Offseason In Review: Cleveland Indians

The Indians fortified their rotation and signed a first baseman, but choosing to retain two longtime players set the team back in the short-term.

Major League Signings

Notable Minor League Signings

Dan Wheeler, Ryan Rohlinger, Julio Lugo, Ryan Spilborghs, Fred Lewis, Jeremy Accardo, Argenis Reyes, Chris Ray, Robinson Tejeda, Andy LaRoche, Jose Lopez, Felix Pie.

Trades and Claims


Notable Losses

When the offseason began, the Indians lacked outfield depth and answers in the rotation. They addressed both weaknesses over the winter, and could be considered a sleeper team for 2012. But this team also has its share of shortcomings.

Asdrubal Cabrera - Indians

Back in October, the Indians faced the possibility that they’d lose longtime fixtures Fausto Carmona and Grady Sizemore. They moved quickly to exercise Carmona’s option and allowed Sizemore to hit the open market before signing him at a bargain rate. At the time, both decisions seemed prudent.

However, Carmona had been using an assumed name and lying about his age. The Dominican government dropped charges against the right-hander, who's now known as Roberto Hernandez. He remains in the Dominican Republic, and though the Indians have re-structured his contract, it’s still a blow for the team. Hernandez isn’t helping them win games and he could face a suspension upon his return if the Juan Carlos Oviedo situation is to serve as precedent. The Indians now face an uncomfortable set of circumstances, even though Antonetti’s decision made sense in October, when he exercised the groundballer’s option.

Sizemore’s injury came as less of a surprise than Carmona's identity issues, but it's similarly disappointing from the Indians’ perspective. He'll miss at least another month or two recovering from back surgery, and Shelley Duncan will get lots of playing time in left as Michael Brantley shifts to center. The Indians invested considerably to retain Carmona and Sizemore, but there’s no guarantee either player will help the team win in 2012. The team’s biggest offseason investments have already become its biggest disappointments.

"Grady’s injury certainly hurts," Antonetti told me via email. "But I feel as if we were able to improve the team from last year. If we stay healthy and our young players develop, we have a chance to have a good team."

That Duncan, Jack Hannahan and Casey Kotchman occupy three of the team's four corner positions may be cause for concern. None of those players have hit 15 homers in a Major League season. However, Hannahan and Kotchman are expected to provide strong defense behind the Indians' pitching staff. Third base prospect Lonnie Chisenhall and first baseman Matt LaPorta, who are both playing at Triple-A Columbus, have more offensive upside than the team's current starters and could join the big league club by the time the season's up.

The Indians added ground ball pitcher Derek Lowe to the rotation soon after the offseason began, taking on $5MM of the right-hander's 2012 salary. Though the Braves seemed eager to move Lowe, this acquisition makes sense for the Indians. He's an extreme ground ball pitcher who should provide 180 innings of league average production in 2012 (last year's 5.05 ERA was deceptively high). The Indians traded for fly ball pitcher Kevin Slowey later on, and he'll provide depth at Triple-A for now.

The Indians appeared to have interest in left field/DH types such as Jason Kubel, Michael Cuddyer and Josh Willingham early in the offseason. Later, the team was linked to players such as Vladimir Guerrero and Bobby Abreu, so the team had interest in adding offense.

If the Indians get off to a hot start, like they did in 2011, I'm guessing they'll be in the market for a left fielder who can hit. Duncan offers power, but doesn't get on base enough to be considered a well-rounded offensive threat. Next offseason, when Hafner's contract expires, the Indians could find themselves pursuing traditional DH types for the first time in years.

The Indians' relievers pitched respectably in 2011 and with the bullpen's key members under team control for the coming season, Antonetti didn't need to spend on relief. He did well to add Dan Wheeler on a minor league deal, since comparable pitchers obtained Major League deals worth $1MM or more. Newly-acquired right-hander Jairo Asencio currently has a spot in Manny Acta's bullpen, but if he falters the Indians have a number of qualified relievers at Triple-A. They'll prove useful over the course of the 162-game season.

Antonetti and team president Mark Shapiro have shown restraint in recent years and their team has no bad contracts going forward. Last offseason, Antonetti's first as Cleveland's GM, included minimal spending on free agents. In fact, until last week, no Indians were under contract beyond 2012.

The Indians recently agreed to a two-year extension with Asdrubal Cabrera that keeps the shortstop in place through 2014. I like this deal for the team, since it buys out a free agent season — Cabrera's age-28 campaign — for a reasonable price without exposing the club to unnecessary long-term risk.

The Indians obtained the rights to a free agent season of Carlos Santana's by committing to the switch-hitter for the next five seasons. They don't appear to have obtained a substantial discount for his arbitration seasons (Joe Mauer and Brian McCann earned comparable amounts for that five-year chunk of their careers), but it made sense for the Indians to extend their control over Santana.

The Indians’ current position seems relatively strong. With no bad contracts on the books and many young players ready to contribute in the Major Leagues, they could break out before long. Yet their most recent offseason didn’t feature franchise-altering trades or free agent signings. Instead, Antonetti added supplementary players during another relatively quiet winter.

Photo courtesy of US Presswire.

Leave a Reply

12 Comments on "Offseason In Review: Cleveland Indians"

3 years 4 months ago

LOL over Chad Durbin being a notable loss.  

3 years 4 months ago

Really, none of those losses are notable.

Paul Shailor
3 years 4 months ago

Jim Thome will send his next home run hundreds of miles into the hood of your car.

3 years 4 months ago

Carlos Santana was not a offseason extension, that happened yesterday

3 years 4 months ago

Close enough.

3 years 4 months ago

Josh Judy was probably a more notable loss than De La Cruz. Tribe lost him on waivers to the Reds. At least pitched in the bigs last year (more of a loss than Burns too).

Really shouldn’t say the Tribe spent $15M this winter either since they didn’t sign Kotchman til after they knew they wouldn’t have to pay Carmona (on the restricted list so wasn’t going to earn any money) and they did restructure his deal this “offseason” so that should be the amount put down, not $7M.

Also, the Tribe got $1.25M from the Rockies to pay part of Slowey’s salary.

3 years 4 months ago

Sign Vlad!

3 years 4 months ago

 Isn’t he in jail?

3 years 4 months ago

I still have to pause to remind myself who Roberto Hernandez is. Fausto such a cooler name.

3 years 4 months ago

that’s probably why he got caught, “hey, this sounds like an awesome name, let’s look him up.  Uh oh, says here his name is Roberto Hernandez. I knew it was too good to be true.”

3 years 4 months ago

Indians keep making the same mistake over and over with Sizemore. Jimenez is a huge risk.  Lowe is just an innings eater. Yet they are so close if management would be more patient.  A great nucleus with Masterson, Santana, Astrubal and lots of good young talent. Sounds like the Blue Jays. Then they go and give up two top Minor League pitchers for Jimenez. Their latest mistake ? Chris Perez obviously not a top closer, Pestano is better. Oh well.

3 years 4 months ago

How have the indians made the same mistake “over and over” with Sizemore? The first deal he signed was a good one. I can understand this second deal being a mistake but hardly making a mistake “over and over”.