Offseason In Review: St. Louis Cardinals

The defending World Champions lost a pair of franchise icons this offseason, but they appear poised to contend for another title after signing Carlos Beltran and promoting Mike Matheny as manager.

Major League Signings

Notable Minor League Signings

Scott Linebrink, Alex Cora, Koyie Hill, R.J. Swindle, Eugenio Velez.

Trades and Claims


Notable Losses

Draft Picks Gained or Lost

  • Obtained 19th overall selection from Angels for Albert Pujols. Also obtain supplementary first round pick, 36th overall.
  • Obtained 52nd overall selection for losing Dotel. 
  • Obtained 59th overall selection for losing Jackson.

No Albert Pujols. No Tony La Russa. The Cardinals team that takes the field on Opening Day will look a whole lot different than the club that won the 2011 World Series. But GM John Mozeliak's offseason moves have the club ready for another run at the postseason.

There's no replacing Albert Pujols, who has been nothing short of baseball's best offensive player for the past decade. The Cardinals appear to have made a substantial bid for the first baseman, but he left for the Angels' $240MM offer. Even at 32, he's one of the best hitters in the game, as his postseason performance showed. The short-term blow to the Cardinals' lineup is undeniable even though they may be applauding themselves for bidding cautiously five or six years from now when Pujols starts declining significantly.

Former Cardinals catcher Mike Matheny took over as the team's new manager following Tony La Russa's retirement. The 41-year-old Matheny inherits a team that's as strong as any rookie manager could hope for. In another significant off-field development, the Astros hired Jeff Luhnow, the Cardinals' longtime VP of scouting and player development, as their new GM.

Carlos Beltran represents the Cardinals' biggest offseason investment and he'll join Jon Jay and Matt Holliday in a strong projected outfield that could include Allen Craig at times. Even at 34, Beltran does a lot of things right and the Cardinals did well to obtain him for two years and $26MM.

The signing shifts Berkman to Pujols' former position, first base. Berkman doesn't come close to matching Pujols' defensive ability, but the 36-year-old is probably better suited for first base than the outfield at this point in his career.

The Cardinals dealt with their middle infield by re-signing Rafael Furcal, locking Skip Schumaker up for two years, non-tendering Ryan Theriot and letting Nick Punto leave via free agency. Furcal, always an injury risk, wasn't much worse than league average at the plate, even during a down season. He has some offensive potential if he can stay healthy and the Cardinals' investment suggests they believe Furcal can stay on the field in 2012-13. However, $14MM seems like an over-aggressive commitment for a 34-year-old who's missed an average of 70 games per season since 2008.

Even though the middle infield doesn't project to add much to the offense, the Cardinals should score enough runs. They led the National League in scoring last year and figure to be among the league leaders again, even after losing Pujols.

The Cardinals' rotation may be better than the group that led last year's team to the World Series, since Adam Wainwright is back from Tommy John surgery (exercising his options was an easy call). They entertained the idea of signing Roy Oswalt, and pursuing the free agent right-hander may become increasingly appealing if the injury currently sidelining Chris Carpenter proves serious. Oswalt's intriguing, especially on a one-year deal, so he figures to be on the Cardinals' radar even as Lance Lynn opens the year in the rotation. Top prospect Shelby Miller will start the season in the minors and could be a mid-summer callup. 

The Cardinals essentially left their bullpen alone this offseason. They've developed and acquired lots of quality relievers over the years and so contented themselves with the signings of J.C. Romero, Scott Linebrink and R.J. Swindle to low-risk deals. The Cardinals' young bullpen looks good on paper, and Mozeliak can add a reliever at the deadline if it falls short of expectations. A major addition to the bullpen wouldn't have made sense for this team.

The Cardinals also locked up Yadier Molina to a five-year, $75MM extension. It's a sizable contract for someone whose knees have been through 1,000 innings per season since 2004, but Molina is emerging as a premium player. Finding an All-Star catcher is difficult, and Molina is just 29, so the deal makes sense for both sides. Back when the Cardinals’ postseason hopes seemed faint, Mozeliak locked up Carpenter and Berkman to deals worth mentioning, even if they technically occurred before the offseason began.

It was an offseason unlike any other in St. Louis. The celebration of a championship, the retirement of a Hall of Fame manager, the departure of one of the greatest hitters in history. But now that the chaos has ended and another season is upon us, the Cardinals are contenders once again.

21 Responses to Offseason In Review: St. Louis Cardinals Leave a Reply

  1. 2ndedition 3 years ago

    An article that doesn’t even mention the loss of baseball’s premier pitching coach, Dave Duncan … fail!

  2. Cheeseballs 3 years ago

    Don’t forget Freese

    • Josher 3 years ago

      It was an article about notable additions and subtractions from the team. Freese wasn’t extended or lost so why would it talk about him?

  3. Madman2TX 3 years ago

    All those personnel losses offset by Carlos Beltran? Don’t think so. Would be shocked if the Cardinals make it back to World Series.

    • That’s what a lot of people said last year after signing Berkman and losing Wainwright…

    • I would be shocked if a lot of teams made it to the World Series… Especially when only 2 teams make it out of 32.  What a typical MLTR statement. You were also shocked they were there last year………. Duh

    • Lanidrac 3 years ago

      We also get Wainwright back (making Jackson completely expendable), Romero replaces Rhodes, and most of the other players we lost have been easily replaced in-system.

    • Tom Rayhawk 3 years ago

       No beltran doesnt’ replace Pujols. No one in the world does. However, look at 2-6 in out lineup _ Beltran, Holliday, Berkman, Freese, Molina(who I bet few knew led our team in batting average) – solid as anyone. Probably even more significant is the maturation of our youngsters. Freese – if he stays healthy is a proven can hit .300 15-20 80 RBI’s and has always been a clutch hitter even before his ridiculous postseason. Crag, once he comes back, has consistently put up big power numbers over 4 professional seasons in the minors and sure as hell wasn’t intimated in the world series, being the most underappreciated contributer. Our Bullpen youngsters have grown up and are greatly improved. We have a legitimate top NL closer now in Motte. People forget who led our team in wins and ERA – Lohse. Garcia will continue to mature after two solid 1st and 2nd year seasons. Wainwright is not going to have to wait a year to exhibit his best stuff – as the typical tommy john contention is. I believe he’ll have another top tier season, contending for the cy young. Carpenter out is a HUGE HUGE problem. though. But we lost Wainwright the entire season last year and I think we ended ok and Carp should be back in couple of months.

  4. headsupkid01 3 years ago

    We’re not getting any love from the Baseball world. Everyone thinks the Reds will take the division. WHAT! When everyone said this last year I agreed but not this year. Even with the loss of AP, Dunc and Larussa. 

    • josh 3 years ago

      they have an all around better team. easy. Vegas and sports illustraed agree witth me.

      • headsupkid01 3 years ago

         They don’t have better starting pitching.

        • headsupkid01 3 years ago

           They don’t have a better middle of the line up.

        • rayking 3 years ago

          False. They didn’t have Wainwright and they started the season with Kyle McClellan in the rotation. There is no conceivable argument that this year’s rotation is worse than last year’s.

      • Josher 3 years ago

        They do not have an all around better team. The Cards are better from top to bottom.

      • Lanidrac 3 years ago

        The Cardinals’ #3 starter (Garcia) is just as good as the Reds’ new “ace” Latos.

  5. Dc21892 3 years ago

    One thing I can say about the Cards is even with Pujols gone, they have some strong veteran leadership all along the club and it comes from guys who are still able to produce at a high level even in their mid 30s.

  6. Josher 3 years ago

    Don’t forget about getting Waino back.

  7. headsupkid01 3 years ago

    Right dude, because they always call it right don’t they. Didn’t they call us to finish 3rd behind the Brewers and the division winning Reds last year after Waino went down? How’ed that turn out? I mean they thought the Reds were going to  have a winning season, how’ed that one turn out also?

Leave a Reply