James Shields Rumors: Saturday

With Zack Greinke and Cole Hamels off the market, clubs could turn to Rays right-hander James Shields for pitching help at the trade deadline. The 30-year-old owns a 4.52 ERA this year but finished third in the Cy Young Award voting just last season. There are club options for 2013 ($9MM) and 2014 ($12MM) in his contract, so Shields offers a ton of flexibility. Here are today's rumors on Tampa's Opening Day starter, with the latest up top…

  • The Cardinals also have interest in Shields according to Jon Heyman of CBSSports.com. He says the Rays seek a package "north of Greinke" in return.
  • Rival executives believe more and more that the Rays will trade Shields prior to the deadline according to ESPN's Buster Olney (on Twitter).
  • The Braves, Dodgers, Indians, and Rangers are among the clubs with the most interest in Shields, according to Marc Topkin of The Tampa Bay Times. The Angels had interest but are presumably out of the running after acquiring Greinke.

43 Responses to James Shields Rumors: Saturday Leave a Reply

  1. mark hampton 3 years ago

    I don’t know why the Braves name even gets mentioned, if he costs over $5.00 we won’t go after him.

    • Alex Sanchez 3 years ago

      5 bucks? So that means that we won’t be going after anyone? Shucks.

      • elijah82 3 years ago

        Well you did get Miguel Bautista….

        • Jwick22 3 years ago

          he said over 5 bucks.

          • elijah82 3 years ago

            Right. My bad.

          • Jwick22 3 years ago

            all jokes aside(i guess) if the rays would take a realistic package for shields i wouldnt be a bit upset if he came to the braves. i think pitching in the n.l. then with quiet a few division games left he would do fine. i dont want to get ahead of things but big ben is looking great so if he holds up, and huddy keeps going strong a front three of shields,sheets and hudson is not so bad. with any luck uggla starts hitting home runs(dont expect his average to do much) and getting simmons back will be a pretty good line up to compete in the playoffs

          • NL_East_Rivalry 3 years ago

            Braves have the 2nd best RS in the NL, ignoring Colorado of course. Their line-up has been good all season, even with streaky hitters and injuries. Braves really need 3 guys they can trust in the post-season and I don’t know how they evaluate Hanson right now.

    • rundmc1981 3 years ago

      We have the prospects to deal for a big name and the money to extend the right headliner. Why wouldn’t every name be tied to that?

  2. elijah82 3 years ago

    Shields is no ace, but the Rays are probably going to want an ace-like haul in return. The Rays will be in no hurry to part with Shields either, as they are still very much in the WC race and have two years of team control left over Shields. With Greinke off the market, Shields market price just went up a bit too. All in all, I don’t think Shields is going to be worth the haul that will be needed to get him.

    • Alex Sanchez 3 years ago

      Agreed. If I was a betting man, I would bet that Shields, Garza and Johnson all stay put. Then teams will have to rely on the Liriano’s of the world.

      • NL_East_Rivalry 3 years ago

        Although this doesn’t go against your that guys argument, don’t you think the AL WC Race is too tight to ignore a decent haul for a spot that isn’t a top priority. Rays may be able to get a lot for Shields now, but next year, might not be as much unless he pitches Dempster like. Then again the Rays love to keep their arms, just look what happened to the Braves this year.

    • JohnPaulP 3 years ago

      I’d agree Shields doesn’t have the upside of Cole Hamels or Zack Greinke, but with two years of control at a good price for what he should give you, I could see him being even more valuable than either of those two in terms of what he should bring back. Get Shields for the rest of this year plus his age 31+32 seasons and let him walk or get Greinke, hope for a deep playoff run and let him walk or pay him $100m+…And now that trading teams can’t even get draft compensation for guys like Greinke, I’d be surprised if GM’s didn’t think Shields value of a rental ace. (I know Greinke was already traded, just using his name as an example.)

  3. NYBravosFan10 3 years ago

    I think Shields would be a great addition. The guy has put up solid numbers pitching in the AL East. Imagine what he could do in a less stressful division. Go for it Frank!!!

    • Jwick22 3 years ago

      i second that motion

    • rundmc1981 3 years ago

      Ain’t worth the price. Shields is great when he’s good, but terrible when he’s bad. When you pay some of these this much – he’s not making a massive amount – you pay for consistency, and he’s not that. AL East or NL East. I don’t subscribe to the theory that he’ll be that much better whatever division he plays in.

      • Tribe/Cavs/Browns fan 3 years ago

        I think he could be a top of the line starter in the N.L. In the A.L. though, he’s not going to be any better than he is right now. Just take a look at the back of his baseball card and you will find out that last season was a career year.

  4. sportsnut969 3 years ago

    The indians are not a match they lack the pieces to make a deal happen IMHO they will not trade Lindor / Howard or Barnes their #1 – 3 guys and view Aguilar / Colan and Paulino as untouchable at the lower levels so I just see the indians running in place for the next 3 to 4 seasons continuing to sign the Damons / Duncans / Kotchman and Hannahans of the world while they waiting on the next wave of Prospects to make it to the majors so I do not view the Indians a real threat to the Central until that happens.

    Choo and Chris Perez both go to Arby again and could at least double their salary this offseason thus coming close to pricing themselves out of the Cleveland market so both could either be dealt by the deadline or in the offseason. JMHO

    Another Indians rebuild is on the horizan.

  5. GoSox2012 3 years ago

    Why aren’t the White Sox after this guy? A deal like this could happen.

    Chicago gets:
    Shields and Rodney

    Tampa gets:

    Reed, Nestor Molina(#1 prospect), Nate Jones, Jaredd Mitchell and Phil Humber.

    • Dynasty22 3 years ago

      I doubt they would trade Rodney when he has a cheap option left.

    • diesel2410 3 years ago

      Rodney? Urrrrhmmmm no. You give us Sale then

    • Tribe/Cavs/Browns fan 3 years ago

      No way the Rays would do that.

    • Being number one prospect for the White Sox isn’t really a ringing endorsement. The Rays aren’t going to trade Shields for a good young reliever and a pupu platter of spare parts, let alone throw in Rodney when his value is peaking.

    • I’m guessing the Rays can do better than that

      • Mauck98 3 years ago

        my guess is to the Braves it would start with Randall Delgado, Joey Terdoslavich, Jose Peraza, and a low level prospect. Rays get 5 years of cost controlled Delgado, a switch hitting 1B in Terdoslavich, a SS prospect in Peraza, and someone else that can develop. Exactly the kind of deal that Friedman makes.

    • the_show 3 years ago

      We aren’t trading Reed he has a chance to an All Star type closer

      • Really? THAT’S your takeaway? That you wouldn’t trade a young reliever for a starter under team control?

  6. Jay212033 3 years ago

    LOL a package “just north” of the Greinke deal for a guy who’s nowhere close to Greinke talent wise. This market is outrageous!

    • Shields has more years of control below market rate. If you trade for Greinke, you don’t even get a draft pick at the end of the year. While Greinke is a better pitcher, Shields is a much, much more valuable commodity.

  7. Christian Hamby 3 years ago

    The Rays will get what they ask for Shields or nobody is getting him. No GM is going to persuade Friedman to do anything, the guy is one of the best in the business.

    • Joey Grimes 3 years ago

      If the Rangers want to dance how about a straight up Shields for Profar trade?

  8. J Walls625 3 years ago

    Would love a deal with the Cardinals. Get Shields out of the AL and get a good return of prospects back.

  9. California_RedBirds 3 years ago

    I think a trade for Shields would work out for the Cards. He’d be a decent add for the rotation and it could also open up an opportunity to move either Lynn or Kelly to the pen. That would knock out two birds with one stone. I think the Cards have the prospects to get a deal done but hopefully they won’t have to pay too high to get Complete Game James

  10. stl_cards16 3 years ago

    I’m not as confident in the pitching. Lynn is wearing down and Kelly has been okay as a rotation filler. Shields would not only be a clear upgrade for the rest of this season, he would be back next year. Wainwright, Lynn, and Garcia are the only 3 locks for the rotation after this season. Add shields into that group and it’s a very good staff.

  11. J Walls625 3 years ago

    You’re saying the Cards couldn’t do a deal around a guy like Matt Adams, who is being blocked by Carpenter, Craig, and Berkman? Of course it would take more than just Adams, but he would be a nice starting point seeing a the Rays need a bat with power and they need a 1B.

  12. The NL definitely has more bad offenses.

  13. Over the past 3 years, James Shields has started over 30 percent of his games against the top 2 offenses in MLB. How do you think he wouldn’t pitch better going up against weaker hitting teams and facing pitchers instead of DHs?

  14. Shields has a 4.29 ERA in 26 career starts against NL teams. Take out the weaker teams, and he has a 5.652 ERA against mid to upper NL teams in 18 games. I would not say that is an improvement at all.

  15. California_RedBirds 3 years ago

    Trading Matt Adams plus one of the arms you mentioned would be a huge over-pay. Miller, Martinez, Rosenthal and Jenkins are all of St. Louis top pitching prospects and Adams is one of their top hitting prospects. I dont see Mo doing a deal like that. Maybe Adams and and a lower tier prospect for example

  16. Andy_B 3 years ago

    Long term Taveras projects as the right fielder, craig can play first which would leave Adams without a spot.

    Adams, Jenkins, and Cox seems like a decent package for Shields

  17. Kendall Adkins 3 years ago

    I don’t see Adams having a future with the Cardinals. Allen Craig is most likely the 1B of the future and Tavares will be the RF. Also, Zach Cox will be blocked for a while by Freese who is already backed up by Carpenter and Descalso. I’d go for Adams and Cox for Shields. Then your rotation next year sets up as Wainwright, Shields, Carpenter, Garcia, and Lynn.

  18. A #2 is exactly what he is and with his current contract is a steal really for any team especially in the National league.

  19. Andy_B 3 years ago

    If I were to forecast St Louis’s rotation in 2014 I would say it would be


    Jenkins has the ceiling of a number 2 starter but he is far from a guarantee. Shields for him and Adams seems pretty fair.

  20. California_RedBirds 3 years ago

    I don’t think it matters what the rotation looks like for the #4-5 spots. Having both Rosenthal and Miller in the rotation would be legit. The Cardinals are so stacked with pitching that it could very well be possible that pitchers like Jenkins, Martinez and Wacha could be destined for the bullpen because of the full rotation. Because of Martinez’s size, he could be moved to the bullpen which actually wouldn’t be a terrible idea. His arm is beyond electric and he could benefit pitching in the bullpen cuz it would allow him to throw his 98-99 MPH fastball multiple times to get the K. Just a thought.

Leave a Reply