MLB Rumors - MLB Trade Rumors
Subscribe to MLB Trade Rumors using RSS
Home     Contact     About     Advertise     Archives     Widget     Twitter      RSS Usage

« Pirates Release Chris Snelling | Main | Dodgers Looking For A Reliever »

Mets, Braves Swap Church For Francoeur

6:07pm: Hubbuch clears up some confusion: the Braves are sending the Mets cash in the deal. That makes more sense given the difference in salaries.

5:48pm: Adam Rubin of The NY Daily News reports that Braves also received cash in the deal. Church is making $2.8MM this year, his second arbitration eligible season. Francoeur is making $3.375MM in his first arbitration eligible year.

5:04pm: Hubbuch says the deal was straight up, one for one.

5:01pm: David Lennon tweets that Church was traded to Atlanta for Jeff Francoeur. Francoeur has put up a .250-.282-.352 batting line in 324 plate appearances in 2009.

5:00pm: Bart Hubbuch of The NY Post tweets that the Ryan Church has "apparently been traded." Church is hitting .280-.332-.375 in 255 plate appearances this season, and has been playing centerfield recently while Carlos Beltran is the DL. 


Comments

odd trade

being rid of jeff should make some braves fans really happy

Good move Omar!

Oh my! Oh my!

WHY? Wren needs to be fired, NOW.

Absoluty makes no sense. Church is the left handed version of frenchy and the braves need a RIGHT HANDED BAT!!!!! what in the hell is frank wren thinking??? And he sends him to a divisional rival. Absolutly no sense.

What is Omar thinking? In Francouer's last 2,196 ABs, he has an OPS+ of 88. He had a good rookie year, and THAT'S IT.

Unreal.

Church is having a down year, but he's still a better hitter than Francouer. Oh, and he plays center field, something the Mets are kind of lacking right now.

Mets easily got the better of this deal in my opinion

WHY? Wren needs to be fired, NOW.

Posted by: BravesRed | July 10, 2009 at 05:04 PM
------------

Ummmm.....because he sucks and you guys have been offering him to any and all takers?

Today must be the day for acquiring sub .300 OBP ballplayers to improve your ball club.

Who cares to predict the next one to go?

HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAlleluja

why would you send a guy to a division rival???? if he turns it around which we all know is possible it could haunt us for years. And why bring in another left handed bat???? The only thing i can think of is the fact that church's contract is up at the end of the year so we dont have frenchys contract hanging over us the next couple years so i like that part but i can find much else that i like with it.

I don't care if we have been offering him for anyone. We get another left handed bat, with 2 homeruns. What the heck Wren!

That's it. I defended Omar Minaya a lot. But this is it. I am joining the Fire Omar Minaya bandwagon. This is a completely dumb move. Francoeur was a non-tender candidate.

NNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Genius for Wren. He makes his team better, and the Mets worse.

Wow some of you are crazy. Doesn't matter who you send Jeff to, the man can't hit a beach ball. And if he gets lucky and does hit it, it's bound to be a short dribbler to the pitcher. Good riddance! Plus if anything, Church can be packaged up for something else. He obviously has more trade value.

In a place where he's happy to play and knows his name will be in the lineup everyday I could see Church putting up a solid .280/.350 line with 30-40 extra basehits.

good god, frenchy had 3 doubles last night and it might have been a sign of new hope. Church has no power, is a downgrade on defense, is left handed, and is 5 years older. MAkes no sense.

Good gracious hallelujah. Someone actually took Jeff Francoeur. I'd take Ryan Church over Jeff Francoeur every day of the week and twice on Sunday. Good job Wren, idk why Braves fan are so upset with this trade. All I've seen out of Brave sfans is bitching and moaning about how bad Frenchy is and then when he's actually traded for a BETTER player, they quesiton it. Ryan Church was abou thte best player you could hope to get with Jeff Francoeur.

The only interesting thing about this is Church can be packaged with KJ or medlen while frenchy had no value in a package. Mabie theyll package church, and KJ for freddy sanchez

Mets lose on this trade. Francoeur is not that great and Church is a very consistent Ballplayer who has really shone in NY due to the ability to actually get playing time (somethign he didnt really get when he was wiht the nationals).

"He obviously has more trade value.

Posted by: BraveNewWorld | July 10, 2009 at 05:13 PM"

Then why were they traded straight up for each other?

Yes!!! Way to go Frank Wren! I dont care if we did get another left handed bat he will prolly platoon with Diaz in right and Anderson will play full time in left!

terrible deal for the mets.

if you dont think this move makes sense for the braves, you havent been watching the braves for the past 2 years. great move. church will play well in atlanta. finally, some real production in right field.

"good god, frenchy had 3 doubles last night and it might have been a sign of new hope. "

Doesn't sound like you've been following the Braves too closely the last couple years. Frenchy is the king of showing signs of new hope without ever delivering.

DUDEs, this means that the braves will have 7 left handed bats in their lineup. Chipper (against right) kotchman anderson KJ(when back) mclouth mccan and now church

Doesn't sound like you've been following the Braves too closely the last couple years. Frenchy is the king of showing signs of new hope without ever delivering.

Posted by: sunking1056 | July 10, 2009 at 05:18 PM

Said "might" now was

Why the hell would Minaya make this deal??? It makes absolutely no sense for the Mets. Don't get me wrong, Church is average at best in right, but this just seems like a move indicating the Mets are looking to sell more than play for this year.

Haha, Minaya is really awful. Church is bad but he's leagues better than Francouer.

I wouldn't want either guy but if I had to pick, definitely prefer Church. Francouer has a hitch in his swing reminiscent of a slow pitch softball player and has a 5% career walk rate.

Church has talent but never put it together....at least he can draw a walk and has some pop, and was actually playing a decent CF for a couple weeks recently

Brent, I would bet you that we don't see KJ, Kotchman or maybe even Church on this team next year. I like Kotchman, but he's expendable. KJ can stay on the DL for as long as he wants for all I care.

Braves Just Dumped some salery. And i do believe that right now Church has more Value...being a left handed bat hurts the trade but church can play all over the place. Frency does have an amazing upside, Like ardruw if you can correct his swing..he would be great. Honestly I think Frenchy will end up playing everyday in right and church will packaged together with someone else to get a better right fielder. I do like this because it means Diaz is gonna get more starts in right...thats what most excites me

Worth noting: Church is hitting .326/.359/.444 this year in ballparks not named Citi Field.

Partly Manuel's doing? I never really believed he didn't have with Church.

Was Francouer a Super 2? If not they basically have the same contract status right (both in 1st year of arb)?

Steal for the Braves. Absolute steal.

Church is much, much better defensively than Frenchy. Although his bat is mediocre, he's still much better with the glove.

He's been worth about a whole win more than Frenchy has this season. Holy crap Omar just made a division rival better.

you guys think they could package him up in a deal for sanchez?? Or, the braves could put church and kotchman together for Laroche in Pittsburg.

The braves didn't dump much salary...they save about 200,000 for the rest of the season.

Not really sure why some of you Braves fans are a little worried about the divisional rival thing..

Jeff Francouer isn't really a good hitter. And if he does turn it around and plays better.. he probably isn't good enough to swing the balance of power. Didn't he post a sub-.300 OBP in his best season?

Aren't the Braves in 4th place? You have more than just the Mets and Jeff Francouer to worry about. Just hope Ryan Church can hit like he did last year before the Metropolitans and their cracker-jack medical staff let him fly and then play with a concussion.

Good news is that Francouer's gone (thanks Mutts), but the bad news is that they got ANOTHER left handed bat in place of him (and a pretty average one at that)


As happy as I am that he's gone, I just can't help but think about the possibility that Francouer actually turns it around and helps the Mets make the playoffs.

*shudders* I really wish Wren would've traded him to an AL team.

The only thing we lose with Francouer is a very very strong arm and a bunch of headaches. At first I wondered and then I realized that Church is better. He has 2 homers but he plays in a horrible hitters park. I'll take a batter with about the same power as Francouer but he hits about 30 to 40 points higher. Not to mention it adds about 3 or 4 million to our offseason spending for 2010.

Surely the Mets will option Francoeur to AAA, right?

with power, the braves are in 3rd with the mets behind them

I don't understand why the braves traded for someone with fewer hr's when we desperately need a power bat.wren needs to be fired now

Church does have a lot more range but Francouer is 34 runs above average with his arm career, so doesn't that sort of bridge the gap defensively?

Wasn't Jeff a fan-favorite though?

pwjhort has the best point in this whole thing so far. Church was putting up better numbers while playing in a park the you have to hit 430 feet to get it out. I really hope church can come here and do something i just really think that this might have been a move to make another move but thats just me

The only thing we lose with Francouer is a very very strong arm and a bunch of headaches. At first I wondered and then I realized that Church is better. He has 2 homers but he plays in a horrible hitters park. I'll take a batter with about the same power as Francouer but he hits about 30 to 40 points higher. Not to mention it adds about 3 or 4 million to our offseason spending for 2010.

Posted by: james | July 10, 2009 at 05:28 PM

Church is an arbitration eligible player just like Frenchy. They're not really saving anything unless they DFA him, which they could have done with Frenchy. That said, great trade for Wren.

Brent: I hope you meant Andy LaRoche. The Adam experiment failed and he is not welcome back.

Bravesfan44: Are you comparing Church's 2 homeruns this year in less games to Francoeur's whopping 5???

NO all the fans know frenchy sucks and are happy to see him go, But all the fans(including myself) wanted to see him leave but were overpricing him. I have changed my mind and i think this is the best player wren could have gotten for frenchy

yeah I forgot church's contract is up at the end of the year. frency still had one more year. The more I think about it. The braves might be doing something smart here. Because even if they do sign Church again he isn't gonna get anywhere near 2.8 next year...so that unloads like 3-4 mil next year too..

You realize the Braves have hit .275/.342/.405 vs LHP but only .242/.327/.392 vs RHP this year, right? Oh no, not a left-handed bat! Dude, Church isn't a free out, and that's a huge upgrade over Francoeur. Braves fans, rejoice.

Two gross displays of complete lack of understanding of OBP and defense by GMs in one day? Two release-worthy players traded for value in one day?

This is hilarious. Can't wait to see which DFA candidate is moved next.

someone just say frency is 34 years old? Cause im pretty sure he is only 26-27 maybe...

Neither of the contracts are up at the end of the year unless each team decides to non tender them. Each is controllable with arb through 2011 I think

Brent: I hope you meant Andy LaRoche. The Adam experiment failed and he is not welcome back.

Braves fan, that was 3 years ago, who said he was not welcome back, and even if it failed, he is way better on offecnse now than he was then. YOu are stupid

What is Wren thinking ? Trading within the division ?...Church is 6 years older, left handed and a much weaker arm than Frenchy . We needed to trade Frenchy , but my god !

This just an add trade to me. I'll take your junk if you take my junk I guess? If Wren was looking to do that I'd rather he done the same deal with the Twins for Delmon Young. While Church is better than Young at the moment, Young is a lot, well, younger and has a lot more potential upside.

As a Braves fan I'm not upset about the deal, but I'd be lying if I said I understood it.

Great. Now winning the division for the 3rd year in a row just got that much tougher. This idea of the Phils getting Halladay will be fruitless if it gets done. Both the Mets & Braves just separated themselves from Philly and the Fish.

god i hate twitter

I don't think they're trading to make Church a starting outfielder. I believe the Braves new OF is Anderson-McLouth-Diaz, with Church as the superutility outfielder.

I dont get why everyone is getting all worked up, these are two bad players that will have little impact. However, i do think frenchy has a lot more potential. Now if the cards could just get someone to take ankiel and duncan off of our hands.

LaRoach hit 29 hr's for the braves like the year before he was traded?? I don't think he failed we just precieved value in getting Gonzo in the trade...

yeah I forgot church's contract is up at the end of the year. frency still had one more year. The more I think about it. The braves might be doing something smart here. Because even if they do sign Church again he isn't gonna get anywhere near 2.8 next year...so that unloads like 3-4 mil next year too..

Posted by: Bravesfan13 | July 10, 2009 at 05:32 PM

Church's contarct is up, as is Frenchy's. They are both arb eligible, and Church will definately get at least 2.8 million again in arbitration(who ever stays healthy and gets a pay cut?). There really isn't much difference in the contract situations.

They should platoon Anderson and Diaz in left honestly and keep Church in right for his D, but they will probably do the opposite and platoon Church and Diaz

Timetheus... I agree with you. So i liek it now. Diaz deserves a strating job. He can tear it up. Reminds me of Pete rose without as much skill. Great upside without the gambling haha

"Today must be the day for acquiring sub .300 OBP ballplayers to improve your ball club.

Who cares to predict the next one to go?"

Orlando Cabrera or Bobby Crosby. Or both. Please.

DOB says the Braves are sending some cash as well. Probably to even out the slight different in salary

Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy. Trade francouer he jus had 3 hits for the braves last night.
church is not the hitter we need in right field. Please trade for someone like holliday ro hawpe. we need people like them not cheap opitions we need real help.

Brent, it shows how much little you know about baseball. Adam's best years were with the Braves. Look at this stats now. On the decline buddy. Not to mention he was an idiot on the field at times. We have a better first baseman right now despite the fewer homerun numbers. Please, don't talk about acquiring LaRoche again and expect the rest of us to take it seriously. The Braves already got Pittsburgh's best player earlier in the year.

I'm personally happy for Jeff, as a childhood teammate of his. I hope getting out of ATL will ease some of the ungodly pressure he had on him.

It's gonna be bizarre rooting for a Met, though.

Braves fans are complaining about getting a right fielder with 50 points of OBP over their old one? Guh??

Wow, people need to look at Church's home park before calling him terrible. Citi field is an offensive black hole, but away from there, he has a .326/.359/.444 line and at Citi it is .216/.297/.278. If he has that away line for the rest of the year then this is a huge win for the Braves. And I assume he'll be almost exclusively platooned with Diaz, so he should make for a very impressive platoon player.

Brent: I hope you meant Andy LaRoche. The Adam experiment failed and he is not welcome back.

Bravesfan44: Are you comparing Church's 2 homeruns this year in less games to Francoeur's whopping 5???

Posted by: BraveNewWorld | July 10, 2009 at 05:32 PM

Brent, it shows how much little you know about baseball. Adam's best years were with the Braves. Look at this stats now. On the decline buddy. Not to mention he was an idiot on the field at times. We have a better first baseman right now despite the fewer homerun numbers. Please, don't talk about acquiring LaRoche again and expect the rest of us to take it seriously. The Braves already got Pittsburgh's best player earlier in the year.

Posted by: BraveNewWorld | July 10, 2009 at 05:39 PM


Ok, you said the Adam Laroche experiment failed, but now your saying his best years were with ATL. I think your the one that knows nothing about anything.

why dont the braves try to get fox from the cubs and play him at 1B. He can rake and his right handed. Would the cubs want too much for him?

in the offseason I had a nice little discussion about comparing Werth and Church with some Mets fans.

I'm feeling more vindicated in that discussion today with Jayson's addition to the all star roster while church has been traded.

Kemp has reason to complain about getting snubbed but only to Broxton for giving up that mammoth HR to Stairs

Lol braves got money too

http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/mets/2009/07/mets-trade-church-to-braves-la.html

Posted by: Braddd | July 10, 2009 at 05:42 PM

Just about every other report is saying it's the Braves who sent cash to the Mets...

Braves need to package Church and another player like CK or KJ for LaRoache.

Just wanted to say, I don't mind if you call me UnbiasedYankee, unbiased, or UY. But, if you want to know my name, it's Jon(athan).

I happen to enjoy watching the Mets, just so you know. This is a dumb bum move by Omar. Where are Moore and Omar getting these drugs? Willie Wison and Lenny Dykstra?

Both were having bad years but Francoeur is having even worse one, if that's possible...

Jeff Francoeur: 68 OPS+. I think Willis, Zambrano, and Sabathia can all hit better than this, personally. Scary thing? His BABIP is at .289. Not to mention, is LD% is down 2.3% from last year (from 20.7% to 18.4%). Ironically, his walk percentage is down the exact same amount- 2.3% (6.1% to 3.8%). In defense of Jeff, though, Church's LD% and BB% have fallen EVEN FURTHER from last year. Not to say Church hasn't tried to be disciplined, though. His Swing % is down 3.0% this year, from 46.5 to 43.5, while Frenchy's has increased for the 3rd straight year, at 58% this year... wow.

Ryan Church: 88 OPS+. Pretty good, not great. This OPS(+), .880, is a difference of .173 than his current OPS, a very noticable difference. Church's BABIP, while noticable higher (.325), happens to be LESS than his career average, .332.

Why are these guys getting jobs when we know we could do it fully better (for instance, I fully nominate scribbletone to have Jim Hendry's job)? When did Omar EVER have success as the Expos GM? NEVER. He was the brilliant mind that made the Pedro trade happen...

My prediction for the next sub .300 OBP player (For the record, Church had an OBP of .332, coming into today) to be moved today is TPJ, via the DFA, to make room for the recently aquired Betancourt That was ANOTHER steal from Big Jack Z, out west. Jack in Black, with his dark horse moves, strikes again.

I'm go post these thoughts to my new blog. So I don't spam here, I'll just say it's at the mlbblogs page, and it deals with sabermetrics in the title. If this is spamming, though, I'm sorry. If you want the page, give me your e-mail.

Hahahahahaha, NO WAY MAN! Well, we got rid of Frenchy, now atch him burn us! JK.

braves4life...Shut up you are no longer allowed to speak. That qualifies as the dumbest thing I have heard today.

LOL Brent you crack me up. It failed because his production is steadily declining! The dude peaked in the 3rd season of his career. It's been downhill ever since.

Braves need to package Church and another player like CK or KJ for LaRoache.

Posted by: braves4life | July 10, 2009 at 05:46 PM

Or, the braves could put church and kotchman together for Laroche in Pittsburg.

Posted by: BrentWt34 | July 10, 2009 at 05:25 PM

I already suggested that. So im not the only one that thinks thats a good deal BRAVESNEWWORLD

By itself this is a trade that amounts to whole lot of NOTHING. Neither player has contributed in 09 in a meaningful way. Both are disappointments with the possibility of being LA at best. This trade will NOT shift the balance of power for either team.

The only thing I can think of is that either the Braves or the Mets have another deal coming down the pike. If this is just a swap then meh. Trade is a wash of mediocre players.

And hey, Churh ain't half bad. And Jeff, well he NEEDS a change of scenery, so it's okay for both teams.

Francoeur and Church are pretty close to even in ML service time, with Church having about 75 more days in the bigs than Francoeur. Both are under team control (arb-eligible) for two more seasons.

Francoeur's numbers from his BEST season (2007) look a lot like Church's career AVERAGE numbers (I'm talking about BA/OBP/SLG/OPS).

Francoeur currently makes about $575,000 more than Church.

On paper, this looks like a great deal for the Braves, and I'm happy about that. Church is a better player right now.

We should remember, though, that Church is almost 31 and injury-prone, and that Francoeur just turned 25 and hardly ever misses a game.

Jeff is a good guy with plenty of upside in him, and for his sake I hope a change of scenery is what it takes for him to get rolling.

Bravesfan13....Sorry, didn't know you were sleeping with Casey Kotchman.

BrentWt34....ur dumb too. catch the drift?

how is that dumb, if they package kotchman and church for laroche, laroche is almost as good with the glove and has better power numbers(which the despretely need) and diaz is going to play everday in right not church, so blanco can fil in the utility outfielder. HOw is that dumb?

haha nice....YEah lets give two people up for less of what we had in the first place? Kotchman is much better. although im not as u put it "sleeping" with him....clever though. Just saying Kotchman hasn't made any errors in a year. He ups his stats when Bobby plays him in the correct spot in the lineup...2nd or 8th...and he is a leader. I wouldn't mind trading him away somewhere...oh and KJ can't be traded umm becuase he is hurt...so fail there too.

Guess it doesn't matter...Church will only be here the rest of the season. I'll find it hard to believe if the Braves offer him arb. next year.

Absolute win for the Braves.

Adam Laroche's Stats in MLB

2004 ATL 110 324 45 90 158 27 1 13 45 27 1 78 0 0 .278 .333 .488 .821 1.24 1 144
2005 ATL 141 451 53 117 205 28 0 20 78 39 7 87 0 2 .259 .320 .455 .775 1.20 1 144
2006 ATL 149 492 89 140 276 38 1 32 90 55 5 128 0 2 .285 .354 .561 .915 1.04 1 144
2007 PIT 152 563 71 153 258 42 0 21 88 62 5 131 1 1 .272 .345 .458 .803 0.77 1 134
2008 PIT 136 492 66 133 246 32 3 25 85 54 7 122 1 1 .270 .341 .500 .841 0.90 1 134
2009 PIT 79 293 45 76 136 22 1 12 39 40 6 72 2 2 .259 .345 .464 .809 1.07 1 134
CAREER 767 2615 369 709 1279 189 6 123 425 277 31 618 4 8 .271 .340 .489 .829 1.00
Game Log
Splits
Batter vs. Pitcher
Hitter Chart


numbers are almost the same except for his down year this year(because hes unhappy in a pirates uny

Laroach is no where near what Kasey is on the Diamond. not only does he make like no errors. he doesn't make mental errors anywhere. And LaRoach not only is Streaky but he is an oaf with little to no baseball intuition...

Guess it doesn't matter...Church will only be here the rest of the season. I'll find it hard to believe if the Braves offer him arb. next year.

Posted by: braves4life | July 10, 2009 at 05:56 PM

They'd be crazy not to...he's probably going to max out at about 4 million, he's definately worth that. Church is alot better player than alot of posters are giving him credit for.

"Adam Rubin of The NY Daily News reports that Braves also received cash in the deal."

Incorrect, yahoo sports and ajc are saying that money was sent to the Mets. Heyman also confirmed the report.

2 starters for LaRoche now?? Are you two related or something?? Forget about Adam. He will not don the Braves colors again. God just the thought of his looping swing and a miss and his emotionless demeanor out there make me angry.

Seriously, you want to replace a LH bat with another one?? Our problems are in the Outfield, not at 1st. I bet you two want Andruw back as well. Hey, Giles is still a FA ya know....

1 2 3 Next »

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment


Top Stories



Search MLBTR

Lijit Search

MLBTR Features



Recent Posts


MLBTR Mailing List

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Rumors By Team



Monthly Archives


Live Chats


Tuesdays at 2 p.m. CST



Site Map     Contact     About     Advertise     Privacy Policy     Widget     Twitter     Rss Feed


MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com.