay Holmes, Griffin Canning and Tylor Megill have all pitched well this season. All five have started at least a dozen games, and none has an ERA higher than Megill’s 3.76. Blacknburn’s most recent outing came in long relief, although Sherman notes that he could get a spot start or two with an upcoming run of 13 games in 13 days.
That said, both Frankie Montas and Sean Manaea are out on minor league rehab stints. The former has made four starts and built up to 76 pitches, while the latter tossed 46 pitches over 2 2/3 innings in his second rehab start two days ago. As such, Montas is the closer of the pair to returning and could even be ready to go next week. He’s slated to make his fifth rehab appearance tomorrow, but there’s still enough time left on his rehab clock that he could make two more starts if the team sees fit. Manaea’s rehab window extends into early July, as he only began his assignment on June 6.
One way or another, within the next two to three weeks, the Mets could find themselves with as many as seven or eight healthy rotation options. All are largely established as big league starting pitchers as well, so it’s not as though they have a young, optional arm to send back to Syracuse for a bit.
Peterson can technically still be optioned, but only for another five days. He’s on the cusp of reaching five years of MLB service time, at which point he’d have to consent to being sent down. It’s a moot point, though, given how well he’s pitching. Megill also has an option, but he’s bounced back from a run of shaky starts in early-to-mid May by rattling off 21 1/3 innings with a 3.80 ERA and 28-to-9 K/BB ratio. His season-long numbers are strong, and a depth-focused Mets front office, helmed by president David Stearns, surely doesn’t want to burn Megill’s final option year at a time when he’s pitching well.
One potential wrinkle that could impact the Mets’ rotation depth unfolded as I was writing that last paragraph: Senga exited today’s game against the Nationals with an injury. The right-hander covered first base on a grounder to the right side of the infield, made a leaping catch to corral the throw, and grabbed at his leg after coming down on the bag (video link via SNY). Senga eventually walked off the field under his own power, but he was down on the field for a couple minutes with the Mets’ training staff.
A lot will hinge on whether Senga is forced to skip a start or head to the injured list. There’s no way to know for the time being. He’s surely just in the very initial stages of evaluation. That situation will be worth watching with a close eye, but so long as he avoids a lengthy trip to the IL, that same scenario of six to eight generally established big league starters vying for five rotation spots will loom as a possibility. The Mets could move to a six-man rotation, of course, though Sherman notes that they prefer not to play one reliever short, as they’d be required to do by rolling out a permanent six-man staff.
If the Mets do end up giving serious thought to trading Blackburn, there’ll be no shortage of interested teams. He’s hardly a front-of-the-rotation piece, but the 31-year-old righty carries a 4.39 ERA, 20.1% strikeout rate and 7.5% walk rate over his past 299 1/3 major league innings. He’s pitched in 58 games over that stretch, with all but two of them coming out of the rotation.
Blackburn is in his final season of club control. He’s being paid $4.05MM this year, with about $2.35MM of that sum yet to be paid out. He’s a free agent at the end of the season, so the Mets probably won’t get a particularly large return for him, but they could get a nominal prospect or perhaps a lower-end reliever with more team control. On top of that, trading Blackburn would actually save the Mets around $4.94MM, given that they’re deep in the top bracket of luxury tax penalization and thus subject to a 110% tax on every dollar over the top threshold.
Any current or former Major League pitcher with his arm still attached will generate at least some “trade interest”. Such is the state of pitching these days.
@mlb fan
Pitchers are to be used and thrown away. Only problem is when you get a good pitcher who excels at this level, some teams get tempted to sign them and then get burnt. Owners need to realize that pitchers are to be used and then thrown away before they expire.
So funny how things change. Stearns is always cautioning about too much speculation. Senga likely pulled a hamstring today, That perhaps changes the foundation for this story, as mentioned in it (was Steve A listening to the game as he was editing it?), It’s another example of “you can’t have too much pitching.” There’s no assurance Montas or Manea will be back and effective when they finally are finished with their rehab. Montas has been slow so far, I suspect it’s Butto who’s really on the bubble.
Yeah, there’s another site where people have been asking for two months what the Mets will do when Manaea and Montas get back.
I’ve repeatedly responded by saying that we still don’t know when they’ll get back, and by that time, someone else could be injured or be performing poorly. But no one recognizes that. The site’s owner/writer even did a full blown article about it several days ago that I did not even bother to read.
I dunno. Butto is out of options. I don’t think they just give him away with a DFA that will surely see another team claim him. Montas and Manaea cannot be optioned either. So if they’re healthy, they will be brought back.
@geofft with the Mets being one of the best teams in Baseball, why would the Mets trade Butto now? He is a large part of the Mets pen. When it comes to postseason play, he will be a major contributor for the Mets. I think it would be foolish to trade Butto.
The Mets have a very good problem with their rotation strength even with Senga injury. They still have depth with Menaea and Montas a week to 3 weeks away from returning to the majors. Blackburn can hold down the fort for awhile until Senga, Menaea, and/or Montas are able to take the ball every 5th day. This is a delightful problem to have right before the trade deadline next month. Mets could trade from the Rotation (Holmes, Blackburn, or Megill) to add elsewhere as needed. Pending any further injuries, 8 starters for 5 spots in the rotation, opens the door to trade one or two to get a player or two to increase their depth in the pen or in the field. I like the Mets odds by increase depth elsewhere with already depth. Why trade from the Pen with Butto when you can trade from depth of the rotation? Holmes, Montas, and/or Menaea could slide into the bullpen as needed or to limit their pitch count after injuries. I stick to keeping Butto unless a multiplayer move happens and a sweet deal comes back to the Mets. Even then, I’d be very reluctant to trade Butto. He’s pitched pretty well in high leverage situations so far. What is it, 4 saves in 7 days from June 2nd to 10th? You want that arm come October
Yes, okay. But why are you addressing this to me? I basically said that the Mets would not give Butto away.
High groundball rate makes him a good fit for teams like the Cardinals or Brewers, with solid infields, could maximize his value by turning groundballs into outs.
The Brewers just had to move Civale to bullpen due to lack of spot in rotation. Civale in a walk year has demanded a trade over this. Adding another SP would probably not be a great idea for them right now.
The Cardinals have Matz who also is in a walk year pitching primarily out of pen(he’s had 2 starts). He also is in a walk year, which for both him and Civale will likely have an impact on earnings with their next contracts.
Just don’t see Cardinals or Brewers being good fits when they don’t have enough rotation spots for the SP’s currently on their rosters.
Hold on to that car wash gentlemen.
Smokey & the Bandit.
Kodi Senga just went down with a hamstring, left the game. Blackburn has much more value to the Mets suddenly.
Just saw that. Blackburn should stay in the rotation for at least another 3 weeks until Montas and Manaea are activated and prove to be 100%.
scrap those plans now that Kodai Senga just got hurt again. depending on how bad it is, Paul Blackburn might have to stick around to replace Senga.
Probably off the market for now with the Senga injury
Why? The Mets have two more starters returning and have multiple in AAA.
Because Blackburn can be an effective bullpen piece. Unless someone blows them away with a trade offer.
The Mets bullpen already is performing well and really doesn’t have a spot for him either. He can’t be sent down. There really isn’t a roster spot for him.
The Mets bullpen has been overworked on the year. At least three of the starters struggle to get through the 6th inning and the rotation as a whole is averaging fewer innings per start than 2/3rds of the league. Having a long man to eat those innings instead of burning 3 or 4 of your 1- and 2-inning guys nightly could be worthwhile.
The reality is he could be traded, he could be kept. Neither is out of the question.
The Mets bullpen isn’t overworked. They don’t even have one bullpen arm that’s in the top 30 in appearances this year. The Mets starters have been going deeper into games over the last month. The Mets analytics pitching department is the best in baseball and they have made adjustments on how a bullpen is used and use relievers at a vastly higher rate for multiple innings then any other team in baseball. This allows them to use less relievers per game and keep arms rested.
none of that really matters here. Starters can go cold and a pen can get overworked – in the short term – at any point.
And the bottom line still is that for now, Senga is hurt. For now, Montas and Manaea are not available. And for now, Blackburn is needed in the rotation.
Whether or how that dynamic changes remains to be seen. And yes, a trade is the best way for a team to resolve a logjam. But suggesting that Blackburn is easily expendable, or that “there really isn’t a roster spot for him” is overstating it.
@ Mets Era… DwayneMurhpy did say “for now”, and thats totally appropriate. Montas and Manaea aren’t here right now, and we don’t yet know how many weeks it will be before they are. Plus Montas has pitched poorly on rehab, and Blackburn has pitched well thus far.
Didn’t have the mets trading sp on my 2025 mlb bingo board
Isn’t Holmes in his first season as a starter? So assuming that, he’s probably going to hit an innings wall, so maybe holding on to Blackburn would be a good idea?
Yes, holding on to a surplus is a good idea. But eight starters is a bit too much. Even at 7, they’d likely go to a 6-man rotation and still have another starter in the now-shorter bullpen.
The inury to Senga doesn’t really affect the rotation crunch. The only reason the Mets have gone six deep in the rotation is because of Senga. Take him out, and they can go with a normal five man setup.
It still makes sense to deal Blackburn.
Why disrupt the routines of the other four pitchers when they’re pitching well? Should be business as usual while plugging in Senga’s replacement.
Senga is not the only reason, hernandez. Holmes is a converted reliever. Canning was weak last year. Megill has never stayed in the rotation for a full season. No way to know how long those guys stay effective in a 5-day rotation all season long.
go to the pirates, you look like a pirate. and why waste a perfect nickname (Paul Blackbeard)
Not trading him now with Senga going on the IL.
Sengai (R)
Canning (R)
Holmes (R)
are the Mets top three —
Peterson (L)
MeGill (R)
Manaea (L)
Montas (R)
of the four, two will be in the rotation – there is no trade market for either Montas or Manaea – I’d say you have to leave Peterson in the rotation. Leaves the possibility for Manaea or Montas to supplant MeGill, who has put up excellent strikeout numbers but has also walked a lot of batters this season.
Walks out of the bullpen are a recipe for disaster. I’d keep Blackburn and see if I couldn’t find a taker on MeGill. Id say Manaea beats Montas out for the rotation spot, and Montas is another righty arm out of the bullpen, I dont think the Mets can find a trade for his contract.
For what a team will pay for Blackburn the Mets should let him pitch. Montas and Manaea aren’t anything special.
Remember that time you took me to see
“Harold & Maude”
because I didn’t know the meaning of the word ‘catharsis?’