Entries for MLB Trade Rumors’ annual Free Agent Prediction Contest closed on November 13, with 4,604 different readers submitting their choice of landing spot for each of the offseason’s top 50 free agents. This year, we’re going to provide another fun resource for reference purposes — which teams were the most popular choices for each of the 50 players.
As you might expect, the bigger-spending teams got a lot of attention, though 21 of the 30 teams were the top choice for at least one free agent. (The Rockies, Cardinals, Pirates, Nationals, Astros, White Sox, Guardians, Royals, and Twins were the only teams not listed as a top choice.) Of the six players who have already signed, the plurality or majority of contestants correctly identified that Josh Naylor, Raisel Iglesias, and the qualifying offer-accepting quartet of Brandon Woodruff, Trent Grisham, Shota Imanaga, and Gleyber Torres would remain with their 2025 teams.
The most popular choice of all 50 players was Bo Bichette returning to the Blue Jays, with 81.5% of contestants predicting a reunion. This narrowly edged out Kyle Schwarber (79.9%) and J.T. Realmuto (76.1%) re-signing with Philadelphia, as readers are confident that the Phillies will retain those two veteran bats, but there is far less of a consensus about the chances of Ranger Suarez (13.2%) returning to Philly. Eight percent of readers predict Ryan Helsley to the Marlins, which represented the lowest top choice of any player in the top 50.
- Kyle Tucker: Dodgers (39.9%), Yankees (17.8%)
- Bo Bichette: Blue Jays (81.5%)
- Dylan Cease: Red Sox (20.9%), Cubs (17%), Mets (13.9%)
- Munetaka Murakami: Mets (20.3%), Mariners (17.4%), Dodgers (16.7%)
- Alex Bregman: Red Sox (37.3%), Tigers (30.3%)
- Framber Valdez: Giants (18.7%), Mets (14.2%), Orioles (10.2%), Cubs (9.8%)
- Tatsuya Imai: Dodgers (20.2%), Mets (13.7%), Giants (12.7%), Cubs (12.6%)
- Cody Bellinger: Yankees (61.2%)
- Kyle Schwarber: Phillies (79.9%)
- Ranger Suarez: Blue Jays (13.2%), Cubs (12.7%), Phillies (12.3%)
- Pete Alonso: Mets (35.8%), Red Sox (29.6%)
- Josh Naylor: Mariners (72.6%)
- Edwin Diaz: Mets (38.1%), Dodgers (23.2%), Yankees (10.2%)
- Michael King: Orioles (14.5%), Padres (12.3%), Yankees (11.8%)
- Zac Gallen: Diamondbacks (26.3%), Giants (10.4%), Angels (8.1%)
- Devin Williams: Dodgers (23.3%), Mets (9%)
- Brandon Woodruff: Brewers (30.3%), Mets (18.4%)
- Trent Grisham: Yankees (25.9%), Angels (13.2%)
- Kazuma Okamoto: Dodgers (11.6%), Padres (10.9%), Mariners (10%), Angels (9.9%),
- Eugenio Suarez: Mariners (18.7%), Reds (17.5%)
- Robert Suarez: Dodgers (15.7%), Mets (13.7%), Blue Jays (7%)
- Shota Imanaga: Cubs (22.1%), Angels (11.6%)
- Jorge Polanco: Mariners (37.7%), Royals (7.8%)
- Chris Bassitt: Blue Jays (30.8%), Braves (15.7%)
- Merrill Kelly: Diamondbacks (38.5%), Rangers (7.3%)
- Brad Keller: Cubs (15.6%), Braves (12.2%), Yankees (11.6%)
- Lucas Giolito: Red Sox (21.1%), Orioles (9.6%)
- Ha-Seong Kim: Braves (45.4%)
- J.T. Realmuto: Phillies (76.1%)
- Ryan O’Hearn: Marlins (18%), Padres (8.4%)
- Harrison Bader: Phillies (15.6%), Royals (11.9%), Guardians (8.8%)
- Raisel Iglesias: Braves (24.3%)
- Nick Martinez: Reds (9.6%), Padres (8.7%)
- Luis Arraez: Rangers (12.2%), Padres (9.1%), Angels (7.4%)
- Zack Littell: Angels (12.9%)
- Ryan Helsley: Marlins (8%)
- Gleyber Torres: Tigers (59.4%)
- Justin Verlander: Tigers (29.1%), Astros (18.2%), Giants (18.2%)
- Cody Ponce: Brewers (11%), Cardinals (10.1%)
- Kyle Finnegan: Tigers (28.1%)
- Luke Weaver: Yankees (17.4%), Cubs (9%)
- Tyler Rogers: Mets (16.1%), Orioles (13.2%), Giants (13.1%)
- Seranthony Dominguez: Blue Jays (25%)
- Pete Fairbanks: Dodgers (12.9%), Cubs (9.3%)
- Gregory Soto: Blue Jays (14.3%)
- Emilio Pagan: Reds (28.8%)
- Tyler Mahle: Athletics (8.9%), Rangers (8.5%)
- Max Scherzer: Blue Jays (33.2%), Giants (14.4%), Tigers (11.9%)
- Victor Caratini: Rays (22.3%), Astros (11.9%)
- Willi Castro: Padres (10.6%)
