Players Who Were Once Designated For Assignment

We see it all the time. Most weeks a handful of players are designated for assignment and more often than not casual fans barely notice. A DFA indicates that a team is willing to part with a player – sometimes for nothing. But sometimes those players come back from DFAs to become stars in the major leagues. Here's a list of some current players who have been designated for assignment:

  • David Aardsma – The Red Sox acquired Aardsma after the White Sox designated him for assignment in 2008. A year later, the Mariners traded for Aardsma, who became the team's closer and posted impressive rates of 10.1 K/9 and 2.4 BB/9.
  • Mike Adams – Adams was designated for assignment in 2006, before he posted absurdly low ERAs and regularly struck out more than a batter per inning.
  • Milton Bradley – The Padres acquired Bradley from the A's after Bradley was designated for assignment in 2007. Bradley hit .313/.414/.590 for the Padres and led them to a one game playoff with the Rockies for the Wild Card spot. Of course Bradley didn't play in game 163, since he tore his ACL while manager Bud Black restrained him during an on-field argument earlier in the month.
  • Russell Branyan – No one claimed Branyan after his 2006 DFA, but the Cardinals traded for him when the Phillies designated him for assignment the next year. He didn't do much for the Cards in his 39 plate appearances in 2007, but Branyan rebounded to hit 31 homers for the Mariners in 2009.
  • Marlon Byrd – The Nationals designated Byrd for assignment in 2006 without losing him and the Rangers did the same in 2007. Byrd recovered from his '07 demotion to post three consecutive productive seasons in Texas.
  • Nelson Cruz – The Rangers designated Cruz for assignment at the beginning of the 2008 season –  usually a good time to sneak players through waivers. The Rangers must be thrilled no one claimed Cruz, who hit 37 homers in the minors that year and added 33 in the majors the following season.
  • Rajai Davis – The A's claimed the outfielder off of waivers from their Bay Area rivals in 2008. Davis was hitting .056/.105/.056 at the time, though he had batted just 19 times. He has gone on to become a useful player, hitting .305/.360/.423 last year with 41 steals and above average defense, according to UZR.
  • Jorge de la Rosa – The Royals designated de la Rosa for assignment in March of 2008, but it wasn't until a month later that the Rockies traded for him. The 29-year-old free agent-to-be has been a productive starter in Colorado since.
  • Ryan Franklin – The Reds acquired Franklin from the Phillies in 2006 after a poor start to the season. Franklin didn't do much better with the Reds, but he has been productive for three-plus seasons in St. Louis since.
  • Jeremy Guthrie – The Orioles claimed the former first round pick from the Indians early in 2007, when Guthrie had just 37 big league innings and a 6.08 ERA to his name. Since, the righty has posted a 4.19 ERA in 610.1 innings.
  • LaTroy Hawkins – The Yankees designated the reliever for assignment in 2008 and traded him to Houston, where Hawkins dominated for 24 appearances. He posted a 0.43 ERA along with 10.7 K/9 and 2.1 BB/9.
  • Bobby Jenks – He has fallen out of favor with the White Sox now, but they deserve credit for picking him up after the 2004 season. Jenks has struck out three times as many batters as he has walked in 301 innings with the White Sox.
  • Ryan Ludwick – The slugger started the 2005 season hitting just .154/.267/.385 so the Indians designated him for assignment. No one claimed Ludwick then, but the Cardinals made a shrewd pickup when they later signed him.
  • Brandon Phillips – The Reds claimed Phillips after the Indians designated him for assignment in 2006. He had just a .206/.246/.310 big league line at the time, but he has averaged 22 homers and 26 steals in his four full seasons with the Reds. UZR rates the 28-year-old as an above average defender at second base, too.
  • Joel Pineiro – The Red Sox designated Pineiro for assignment in 2007 when he had a 5.03 ERA and just 20 strikeouts to go along with 14 walks. Later that summer, the Cardinals acquired Pineiro and he went on to post 426.1 solid innings for the Cards. Under the tutelage of pitching coach Dave Duncan, Pineiro posted a walk rate of 1.6 BB/9 in a Cardinals uniform.
  • Grant BalfourRyan ChurchJack CustMatt DiazJerry Hairston Jr.Joel HanrahanLivan HernandezMike JacobsColby LewisJulio LugoMike MacDougalEvan MeekVicente PadillaScott PodsednikJ.C. RomeroDavid Ross, Brian Tallet, Todd Wellemeyer and Randy Wells are among the many big leaguers who have been designated for assignment.

It's worth noting that this group does not include a superstar (Cruz might be the closest thing to one). Teams designate many talented players for assignment because of roster constraints, but few enjoy as much success as the group above.

Thanks to Cot's Baseball Contracts for the information.

15 Responses to Players Who Were Once Designated For Assignment Leave a Reply

  1. cardrob 5 years ago

    Was Carpenter designated for assignment from the Blue Jays? I know they did not want him anymore. Wikipedia said he was removed from the 40 man roster?

  2. Guest 5 years ago

    Any chance you can add Craig Breslow to this list, Ben? He’s had a pretty respectable 2.84 ERA and a sparkiling 1.080 WHIP in 66.2 innings for the A’s, since being claimed by Minnesota one year ago. He deserves some props, IMHO! :)

  3. porkchopxpress 5 years ago

    NIce list of players that the Tribe designated!!! I guess that goes along with their scouting of talent before the draft.

  4. Jeff Francoeur too

    • jcrabtree7 5 years ago

      Frenchy wasn’t DFA’d, he was just straight up traded.

  5. porkchopxpress 5 years ago

    Nice list of former players that the Tribe has given up on. The scout their current talent like they do talent prior to the Draft – poorly.

    • melonis_rex 5 years ago

      Guthrie’s actually pretty bad peripherally.

      Agree on Ludwick and Phillips though, but then, Ludwick had been on about 2-3 teams before the Indians DFAd him (A’s and Rangers, off the top of my head)

  6. cardrob 5 years ago

    It would be interesting to see who has been designated multiple times. I feel lik Livan gets designated for assignment at least twice a year.

  7. Mark P 5 years ago

    Nice compilation…I’d say Gary Matthews Jr. will be DFA’d this week if I had to guess.

  8. dickylarue 5 years ago

    Shouldn’t Carlos Pena have made this list or did I miss him?

  9. melonis_rex 5 years ago

    Wasn’t Chad Gaudin DFAd by the Cubs, which is when the Padres picked him up.

  10. Wasn’t Cody Ross DFA by the Dodgers? I believe he went to the Reds for a stint after the Dodgers needed his roster spot. He’s been pretty solid since he’s been with the Fish.

  11. thelaser69 5 years ago

    I’m pretty sure Casey McGehee was DFA’d by the Cubs 2 years ago, he’s not a star but 5th in RoY balloting deserves some credit.

  12. thelaser69 5 years ago

    I’m pretty sure Casey McGehee was DFA’d by the Cubs 2 years ago, he’s not a star but 5th in RoY balloting deserves some credit.

Leave a Reply