With Luis Arraez having departed for San Francisco on a one-year deal yesterday, it’s now official that the Padres will have a new face at first base this year. As noted by Jeff Sanders of the San Diego Union-Tribune, Gavin Sheets figures to get the first crack at the position for San Diego this year.
Sheets, 29, turned in a decent performance in his first year with the club last season. Across 145 games, Sheets slashed .252/.317/.429 with a wRC+ of 111. Sheets’s overall production was dragged down by atrocious defensive numbers in the outfield, however, and it’s possible that a return to his natural position for the first time since he was a farmhand in the White Sox organization (where he was blocked by Jose Abreu, prompting his ill-fated move to the outfield) could help him recoup some defensive value and build on 2025’s solid offensive numbers to become a more well-rounded contributor.
While improved defense as a result of moving from the outfield to first base would be helpful, it won’t fix the hefty platoon split Sheets had last season. He posted a 119 wRC+ against righties while struggling to the tune of an 89 wRC+ against same-handed pitching. That difference was mostly seen in the power department; Sheets slugged 17 of his 19 homers against right-handers in 2025, as well as 37 of his 48 extra-base hits overall. Getting a right-handed complement to Sheets in the door would make plenty of sense, with Paul Goldschmidt, Ty France, and Rhys Hoskins among the right-handed first baseman still available on the market.
Such an addition could also factor into the DH mix, which has been unsettled by Sheets moving over to first. Offseason signing Sung Mun Song and youngster Will Wagner could both factor in at the position, though they’ll also get the opportunity to handle some first base duties behind Sheets as needed. Song’s versatility as an infielder capable of handling first, second, or third base creates an opportunity for the DH slot in the lineup to be used to rest regulars at other positions. Manny Machado, for example, could get days to rest at DH while Song fills in for him at the hot corner. Xander Bogaerts could also see time at DH, with Jake Cronenworth capable of giving him a breather at shortstop as needed.
Sanders writes that utilizing the DH to rest regulars is part of the plan for newly-minted manager Craig Stammen, but Annie Heilbrunn of the San Diego Union-Tribune also relays that president of baseball operations A.J. Preller has not ruled out the possibility of a meaningful addition to the DH mix. If the Padres were to sign a platoon partner for Sheets, that player could surely factor into the DH mix against right-handed hitters while spelling Sheets at first when a lefty is on the mound, thereby opening up DH to rest veterans like Machado and Bogaerts.
With all that said, it’s at least plausible that the most important signing the Padres make in the coming weeks is with Preller himself. While Preller acknowledged to reporters (including Heilbrunn) that he hopes to add players who will impact the roster in the coming weeks, as he has in previous years when making additions like Nick Pivetta and Dylan Cease late in the offseason calendar, he also noted that his focus on the roster has caused his own contract status to fall to the wayside.
As relayed by Heilbrunn, Preller told reporters that an extension ahead of his final season under contract not yet being in place is partially “on him,” and that while the sides have not yet reached a “win-win deal” he hopes to have something in place soon. That’s a different tone than was struck by reporting back in November, which suggested that Preller was in talks on a new contract with the club and that a deal could’ve been just days away. That obviously did not come to fruition, and now it seems at least plausible that Preller could enter 2026 without security about his future.
It’s an especially precarious position for San Diego’s front office leader to be in considering previous reports of behind-the-scenes tension between Preller and club CEO Erik Greupner. It will be worth watching Preller’s status until an extension is revealed, as he would surely be a coveted talent for rival franchises around the league if the Padres were to decide to let him go. Preller took over in San Diego in the final weeks of the 2014 season, and while the Padres have only made the playoffs four times under his leadership, the team’s body of work over the past six seasons represents the most successful stretch of baseball in franchise history.
