The Path From Indy Ball To The Majors

Two Red Sox players are joking about their respective agents.

“Mine takes me out for dinner,” one says. “With my own money!”

“At least he buys you champagne,” another responds, gesturing towards an expensive bottle in his teammate’s locker.

Their conversation continues, and before long it turns to Daniel Nava, who is sitting nearby. You’ve heard of him by now. He’s the 27-year-old rookie who hit a grand slam on his first major league swing. The former indy leaguer who’s now hitting .300 at the highest level. Nava takes some good-natured ribbing from his teammates, because he doesn’t even have an agent. When the Red Sox signed him for $1 in 2008, he simply didn’t need one.

“There really wasn’t much to negotiate,” Nava told MLBTR. “It was just 'here – here’s the standard protocol for what you sign – here’s the contract.' So I was in no position to negotiate anything anyways … I just took what was given to me.”

Not a whole lot of leverage.

“Zero leverage,” Nava said. “I’m sure they just would have said ‘well, we can grab someone else.’”

Nava didn’t have an agent when the Red Sox purchased his contract from the Golden Baseball League’s Chico Outlaws, but he and other independent leaguers do have some support. Golden League commissioner Kevin Outcalt actively tries to show off his league’s best players to MLB organizations. Sometimes that means making a sales pitch.

“We’ll take our player of the week or player of the month and almost do a mini-Heisman campaign on them where we’re sending out a bio on them, what they’ve done lately, what have they done in the past,” Outcalt said. “I’ll blast that out to all of the [major league] farm directors.”

If MLB teams like what they see, they can call the Golden League and make a deal. But even players who do join big league organizations have to work their way through the minors, so Nava’s two-year ascent from complete obscurity to minor celebrity stands out.

“That’s a New York rise,” Outcalt said. “But given the kind of experience someone like him gained in independent ball, he knew he had the ability to hit pitchers at almost any level and he was able to take that and work his way up very quickly.”

Nava has hit at every level, never posting an OPS below .856 for any of his teams, including the Red Sox. He says he is still adapting to the speed of the game, but that’s just part of the adjustment process.

“Your first time going on a road trip or a homestand it’s all new and once you’ve done it once or twice it’s like ‘OK that’s how it works,’” Nava said. “Just basic stuff like that that you’ve done for years in the minors, all of a sudden it’s all new up here.”

Every time a player like Nava graduates to a major league organization, an independent team loses one of its top players. But that doesn't bother Golden League officials. Outcalt compares the league to a trampoline that helps independent leaguers find jobs in MLB organizations. Every time the league bounces a player back into affiliated baseball, it becomes a more appealing destination for others looking to prolong their pro careers.

Outcalt generally fields three types of calls from MLB teams. Sometimes, clubs will ask about a specific player, like Nava. In that case, the league works out an agreement with an MLB organization for a standard purchase price. These deals can be in place within an hour.

Sometimes, teams are looking for a specific type of player, like someone who has caught at Triple A or a left-handed reliever. And sometimes MLB executives inquire about the league’s best players, regardless of position. Outcalt estimates that 20 or more players make the leap from the Golden League to affiliated baseball each season, most recently Gilbert De La Vara.

Not all teams comb through independent leagues aggressively. The Golden League, for example, hears regularly from the Tigers, Brewers, Red Sox, Blue Jays, Mariners, Padres, Phillies, Astros and Dodgers. 

“Some other teams you never hear from,” Outcalt said.

Tonight, scouts from many organizations gathered to search for the next Daniel Nava, when the Golden League’s All-Stars faced off against the Northern League’s top players in Tucson. The All-Star Game is an informal filter for scouts, who regularly sign players soon after the contest.

Back in April of 2009, when Nava was still playing for the Salem Red Sox, another Golden League alum was emerging as the poster boy for former independent leaguers. Scott Richmond had pitched his way from the Edmonton Cracker-Cats to the Toronto Blue Jays and become the AL Rookie of the Month.

Richmond’s story shows that scouts and front office types are willing to listen when independent leagues come calling. Rob Ducey, a 13-year MLB veteran who now scouts for the Rays, was scouting for the Blue Jays in 2007 when two of his former teammates recommended that Ducey consider Richmond. The right-hander was pitching well and Ducey thought he could produce in affiliated ball.

“You know what, I kind of expected him to pitch well,” Ducey recalled. “He wasn’t a spring chicken. It wasn’t like he was 20 years old and immature. He had a lot of weapons as far as pitches and he threw strikes.”

Richmond, now 30, pitched to a 3.69 ERA in the first half last year, striking out 71 and walking just 30. He has struggled since, but last year's hot start helps explain why teams scout independent leagues: talent can turn up in unexpected places. Ducey can think of another reason.

“Some players, when they get back to professional baseball, not only is their attitude a whole lot better, but they work a whole lot harder because they know what’s on the other side of the fence,” Ducey said.

Richmond encountered shoulder problems in the second half of 2009 and his ERA ballooned to 5.52. He’s now pitching in the minor leagues, but his major league future is largely uncertain. Like Richmond, Nava could find himself in the minors once again. In fact, that reality helps motivate him.

“You’re never going to sit there and say you’ve got it all figured out,” Nava said. “And if you do, usually something’s coming the other way so you don’t have it all figured out.” 

Nava may not have enough job security to seek out an agent, but he sure doesn’t mind playing baseball for a living, whether it’s in front of Fenway Park's Green Monster or back in Chico, California.

“There’s plenty of time to get a nine to five job,” he said. “So you may as well enjoy the chance to do something you love.”


Full Story | 32 Comments | Categories: Daniel Nava

Leave a Reply

32 Comments on "The Path From Indy Ball To The Majors"


Ferrariman
5 years 1 month ago

did that guy named ace walker ever sign? didn’t he win the cy young equivalent of the indy league last year or something.

dire straits
5 years 1 month ago

What a good story. I hope Nava can stick with the Red Sox.

elclashcombo
5 years 1 month ago

Nice job Ben! That article was really well written. Since the off-season, this site has transformed 10-fold. The creativity and quality of writing from regular transaction posts to original content has really improved. Keep up the good work!

frontdeskmike
5 years 1 month ago

Fantastic work, Ben! I love when you mix things up. This article is a very interesting read.I run the ticket office of an indy team but I’ve worked in affiliated ball before. There’s a lot of talent in independent baseball, and we hope they all make it big!

Sniderlover
5 years 1 month ago

Great article. Hopefully Nava can keep it up, he’s a great story!

Guest
5 years 1 month ago

Nice one Ben, enjoyed the read

baseballz
5 years 1 month ago

Yah after reading that i just have to say thanks Ben that was a great read.

5 years 1 month ago

Brilliant article. I am not someone who comments much, but this forced my hand. Nice work Ben. From a reader and visitor since 2006.

5 years 1 month ago

Something that sort of neglected in this article is that Richmond just came of the DL is currently rehabbing down in High A. It’s not as if he’s down their based on performance, which is what seems to be implied in the article.

John Meloche
5 years 1 month ago

Agreed… while the Jays have great depth in Pitching Richmond did a great job before his injury. I think the Jays still view Richmond as a solid back end of the rotation guy or a long reliever out of the bullpen. He seems like the predecessor to Brian Tallent for the Jays.

aap212
5 years 1 month ago

Nice piece. Is there a Mr. Irrelevant in baseball? I know there are zillions of draft picks, and many of them either don’t sign in the late rounds or are strictly organizational filler, but someone has to be the last person drafted, right? I’d love to hear from that guy.

jwredsox
5 years 1 month ago

Mike Piazza was pretty close to being drafted last I think.

ArmchairGM
5 years 1 month ago

He was drafted in the 62nd round, if memory serves me correctly. What a steal that was.

Steve_in_MA
5 years 1 month ago

63rd round.

Steve_in_MA
5 years 1 month ago

62nd … edit button didn’t work. Kudos to Armchair.

bw831
5 years 1 month ago

wish i would have seen this all-star game. missed the Trip-A game as well as i was at work. good read, though.

johnsilver
5 years 1 month ago

Great story with him and the story here. Bad one is he has options and McDonald does not, so he will be the 1st to go back to Pawtucket, undeservingly so since he seems to know the strike zone an awful lot better.

5 years 1 month ago

I’m glad to see an article that was actually written by one of the MLB Trade Rumors staff members. Taking material from other columnists and beat writers in manner that borders upon plagiarism hardly makes the site a resource so it’s great to see someone here actually writing and researching something original on the site. Great job, Ben.

(This isn’t a backhanded compliment. I hope to see more articles like this regularly. Hopefully Ben’s work here will inspire more.)

ChefR
5 years 1 month ago

I meant to reply not, “like”… see comment below.

aap212
5 years 1 month ago

Oh, rest assured, it IS a backhanded compliment.

ChefR
5 years 1 month ago

The site helps gather all the information floating on the web and putting it all in a coherent fashion. As the site says, “Rumors come from established journalists, and always include a link to the source material.”

Honestly, if the site is “hardly a resource” then why are you even here?

Great article! Picked up Nava after his first game in my AL-only roto league

elclashcombo
5 years 1 month ago

“in manner that borders upon plagiarism”

Seriously, I almost spit my coffee out when I read this BS.

5 years 1 month ago

Great Read..I would love to see more stories like this on slower news days…Keep up the Great work MLBTR!!

5 years 1 month ago

Great article. I actual met Nava out in Boston a few nights ago at a bar. And the guy literally bought me a beer and I made a joke asking if that was half of his year’s salary. He got a good laugh out of it. It’s great to see stories like this happen to good, passionate guys like Daniel.

PS You forgot to mention that Nava ALWAYS left two tickets at will-call for ESPN reporter Erin Andrews every single game he was in Pawtucket (Red Sox AAA). The man is my hero.

tmoney352
5 years 1 month ago

do you have a link or anything about the Erin Andrews tix? That is just about hilarious and makes me like Nava infinitely more than I already do.

East Coast Bias
5 years 1 month ago

I’ll echo everyone else – great piece, Ben. Hard not to root for Nava… and that’s coming from a Yankees fan.

The_Dude_79
5 years 1 month ago

That’s awesome that he left tickets everyday for Erin Andrews…he has now become my hero as well.

Oops…supposed to be for the comment above this one

Fangaffes
5 years 1 month ago

When people start coming back off the DL, I hope Theo finds a way top trade Hermida for some bullpen help and keeps Nava.

louis_09
5 years 1 month ago

Great piece…I just hope Neal Huntington didn’t read this one…he might confuse “indy league” with India…and go grab a few more pitchers!

Steve_in_MA
5 years 1 month ago

LOL

Guest
5 years 1 month ago

Hes a really nice dude.. The RS signed him for filler, I cant remember how long he was hitting 400 on the bench in Lancaster.

Garafraxaguy
5 years 1 month ago

Shut up. I thought that was a great read.