The Mets have several areas where they could plausibly pursue upgrades prior to next week’s trade deadline, but president of baseball operations David Stearns indicated yesterday that his primary focus is on improving the bullpen (link via ESPN’s Jorge Castillo).
Mets relievers have been a middle-of-the-pack unit overall, ranking 13th with a combined 3.87 ERA on the season. They’ve struggled to a 5.30 mark over the past month, however, due in no small part to injury. A.J. Minter’s season ended in early May when he required surgery to repair a torn lat. Fellow southpaw Danny Young had Tommy John surgery that same month. Righties Max Kranick and Dedniel Nunez both went down with season-ending arm injuries as well.
The Mets have used a staggering 30 different relief pitchers this season, including 23 over just the past 30 days. They’ve treated the final couple spots in the relief corps as a revolving door, frequently shuttling in waiver claims and minor league signees when they need a fresh arm, than designating those players for assignment in favor of the next arm that comes down the conveyor belt. It’s led to a dizzying number of Mets transactions and constant turnover among the relief corps. Many of those stopgaps have been hit hard, and mainstays Reed Garrett and especially Huascar Brazoban have struggled over the past month.
Edwin Diaz, Ryne Stanek, Garrett and Brazoban have been constants in Carlos Mendoza’s bullpen. The Mets clearly have room to add multiple arms and should likely be expected to do just that. They were in the mix to sign David Robertson before he opted to reunite with the Phillies, and they reportedly have some interest in Twins left-hander Danny Coulombe (at a time when Minnesota is said to be increasingly open to offers on rental players).
The Mets have been tied to rotation upgrades, reportedly showing interest in Pirates righty Mitch Keller and in Marlins righty Edward Cabrera. Stearns downplayed the possibility of adding to his starting staff, however, stating that he’s “comfortable” with the in-house group and its ability to navigate a postseason series. If Kodai Senga, Sean Manaea, Clay Holmes, David Peterson and Frankie Montas can all remain healthy, New York’s starting five indeed looks sharp, but health is hardly a given. Each of Senga, Manaea and Montas has had a monthslong IL stint within the past 15 months. Holmes is in his first season stretching back into a rotation role after years as a high-leverage reliever.
Similarly, while Stearns acknowledged that he expects to explore the market for center fielders, an acquisition isn’t necessarily likely. The Mets have been pleased with Jeff McNeil’s increased comfort in center and Tyrone Taylor’s defensive play. “[T]he bar to improve center field has probably risen over the past, let’s say, two weeks,” Stearns said.
Stearns naturally did not decisively rule out a center field addition, but it’s a thin market in terms of options. Cedric Mullins is likely available in Baltimore, and the O’s have multiple relievers available (e.g. Gregory Soto, Seranthony Dominguez and perhaps Andrew Kittredge). Similarly, if the Mets already have interest in Minnesota’s Coulombe, they could look into both him and old friend Harrison Bader, who’s on a one-year deal and has performed well on both sides of the ball in the Twin Cities. The White Sox have both Luis Robert Jr. and Mike Tauchman available. The former has finally begun to heat up in recent weeks, while the latter has hit well for much of the season. If the Mets wanted to take a bigger swing, they could try to pry Oneil Cruz from Pittsburgh. He (reportedly) is not completely off the table, but the asking price would surely be extreme.
The Mets are willing to deal from their collection of young infielders, which includes Brett Baty, Mark Vientos, Ronny Mauricio and Luisangel Acuña. They also have several pitching prospects on the cusp of the majors, including Brandon Sproat, Nolan McLean and Blade Tidwell. Stearns noted that any of the three could be a candidate to join the bullpen down the stretch but added the Mets will be cautious with such decisions, as once a starting pitcher is ramped down to a bullpen role during the season, it’s hard to stretch him back out.
The Mets are willing to deal from their collection of young infielders, which includes Brett Baty, Mark Vientos, Ronny Mauricio and Luisangel Acuña. 🤮🤮
You left out two things:
1) The quotation marks around your verbatim comment lifted from MLBTR, and
2) Those guys have little trade value, even though most Mets fans fail to understand that particular aspect of making trades.
Thanks for your judicious ignorance.
If it were the Yankees it would bag us Paul Skenes though
🧢
Just to keep this focused and simple: Can you explain how Brett Baty (for example) has little trade value to a team looking to retool when he has multiple years of cheap control, has shown flashes of serious upside potential, can play multiple positions well, and can certainly contribute to a winning team in 2026 (1.8 fWar and .727 OPS so far in ’25)?
Keep Baty and Acuna; trade or send down Mauricio and Vientos.
Don’t waste trading any young talent as despite position in standings this team does not have it; this horrible RISP performance has not changed and will not play at all if they make the playoffs.
Stay with what we have and bring the promising starters in the minors up for the bullpen.
And these long slumps by Lindor, Alonso, and even Soto are not going to get us to the promised land either!
This team has no heart and Mendoza is no manager!
I think Batty might be the only one, that generates any interest or really return of value.
Fans like you deserve the Wilpons, always looking for something to complain about.
The Wilpons sold the Mets five years ago
Thank you captain obvious
Every single contender is looking for pen arms.
And Starting arms.
Unless the Mets plan to bring up Nolan McLean and/Jonah Tong, they do need another reliable and durable SP. Someone who goes 6+ innings per start.
The position player mix should be good enough, and definitely the pen needs a lot of improvement, but I would be disappointed if they don’t add a quality SP.
In Stearns presser yesterday, he said that he could see McLean and/or Sproat being able to contribute sometime within the next couple of months.
Jonah Tong is not in the mix yet. We mustn’t get carried away with numbers posted in AA, a level in which only 1 out of 3 players will reach the majors, and some (many?) of those will either disappear after a couple of all-ups, or ride the quad-A shuttle for the rest of their careers. He’s got great stuff, and its confounding to wonder why he isn’t in AAA yet. But he’s not. Given the recent history of AA starters largely struggling upon their promotion to AAA, it makes sense to see Tong at that level before calling him up.
There is more talent in AA than AAA in mlb baseball. AAA is designed for has beens and journey men who can fill in now and then. You do most of your talent development at AA.
You might have an argument on raw talent of the highest prospects. But not the rank and file. . The level of play in AAA is higher and more polished than AA.
You scoff at the washed up journeymen. But the statistical fact quoted by Josh Lewin about 8 years ago was that players reaching AA have a 1 in 3 chance of reaching the majors. For players who reach AAA, its 2 out of 3. So those have beens and journeymen you refer to in AAA are still better than the never-will-And the Mets are a bad example. They are worse off than most orgs in their reliance on journeymen for depth. Other teams have more prospects and fewer journeymen.
The Mets double A team is vastly more talented than their triple A team. They would beat them 6 out of ten times. You are right a lot of so called AAAA players in triple A that get minimal major league experience but the really good players especially pitchers are in double A and usually spend minimal amounts of time in AAA as they get fast tracked to the majors. When Benge, Williams and Tong get promoted to triple A don’t expect them to be there for long as it’s just a rehearsal for their call up. The only reason David Wright played in AAA was because it was his home town and he wanted a couple weeks there for nostalgia.
David Peterson came up directly from AA.
It happens. But its the exception, not the rule. And BTW, Peterson also spent time at the Mets Alternate training site, which was arguably more advanced than AAA, during the 2020 COVID year. David Peterson was also a 1st round pick, projected to be a #2 starter and tio move quickly thru the system. Thats not the typical AA player.
Tong is in AA. If they called up anyone, it’d be McLean, followed by Sproat. Though I would be a little surprised if they called any of them up this year.
For whatever it’s worth, Sproat has 23 straight scoreless innings with 27 Ks and 6 BBs. He’s only gone more than 5 innings four times this year, though. McLean has better overall numbers, but Sproat has been better recently. Tong has been outstanding but should get called to AAA rather than MLB.
The hang-up with McLean that does not show up in the basic numbers is that, while he is absolutely dominating RH hitters (they have a mid-400s OPS against him), he is getting hit reasonably well by LH hitters (mid-700s OPS). Since RHers represent 70% of the batters, their numbers have more effect on his overall numbers. Its fair to suppose that MLB hitters from both sides will hit him more than AAA batters have.
It’s really hard to tell. We’ve seen several top starters put up concerning stats in AAA and then step up their game in the majors. Guys get bored, tinker with pitches, pitch in badly maintained parks etc. Look at Harvey, Syndergaard, Wheeler & deGrom as examples.
They have 5 healthy starters going well right now and 2 spot starters returning soon, what would they do with another starter? Sure its good for depth but who goes to the pen? Holmes? Montas?
Unfortunately, we do not have any confirmation that Megill will be back soon. His placement on the 60-day IL ahead of Nunez just days after Megill was reportedly playing catch from 75 feet, while Nunez was still idling and had already told the press he might need TJ is very suspicious to me.
Pierce Johnson for Acuna
We’ll add Iglesias for free and you can roll the dice as little or as much as you’d like
Done deal. Then the Mets swivel to Miami and trade for X Edwards or Otto Lopez who are both better hitters/players than lil Acuna.
While the asking price for Oneil Cruz may indeed be high it’s unlikely that anyone will pay it. Statcast records don’t win games and while Cruz occasionally hits a ball very far or very hard he mostly strikes out. BA and IBP have cratered this season and his OPS has been in steady decline since May or so. As a center fielder he can rifle a throw at record speed but plays the position poorly – more so now than a few months ago. I’d be delighted if the Pirates could offload him but I doubt it.
I agree on the Cruz asking price. Tauchman will likely cost less. As for the Mets, they absolutely have to prioritize relief pitching. They need more than one of the available relievers in order to have a pen built for postseason play.
Agreed, Bill. This team needs multiple BP arms. Right now, it’s been Diaz, Garrett, Brazoban. Raley with the team should help and hopefully they get Butto back tomorrow. Can’t keep throwing guys out there who will get DFA’ed over and over again.
Lol, I forgot about Stanek.
He’s a RF right now but they need him in CF.
They need a CF cause they traded their 1st round pick for a rental and now he’s a star in Chicago.
This was done 4 years ago by an interim GM, and is one the example reasons why the Mets haven’t cast away young talent frivolously since.
I know, but it didn’t take much to realize dealing your 1st round pick in CF for a rental that wasn’t going to help you that season was a bad decision.
At the time, the mindset with Sandy was the team president with Zach Scott as AGM. PCA was drafted under BVW and had just injured his shoulder badly, which at the time (ironically) the organization felt it could impact PCA’s ability to hit for power which he wasn’t projected to have much of anyway. Between the recovery time and PCA being a pick from a different GM, Sandy greenlit the trade.
lend me that crystal ball dude
Spot on carlos15, a rental that gave us fans the thumbs down sign.
Taylor is painful to watch at the plate, and I knew Torrens would come back down to his reality.
And you might as well ask the Siri on the phone to play than the one on IL
Do a trade that has little downside and maybe some upside. Call CWS up and see if they’ll eat some of Robert’s remaining 2025 contract and throw in Steve Wilson or Tyler Gilbert for one of those extra 3B and maybe a prospect somewhere out of the top 20. Maybe Robert playing next to Soto helps.
That has nothing but downside.
Robert has great numbers against LHP.
He has a role in the NYM outfield if they deal for him. He’s also been on a SSS heater lately. Trade for Robert. The prospect capital would not be top shelf.
They are happy with McNeil in center. They are only trading for a top end center fielder if available. There is a reason the White Sox have been monumentally bad and Robert if a big reason.
When your team leads the National League in blown saves, you’ll need plenty more relief than what all the other ballclubs will give you at the deadline.
They’re leading the league in Save Opportunities so it makes sense that they’d be near the top in blown saves. Focus on your Yanks, Chuckster. They’re in a free fall.
If the Guardians are indeed willing to listen on Cade Smith, I do wonder what Stearns would be willing to offer since Smith would come with significant control. I wonder if he would be one of the few rumored available targets that Stearns would consider trading one of the high end prospects for.
Cleveland is not trading Cade Smith.
Mets need to go after Jake Bird, Cade Smith or Bednar plus the lefty from the Twins , bring up Sproat or McLean and put Holmes in the bullpen since he hasn’t started in years . We do need at least 1 bat Suarez/ Buxton/ Mullins
Bird & Bednar would be huge
Buxton is a 10/5 player and can veto a trade.
And he just said last week that he intends to be a Twin for life
Holmes hasnt started for years, except all the starts in April, May, June, July 0f 2025. He signed to be a starter, dont Lugo him back and forth or he is toast
Give ya Mullins Morton and Dominguez for one of you’re top 5 pitching prospects I’ll take Bidwell
If I’m the Mets, I do that one.
I think the Mets acquire both a right handed and left handed reliever, in addition to a starting pitcher which would allow them to bump Holmes back to a reliever for the remainder of the season. Don’t expect either future acquisition to be a major pickup.
I asked one of the MLBTR hosts about Holmes during a live chat the other day. He agreed it would help the innings count, but suspected the Mets wouldn’t want to bounce him between short stints and starting.
He’s currently at 109 IP. That’s 39 more IP than he’s ever thrown and 46 more IP than last year. He can’t throw 5 innings every 5th Day the rest of the year. He’ll either get arm fatigue or an injury. He needs to go to the Pen to keep those innings low. Next year he should be stretched out to go a full year as a SP.
Didn’t say I would or wouldn’t be in favor of that move, only that an MLBTR host said it probably wouldn’t happen.
To me, I think they either need to acquire another starter (or call up a prospect) or get a reliever who can regularly eat innings so they can marry them with Holmes. Planning on him having success as a mid-rotation arm into a playoff run with this change isn’t realistic.
I’d be on-board with getting an established hitter to lengthen the lineup. Flexible on position and doesn’t have to be a star, but batting average north of .275 with ops high 7s or higher would likely translate to more rallies actually scoring runs.
That sounds like a star
Would you call Luis Arráez a star? I feel like most would call him polarizing or a net negative due to lack of other skills beyond hitting. I would not be opposed getting him as a DH.
I have no confidence in Stearns to make any deals of consequence. The Mets and him are worried more about the luxury tax and their “prized” minor leaguers. He will continue to pick up scrap heap for cheap and pass on acquiring major talent that is necessary to get to the playoffs. Mark my word. Stearns is ruining our team.
He’s not ruining the team – he’s trying to build something that can have sustained success year in and year out, rather than having to be re-tooled and payroll increased every single year. . You cannot do that with $300+ million payroll, a porous farm system, and having our draft pick dropped 10 spots and your international pool money reduced by payroll penalties.
He inherited a team with only half of a major league roster, and close to nothing in AAA or AA at the time. He’s given you a gift in forming a team that has done as well as it has. Sit back, and enjoy the ride.
Mets aren’t getting Cruz!