The Rockies dropped to 21-71 with today’s loss in Boston, putting them on a 37-win pace for the season. That’d have them four wins shy of last year’s White Sox, the worst team in modern history. The Rockies are obviously going to be deadline sellers, but the extent of that sale is complicated by the organization’s track record of holding onto players that any other team would have traded.
Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic writes that the Rox intend to be more willing to listen on veteran players than they have been at prior deadlines. He suggests they’ll seriously entertain interest in the likes of third baseman Ryan McMahon, reliever Jake Bird, and starter Germán Márquez. That broadly aligns with a report from Jon Heyman of The New York Post last week. Heyman reported that the Rockies are open to offers on McMahon, specifically, after they pulled him off the trade market early in 2024.
However, that increased willingness to deal veterans doesn’t mean the Rockies are completely open for business. Rosenthal writes that the team remains unlikely to trade young players whom they view as core pieces. He lists shortstop Ezequiel Tovar, center fielder Brenton Doyle, and rookie righty Chase Dollander in that group. Rosenthal more surprisingly adds relievers Seth Halvorsen and Zach Agnos, plus starter Ryan Feltner, as players who may fall in the latter category.
McMahon, Márquez and Bird are Colorado’s three most obvious trade chips. They all featured prominently on MLBTR’s initial list of the top 40 trade candidates last week. McMahon is a plus defensive third baseman with power and strikeout concerns. He had an abysmal April, raked in May, and has cooled back off since the beginning of June. He’s hitting just .210/.310/.373 on the season and has been a well below-average hitter (.207/.305/.350) over the past calendar year.
There’ll nevertheless be interest in McMahon, particularly given the scarcity of infield talent that may be available. The Yankees need to acquire a third baseman and have reportedly already checked in. The Cubs and Tigers are speculative possibilities. McMahon is playing on a $12MM salary in his age-30 season and will make $16MM annually between 2026-27.
Márquez is an impending free agent who is making $10MM. He was an above-average starter earlier in his career but hasn’t been as sharp since undergoing Tommy John surgery in 2023. He’s sitting on a 5.84 ERA with a subpar 15.3% strikeout rate over 18 starts. The 30-year-old righty is coming off his best month of the season, though, working to a 2.97 mark while striking out 21% of opponents in June. His fastball still sits around 95 MPH, so teams could view him as an upside play outside of Coors Field. He’s unlikely to be a qualifying offer candidate, so there’s little reason not to trade him.
Bird, 29, had quietly been one of the league’s best relievers until he was blown up by the Red Sox on Tuesday. That outing jumped his season ERA by nearly a full run, up from 2.79 to 3.70. Bird has fanned more than 27% of opposing hitters and has generally done well to keep runs off the board. He looked to be a fairly nondescript middle reliever entering the season. He’s under club control for three seasons beyond this one, but this is a breakout year for a reliever approaching his 30th birthday. The Rockies would be wise to cash him in this summer while his trade value is at its peak.
The Rockies have a few other veteran players, though they’d have little to no trade value. They’ll presumably hope to find a lottery ticket prospect for the likes of Thairo Estrada, Austin Gomber and Tyler Kinley. It’s not surprising they’re reluctant to move Tovar or Doyle, both of whom are struggling through down years but looked like potential cornerstones a season ago. Dollander has been hit hard in his debut campaign and was recently optioned back to Triple-A, but he’s a recent top 10 pick and the organization’s best hope of developing a front-line starter.
Feltner is a back-of-the-rotation starter who has missed most of this season rehabbing a back issue. He just returned from the injured list last week and has been limited to six starts. The Rox could get a notable return for Halvorsen, a fireballer who has gotten a look in the ninth inning. He’s only 25 and controllable for five more seasons. A team in Colorado’s position should arguably be willing to trade any reliever, but there’s more of a case for holding Haloversen than there would be with Bird. It’s tougher to see the logic in including Agnos as a potential building block. He’s a rookie reliever with a 5.19 ERA and 15 strikeouts in his first 26 career innings. Agnos, a former 10th-round pick, has good but not elite velocity and has never been a highly-regarded prospect despite excellent minor league numbers.
They should absolutely trade Tovar
Why?
@CenterWingPolitics
His only saving grace is his defense and he plays in Coors field where he can’t hit the ball. He should be sent to the minors to work on his game.
lol 4 WAR SS last year who currently has a 90 OPS+ in about 150 abs.
They should send him to the Dominican summer league!
@Jbigz12
Agreed. He’s just not ready for the majors.
You mean the guy who had 73 extra-base hits last year, in his age-22 season?
@Moonlight Graham
Yes, there are a lot of one-hit wonders in MLB. He’s no different. I’d be getting rid of him before he becomes a burden on the team but this is the Rockies so they’ll most likely sign him to a 30 year contract and then trade him elsewhere and pay his full salary while he plays elsewhere.
Another fan saying another dumb thing because they don’t have any accountability for the dumb thing they say. If they’re proven wrong, they say they were joking or didn’t say it. If they’re proven wrong teams does what they want and it doesn’t work it was a dumb move.
@ThatsIT
Don’t worry. I’ll be correct. Now, time for the kids to move along…
One hit wonder? He was pretty good in 2023 and great in 2024. Hes been injured and missed the pat month and hes only 23.
Your statement here just unequivocally false.
About the only player they have that Rockies fans would be right to be upset about them trading.
Honestly, just trade Dollander for a really good hitting prospect. Embrace the fact that most pitching is not going to work well in Coors Field, and completley lean into the thin air and flyballs. Rangey outfielders with power, slugging corner infielders, and some solid hitters up the middle, with a bullpen that throws flames to make up for bad fastball shape is the way to go for the Rockies.
I don’t know why they moved their AAA team out of Colorado. It seems to me that you’d absolutely want your prospects getting a chance to pitch in the same environment in the minor leagues to learn how to make it work.
They moved it to Albuquerque, which is actually closer to Denver’s elevation than Colorado Springs is. Stadium in the Springs was not really modern AAA quality.
Thanks. I’m not especially familiar with New Mexico. Interesting that Dollander was pulled up from AA without getting a chance to throw serious innings there if there’s an elevation match in Albuquerque. Hartford Connecticut is absolutely nothing like Denver.
Drop a bomb on it. Everybody must go!
Rockies ownership says they need “new eyes”. John Mozeliak is the perfect solution. He will soon have his summers free. He began his baseball career in the Rockies organization. He is very adapt at convincing ownership that he is indispensable. He makes tons of terrible, head-scratching decisions, and the Monforts seem to love that.
So there you have it, the perfect solution to all the Rockies front office needs. The Rockies should waste no time and convince Mo to jump ship tomorrow, or better yet today.
I think the Dodgers, Josh Byrnes, would be a more ideal fit. He’s also a former Rockies Assistant General Manager, he originally came over with Dan O’Dowd from Cleveland’s organization.
Another name I’d consider is Todd Helton, as President of Baseball Operations, and let him rebuild the franchise as the Colorado Avalanche did for Joe Sakic.
It ultimately won’t matter who comes in if Montfort won’t let them modernize the FO. Worst division to come in also. Hazen is a smart guy and the other 3 teams have deep pockets with good FO’s. Obviously especially deep in LA.
Any GM job holds appeal but this would be at the very bottom of my list if I was a GM candidate. I think Pitt is an easier turnaround.
I’d like to see them go for it just to see it
Maybe the Rockies could entertain the idea of trading their owner perhaps? Just saying 🙃
The problem is Monfort’s statcast owners page is pretty much all dark blues. The only red he’s got is his occasional willingness to spend money, but that one bright spot is tamped down by his dark, dark blue inability to adjust or adapt, which completely invalidates the spending capacity.
In the end, he has no real trade value. At best, you might be able to make a bad owner swap. Maybe the franchise formally known as Oakland might bite, but then you’re looking at John Fisher as your new owner. That probably makes things worse.
no veteran in Colorado’s rotation (Freeland, Marquez, Gomber, Feltner) is bringing back anyone that will actually help the Club.
Losing 100+ games next season seems inevitable
When your long awaited guys like Amador and Veen hit below .175, time to just blow it all up. Play Fernandez, trade any hitter 27 or older..Doyle and Toglia too. See if Condon or Carrig can win a job next year. Hope Dollande rand Palmquist can adjust. What’s the point of keeping any of these guys to win 41 instead of 37…
Aim at 2028.
When you’re a team on pace to set a new record for losses in a season, there should be no untouchables save for perhaps, Chase Dollander.
Relievers, except elite closers like Hader or someone who is the second coming of Mariano Rivera, are the most fungible and up-and-down players in all of MLB. One year they are lights out. The next year? They can’t get anybody out.
Should have moved McMahon last year. Hope they don’t make the same mistake again this year. His salary, present and future, shouldn’t be an impediment to making a trade. It’s not a bargain but it’s nowhere near as bad as the one the Reds gave to Candelario that they eventually will eat after releasing him.
Being LH, he’d be a good fit with the Yankees. That short porch in RF at Yankee Stadium will help offset any fears that a move away from Coors will be a detriment to his pop.
Every contender almost without exception is looking to add to its bullpen. Rox should be accommodating and feed the market’s appetite. Who cares about having a decent closer if you’re a team who is bound to lose 100 games again next year? The answer should be nobody. And the Rox should obey that answer.
Send Kinley to the Rays and he’d be the best reliever in MLB in the 2nd half
Article should have mentioned Mickey Moniak, who is having a decent season. Not a major trade chip, but could be a decent 4th OF for somebody and bring back a lottery ticket prospect.
Now Moniak is a name that might interest the Mets. CF has pretty much been a zero for them all year with intended starter Jose Siri on the IL and Tyrone Taylor offering nothing but a nice glove. Lately, on occasion they’ve played Jeff McNeil in CF, but the now 33-year-old infielder may not have the wheels to be a solid defender there, and especially in spacious Citi Field. But the Rox wouldn’t get Mark Vientos for him either despite Moniak being a former Number 1 overall draft pick by the Phillies (Thanks Matt Klentak for that brilliant move!!!).
Moniak is settling in and is starting to hit, he has two more seasons of ARB at what will be a relative bargain should he continue to hit at a .260/.310/.500 — K to BB is still an issue with Moniak but he is only 27, has improved this season, if he can make incremental improvements year to year he could be a real nice player in his age 30 to age 35 seasons.
Vientos for Moniak, no thanks.
Would Colorado do a Jake Bird for Mark Vientos swap ? Than McMahon can switch back to 2b for the Rockies ?
They absolutely should if the Mets offered that.
The Mets aren’t gonna give up Vientos so readily nor cheaply. If they offered up Halverson that might get them someone like Luisangel Acuna (2B-SS) or maybe one of their SP prospects far down the food chain.
Pass on Vientos all together.
Rather have Brent Baty and Acuna.
In his last 2 outings combined, Jake Bird has given up 7 hits and 1 walk while retiring only 2 batters. It’s a small sample size, but he looks like a less valuable trade chip now than he did in June.
Sell your relievers at first opportunity. Way too volatile
Nobody on the team is worth trading for.
They have better options in CF than your team
.596 OPS in Coors is good ? What would that equate to in New York? .400. Stop drinking the kool aid.
Check out his expected stats. He’s had a ton of bad luck this year and has actually improved on the improvements he made during his breakout year last year in swing decisions. He’s also easily one of the best defensive players in baseball
the top of Colorado’s lineup looks good with Freeman, Moniak and Goodman. They should run all three all the way to FA.
Keeping Moniak is important, he seems to have found his game in Colorado, a former 1/1.
Toglia has shown some good power and Doyle and Beck can hit a little. Tovar, Yanquiel Fernandez, Zac Veen, Charlie Condon — they have some players on the offensive side of the ball.
They should trade McMahon, Estrada and all the bullpen arms for SP prospects.
Actually the worst team in modern baseball history is still the 1962 New York Mets.
They had a record of 40-120.The White Sox last year were 1-1 in their extra 2 games and thus had a higher win percentage.
Sucks that mcmahon is having a down year so he won’t get as much of a return, I’d ship out the pitchers for lottery ticket type prospects. They need infield depth bad, if they trade thairo, they may be forced to use amador again before he’s ready which is likely hurting his development. I hate selling low so I’d lean towards keeping mcmahon, doyle, tovar. Like in the name of not putting an embarassing product on the field, the fans don’t deserve that. I would cash in on moniak and the veteran pitchers if possible.
That’s not true. He’ll still hit for 20 homers, be a 3-4 WAR player and be in consideration for a Gold Glove.
He’ll still get you Top 100 prospect or two depending on the System and a lower tier prospect or two.
3 prospects realistically in the 45-50 range on MLB’s 20-80 scale.
I just don’t see anyone meeting that ask. McMahon has an excellent glove at a position that doesn’t require an excellent glove. He doesn’t hit for average. His contract is overpaid. I see one solid prospect,and maybe a lotto ticket.
Ryan McMahon isn’t going to fetch a 3 45FV package.
He’ll land you one of those and a lotto ticket. He’s not a bargain.
More realistically, McMahon will get 1 45-50 prospect, maybe another 40 grade prospect, and a lower level lottery ticket. The Yankees are one of the teams that needs a 3B. Be happy if they get like an Everson Pereira as a headliner.
Value wise you’re right. Rox likely won’t look at outfielders though. That’s about all they have in their system.
There shouldn’t be a comma before “specifically.”