The Orioles announced this morning that they have optioned right-hander Yennier Cano to Triple-A Norfolk. Right-hander Yaramil Hiraldo was recalled to the majors in a corresponding move.
It’s a somewhat shocking decision given Cano’s history as a key arm in the Baltimore bullpen. Acquired in the Jorge Lopez trade with the Twins at the 2022 trade deadline, Cano struggled across 18 MLB innings during his rookie season with Minnesota and Baltimore but was utterly dominant for the O’s in 2023. He formed a dynamic duo with closer Felix Bautista in the late innings and posted a sterling 2.11 ERA in 72 2/3 innings of work that year. While Cano’s 23.0% strikeout rate that year hardly jumped off the page, he walked just 4.6% of his opponents and generated an excellent 58.0% ground ball rate that season. Cano’s grounder-heavy, command-driven approach that season served as an excellent complement to Bautista’s overpowering stuff and helped to create a dominant bullpen that led Baltimore back to the playoffs for the first time since 2016.
Cano followed up that dominant 2023 campaign with another solid season last year. While his 3.15 ERA and 3.55 FIP were both a far cry from the elite results he posted the year prior, Cano generated an even more impressive 62.9% ground ball rate and watched his strikeout rate tick up to a more robust 26.1%. Those were encouraging developments, but they were offset by the fact that Cano’s walk rate more than doubled as he allowed free passes at a 9.6% clip. That helps to explain why Cano’s results were less impressive last year, but a look at underlying metrics such as xFIP and SIERA suggests that Cano’s actual performance was more or less on par with his excellent 2023 campaign.
That trend of worsening results despite strong peripherals has continued this season. Cano’s 4.73 ERA in 26 2/3 innings of work this year speaks for itself as unacceptable production from a high-leverage arm, and he’s posted an even more brutal 7.41 ERA since the calendar flipped to May. With that being said, a look at Cano’s under-the-hood numbers reveals that Cano is looking better than ever in at least some ways. His 27.4% strikeout rate is by far the best of his career, and he’s walking opponents at a 7.1% clip that stands as an improvement over 2024, even if his control isn’t quite as pinpoint as it was back in 2023. While his grounder rate has dropped substantially, down to just 52.8%, it remains above average overall. Cano’s 2.85 xFIP and 2.73 SIERA are actually both career-best figures, suggesting he’s pitching better than ever and largely being held back by a shockingly high .362 BABIP allowed.
That didn’t stop the Orioles from sending Cano to the minors in hopes of getting his results back on track, however. Shocking as the decision may be based on his excellent peripherals, it’s worth noting that Baltimore’s bullpen has precious few relief arms who can be optioned to the minors at all. Aside from Cano and Bautista, the only reliever on the Orioles’ roster with options remaining is Keegan Akin, who has a 2.70 ERA this season and is one of just two southpaws in the Baltimore bullpen. That reality might have made Cano’s leash with the Orioles shorter than it would be on a team with more flexibility built into their bullpen mix. Gregory Soto, Bryan Baker, and Seranthony Dominguez figure to handle the work of setting up for Bautista while Cano is in the minors.
As for Hiraldo, the right-hander got his start in professional ball with the Diamondbacks but departed affiliated ball for a few years following the 2021 season. He returned with the Orioles this year on a minor league pact and has put up brilliant numbers at every step of the way in the minors, with a 2.77 ERA, 1.65 FIP, and 32.7% strikeout rate across 26 MiLB innings this year. The 29-year-old has made just one appearance in the big leagues where he threw 1 1/3 scoreless innings for the Orioles earlier this year.
