When the Rays signed Ha-Seong Kim to a two-year, $29MM contract in February, they knew he wouldn’t be ready to play by Opening Day. The question was how much time he would miss. Kim underwent shoulder surgery in October. At the time, the infielder suggested he could potentially return to the field by mid-to-late April or early May. His agent, Scott Boras, made similar comments. On the other end of the spectrum, Padres president of baseball operations A.J. Preller told reporters that Kim’s return could fall anywhere between May and July. It now seems as if the POBO from Kim’s former team was correct to be less optimistic. According to Marc Topkin of the Tampa Bay Times, the timeline for Kim’s return to full-time shortstop duties has been “pushed back” to the “mid-June/mid-July range.”
This isn’t necessarily a sign that Kim has suffered a setback. On the contrary, Topkin reports that Kim is doing quite well in his recovery; in some ways, he is apparently “ahead of schedule.” Yet, the Rays are exercising the utmost caution after what manager Kevin Cash described as a “major surgery.” Both Cash and POBO Erik Neander brought up the rigors of playing shortstop as a reason not to rush Kim’s rehab. Notably, Neander did not seem particularly open, at least not yet, to the possibility of Kim returning sooner to play a less physically demanding position. Kim has played 127 games at second base in his MLB career, including 106 appearances at the keystone in 2023, the year he won his Gold Glove. However, Neander told Topkin that the team is not ready to consider Kim playing any position other than shortstop – although he didn’t shut down the idea entirely. Perhaps playing second would indeed help Kim get back on the field, but Neander’s position isn’t unreasonable. Kim’s strong defense at a premium position (i.e. shortstop) was surely something that drew the Rays to him in the first place. What’s more, Tampa Bay already has Brandon Lowe to play second base. As things stand, the only clear opening for Kim on this team is at shortstop.
Kim’s player option for 2026 could be another factor influencing the team’s decision to play it safe with his recovery. His $16MM option would represent a $3MM raise from his current $13MM salary. It would also be the highest single-season base salary the Rays have ever paid a player. It might sound cynical, but one has to wonder if the close-fisted Rays were counting on Kim opting out of his contract after year one. As the name suggests, player options are always player-friendly, which means, in theory, that teams never hope a player will exercise his player option when they include one in a contract. In this case, however, Neander might feel a particular pressure to ensure that Kim plays well enough in 2025 that he doesn’t opt in to what would be a record salary. If Kim returns too quickly and struggles to perform (or suffers another injury), the chances of him exercising his player option would grow. Conversely, if he comes back at full strength and thrives in the second half, that might encourage him to give free agency another go.
In Kim’s absence, Taylor Walls was Tampa Bay’s primary shortstop to start the season. However, Walls has struggled even more than usual at the plate (.415 OPS, 31 wRC+), leading to the red-hot José Caballero seeing more time at shortstop in recent days. There is little doubt the Rays would be better off with Kim in the starting lineup – Caballero’s hot hitting isn’t sustainable, and he’s better suited for a part-time, utility role – but Caballero and Walls give the Rays options while Kim is out. Carson Williams, the consensus top prospect in the organization, is another shortstop to keep in mind. That said, he’s not yet 22, and he’s currently struggling offensively at Triple-A. While he could debut later this year, no call-up is imminent. For now, expect the Rays to stick with Caballero and Walls unless Williams forces the issue.
