Roy Oswalt Rumors: Sunday

6:24pm: Nats GM Mike Rizzo will neither confirm or deny the club's interest in Oswalt, according to Adam Kilgore of the Washington Post.

Kilgore writes that even if the Nationals are interested, it is unlikely a deal could be struck between the two sides.  First, Washington would have to be willing to part with farmhands that they have worked diligently to stock.  Secondly, they would have to take on Oswalt's hefty contract. 

Finally, Oswalt would have to approve a deal to the nation's capital.  Despite the fact that the Nats appear to be contenders at present, Kilgore wonders how the 32-year-old feels about a club that has lost more than 100 games in back-to-back seasons.

12:58pm: A baseball source tells's Bill Ladson that the Nationals are interested in trading for Oswalt.

12:27pm: Roy Oswalt's trade request has inspired plenty of speculation about potential suitors for the right-hander. Here's a roundup of the latest discussion about possible trade partners for the Astros:

41 Responses to Roy Oswalt Rumors: Sunday Leave a Reply

  1. Here comes the obligatory “Ned Colletti trades away the farm” deal we’ve come to expect. Oswalt makes too much money, has injury problems, isn’t getting any younger, and isn’t needed. I’ll go to bat with Kershaw-Billingsley-Kuroda against any team, anytime.

    • jdub220 5 years ago

      Oswalt has injury problems? News to me.
      He hasn’t had a season with under 30 starts since 2003.

    • Ryan H 5 years ago

      Why does everyone continue to say he has injury problems? Besides being shutdown a bit early last year, he has been one hell of a durable pitcher.

      • Back injuries can flare up at any time.

        From Buster Olney:

        “Oswalt’s health history. He’s had back problems and has required injections in order to pitch, so there would be reason for concern about whether he could be physically able to serve out the rest of his contract.”

        • Ferrariman 5 years ago

          i stopped reading as soon as you said “FROM BUSTER OLNEY”

          • Don’t get me wrong, I’m no huge Olney fan (I’m a Keith Law man myself), but what he said is true. You think he made up that Oswalt has needed or still receives injections? Back injuries are very concerning.

          • Ryan H 5 years ago

            Oswalt has had ONE back injection at the beginning of the season and that was all he needed. It is rare that he has not made at least 30 starts and pitched at least 200 innings in a season. A one time injury is a lot different than a history of injuries or injuries problems as Buster put it.

          • Injury or not, I wouldn’t break the farm for him. Which means Colletti probably will.

          • Ryan H 5 years ago

            If the Dodgers did try and make a run for him, what kind of package do you think they should offer? In other words, what do you think Oswalt is worth in terms of your teams prospects?

          • Again, I would pass, but my personal offer would be something like James McDonald or Scott Elbert and a lower level prospect if I were to make one. But again, I would pass. The Dodgers have a ton of talent in the farm system, it’s just at the lower levels and generally a couple of years away. Still valuable though.

            I imagine the Astros want a couple of pitchers and a position player, because they have a ton of holes. Again, not saying Oswalt isn’t good, but I would stand pat. Especially considering the Divorce Drama.

    • Mickeyblue 5 years ago

      Wow never heard a Dodger fan turning down a true ace before. I think LA needs Oswalt more than he needs them either way I don’t think he would mesh well w/ the clubhouse enviornment there

  2. Brad Vance 5 years ago

    How about to the mets for Jonathan Niese, and Fernando Martinez? I know it’s not a lot, but His value isn’t what it used to be…

    • VinnyG917 5 years ago

      They are both on the DL. Both have been there before. And you’re saying Oswalt is the one with lowered value? The Mets would have to put together more prospects than that to trade for him.

  3. PDR297 5 years ago

    Back three years ago, Oswalt’s contract was considered one of the most club friendly contracts. I find it hard to imagine his value has dropped so far as to make his contract prohibitive to a trade.

    • Injuries and the economy have changed that.

      • PDR297 5 years ago

        I don’t disagree that those have lessened his value, but not to the degree that seems to be imagined. Jake Peavy traded after injury; John Lackey signed after injury; and both of them are making more money than Roy. Throw in Roy’s resurgence as a dominant pitcher (Better this year than either of those two, and a team making a trade would be looking to win now) would all point towards some above average prospects from a trade.

  4. ThinkBlue10 5 years ago

    lets hope ned isnt just talking and actually takes some action.

  5. Guest 5 years ago

    I’d love to see the Nationals land Oswalt, but it is a terrible idea. The Nats will be competing in a couple more years, there is no reason to trade whatever is in their farm for a chance to compete this year.

  6. rainyperez 5 years ago

    Hmmmm Nationals getting Oswalt is signifying they want to win now. They would be intriguing team to watch especially if the “Jesus” pitcher makes his debut. Oswalt teaching Strausburg the ins and outs of pitching is going to benefit him tremendously.

    • fitz 5 years ago

      Don’t sleep on Jordan Zimmerman either. He should be back this year and showed a lot of promise before TJ.

  7. danks50 5 years ago

    Nationals and Oswalt seems like a solid idea, a ton of arb cases next offseason but right now they have around $24 million committed to 2011. Its shouldn’t take a ton of prospects as well as the Astros should probably rebuild and I don’t see a huge market for Roy and his contract.

    • Ryan H 5 years ago

      I agree, Oswalt to Washington is interesting. Oswalt did say he wanted to be dealt to a TRUE contender and I don’t really think the Nats have proven that at this point.

  8. squadwagon6 5 years ago

    If The Nats signed Oswalt ! It would be great ! a lineup of Strasburg , Oswalt , Wang, Zimmermann , Hernandez , with Marquis and Olsen in as back up would be great ! With Storen, Clippard , and Capps in relief ! Id say We would have one hell of a pitching staff ! Lets go NATS !!

    • Ferrariman 5 years ago

      when is wang suppose to be back? im assuming post-allstar break.

    • dire straits 5 years ago

      You just started following baseball, huh?

      • Haven’t you heard? Livan is the second coming of Drysdale, and Marquis is the next Pedro. Olsen, well, he’s got Koufax written all over him, with perhaps a splash of Randy Johnson mixed in.

  9. markjsunz 5 years ago

    Oswalt would be a big help to the Dodgers pitching staff. Not so sure they want to take on his contract, but with a pitcher like Oswalt the dodgers might get to the world series.

  10. bucco_nation 5 years ago

    Trading for a Roy Oswalt is exactly what a club like the Nats SHOULD NOT do.

  11. ZeroZeroZero 5 years ago

    I dont see any team giving up a ton of kids AND taking on his $30+m owed. The Astros should be looking for one or the other.

    • souldrummer 5 years ago

      Totally agree with this. The Nationals farm system unfortunately is bottom and top heavy. The top heavy guys are mostly in the majors or close to the majors already. That would be Desmond, Storen, and soon to be Strasburg. Perhaps you put Danny Espinosa in that list.

      Basically, we are kind of screwed because of the 2006 draft of Bowden. They hyped Chris Marrero to the moon and he’s struggled in the field with his luck (losing a year to a broken leg in his second year) and now he’s struggling in AA. Were he to continue his recent hot streak (three home runs in his last 3 games) and get back on the prospect radar it would certainly help the Nats as I believe he would be someone that they are willing to move should they be confident that they are going to resign Dunn.

      Middling B- and sinking prospects just ain’t that valuable so I’m not deluding myself into thinking he’s a significant trade piece though.

  12. The bargain deal is around the corner in Seattle, where Cliff Lee awaits yet another unneccessary move. Did Seattle really think one left handed pitcher was going to solve all their problems? Lee is a prime time competitor that would probably comerelatively cheap in terms of farm talent. I like Oswalt, always have respected him toiling away in relative anonymity down there in Houston. But I believe better and more consistent results will come if they can land Lee. GO BLUE!

  13. And now, strictly editorially speaking as I bleed Dodger blue like the rest of you:
    Do any of us REALLY think that Lee or Oswalt or Hamels or any other front line SP
    is going to solve the mess the team is in? They say that winning solves a lot of problems. The team as a whole may have more problems than even winning the World Series would solve!
    i’m not sayin…i’m just sayin!

  14. aap212 5 years ago

    Not if the Mets take all his salary.

  15. aap212 5 years ago

    I’m guessing you’re wrong. Especially if a third, less substantial player was added. That salary’s going to be really, really difficult to move. Martinez and Niese is better than what the Padres got for Peavy’s whole salary. But Martinez is probably an ill fit for the Astros anyway, since they won’t move Pence and can’t move Lee.

  16. Colletti has a history of overpaying, why wouldn’t the Astros look to make that happen again? And I highly doubt they take two B prospects.

  17. thegrayrace 5 years ago

    Agreed. I’m a Dodger fan, but the farm system is looking pretty pathetic. The guys that were supposed to be our top pitching prospects (Lindblom, Withrow, E. Martin, Eovaldi, Elbert, McDonald) are all putting up either mediocre or downright terrible numbers in the minors.

    Though there are some nice surprises among other minor league arms. Jansen in AA and Webster in LoA are pitching great. And on the offensive end Russell and Sands have been crushing the ball (Lambo, unfortunately, is suspended for drug use).

    Gordon and Jansen are probably our most valuable prospects right now, and who aside from Dodger fans have heard of either? Not many.

  18. souldrummer 5 years ago

    Wang is not even close to picking up a rehab start yet. Detwiler is the next arm of the inventory hopes for this year (Detwiler, Wang, Zimmermann starting in relief) that will start rehab, probably in the next 2-4 weeks. Wang probably won’t start rehab until late June at the earliest, probably more like July and really seems to be someone who isn’t that likely to help the Nats this year. I’m hoping that Marquis remains 6 weeks away from returning to help the Nats year. I felt that was a good process, bad results kind of outcome that has been mostly offset by the good(lucky?) work of Livo so far and the gutsy/lucky performance of Luis Atilano who has done serviceable work in his starts with better peripherals but worse results than Craig Stammen.

    Zimmermann remains the wild card in this scenario. They’ve pretty much talked about limiting him to relief as he comes back from Tommy John. On the other hand, they’ve supposedly said that he’s ahead of schedule and it would be intriguing to see what kind of role he takes if he’s 75-90% of the pitcher he was come say August.

  19. thegrayrace 5 years ago

    Lambo is suspended for drug use and E. Martin hasn’t been pitching that great. Hu is a marginal prospect. Unfortunately McDonald, Elbert, Withrow, Lindblom and Eovaldi are putting up mediocre numbers right now, too.

    DeJesus, Jr. and Gordon are probably the only guys you listed with any value. John Ely, Xavier Paul, and Kenley Janson would also have some trade value. I suspect the Dodgers would have to part with 3 or 4 of them to get Oswalt.

  20. We can’t afford to trade Gordon, he’s our SS of the future. McDonald had a fingernail injury if I recall, but he’s healthy last I checked.

Leave a Reply