Headlines

  • Hayden Wesneski To Undergo Tommy John Surgery
  • Dodgers Release Chris Taylor
  • Jose Alvarado Issued 80-Game PED Suspension
  • Orioles Fire Manager Brandon Hyde
  • Ben Joyce Undergoes Season-Ending Shoulder Surgery
  • Dodgers Promote Dalton Rushing, Designate Austin Barnes For Assignment
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Poll: In-Season Managerial Changes

By Nick Deeds | May 9, 2025 at 6:33pm CDT

The Pirates fired manager Derek Shelton yesterday, bringing his five-plus year tenure as the organization’s manager to an end. That tenure didn’t exactly have many highlights, as the Pirates never won more than 76 games in a season under his guidance and he leaves the manager’s chair with a 306-440 record overall. For a job as nebulous and difficult to evaluate from the outside as that of a big league manager, there are few options other than viewing a club’s record as a reflection of the manager’s job performance.

All of that is to say that replacing Shelton with Don Kelly in the dugout is not necessarily a shocking or controversial decision for the Pirates. After years of failure including a disappointing 2024 season where they finished with an identical record to 2023 despite adding Paul Skenes and Jared Jones to the rotation, Pittsburgh was surely hoping for a big year in 2025. It’s a long season, but things haven’t worked out that way so far: the club has gone 12-26 so far and is currently riding a seven-game losing streak with just three series wins total this year.

With that being said, it’s difficult to argue that even a Hall of Fame-caliber manager would be able to turn this club around. The Pirates had an extremely quiet offseason that saw them enter the season having spread just $22MM in spending across seven free agents this winter. Perhaps if Skenes was being complemented with above average regulars like Teoscar Hernandez and Gleyber Torres instead of role players Tommy Pham and Adam Frazier, the team would be in a better position and Shelton would still be employed.

Zooming out from Shelton’s specific situation, in-season firings for managers have become increasingly rare over the years. Rather famously, the 2022 season saw four managers get fired with more than a month of baseball left to play. The Rangers fired Chris Woodward in mid-August. The Blue Jays fired Charlie Montoyo in mid-July. The Phillies and Angels both fired their managers (Joe Girardi and Joe Maddon, respectively) by the end of the first week of June. Two of those four teams went on to make the postseason, although it should be noted that Toronto had a winning record and was in playoff position when Montoyo was dismissed.

For every firing like that of Girardi, which occurred when the Phils were just 10-18 before they eventually turned things around and made it to the World Series under Rob Thomson, there’s several that do not change the outcome of the season. Prior to the successes of Thomson and John Schneider in 2022, the last team to make the playoffs after firing their manager was the 2009 Rockies. On the other hand, the Orioles and Royals in 2010 both improved significantly after hiring Ned Yost and Buck Showalter midseason. Though neither of those teams made the playoffs, Showalter led Baltimore to the postseason in his second year as manager while Yost eventually led the Royals to back-to-back World Series appearances in 2014 and ’15. The Mariners’ season turned around last year following Scott Servais’ dismissal in favor of Dan Wilson, and Seattle currently holds the second-best record in the American League.

Perhaps, then, the argument for making an in-season managerial change is that it offers your new manager an opportunity to get comfortable in the role in a season that’s already had its expectations diminished by a poor start under the previous manager. There could certainly be value in that, as well as the opportunity to give an internal candidate a sort of trial run in the dugout before weighing external candidates during the offseason.

On the other hand, one could argue that if a club lacks the confidence in their manager to stick with them for more than a month of poor performance from the team, then that club should have simply made a managerial change the prior offseason so that the team would be led by the organization’s ideal person for the job from the very start of the season.

Where do MLBTR readers fall when it comes to this debate? Are in-season managerial changes a good practice that brings about positive change within the organization and can spur teams to success, or are they largely meaningless moves meant to demonstrate urgency that would have been better demonstrated during the previous offseason? Have your say in the poll below:

Share 0 Retweet 0 Send via email0

MLBTR Originals MLBTR Polls Pittsburgh Pirates Derek Shelton

Fantasy Baseball: Dealing With Early Anchors
Main
White Sox To Select Tim Elko
View Comments (61)
Post a Comment

61 Comments

  1. DarkSide830

    2 weeks ago

    Being or having a lame duck in charge does nothing for no one. Might as well pull the rip cord when you feel you must.

    4
    Reply
  2. AL B DAMNED

    2 weeks ago

    FIRE SNITKER NOW!

    1
    Reply
    • sad tormented neglected mariners fan

      2 weeks ago

      Why??? He just got them back at .500 using Eli white and Alex verdugo???

      6
      Reply
      • AL B DAMNED

        2 weeks ago

        .500…When…Last Year?
        He started Stuart Fairchild batting .048..
        after today .043 over Alex Verdugo.
        Granted Alex is struggling but so was Harris.
        Harris turned it around last few games.
        Verdugo Can’t shake rough spot if not in lineup! Snit doesn’t know how to use the bullpen OR make out a lineup!

        Reply
      • SoCalBrave

        2 weeks ago

        @mariners fan, just ignore AL. His opinions are the baseball equivalent of a teenager yelling CHICKEN JOKEY at the movie theater

        Reply
        • sad tormented neglected mariners fan

          2 weeks ago

          Flint and steel!

          Reply
  3. Rynoshield

    2 weeks ago

    The problem with this poll is that neither option applies to the pirates. They are not underperforming, they are performing exactly how we should expect them to based on everything ownership and the front office has done. Firing Shelton does nothing to change that. The next manager will be in the same situation in a few years

    10
    Reply
    • tj13

      2 weeks ago

      Thank you. This post belonged on a different firing, definitely not this particular one. This was a GM trying to save his house by burning down his hand picked employee’s.

      2
      Reply
      • cheapseater

        1 week ago

        I’d look a little higher than the GM for who’s responsible for the Pirates current state of affairs.

        1
        Reply
    • Eric T

      1 week ago

      I’d say it’s also a problem that “Yes, it lets try to shake things up” is the biggest word salad I’ve come across in 2025.

      But to your point, I agree with you. Shelton did the best he could… it would seem the GM not building the team in the offseason at all and the owner who spends Nutting would be the bigger culprits.

      Reply
    • Major League Baseball Fan

      1 week ago

      The problem is every situation should be judged and acted upon based on its own unique factors. Life is not as simple as yes/no.

      Reply
  4. TheMan 3

    2 weeks ago

    Shelton should have never been hired in the first place, his teams lacked discipline, basic fundamentals and leadership

    7
    Reply
    • tj13

      2 weeks ago

      Same goes for the clown that picked those undisciplined, unskilled, followers. Or did the front office pick all winners and Shelton ruined them all? I guess your comment doesn’t fit all of reality.

      1
      Reply
      • TheMan 3

        1 week ago

        apparently you never watched the Bucs on a regular basis over the last 6 years, but then again, you’re probably one of those know it alls who don’t know squat

        1
        Reply
    • Rynoshield

      1 week ago

      Unfortunately no one who is a good option for a manager is going to accept the role with the pirates

      1
      Reply
      • Major League Baseball Fan

        1 week ago

        Right, because Pittsburgh won’t pay for a good field manager/leader.

        2
        Reply
        • PoisonedPens

          1 week ago

          Just starting the countdown until Skenes’ agent forces a trade.

          Reply
  5. ctiger14

    2 weeks ago

    Is Brandon Hyde next? I think the seat is getting warm.

    3
    Reply
    • BEISBALL

      2 weeks ago

      orioles future look more like the white sox than the astros

      4
      Reply
    • Major League Baseball Fan

      1 week ago

      Brandon Hyde didn’t create that pathetic roster.

      1
      Reply
      • Windowpane

        1 week ago

        I guess your definition of pathetic is different than most people’s. Starting pitching? Yes. Entire roster? Umm, no.

        Reply
  6. TrillionaireTeamOperator

    2 weeks ago

    I’m purposefully not googling this myself, for the sake of the discussion, but have there been teams under water who fired a manager early or mid season and then the replacement manager turned the team around to such a degree that a lost season turned into a playoff run?

    1
    Reply
    • nonchalanto

      2 weeks ago

      I am also not googling but maybe the Mariners last year?

      2
      Reply
    • Joe says...

      2 weeks ago

      The Phillies fired Joe Girardi to great results.

      12
      Reply
    • Duffy S. Cliff

      2 weeks ago

      2003 Marlins, classic example. Went from being 16-22 under Jeff Torborg, to 75-49 under Jack McKeon and winning the World Series.

      4
      Reply
    • letitbelowenstein

      2 weeks ago

      Jack McKeon with the Marlins in 2003?

      2
      Reply
      • whyhayzee

        2 weeks ago

        Morgan’s Magic.

        Reply
    • Major League Baseball Fan

      1 week ago

      Purposely?

      Reply
  7. Chuck from Uniontown

    2 weeks ago

    If youre not going to give me a good team, give me an entertaining team. Ozzie Guillen for Bucs Manager.

    4
    Reply
  8. King Floch

    2 weeks ago

    Brandon Hyde next, please.

    1
    Reply
    • BEISBALL

      2 weeks ago

      orioles are the new white sox

      1
      Reply
      • King Floch

        2 weeks ago

        Maybe, but I strongly doubt it.

        Reply
    • PoisonedPens

      1 week ago

      It’s certainly not Hyde’s fault they chose to replace Corbin Burnes with Charlie Morton,

      Reply
      • King Floch

        1 week ago

        And it’s certainly not Charlie Morton’s fault that the team constantly looks sloppy, unfocused, and unmotivated.

        Charlie Morton also isn’t filling out the lineup card and stubbornly pencilling Mountcastle into the 4th or 5th hole everyday when he hasn’t performed all year while guys that are performing well, like Holliday, consistently bat in the bottom third of the lineup.

        Reply
    • solaris602

      1 week ago

      Connie Mack himself couldn’t win with that rotation, but Hyde hasn’t done himself any favors. The blame lies with Elias, but he isn’t going anywhere. This is a lost season for BAL, but I still have Hyde getting bounced before the ASB.

      Reply
  9. CTS4

    2 weeks ago

    In Toronto it makes sense to Fire the Lousy GM shapiro and his lackie atkins…

    Reply
  10. plmbloco48

    2 weeks ago

    Probably won’t help Pirates though. Their problem is ownership

    2
    Reply
    • Major League Baseball Fan

      1 week ago

      Cherington has had how many years to assemble a talented and capable roster?
      Cherington is the weakest link, not Nutty Bob.

      Reply
  11. Brad Johnson

    2 weeks ago

    It’s obviously more nuanced than these two poll options. In my view, the manager’s main job is to set the tone for the clubhouse culture. An in-season change is best for when the culture is in a rut with little hope of escaping. As an owner, the question of fire/stay the course often comes down to assessing if a new leader might improve the culture.

    2
    Reply
  12. BlueSkies_LA

    2 weeks ago

    Managers have to be fired because ownership will never fire itself.

    2
    Reply
  13. Acoss1331

    2 weeks ago

    It worked for the Phillies in 2022. Rob Thompson has been able to take the Phillies to the playoffs since Joe Girardi got the boot early on in the 2022 season.

    1
    Reply
    • Major League Baseball Fan

      1 week ago

      Philly had some players. Pirates are not close to the 22 Philly roster.

      1
      Reply
  14. Baseballisthebest

    2 weeks ago

    Nick Deeds tells us that without a doubt he doesn’t understand what it takes to be a good manager in MLB. I pay to read your opinion why? There are at least a dozen people that comment here regularly that know more about baseball and write succinctly with at least a basic understanding of journalism.

    2
    Reply
    • Major League Baseball Fan

      1 week ago

      10 cents a day. That’s all it costs, you cheap MF.

      Reply
      • Baseballisthebest

        1 week ago

        Good bye.

        Reply
      • PadresWSChamps2025

        1 week ago

        That’s a lot of money for his burger-flipping job.

        Reply
  15. TroyVan

    2 weeks ago

    I think if you’re an a-hole manager or if you really dgaf, you should be fired midseason if the team is terrible. But, managers really don’t make that big of a difference. I mean, they can definitely cause wins and losses based on in game moves, but I think success and failure is 90% or more the result of the players performance.

    My team (the Tigers) have been terrible at player development for 40 years (especially position player development). I watched scapegoat managers like Buddy Bell, Phil Garner, and many others go down for many years because they couldn’t win enough games with the players the organization provided for them.

    The Pittsburgh problem seems very similar.

    2
    Reply
    • Skeptical

      2 weeks ago

      Management impacts player/employee performance. True in sports, true is business, true in the military. Management should provide leadership and should shape the culture of the organization. Organizations with bad management underperform. Organizations with good management overperform.

      Reply
      • TroyVan

        1 week ago

        You’re absolutely correct. But, I think you are confusing the on field manager with organizational management. They are two different things. The on field manager is not capable of changing organizational culture. Period. Those changes come from above; usually the owner.

        Example: Detroit Lions. Technically, there wasn’t a change in the organization ownership. But, Bill Ford was inept and cheap. He failed for decades, things that came to light after Barry Sanders penned his book. But, he always hired GMs who preached the same thing: We are going to hire a COACH to change the culture of the organization. I laughed because at that time, I wanted the Lions to fail so badly that the Fords would sell the team. I knew that a coach cannot change organizational culture.

        Bill Ford retired from the Lions. Enter Martha Firestone Ford and daughter Sheila Ford Hamp. These women actually cared about the organization and everyone in it, and clearly wanted everyone to succeed. And now, they are one of the best teams in the NFL.

        That’s an example of how a coach or GM cannot change organizational culture. It comes from above.

        Reply
  16. dcahen

    2 weeks ago

    Shelton should have been gone 2 years ago. He allows laziness, has no idea how to make & stick to a line-up. Cutch as DH needs to rest every 3-4 games. Sitting in the dugout is very taxing on his 37 year old body. A .150 hitter gets an extra base hit, maybe even a HR & he hits clean-up next day; guaranteed! He can’t manage starting or relieving pitching. They lose due to walks by SP or RP & starters are at 100 pitches after 5-6 innings. Why? Because they’re told to pitch to the edges of the plate. Every team knows this & figured it out 3 years ago. Cherington gave him too many “versatile” players, just another way to “mix & match” his line-up daily. He might be the worst manager in baseball history.

    2
    Reply
    • retire21

      1 week ago

      I love this post.

      Reply
    • fbf923

      1 week ago

      This is a great summary of Shelton’s failings. It’s easy to criticize from your recliner, but this is a man who continued to do the same thing over and over for five years. He lacked imagination, problem-solving skills, and was in no way inspirational to his team or fans. Every post-game interview was about how “we need to do better,” but there were never any actual solutions posited. Im glad he’s finally gone.

      Reply
  17. WSnotAstros2017

    1 week ago

    I think Astros Manager Espada needs to go and Cintron the main hitting coach and Snitker our assistant hitting coach. Espada never fit. Yes in 2 year but I do not feel it with him. Crane would have Bozo the Clown at things right now. Do not have the best GM either. No good GM since Luhnow. Hinch had the team as well. Despite … Dusty had the team too. Many fans are calling for all their heads. Yes slow start again. Would not be better with Bregman. But Crane will not do anything till October when we do not make playoffs

    Reply
  18. poppopts

    1 week ago

    The question should have been, “Does it make sense to fire the manager during the season when a team underperforms for the 6th straight season?” Then, you would have received 100% YES votes.

    1
    Reply
    • Major League Baseball Fan

      1 week ago

      Define underperform. The pirates roster sucks.

      2
      Reply
  19. retire21

    1 week ago

    Exactly right.

    Reply
  20. CleaverGreene

    1 week ago

    The next to go are Joey Cora and Brandon Hyde. Bad GM’s gotta protect their jobs..

    1
    Reply
  21. dajuba

    1 week ago

    💁🏼‍♀️ My wish for the ‘25 season was for Alex Cora to finally have a DRAMA FREE season and club house, and for him to get his team prepared to play defensively, 2 things he’s never been able to accomplish. Obviously, that ship has sailed. Is there a more overrated Manager in the game today?

    Reply
  22. joew

    1 week ago

    Mid season changes with a bunch of people settling in, not really a good thing. Mid season changes after years with a similar core group and failing most of the way is often too late. So….

    I don’t expect a huge change in game plan

    Reply
  23. Supersc

    1 week ago

    Rockies. Bud Black. Toast.

    GM, same thing. Burnt toast.

    Reply
  24. MLBTR needs to hire editors

    7 days ago

    Deeds stinks. “Perhaps, then, the argument for making an in-season managerial change is that it offers your new manager an opportunity to get comfortable in the role in a season that’s already had its expectations diminished by a poor start under the previous manager” is a poorly written sentence. “Then” adds nothing of substance and only disrupts the syntax.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Hayden Wesneski To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Dodgers Release Chris Taylor

    Jose Alvarado Issued 80-Game PED Suspension

    Orioles Fire Manager Brandon Hyde

    Ben Joyce Undergoes Season-Ending Shoulder Surgery

    Dodgers Promote Dalton Rushing, Designate Austin Barnes For Assignment

    Major League Baseball Rules That Permanent Ineligibility Ends At Death

    Rangers Place Corey Seager On Injured List

    Cubs Promote Moises Ballesteros

    Evan Longoria To Sign One-Day Contract, Retire As Member Of Rays

    Diamondbacks To Promote Jordan Lawlar

    Rockies Fire Bud Black

    Cubs Promote Cade Horton

    Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base

    Pirates Fire Manager Derek Shelton

    Mariners Claim Leody Taveras

    Rangers Hire Bret Boone As Hitting Coach

    A.J. Minter To Undergo Season-Ending Lat Surgery

    Blue Jays Sign Spencer Turnbull

    Blue Jays Sign José Ureña

    Recent

    Cubs To Activate Ian Happ, Option Moises Ballesteros

    Roberts: Andy Pages To Continue Seeing Regular Playing Time

    The Opener: Buehler, Twins, Guardians, MLBTR Chat

    Bo Bichette’s Earning Power Spectrum

    Phillies Had Reached Out To David Robertson Before Alvarado Suspension

    Astros To Select Brandon Walter

    Alan Trejo Elects Free Agency

    Padres’ Oscar Gonzalez Granted Release To Pursue Opportunity In NPB

    Poll: How Effective Has The Prospect Promotion Incentive Been?

    Tigers Place Reese Olson On Injured List

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version