MLB Rumors - MLB Trade Rumors
Subscribe to MLB Trade Rumors using RSS
Home     Contact     About     Advertise     Archives     Widget     Twitter      RSS Usage

« Twins Sign Adam Everett | Main | The Mitchell Report »

Jays Sign David Eckstein

UPDATE, 12-13-07 at 10:56am: Rosenthal says it's a one-year, $4.5MM deal.  Who can complain about that?

FROM 12-13-07 at 8:30am:

This one's from out in left field - Ken Rosenthal reports that the Blue Jays are close to signing David Eckstein.  Rosenthal expects the signing to push newly inked defensive specialist John McDonald to a backup role.

Perhaps the Jays can go for some kind of offense/defense platoon.  If a groundballer like Jesse Litsch or Jeremy Accardo happens to be on the mound, the Jays could opt for defense.


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515b9a69e2010534ada14c970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Jays Sign David Eckstein:

Comments

God damn it, I don't wanna see that little albino piece of crap 19 times this year. Leave it to him to find a place that he would actually be an offensive upgrade, to continue the mythos of pigmentless man.

This will just add to the ridiculous number of times we have to hear an Eckstein-Pedroia comparison.

Little albino piece of crap.....

Classic.

So... in that platoon, which guy would be offense and which would be defense?

He has the same career OPS as Marco Scutaro. Why was this necessary?

I suspect this will mean McDonald vs lefties as he hit 270 last season and Eckstein vs righties tho he was pretty bad vs them

bah looked at the wrong Eckstien stats forget what I said

I really like this signing, if it actually happens, Paul Lo Duca was "close to signing" the other day but that didn't happen.

Having Eckstein at short is an offensive upgrade and not much is given up defensively either. Eckstein can bat at the top of the order which the Jays will undoubtably need if Reed Johnson does not bounce back from his injury and it will give the jays a really deep bench of Scutaro, MacDonald, Stairs and who ever their back up catcher will be (Curtis Thigpen?, Sal Fasano?, Miguel Olivo?).

this move should solidify the jays order:

ss - eckstein
lf - stairs
rf - rios
dh - thomas
cf - wells
3b - glaus
1b - overbay
2b - hill
c - zaun

if healthy (as if Jays fans need to hear that anymore), that could be a lethal offensive attack

compare the numbers the last 3 seasons.
Eckstein..
07- .309 AVG/ .356 OBP
06- .292 AVG/ .350 OBP
05- .294 AVG/ .363 OBP

McDonald..
07- .251 AVG/ .279 OBP
06- .223 AVG/ .271 OBP
05- .290 AVG/ .340 OBP (in 93AB)

so how is Ecstein not significantly better than McDonald?

id love to have Eckstein. he becomes the starter and McDonald becomes the backup, which he should be. it also allows Scutaro to backup all over the infield.

In addition to solidifying the line up, this move may open up a few rosters spots so J.P. is not constantly stocking up on shitty little infield guys like Howie Clark, Russ Adams, Joe Inglett, Hector Luna, Jason Smith, Ray Olmedo an so on.....

BJays Fan!:

Good point. That didn't immediately occur to me. With Scutaro, Mac, and Eckstein...

Adams, Inglett, Olmedo... These guys aren't even going to make the bench.

I don't like the money they'd have to give to Eckstein, but it really does make the line-up better.

I love Mac's defense to death. He will always be one of my favourite players because together him and Hill are the most exciting DP combo I've ever seen. They're amazing. But the more other teams in the AL East bolster their line-ups and rotations, the more apparent it becomes that the Jays can't afford to have .240 coming out of his spot in the order.

The Jays can now bring out a lineup of the best defensive team in the majors (easily, bar none) of...

Reed
Rios
Wells
Thomas
Glaus
Overbay
Hill
Zaun/Olivo maybe?
Mac

when the pitch Halladay or Burnett or Mcgowan (ground ballers bigtime. Especially Doc)

Or they can put out a pure offensive lineup of

Eckstein
Rios
Wells
Thomas
Glaus
Overbay
Hill
Stairs
Zaun

It's a nice bench now too. If Ecks is cheap enough, it's a good sign.. This makes the bench probably

Reed/Stairs
Scutaro (very useful backup)
Mac (best defensive AL SS)
And hopefully someone like Olivo who can hit lefties hard and throws out 33% of runners.. defenite upgrade on Fasano lol.

I like that Jays are acquiring "glue" guys, but Scutaro, McDonald, Eckstein, and Hill all on the same team seems like an excessive amount (and an expensive set) of middle infielders to have on your major league roster. It just seems like a strange mix of players on that roster.

But hey, if Burnett and Ryan are healthy this year the Blue Jays are stacked. I could see a Ana/Det/Bos/Tor playoffs, but everything would have to go right for Toronto. The AL is ridiculously loaded this year.

i think if this signing happens.i think the Jays lineup will be:
Eckstein
Reed
Wells
Thomas
Gluas
Rios
Overbay
Hill
Zaun

What happened to that four year deal? Some of the concessions on these recent contracts have me puzzled.

probably wants to prove himself that he deserves a 4 yr so he took a 1 yr deal

"Little albino piece of crap," as the first poster called him, is the classic overachiever. He should be appauded not denigrated. Also, just think...all you would have to do is change his skin color and you would be called a racist!

I like this move for serveral reasons, but Eck is a great SS so you can't go wrong. I like the price, and it's obivous he's gonna try to have a solid year to rebound next off season for a better deal.

As for Johnny Mac, we have to consider the chances that if Troy's name appears on the Mitchell report... then Jays might start him at 3rd decent chunk of the first month or two.

if Rios is still on the Jays i doubt hes hitting 2nd. hes more likely to hit 5th behind Thomas. id prefer to have Rios hit 3rd and Wells hit 5th, but i dont think the Jays do that.

with Eckstein on board the 1-2 spots will likely be either Johnson/Eckstein or Eckstein/Johnson.

Someone remind me to congratulate Ed Wade on the Kaz Matsui signing next time I see him.

After Iguchi and Eckstein both sign for 1 year and $5 million or less, Matsui's contract looks even more terrible then before. Don't know if Eckstein would have wanted to play 2nd, but $10 million over 2 years might have convinced him otherwise and his defense probably would have been pretty decent at 2nd. His .295/.355 lines will be much better than Matsui's. Same goes for Iguchi.

Can't believe the Cubs weren't in on these guys after losing out on Matsui. Why 3 teams were chasing Kaz (Rockies, Cubs, Astros) but there was so much less interest in Iguchi and Eckstein really confuses me.

"Perhaps the Jays can go for some kind of offense/defense platoon. If a groundballer like Jesse Litsch or Jeremy Accardo happens to be on the mound, the Jays could opt for defense."

So Eckstein gets to play when Marcum is on the mound? The rest of the Jays staff is HEAVILY groundball oriented.

Reed shouldn't be batting 2nd. I'd toss Rios 2nd and move Reed down the line, probably to 7th or 8th.

having Rios that high in the lineup would move alot of the offense at the top of the lineup .Rios at 5th or 6th is better

I think this signing may put Reed Johnson's role with the jays in jeopardy. Not expecting the Jays to get Eckstein I thought Johnson was going to be platooned with Matt Stairs when righties and lefties were on the mound with Johnson getting the majority of time because he is better defensively and the Jays needed a lead off hitter.

With Eckstein the Jays have a proven lead off hitter and Stairs will likely spend the majority of time in the number two slot in the order because he is the only other left handed hitter beyond Lyle Overbay.

Maybe this will make Johnson expendable in a trade involving adding more starting pitching/ bullpen depth & the jays could sign Kevin Mench to a one year pact to pair with Matt Stairs in a decent lefty/ right mashing pair.

God damn it !

I hate Geekstein, and now i have to watch him every game.

This is brutal news ! They should have used that cash to get some pitcher, or , i don't know anything but this !

I still think the Jays should try to trade Glaus to the Angels straight up for Figgins. Picture this line-up "if Healthy":

1. Figgins
2. Eckstein
3. Rios
4. Thomas
5. Wells
6. Overbay
7. Stairs/ Johnson (or Mench as I suggested earlier)
8. Hill
9. Zaun

"Also, just think...all you would have to do is change his skin color and you would be called a racist!"

That goes to the point that many have made that he gets so much hype, and credit because he is white. How "gritty", "grinders", and "gamers" always seem to be not that talented white guys.

ya i think the jays should trade Glaus as soon as they can because of this Riods stuff

Why would the Jays need Olivo vs. Lefties, Zaun has hit .302 vs. lefties from 05-07?

funny how someone mentioned Accardo and Litsch as the groundballer examples on the Jays.. Yea, they are groundballers bigtime..

But Halladay, Burnett AND McGowan were all like top 10 in all of baseball in terms of groundball pct.. disgusting isn't it??

Jays have insane groundball pitchers... 3 of the best in their rotation, and a few more in the pen.. ryan coming back too.. oh.. and League.. bigtime sinkerballer, throwing sinkers at 99mph..

the Jays defense was also the best in baseball last year, and even with Ecks, it would still be the best.. Glaus is the only downfall... and of course Zaun's spaghetti arm..

is there any rumors about the glaus for figgins? cause that would be a sickkk trade

has the jays and angels even talked about that possible trade? if so than the jays will turn into more of a running team and you will even see wells steal alot more bases.
The Jays could deffinetely be world series contenderes this year!:)

well Gluas was rumored to get traded to LAA but no LAA players were named

I love all these "I hate Eckstein" statements. I mean, is that how you build your baseball team? If you *like* the guy or not? Last time I checked, that doesn't help you win games.

This is an extremely solid move for the Jays. The take an auto out and turn him into a very viable resource w/o taking much of a defensive hit. With his decent onbase skills and speed, a healthy Jays lineup should be able to plate him 100+ times. The AL East should be looking very interesting next year with a ramped up Rays team and a healthy and improved Jays team.

No, there were no rumors for a Glaus for Figgins swap but it just seems to make perfect sense for both clubs.

The Angels are obviously swiming in cash, so the 13 million a year he is owed for the next few years is not a problem. The Angels, even with the addition of Tori Hunter do not really have that big bat in the line up to protect Vladamir Guererro. Glaus was cleared by MLB for the steroid allegations so that should not be an issue and Glaus would surely waive his no trade clause to play for one of the league's superpowers and play on the west coast again.

For the Jays, they have no on on their roster who is a big threat on the bases (Wells/ Rios arguably). They have plenty of big bats to produce RBI's even with the subtraction of Glaus, in Overbay/ Stairs/ Rios/ Wells/ and Thomas, but they never have anyone on base.

I think if this trade were to actually go down, the Jays would have to look for a new manager. John Gibbons dosen't seem to have the ambition to take his hands out of back pocket and send a signal for anyone to steal bases.

It's certainly a strange move being that Mac is such a good shortstop.But Eckstein is a winning player and he is a spark plug and maybe this is what this organization needs to get to the next level.I think the playoffs might be NY/Tor/Anaheim/Cle and it might finally be Toronto's year.I can't wait to see Eckstein hit a leadoff homerun off of Mr 7 ERA at Fenway ,Santana, if he becomes a Sox!

All this inflied help seems like a backup plan in case one of the infielders get injured again.The Jays don't need a repeat performance of last year!

alot of people seem to be confident that not only Stairs starts in LF but that he can repeat his 07 numbers.. im not so sure. i think its more likely Stairs comes back down to the numbers he had in 2006, 2005, 2004.
im guessing Reed Johnson will be the starter in LF, pushing Stairs as the LH bat off the bench. that favours the Jays more than having Stairs start and Johnson coming off the bench.
Johnson and Eckstein are good OBP guys at the top of the order for the rest of the order Wells, Thomas, Rios, Overbay, Glaus, Hill, and Zaun.. who walks alot and can get on base to turn the lineup over for the top of the order.

no there will be no johnson. Lind is ready to take over the starting role. Any money says johnson is traded for a decent pitcher like i said before.

"I love all these "I hate Eckstein" statements. I mean, is that how you build your baseball team? If you *like* the guy or not? Last time I checked, that doesn't help you win games. "

Neither does David Eckstein. Can't field, can't throw, can't hit, but he's a gamer. Wait he's been averaging 120 games a year the past two, so he's not even that.

the safe move would be to keep Johnson starting in LF and leading off, while keeping Lind in AAA.
the Jays have a team that can contend on 2007, and Johnson/Eckstein make a nice 1-2 combo at the top of the order to get on base for the other hitters.
Lind's not going to get ruined spending another season at AAA.

your not going to get much by trading Johnson. if the Jays wanted to trade for a pitcher to compete for the 5th spot youd have a better shot at trading Lind and bring in a quality pitcher rather than some fringe pitcher whos not that good.

now if Rios ends up getting traded for a star type pitcher THEN i could see Lind in LF with Johnson in RF ..but with Rios in RF, Wells in CF, i see Johnson staying in LF

ArodSucksAtLife did you happen to even look at the stats? cant hit?
i post the stats again..
07- .309 AVG/ .356 OBP
06- .292 AVG/ .350 OBP
05- .294 AVG/ .363 OBP
he hits and he gets on base.. which is what you want from someone at the top of the order.

maybe you were confused and looked at McDonald's stats, because theres someone who cant hit.. which is why Eckstein was signed.

07- .382 SLG/ 93 OPS+
06- .344 SLG/ 81 OPS+
05- .395 SLG/ 99 OPS+

career avg:

.286/.351/.362 89 OPS+

Who can't field, can't throw, isn't fast or smart about when he runs. Who was less valuable to his teams chances of winning than John McDonald last year and cost 4.5 million dollars.

The Blue Jays could just bring up Sergio Santos from AA/AAA and he would provide the same value for the team as David Eckstein.

David Eckstein has no business being on a major league roster making more than league minimum. His on the field performance can be easily replaced or at least closely matched by a minor leaguer. You are basically paying 4.2 million dollars for a perceived grittiness or veteran leadership. That is just not a smart move when you are trying to compete with the Boston Red Sox and the New York Yankees. Teams that have the financial flexibility to pay 9 million dollars for a SS with a negative VORP.

Wait a second, um Sergio Santo's hits about the same as John MacDonald does, with 1 glaring exception, he's in AAA. Personally I would of rather seen a 2 year deal, since the jays have no one coming up behind him now.

Seriously tho ArodSucksAtLife did Eckstein nail your wife or something? I mean really wtf's yer deal.

a side note tho, a lot of fellow Jays fans seem to be saying this move puts us in the playoffs or something. I agree it improves our chances but I think its still going to take some luck.

ARodsucks, you are simply a moron for posting slugging stats for a leadoff guy. You think they hired him for his ability to drive in runs. He gets onbase and is fast. That's all they need out of him. McDonald simply blew at that. Jays have more than enough rbi power. If things don't pan out for the Yankees "future hall of famer" young arms, they'll be sucking wind in 3rd behind the Jays.

Johnny Damon

career BA .288
onbase .353
slugging .433

Yea, I guess both Damon and Eckstein suck. Neither has any business being on a major league roster.

"a side note tho, a lot of fellow Jays fans seem to be saying this move puts us in the playoffs or something. I agree it improves our chances but I think its still going to take some luck."

Sorry Blue Jay fans, you actually have a fantastic team, but you don't stand a chance. Considering that the Angels will probably win the West, the Tigers win the Central and the Red Sox win the East, that'd leave the Indians, Yankees, Blue Jays, Twins, and Mariners to fight for the wild card. Sorry but in a league so stacked with good teams, you're probably the 6th or 7th best, which won't get it done.

Good move for the Jays. According to Tim McCarver, Eckstein is the best player in baseball (besides Derek Jeter of course).

Assuming the offence comes back healthy next year, Toronto is a better team than both Seattle and Minnesota and I do not see how everyone is so high on the Tigers who although will have a juggernaut of an offence, still have no bullpên to speak of and a very unproven rotation.

Since I am a Jays fan, assuming everyone is healthy next year, I predict a Boston, Toronto, Cleveland, Anaheim playoff.

I do not consider the Tigers a playoff threat for the above reason that I mentioned and if the Yankees do not land Santana then the younger players will still need another year to adjust to the big leagues in my opinion before they can be fully dominate which opens up a window for Toronto.

dominant*

Will not make a bit of difference. Whatever they do they will finish 3rd, conunt on that.

actually, what I said makes complete sense and could happen,

Don't get how anyone can hate Eckstein. All he's ever done is win.

And for those pushing to move Troy Glaus to the Angels, I'd be surprised if that happened. They parted on bad terms... the Angels upset with him for electing to have surgery during his final season in Anaheim, when they believed he could tough it out and have off-season surgery. They believed Glaus made the choice to enhance his free agency at the expense of the team.

And Arte Moreno has so publicly condemned steroid users, it's unlikely he'd acquire anyone named in the Mitchell report.

Pretty awesome that David Eckstein is considered "pure offense". I feel bad for the Jays.

For everyone who is saying they feel bad for the jays, do not. Toronto does not need slugging, we have Frank Thomas, Troy Glaus, Alex Rios, Vernon Wells, Aaron Hill, Lyle Overbay, Matt Stairs, and Adam Lind who are all sluggers and can all hit 20+ home runs.

Toronto had a problem that was fixed with a cheap signing of David Eckstein for his lead off abilities incase Reed Johnson is not able to return to his 06 form and at the same time making a significant offensive upgrade at shortstop.

If you do not see why this move was so good for the Blue Jays then you do not understand their organizational needs, simple as that.

A bad signing is Kaz Matsui for the Astros, not David Eckstein for the Blue Jays.

Um, Bunk I agree with you about Eckstein, but it's hilarious that you just made the same mistake with your Matsui analysis. The Stros are getting Matsui for the exact same reason the Jays are getting Eckstein -- good on base and speed. I just have to wonder, how on god's green earth did you do that?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment


Top Stories



Search MLBTR

Lijit Search

MLBTR Features



Recent Posts


MLBTR Mailing List

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Rumors By Team



Monthly Archives


Live Chats


Tuesdays at 2 p.m. CST



Site Map     Contact     About     Advertise     Privacy Policy     Widget     Twitter     Rss Feed


MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com.