![]() |
|
|
| |
« Baseball Blogs Weigh In: Holliday, Teixeira, Mussina | Main | Marlins Re-Sign Helms »
Next up in our Offseason Outlook series, the Blue Jays. Here's the roster:
C - Rod Barajas - $2.5MM (club option)
C - Curtis Thigpen - $400K
1B - Lyle Overbay - $7MM
2B - Aaron Hill - $2.59MM (cleared for physical activity in October?)
SS - Marco Scutaro - $1.1MM
3B - Scott Rolen - $11MM
IF - John McDonald - $1.9MM
IF - Jose Bautista - $1.8MM+
IF/OF - Joe Inglett - $400K
LF - Travis Snider - $400K
CF - Vernon Wells - $10MM
RF - Alex Rios - $5.9MM
DH - Adam Lind - $400K
SP - Roy Halladay - $14.25MM
SP - Jesse Litsch - $400K
SP - Dustin McGowan - $404K (shoulder surgery July '08)
SP - Casey Janssen - $404K (shoulder surgery March '08)
SP - David Purcey - $400K
RP - B.J. Ryan - $10MM
RP/SP - Scott Downs - $3.75MM
RP - Jesse Carlson - $400K
RP - Jason Frasor - $1.125MM+
RP - Brian Tallet - $640K+
RP - Jeremy Accardo - $400K
RP - Brandon League - $400K+
Other bullpen candidates: Brian Wolfe - $400K, Shawn Camp - $412K+
Other rotation candidates: Scott Downs, Ricky Romero, Brett Cecil
I have the Jays with about $80MM committed plus arbitration raises to Bautista, Frasor, and League. After that they'll still be under $85MM. The Blue Jays entered '08 with a $98MM payroll, so they should have over $13MM+ to spend. '09 payroll will apparently be "appropriate, but not significantly higher" than in '08.
Let's start with the rotation. Looks shaky, which shows you how quickly starting pitching depth can evaporate. The Jays will need one of McGowan and Janssen to return successfully from shoulder surgery, or for Downs to convert successfully back to starting. They'd look a lot better with another veteran starter. But do the math - if payroll stays the same the Jays will barely be able to squeeze in A.J. Burnett at $15-18MM. I don't see Burnett remaining with the Jays.
The Blue Jays had a below-average offense in 2008. Maybe full seasons of Wells, Lind, Hill, and Snider can remedy that. The clearest position to upgrade via free agency is shortstop, where Rafael Furcal is tempting. A DH type like Milton Bradley, Jason Giambi, or Raul Ibanez could work if the Jays don't mind sitting Snider or Lind.
Toronto seems to have a surplus in the bullpen, though not as much if Downs goes to the rotation. If he stays in the pen, J.P. Ricciardi should aggressively shop Ryan. Ryan at two years, $20MM looks decent in a weak closer market. That'd free up $10MM in '09 payroll without weakening the team much. With that the Jays might be able to afford Furcal plus a free agent starter. Even then they'd need a lot of things to go right to snag a playoff spot in 2009.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515b9a69e20105352d5717970c
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Offseason Outlook: Toronto Blue Jays:


|
|
What about Shaun Marcum? Or is he out all season?
Posted by: bosox10 | October 03, 2008 at 03:31 PM
bosox10- I would probably say Marcum is out for the bulk of '09, although probably not all of '09. Jays shouldn't count on him for '09.
Posted by: melonis rex | October 03, 2008 at 03:49 PM
also, JP Arencibia will probably be the other catcher not Thigpen.
Posted by: jstuart | October 03, 2008 at 03:50 PM
Maybe we'll have Marcum back for the world series. :)
Posted by: jstuart | October 03, 2008 at 03:51 PM
A couple things Tim:
- Jesse Litsch is not eligible for arbitration until possibly 2010 or 2011 as a super two. This was his first full year in the big leagues.
- Vernon Wells' salary is 1.5 million. Rogers made it clear that his signing bonus was not part of the payroll.
- Paul Godfrey said that Jays payroll would continue to rise to about 105 mil if needed. They have approximately 32 million to spend in the offseason.
www.forums.mlb.com/n/pfx/forum.aspx?tsn=1&nav=messages&webtag=ml-bluejays&tid=55433
Posted by: Grant77 | October 03, 2008 at 04:34 PM
Also I'm not sure where this Scott Downs as a starter again stuff came up but it just isn't going to happen. Wolfe is someone that will get looked at as a starter, Scott Richmond and maybe John Parrish.
The one thing that is forsure if AJ leaves the jays need another arm either via Free agency or Trade if the plan is to compete which we have to assume it is.
Also if Aaron Hill is healthy and back to his old self I still like him at Short with Inglett at 2nd.
Posted by: Dev0 | October 03, 2008 at 04:55 PM
"Vernon Wells' salary is 1.5 million."
Seriously? That contract must be incredibly back loaded.
Posted by: start_wearing_purple | October 03, 2008 at 07:14 PM
Wells salary for 2009 is 1.5 million with an 8.5 million signing bonus; his contract has a 24.5 mill signing bonus which includes 8.5 mill installments from 08-10; but the Jays probably average out the bonus over the life of the contract, which works out to 3.5 mill a year. Either way, I don't expect Wells to ever exceed 15-20% of the team's payroll so it shouldn't handicap the team down the road or in the present time.
Tim is pretty much right about the current state of the team. Without a couple of transactions the playoffs are a longshot in the AL East. Keeping Burnett is also a longshot, but if it does happen I'd expect this team to win between 86-90 games without any other moves, and there will be some moves for sure. If AJ is kept, I'd like to see an attempt to move BJ (and maybe Overbay) for Delgado and also take a shot at signing Furcal and Juan Rivera. Those 3 additions, along with retaining Burnett and the subtraction of BJ and Overbay would keep the payroll around the same and make this a 90-95 win team, IMO.
If Burnett does leave (which is likely), then trades may have to be made but I don't think the team is in as bad shape as some people make it out to be. Marcum/Litsch/ Janssen came out of nowhere to be solid 3 and 4 starters and excellent set-up man; R Romero, Cecil and Purcey are even better prospects and Toronto seems to be good at cultivating arms. An active winter could make us comparable with the Rays and Yanks unless both these teams make massive upgrades as well, which is entirely possible. Hopefully the run differential luck will make up some of the difference.
Posted by: Jays2010 | October 03, 2008 at 07:56 PM
"If Peavy becomes Avaialbe, I'd like too see the Jays make a run at him.. Something like Tarvis Snider and one of David Purcey or Brett Cecil + some minor league players for him?? seem fair to me.
thoughts?"
My thought is other teams will offer a heckuva lot more than that to land Peavy.
Posted by: RoyalsRetro | October 03, 2008 at 08:28 PM
Snider is probably the best hitting prospect in the game considering he is 20 and tore up the league. Cecil is also a top 50 pitching prospect. The Padres wouldn't get a whole lot more than that for Peavy.
Posted by: Grant77 | October 03, 2008 at 09:39 PM
Thanks Grant. Godfrey specifically said payroll would be $105MM?
Posted by: Tim Dierkes | October 03, 2008 at 11:07 PM
I'd like to see the Jays trade away Ryan/Overbay in the offseason. Frees up millions and gets rid of expendable players (assuming Accardo/Jansen come back 100%)and the Jays could pick upvaluable prospects. This way they could either put Snider or Lind at 1st so neither had to sit, or send one to DH and pick up a 1b like Bluejays2010 said or Gonzalez with the Padres in need of a closer although other players would likely need to be included. They could even go after Huff in FA. But lets face it J.P. is out G.M., at least for one more year
Posted by: Jays09 | October 03, 2008 at 11:49 PM
No offense Jays2010, but I watched 15-20 Jays games late last year and it seemed as if Ryan's FB was getting slower and slower, is that correct?
I understand that the Jays have Carlson possibly to take over the closer role if he can be moved, though if Ryan's arm is really going downhill, is it possible to get much of value for him without eating the 20 million still owed on his contract?
That Carlson looked very impressive in the games I saw, shame they may be forced to move Scot Downs to the rotation.
Posted by: johns | October 04, 2008 at 05:41 AM
"No offense Jays2010, but I watched 15-20 Jays games late last year and it seemed as if Ryan's FB was getting slower and slower, is that correct?"
Considering Ryan was out for the season last year you'd be wrong. Also Ryan isn't going down hill he missed about a year last season for Tommy John and came back better then we could of hoped he is only expendable because we have such amazing depth in the Bullpen. Carlson won't be closing it will be 1 of Downs, League or Accardo.
Posted by: Dev0 | October 04, 2008 at 07:20 AM
that sure doesnt look very appealing wheres the big bat in the line-up and they need another starter
Posted by: Turnkey | October 04, 2008 at 08:26 AM
The lineup as it is right there I really like if a couple things happen. Snider and Lind play like they have since Cito was here, Wells Rios stay healthy. The main issues/key to that lineup is Scott Rolen and Lyle Overbay, if they can hit the ball that is a great lineup if they can't its weak.
The Jays do need another starter badly if AJ leaves which is very likely. I think the Jays could use a Good pitcher with a Extremely high ground ball rate and he will look twice as good with the jays.
Posted by: Dev0 | October 04, 2008 at 09:05 AM
A couple of points:
-Snider isn't likely to break camp with the Jays. Just look at their handling of Adam Lind for comparison's sake.
-The backup catcher will be Thigpen or maybe Jeroloman, but definetly not Arencibia.
-Breaking camp, the starting rotation could conceivably be Halladay-Litsch-Purcey-R. Romero-Wolfe, with Parrish, Richmond, D. Romero et al. waiting in the wings
As I understand it, 2009 is essentially going to be an audition for 2010 when the Jays will have McGowan, Marcum and Janssen back. Just imagine if the Jays had completed the Rios-Lincecum swap.
Posted by: pmilway | October 04, 2008 at 10:49 AM
No problem.
The specific number of 105 million did come up during the interview with Godfrey.
From what I got out of it, payroll will be slightly higher because of the strong dollar and more fan support, but it could rise to 105 million if the opportunity presents itself.
Posted by: Grant77 | October 04, 2008 at 12:34 PM
What they should do:
Dump Ryan, Overbay, and McDonald, move one of Snider/Lind to 1B, sign Abreu, sign Lowe, sign Furcal.
What they will do:
Stand pat.
Posted by: andagh | October 04, 2008 at 01:36 PM
"No offense Jays2010, but I watched 15-20 Jays games late last year and it seemed as if Ryan's FB was getting slower and slower, is that correct?"
No, it's not. If anything, Ryan's command seemed to improve late in the season, which is what one would expect when he comes back from Tommy John surgery and is pitching in the majors within 12 months. Ryan's fastball was never as fast as people seem to think it was - when he was healthy it was 90-91, and for the most part this year he was throwing at 88-90. It's his ability to locate and throw his breaking stuff that make him deadly, and there's no reason to think Ryan won't return to his pre-2007 levels in 2009.
Tim, there is almost no way with a core bullpen of Ryan, Downs, League, Janssen Accardo, Carlson, and Wolfe and NUMEROUS options in AAA (DRomero, Parrish...) that Frasor and Tallet are going to be kept after arbitration raises. Also, I don't know why you have League as arb-eligible - he was at 2.031 and missed basically all of April, May, and June in the minor leagues, so unless you have him down as a Super2 he might still be on the MLB minimum.
And to list Casey Janssen in the rotation is a bit generous. There's almost no way he returns from a torn labrum to start pitching in the rotation - it's much more likely that 2009 will be spent rebuilding his arm strength in the pen making him ready for perhaps starting again in 2010. Scott Richmond (very consistent 6 starts this year in the majors), Brett Cecil, and even Ricky Romero are better bets to start than Janssen. Brad Mills is the wildcard, a prospect showing good stuff in the minors who may get a chance in 2009.
And Rafael Furcal? God no. He won't be worth anywhere near the dollars or term he will be asking for. JP said that his 3 offseason priorities (this was prior to the Marcum injury) were a power bat, a mid-level SP, and a SS upgrade, in that order. I think the only chance a Furcal or Cabrera make their way to Toronto is if they both find the market isn't as fruitful as they were expecting and can be had on a reasonable one year deal, similar to what happened with David Eckstein. Otherwise it's more likely guys like JJ Hardy and Khalil Greene could be targeted in a trade than a FA SS signing.
Posted by: 92-93 | October 04, 2008 at 03:22 PM
Keep in mind that the offseason outlooks often veer into what I think the team should do rather than what they intend to do.
Posted by: Tim Dierkes | October 04, 2008 at 05:16 PM
Many scouts, experts and commentators say that Ryan's unique mechanics are in baseball's lower ranks, so it would be a good idea to sell him high now before his arm breaks down and his trade value goes with it.
Here is an analysis of BJ Ryan's mechanics:
http://www.chrisoleary.com/
[edited by Tim...the site's new design struggles with longer links and it messes up formatting. So I had to shorten this one unfortunately.]
Posted by: cyberzero_jays | October 04, 2008 at 07:32 PM
Tim's outlook for the Jays is pretty much accurate; if Furcal is available we should go after him. Getting AJ's replacement and a SS are the hardest things to do; a DH shouldn't be that difficult by comparison, espescially with BJ to dangle.
Posted by: Jays2010 | October 04, 2008 at 11:14 PM
Talked to Jeff at Cot's Contracts...Brandon League has 2 years, 146 days service time in his career and that should be good for Super Two status.
Posted by: Tim Dierkes | October 05, 2008 at 10:29 AM
I think that the Jays should let AJ go and use that 15 - 17 mil that they are planning to offer him and use it towards CC. Going rate should be about 20 a year and it would be great having a lefty in the rotation.
Posted by: hypperboy | October 06, 2008 at 03:51 PM