MLB Rumors - MLB Trade Rumors
Subscribe to MLB Trade Rumors using RSS
Home     Contact     About     Advertise     Archives     Widget     Twitter      RSS Usage

« Trades Of The Decade: Runners Up | Main | Odds & Ends: Torre, Braves, Blue Jays »

Mateo To San Francisco?

ESPN.com's Jorge Arangure reports (via Twitter) that the Giants may be on the verge of signing 16-year-old Dominican prospect Wagner Mateo.   A deal could be finalized  "within [the] next couple of weeks."

Mateo was originally signed by St. Louis in June to a contract with a $3.1MM signing bonus, but the deal was voided by the club in September after medical tests revealed that the young outfielder was suffering from vision problems.  The entire situation is nicely detailed in this piece by Joe Strauss of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, noting that Mateo's signing was an impressive victory for the Cardinals' rebuilt Latin American scouting operations.

In a tweet from last June, Arangure said that San Francisco came closest to signing Mateo away from St. Louis' grasp in the first place, but got "cold feet" offering a bonus of $3.5MM.  The Cards and Giants were two of several teams interested in the highly-regarded young outfielder.



Comments

I would like to know more about the extent of his vision related problems. That aside, bring him on in. We need all the top tier positional prospects we can get...especially after losing Angel to his murder charges.

If his problems are as bad as STL said they were, why would SF take him? Something is strange here.

He's playing this weekend in the WWBA tournament in Jupiter, FL with the Texas Scout Team Yankees if anyone's interested. I bet San Francisco signs him soon after the weekend if he does well, as that team is one of the main competitors in the tournament, and they'll have a good read on how he stands up against top U.S. prospects. He's on the same team as Jameson Taillon, Josh Sale, and Brian Ragira to name a few top players.

What, St. Louis couldn't afford to give the kid some laser eye surgery or some glasses? Brian McCann had eye troubles and they didn't bitch or moan about it. Sorry to be so harsh, but vision problems can be easily dealt with in this day and age, unless the kid is literally going blind, in which case such a thing would be reported and we'd all know.

Actually it makes perfect sense. Our same doctors that cleared Freddy Sanchez cleared Mateo. Hello Dr. Nick. Hello Brian Sabean.

how nasty is this kid really? I just don't know a lot about him, is he a can't miss gonna be superstar player?

alotta questions what position does he play? how good? how much 4 contract? is he worth it? alotta questions i hoe we sign him and he's the new willie mays

Wagner is a good baseball name. That I know. Will he ever be a ML outfielder, or is he worth a couple million dollars? He's "16" years old, so it's anyone's flipping guess.

It's too bad that he's on the same team as Tallion, that would be a great showdown of elite young talent.

And the problem with Mateo is that his vision problems is rather significant. Even with contacts or glasses on, he still only has 20/30 vision in one eye, and when you're trying to differentiate between a 94 MPH fastball and a 84 MPH slider, that can be a problem.

Maybe when he gets older they could try Lasik eye surgery, but that's a risky procedure to do on someone who just turned 16.

And I think that he makes sense for the Giants. Between Mateo and Rafael Rodriguez, the Giants could have a couple of sick five-tool prospects if those guys develop properly.

That is one things I've been wondering about since I saw the Tweet: why did the Giants have to bid $3.5M when the Cardinals bid $3.1M? Is there a rule governing the next bid?

Plus, I'm no optometrist or opthamologist, but why couldn't his vision be corrected to better than 20/30? I'm, like, blind (20/600?) but wore contacts for years and I was able to read down to what I thought was 20/20 on the chart when the doctor had me looking at it. But yeah, vision sometimes gets worse for short-sighted people as they age to middle age, though mine has been pretty steady until lately when they begun needing bi-focals.

Lastly, I lost interest in Wagner once the Cards "signed" him, is there a good scouting report on him somewhere? Thanks.

Oh, and I would note that the historical success rate of the top signing bonus babies from Latin America is more Wily Mo Pena and Jose Guzman than Miguel Cabrera.

So I would say, instead, that between Wagner and Rodriguez, the Giants have a better chance of developing a five-tool outfielder but it is still no slamdunk.

So far, so good on Rafael, he was ranked in the Top 20 for his level by BA this past season, but still no power yet, but good discipline (16W/22K in 128 AB), plus his hitting greatly improved in his last two months after a very poor first week or so. Oddly, he played mostly in LF, not RF, which he was signed as.

Of course it's no slam dunk, but these guys come relatively cheap compared to the potential returns, and if you keep gathering up these kind of high-upside prospects, eventually a few are going to pan out into pretty nice players.

Sorry, I figured you would know this, just wanted to note it for those not as familiar with Latin bonus babies.

Laser eye surgery isn't "risky" in a health sense for a 16 year old. There is no difference in the procedure for a 16 year old and a 96 year old. The problem is that vision can continue to decrease at 16 years old, and the surgery would have to be done several more times as the vision decreases over the subsequent years.

I think at this point, even a semi-blind 16 yo is an upgrade over Lewis... haha

Seriously though we've stock piled pitchers into our system and are at a good point in terms of depth... now we need some hitters and we should jump on any prospects that show signs of someday being a 5 tool guy and play the law of averages.

Too bad the Giants gave away the top end of that depth for garbage. I guess we owe the Pirates for stealing away Jason Schmidt from them. Here's to hoping Bumgarner is the real deal.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment


Top Stories



Search MLBTR

Lijit Search

MLBTR Features



Recent Posts


MLBTR Mailing List

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Rumors By Team



Monthly Archives


Live Chats


Tuesdays at 2 p.m. CST



Site Map     Contact     About     Advertise     Privacy Policy     Widget     Twitter     Rss Feed


MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com.