The Phillies enter deadline season as clear buyers, sitting atop the NL East with a 47-32 record — the third-best record of any club in the game. It’s a familiar refrain, but president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski made clear this week in interviews with Daniel Alvarez Montes of El Extrabase and Jayson Stark of The Athletic that his focus will be on adding to the bullpen.
“Our starting pitching’s so good,” Dombrowski told Alvarez Montes. “When [Bryce] Harper comes back, our lineup is in pretty good shape at that time. It’s probably bullpen is our biggest focus.”
Dombrowski offered similar sentiments in his chat with Stark and podcast co-host Doug Glanville, though he expanded a bit deeper. While the Phils clearly have a need for some relief help, The longtime baseball ops leader reminded that lefty José Alvarado will be back for the end of the regular season, which will be a boost to the team’s bullpen. Because Alvarado is serving an 80-game PED ban, he’s ineligible for this year’s postseason, but Dombrowski noted that his club will likely shift multiple members of its vaunted rotation into the ’pen for the postseason, just as one of his former teams — the 2018 Red Sox — did to great effect when plugging Nathan Eovaldi and David Price into the playoff bullpen.
That’s not to say the Phillies won’t go out and add a bullpen arm (or perhaps even two). Dombrowski is nothing if not aggressive and straightforward when his team has a need. He emphasized to Stark and Glanville that winning opportunities only come around so often and should not be taken for granted, even if it means “you may give up a little more than you would want to in other circumstances.”
[Related: Philadelphia Phillies Trade Deadline Outlook]
Dombrowski pointed back to his 2022 trade of righty Ben Brown to Chicago in exchange for David Robertson as one such example, noting that it was a painful decision that was made out of what he believed to be strong pitching depth in the system and a major league roster that was capable of making a deep postseason run. Brown, 22 at the time, was ranked as the Phillies’ No. 7 prospect at Baseball America and was ready for a bump from High-A to Double-A. Robertson was a pure rental but in the midst of a terrific rebound season for the Cubs. He went on to pitch well for the Phils down the stretch and into the postseason. Brown was in the majors less than two years after the trade. He’s struggled in 2025 (and was optioned yesterday) but pitched quite well for Chicago last year and is still viewed as a viable long-term member of the pitching staff.
Phillies relievers currently rank 25th in the majors with a 4.63 ERA. They’re slightly better when it comes to FIP (4.24, 22nd) and SIERA (3.78, 15th). The Philadelphia bullpen has a 22.2% strikeout rate that’s right in line with the 22.4% league-average for relievers, and their 8.8% walk rate is a bit shy of the 9.4% league-average mark. However, the group has been far too homer-prone overall, sitting with a 1.29 HR/9 mark that is tied for the second-worst mark in the majors.
The Phillies have gotten generally good work from Matt Strahm, Orion Kerkering, Tanner Banks and (before he was suspended) Alvarado. Offseason signee Jordan Romano struggled considerably in the season’s first month but has posted a 2.95 ERA with a huge 35.6% strikeout rate and 9.6% walk rate over the past two months. Taijuan Walker, moved from the rotation to the bullpen, has shown flashes of excellence — he tossed three scoreless innings of one-hit ball and fanned seven Rays in a relief outing back in May, for instance — but has been inconsistent and stumbled as of late.
Stark did touch on other topics with Dombrowski, notably wondering whether the Phillies might be open to moving Harper back to the outfield if the opportunity to acquire a right-handed-hitting first baseman presented itself. The Phillies’ president declined to speak in absolutes but said he would strongly prefer not to do so, citing Harper’s defensive acumen at first base. In more general terms, Dombrowski downplayed the possibility of adding a bat in any capacity, pointing to previous trade deadlines where he’s promoted players from the farm rather than make an outside acquisition. Twenty-five-year-old Otto Kemp, who hit .313/.416/.594 in Triple-A before a recent promotion to the majors, is currently getting a look and was mentioned specifically by Dombrowski.
Dombrowski also spoke in broad terms about hoping to re-sign Kyle Schwarber and J.T. Realmuto after the season, as both are up for free agency this winter. Phillies fans, in particular, will want to check out both interviews, which clock in around six minutes (Alvarez Montes) and 30 minutes (Stark/Glanville) in length.
It’s Over Phillies!!!
Time to dismantle the Dumpster Fire 🔥!!!
1st place. Lol
need bullpen and a big bat
Who doesn’t?
Mendoza line hitters and this guy von purple thinks this lineup can compete over 162 games. Watching a lineup of triple A hitters, overpaid past their prime and free agent mistakes won’t cut it. Completely unbalanced lineup cannot hit right handed pitching. No power from the right side. Bullpen is a disgrace. 2 games up on a mets team ravaged by injury and von purple hays is 1st place lol ?
The Phillies need a 6th/7th inning guy, and a closer. That is all they really need. Kemp will get his shot, platooning with Kepler in left field. A rh hitting platoon cf, is also a possibility. Rojas is a major liability at the plate. Young ( Nats), is a possible target. He would come cheap.
“Mets team ravaged by injury.” Harper and Nola say hello. Also the Phillies are the 2nd best team in the NL. They’re on pace for 95 Wins in a very tough NL. They have obvious flaws, but so does everyone else. Johnny Devil, you’re one of the most insufferable “Phillies fans” on the planet who will complain about a strikeeout while they’re winning a playoff game. No team is perfect. Of course I want the Phillies to get better. But to act like they have more problems than the average team is literally insane. They’re a top 5 team in all of baseball. A top 2 team in the NL. On pace for 95 wins. What more do you want? Go touch grass.
Nola is 1-6 and getting hammered? Harper has contributed not much. This lineup doesn’t scare anyone. Wake up von purple hays.
2nd best team in the NL. In what is going on 140 plus years of Phillies baseball only 2 other times in their history did they consistently make the playoffs. Newsflash guy, Nola is 1-6 probably because he was pitching hurt. If you got out of your bubble you would probably realize that every team is in complete and most envy the depth the Phillies have with their SP and a deep lineup. They need a serviceable bat and a reliable arm out of the pen. And as a matter of fact, if they would have stuck with Austin Hayes and Carlos Esteves and truly ran it back, they wouldn’t really need that either.
Dumb
@Iceman. I agree completely. Everyone on the table. The only untouchables are probably Harper, Turner, and Wheeler. I wish the Yankees would consider an overhaul as well. Yankees need to get rid of the dead weight. I’d consider trading Volpe with Lombard on the way. Robertson is still waiting to help any BP
2 1st place teams need a complete overhaul? I’m glad you guys aren’t GMs.
Unpopular opinion, but as a Phillies fan, I want to see the same thing. It’ll be great if they go deep in the postseason this year, but I’m kind of sick of this group of guys. Other than Wheeler, Kepler and Schwarber, I don’t even like any of the players. I genuinely looking forward to a totally re-vamped team next year. Fingers crossed for a whole new outfield.
Weird take considering before this group we were in one of the longest playoff droughts in sports history. The team needs to get younger for sure, and I wouldn’t want to resign all these older guys, but other than that, I’m pretty happy with what we got. I remember years and years of meaningless baseball.
Both the Yankees and Phillies are likely to win their respective divisions. None of the Phillies starting players will be traded. Fortunately D D is too smart for that!!
The average fan’s solution to their team’s problems is to fire the manager the GM,the POBO and rebuild,. If they don’t win the World Series within 3 years, fire everyone and rebuild again.
Sadly they can’t trade the incompetent manager. Worst bottom of the lineup in baseball. Bohm batting third ? Pathetic. Your clean up hitter has 8 dingers ? Not good enough. Worst hitting outfield in baseball. Ouch!!!
1st in the NLE. 2nd in the NL. On pace for 95 wins. Ouch! What a terribe team. Please bring back the years of 76 wins and no playoffs. Those were so fun. Get Girardi back here. We don’t need the 2nd most successful manager in Phillies history. Too many wins! So disgusting!
@Johnny Devil: Every team has the same problems.
Nonsense. Terrible game manager. Can’t handle a pitching staff. Still recovering from his brutal handling of his bullpen in the playoffs against the Mets. Worst hitting outfield in baseball. Will finish 500 . Stop extrapolating past success. Bullpen is laughable.
47-32 is current success, not past.
Tell me, what are Bohms numbers post May 1st?
As they should be, but they really need an OF bat as well. They have no power this year.
DD needs a powerful hitter to follow Harper. In Detroit, he used to have Fielder and Cespedes behind Cabrera.
Time for a blockbuster Phillies Mets trade.
Johan Rojas for Jared Young.
I like that. I think the Phillies need to kick in a 15th or so prospect added to Rojas. His value is pretty low.
So is Young’s. You don’t get that return. 1:1 possibly. A 29 year old sub .200 hitter isn’t going to get you much. I wouldn’t even part with Rojas for him.
Cardinals have helsley, maton, matz and Romero. All would be helpful for the Phillies. I’m sure they could work out a deal
Cards will never sell if they’re within spitting distance of the division lead.
Cardinals are currently tied for the final NL Wild Card spot and 2.5 games out of 1st in the NL Central. They may eventually be sellers depending on performance before the trade deadline, but they aren’t right now.
Looking at the broader landscape, I only count 7 teams that are clearly sellers right now, though that list will most likely add a few teams in the next month.
This team needs to demote little big league(Rojas) and bring up Crawford. I’m over the Rojas experience at the plate. Been 3yrs and he can’t hit his own weight. He stinks
Agree, he is putrid at the plate and overrated in the field and negative overall instincts for baseball. But Topper loves him, what a joke.
Topper was 59, when he got his first intrim managers job. He is a nice guy, and well liked by the players, but just isn’t smart enough to make good in game decisions. He gets out – managed in the playoffs in virtually every series they play. They can win in spite of Thomson, but it is more difficult.
I think that they are concerned about getting Crawford more time to ferment. Yes, he is performing well in AAA – better than they expected. But that swing is still a work in progress, and the defense needs some adjustment as well.
Exactly. Scouting and drafting is just phase one. Development is super important. It’s too early for Crawford. Give him time.
@Von – I also suspect that they don’t quite have as high an opinion of his eventual ceiling as we would like to hear, and might be keeping him down there to take advantage of perceived peak trade value rather than have him come up and falter before the deadline.
I would rather that we keep him and end up with a high impact CF and leadoff hitter given my druthers, but they are the experts that see him every day.
It’s a simple decision: can Crawford contribute more — right now — than Kepler or Rojas?
Offensively, yes. Crawford seems to have some plate discipline where Rojas has none. Defensively, Rojas is a significantly better fielder. As for Kepler, he has pop and can work counts and will take his walks. Something the Phillies only get from Harper and Schwarber.
Terrible take. Another no pop outfielder.
Dombrowski could have plenty of Red Sox relievers to choose from …. Wilson and Chapman have been dominant and are free agents after this season.
Are you punting already?
YBC – Just preparing for the deadline.
The Sox won’t make a decision until after they play 13 straight in late July against Tampa, Cubs, Phillies and Dodgers. That stretch will determine whether they are buyers or sellers.
Sox should swing an Aroldis trade. They’re not going anywhere this season and I still fully expect Baltimore to pass them in the standings. Chapman could get them a halfway-decent prospect.
let – If they become sellers a month from now, Chapman is surely gone. Hicks will be the closer to start next season. Sox won’t give Chapman the $35M/2 that he will likely be seeking.
DD is a great GM but if he has a weakness, the pen has been his low point. In truth, his pen in Detroit was better than it performed. Ole Smoket was a poor game time bullpen manager.
A great GM would have addressed the issue.
Time to call up Justin Crawford. And he hit LH pitching very well (.450/.491/1.131) in 56AB
Agree, Rojas is never going to be the guy. A pinch runner at best on a post season roster.
I think that I have finally figured out (perhaps I am slow on the uptake here) why so many fans jump to the concept of “fire-sale” when conditions on the ground do not come close to matching that approach.
We have seen the dramatic rise of the fantasy league fans, and their compatriots the saberdude fans. Now, as long as there are fans, I don’t care what particularly drives them. Fans of all stripes contribute to the dynamic and as long as they are going to games and buying merchandise and enjoying baseball it is all of a piece.
But the way that they think about the game is different than those of us that grew up with the game where we played it all of the time; watched it on TV and got to the ballpark when we could and the fan experience was focused on the team and your favorite players and the drive to win. The fantasy-minded approach seems to find the thrill in trades (Trade Idea Tourettes Syndrome) and metrics and everything that surrounds the process, more than enjoying the ride and hoping that the team wins.
The Phils are not just a playoff hopeful – they are a top contender again this year to win. And teams should try to win when they can – it is as simple as that.
As far as that window – it only closes if the player development fails. So far DD is hanging on to the premier youngsters and in my book he is right to do this. We need to replace from below when possible, as they will balance out those big contracts as they age, and allow for other big contracts to come in when necessary.
Good post. This also applies to other pro leagues.
There is always one or two guys in every dynasty fantasy league that thinks they need to tear everything down unless they can roll out a super team. Any sign of mediocrity is a signal to rebuild rather than retool or add to. They become obsessed with acquiring prospects and draft picks and anyone who isn’t a top 10 pitcher or a MVP candidate they will trade for any combination of 19 year old A+ ball guy, a first round pick, and a dream.
They hoard prospects… Most turn out no better than the guy they traded for and some don’t ever contribute in any meaningful way. A few turn into good players who they will trade away for 3 more prospects and repeat the cycle.
These are the people demanding a rebuild for a 1st place team basically because they aren’t the Dodgers.
Spot on. With the Phillies current crop of starting pitching and with Painter and Abel on the doorstep, their window can remain open.
Fancy baseball is just another pathetic excuse to gamble. You’re right, it has degraded the game experience. A co-worker of mine had a family fantasy league in 1980. I played in a mail APBA league around 1970 and then we created our own league off the concept to play in person. It’s nothing new. But as soon as you put money into it, down the toilet it flushes. So play your flushy baseball all you want. Sit around and watch the swirl. And just remember, it goes in the opposite direction down under. The Mets play in Flushing, you can get there on the 7 train. Brief aside about the NYC mayoral candidate. Some of these right wing commentators need to stick their heads where the sun don’t shine. 9/11? Really? That’s your take? Holy freaking cow.
u ok?
For me, it’s the attitude towards players. A lot of ignorance towards human elements. Players are just a profile pic and a table of stats.
May I interest you in a Chad Green?
Phillies fans are a bunch of emotional children unable to see the forest for the trees. The Fightins are, as predicted, one of the best teams in baseball. Of course they have holes, as does every team. Fans were frothing at the mouth because Dombrowski had the audacity to run it back. Imagine if he would have held on to Hayes and resigned Estevez. They would be in need of only one bullpen arm.
Big market fans are mostly impatient. You just have to tune out that noise and listen for the reasonable ones who are out there.
I know. But for a fan base who is credited for knowing the game, they have yet to realize the crapshoot of October baseball. It is very, very difficult to be the last team standing. The Phillies have come up short the past few seasons, but that is certainly better then the irrelevancy of 2012-2021. The Phillies are in a good spot as they can be creative in grabbing a bat, either infield or outfield, while having some flexibility with Harper and Bohm. Personally, I would like to see Eugenio Saurez and Aroldis Chapman in red pinstripes.both are streaky, but they are rentals and should hopefully not cost our top 5.
Yup. The last few years have been one of the best stretches in Phillies history. We haven’t gotten a ring. We may not, but they’ve certainly been good enough to get there if they get hot.
@skiman – I think that it is less about the fan base (no matter which set of fans) and more about social media and those that spend time on it.
I heard someone the other day talk about it. Now, I am not on social media at all, except for relatively recently the mlbtr site, as well as a Phillies forum. That is it – no FB or any of the others. And even though the baseball stuff is relatively unimportant in the grand scheme, the amount of utterly silly nonsense that goes on here outlines the overall problem.
So this very successful guy (and his guest) both had used social media for professional reasons – and it made utter sense. Why I listened because I have been contemplating this for the same set of reasons. and wanted to learn more. Their conclusion – it is such a sinkhole of stupidity and iniquity that it was no longer worth it. The negative energy was incredibly high. And when they both stopped, it made literally no difference to them professionally at all, and they were so much happier to just avoid the idiocy.
Of course, I relay this as I have spent more time on here in recent months than ever before. I really need to go back to just reading the articles and avoiding the comments. But I kinda’ got hooked as there really is a small but very cool group on here that are not only sound in their approach and thought process but very decent as well and I would miss that.
They could use a good bat or two. If not for such good starting pitching, their run differential would probably be a negative number.
Andres Munoz for Bryson Stott, throw in prospect and Max Kepler?
As a fan of both teams, I don’t see how the Ms benefit.
If they’re prioritizing bullpen help in the trade market, then it’s time to call up Crawford to play center field. They cannot keep trotting out these terrible platoons in left and right field for a full season.
Good news for them, the Mets are not looking for bullpen help
Still hoping they can reach a deal with David Robertson that works for both sides. He’s much better than multiple folks out there and will not cost talent just $$$
@FRBob – That is the mystery, as one would think that someone would have signed him by now. He will need time to ramp up, which could be quite a spell and one would think that teams would like to see if he is contributing prior to the deadline so they can determine if they need another arm as well.
The best guess is that no one wants to meet his price, and he is perfectly comfortable with retirement if no one gets there.
At this point, what can you expect from an aging veteran who hasn’t thrown a single game this season? I don’t think he’d be much help. He needs significant ramp up time.
If there is any one thing that is literally a telltale sign that Dave Dombrowski is running the show is a need for bullpen help. Always.
Troy – I know you’re talking mostly about the Tigers, but he put together a really good pen with the Sox.
And the Phillies, ironically. Just not so much this year, and that’s partly because one of their best pieces is suspended. The Klentak years saw the Phillies have one of the worst bullpens in baseball history, and that’s no exaggeration. Things improved under DD. They need to improve more obviously.
It wouldn’t be a Dave Dombrowski team if the bullpen wasn’t an issue…
Rsox – LOL …. you don’t remember his time with the Red Sox?
2018 – 8th best in MLB
2017 – 2nd best
2016 – 8th best
Won’t count 2019 because we all know how Cora screwed up that team.
More often than not building a bullpen is Dombrowski’s Achilles Heel.
The core of those team’s bullpens was mostly already in place when Dombrowski took over (Barnes, Hembree, Workman) with Kimbrel being added in ’16, which was mostly a win for Dave
Rsox – The conversion of Joe Kelly from starter to reliever was entirely Dave’s doing as well.
I think most would agree Kimbrel & Kelly were the big guns in the BP during the 3-year postseason run.