Carlos Lee Rumors: Sunday

Yesterday, we learned a deal is on the table for the Dodgers to acquire Carlos Lee and cash from the Astros for pitching prospect Garrett Gould. All that is needed is for Lee to approve the trade. Here's the latest:

  • The Dodgers have pulled the plug on the Lee trade and will look elsewhere for a bat, tweets Jon Heyman of 
  • Sources tell's Buster Olney that Lee has not changed his mind since Saturday and won't agree to a deal (via Twitter).
  • Lee told reporters, including Brian McTaggart of, that he still hasn't made a decision and admitted the weight of trying to decide whether to accept the trade to the Dodgers or stay in Houston has been difficult. McTaggart writes several of Lee's teammates feel he wants to remain with the Astros.

74 Responses to Carlos Lee Rumors: Sunday Leave a Reply

  1. bigpat 3 years ago

    No offense to Houston, because I do think they are doing a lot of good things with their new regime, but why should this be much of a decision? They probably won’t re-sign him anyways so why not go to a division leader and try to get them in the playoffs? I guess first basemen named Lee are very stubborn. 

    • If you looked into it a little more, Carlos Lee has made a home in Houston, he probably doesn’t want to leave so quickly, even if it is for a few months.

      • $1631560 3 years ago

        Three months???? Is he planning on retiring this year? Silly, but as posted above, we don’t want him anyway.

        • thegrayrace 3 years ago

          He’s a free agent after this season, regardless of whether he stays in Houston for the next few months or not…

      • letsgogiants 3 years ago

        I understand that Lee doesn’t want to leave Houston due to the fact that he owns a cattle business there. But what player would give up the opportunity to play in the playoffs? And especially in Lee’s case, he’s only been in the playoffs once in his career, and that was back in 2000. Isn’t it every player’s goal to go to the playoffs and play for a world series ring? It should be, at the very least.

        • slider32 3 years ago

          I agree, any player worth his salt would go.

        •  Not Carlos. He’s a bum and a slob and he only shows up to collect his paycheck. He’s late a lot and reporters are always saying how they see him texting on his phone at his locker 15 minutes after everyone else has started practice. He doesn’t care about winning or the playoffs or anything, he just wants to makes his money and putz around on his cattle ranch.

      • coolstorybro222 3 years ago

        Jeez, people act like the players can never return to the city after they get traded. 

  2. longlivethecool_a_coo 3 years ago

    Good let him stay where he is ……last thing we need is another aging player that has lost his power .I know he can hit for average but we need more power and run production out of first base

  3. thenubigbaddblue 3 years ago

    This very good news to me. Stay, we dont want you! VETO!

    • Dustin Baugh 3 years ago

      Well me and many other Astros fans really don’t want Lee anymore. He’s really not a bad ball player, it just seems he’s being far too selfish. Compared to Berkman and Oswalt, but then again they actually liked to win.

      • mrsjohnmiltonrocks 3 years ago

         You know, I can’t really agree with the selfish tag.  He signed a contract; he asked for and was given a no trade clause.  I’m not going to penalize a player for wanting his contract terms honored.  Houston should have considered they may want to trade him some day way back when they agreed to the no trade clause, and should consider the mistake here is on them.  Lee is apparently content to honor the terms of the contract he signed.  It is his right to do so.

        • James L. Carlson II 3 years ago

          That was actually by the old regime and not the current owner and GM.  Purpura back then should never have had the title GM.  He cost us alot of players and draft picks.  Drayton McClane wasn’t much of an owner.  So the current owner is stuck with prior Owner and the GM’s mistake.

        •  nooo i think this guy is pretty selfish.  This guy has no real desires to play baseball anymore.  He is overweight season after season.  He only wants to stay so he can be close to his ranch.  He has a chance to win, but doesnt want to deal with any real scrutiny.  I’m hoping someone will sign him and we will get a comp pick

          • NickinIthaca 3 years ago

            If he doesn’t want to leave to help a team in the thick of a playoff race, I’d assume he’s not going to want to leave in the off season. Do Astros fans think it’s at all possible he either stays in Houston (on a much smaller contract) or retires, and considers those his only options?

  4. vtadave 3 years ago

    As a Dodgers fan, I don’t understand why people don’t want this deal. Sure, Lee isn’t the guy he was a couple years ago, but aren’t you tired of James Loney and his lack of production? I know I am.

    • $24144853 3 years ago

      Yeah we are tired of Loney. But at least Loney has great defense. With Carlos Lee your getting an ageing bat with no defense. We all want someone to replace Loney but getting Lee just seems like such a desperate move.

      • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

        It is a desperate move, but these are desperate times. How many more shutouts can you stand to watch? If Lee does come, Loney is not gone but moved into a more situational role. I think this is an okay stopgap move, but not if Lee keeps doing his Hamlet act.

        • $24144853 3 years ago

          Your right. I guess i never thought of it that way. I assumed Lee’s coming to L.A would mean Loney’s ultimate departure. I guess i just felt like we could weather the storm till the all star break, but like you said I dont want to see another shut out.

        • lakersdodgersyankees4life 3 years ago

          With everything that has happened, we are……. 1 game back. Holy crap! Call in Carlos Lee to save the day! He’s a marginal offensive upgrade, in the he gets singles instead of pop outs. It’d be nice, but not worth a very good prospect. We are one game back! Chill

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            As much as I’d like to chill, scoring like five runs in three weeks is not a sign that everything is going to be just fine. I don’t know if Lee will “save the day” all by himself, but I think it’s beyond obvious that this lineup is in need of a shakeup.

          • lakersdodgersyankees4life 3 years ago

            Of course it is. No duh. But Lee really isn’t an improvement. If it was 3 years ago, itd be a totally different story. We need offense. Yes. But if the guy doesn’t want to be here AND isnt all that great beside battig average, what’s the point to give up a prospect who could be used to get someone younger, more controllable and better?

          • thenubigbaddblue 3 years ago

            totally agree, glad this deal seems to be close to dead. 

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            I’m all for it if and when that perfect player turns up, but we can’t wait forever. I think that is pretty clear.

          • thenubigbaddblue 3 years ago

            what are your guys thoughts about Headley from the Pods? 

          • vtadave 3 years ago

            Who wouldn’t love that? Still, it would probably take a massive overpay – Zach Lee, Gould, and more considering it’s a supposed rival.

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            Not to mention, under team control for three more years.

      •  oddly enough, Lee is a pretty good defensive 1b.  I do understand why the fans dont want him though

    • thenubigbaddblue 3 years ago

      As i do grow tiresome of Loneys bat, his D is awesome. To be honest i would much rather sign Derrick Lee, give him three weeks to get back into shape, and save the prospects for someone who is a major upgrade at third. This would only cost money, which is what the Blue have most. C Lee doesnt want to win or he would have jumped at the opportunity to be on a contending team, we dont need someone with that attitude. He is also on a massive decline…….THAT is the reason i dont want him. Just me though

      • Mike C. 3 years ago

        With All Star Break upon us, D. Lee will only miss about 15 games over the next three weeks as he gets ready.  Heck, D. Lee could step on the field tonight and be the Dodgers best hitter with the journeymen, minor leaguers, and bench guys in their lineup. 

      • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

        The “doesn’t want to win” thing gets old. Ballplayers are people too. They often like their situation even it isn’t ideal in every respect. If Lee says he likes playing in Houston and want to stay there, as another human being, I get it, and respect it. That’s what Kuroda did last year. The part that bugs me about Lee is that he doesn’t seem to know what he wants. At this point in his career he should know.

        • thenubigbaddblue 3 years ago

          “ballplayers are people too.” Very true indeed. Just saying if he doesnt jump on the opportunity to win, I would prefer not to have him. I would think plenty of dodger fans including yourself would agree…..i hope. The fact that he is hesitant is a big mental red flag.

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            I’m not sure if it’s a “mental red flag.” Kuroda really wanted to play out his contract in LA last year, and you could see at the end how much that meant to him personally. Then he went to New York and is playing his heart out there, so staying had nothing to do with the illusive “desire to win” thing. Lee’s been a pro long enough to know what it’s like to change your situation in midseason. I think dawdling over the decision is unfair to both clubs.

          • thenubigbaddblue 3 years ago

            Personally i believe Kuroda’s decision to stay was more do to his culture and loyalty. Lee is a professional, but a aging one. I bet he would have jumped at the idea of being traded when he was 30, but he is now 36, 6 years can make a big difference.  I believe he is to be set in his ways and wants nothing more than to be comfortable. 

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            Culture, loyalty, it’s all part of a comfort zone. I’m not saying a player should not have a comfort zone, but that by a certain age he should know what it is.

          • I think it strictly has to do with the fact that he wants to stay near his ranch.  I dont think this guy rly cares much about baseball anymore.  Look at his weight.  He still knows how to hit, but does no type os athletic maintenance

    • Mike C. 3 years ago

      Probably the fact that he will be paid like a superstar, cost a decent prospect to acquire, and is only marginally better than James Loney.  Loney probably has his annual six to eight week solid run in him.  Based on Lee’s road numbers it is probably only 60/40 that Lee will outperform Loney from now to the end of the season offensively.  Defensively it is a big downgrade. 

      Plus adding Lee clogs a spot where, maybe, just maybe a better player becomes available in the next month.  

  5. Mike C. 3 years ago

    Never have the fans of two organizations every been in more agreement…

    Fans of the Houston Astros do not want Carlos Lee 

    Fans of the Los Angeles Dodgers absolutely do not want Carlos Lee

    The only two people who want Carlos Lee are Ned Colletti and Carlos Lee’s mother…

    Stay on your ranch in Texas Carlos, Please!  

    • vtadave 3 years ago

      I guess I’m okay with this, as it can’t be all that hard to go out and find a 1B upgrade that is on par or better with what Lee brings to the table. I personally would rather have him than Loney, but either way, no big loss.

      • b00tz 3 years ago

         Agreed. Lee would be a huge upgrade over Loney, but the Dodgers are looking for salary dumps, because they don’t want to give up our prospects.

  6. As an Astro fan, it would be nice to move Lee. Lee has always been an RBI machine. He would help the Dodgers immensely. I can understand why Lee would veto this deal, however I believe he will be dealt before the deadline to someone. I’d hate for it to be to 1 of the teams that’s competing for a wild card berth with L.A. Lee doesn’t have a lot of range but has only 3 errors. Fielding % is .995. That is not shabby.

  7. Joe310 3 years ago

    Why don’t they call up Josh Fields?

    • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

      Because he has hammer hands and can’t hit major league pitching?

      • Joe310 3 years ago

        And Uribe is raking right? He can’t get a hit if you put on a tee. That guy rerrachea for everything.

        • he is up there cuz of his contract

        • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

          At least Uribe can play his position. Fields is a fence post with a glove, and he still can’t hit. He isn’t stuck in the minors at his age for nothing.

        • and also if you havent noticed Fields is playing in the PCL that doesnt translate well in the majors . slyke and Castle were and are both racking at triple A and they havnt done anything up here. Why does fields deserve to be up there? He is not even on the 40 man roster so that would mean they’d have to remove someone off it and they are not gonna do that for him.

          • vtadave 3 years ago

            Yeah I’d hate for a guy like Adam Kennedy to be waived to make room for Fields. Oh wait… :-)

          • umm what position does Fields play?? oh thats right 3b ONLY. What position does kennedy play or should i say POSITIONS!! does versatility come to mind? have you realized we short of players especially in the infield as much as i hate kennedy we need him right now he can actually play more then one position. :) -__-

          • Joe310 3 years ago

            Actually Fields plays 3b, 1b, OF

          • true but majority at 3rd 48 games i rather have kennedy he play anywhere other then catcher ofcourse 😉 

          • vtadave 3 years ago

            Do you realize that Kennedy can’t hit or play defense any more? Did you see that play at 2B tonight?

            Just becaue the team rolls him out there at multiple positions doens’t mean that he has any value. It’s more desperation than anything.

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            And all of them equally poorly.

  8. mgsports 3 years ago

    Rangers then.

  9. I hope Lee stays in Houston. I really don’t want Houston getting any prospects whatsoever since they will be moving to the AL West.

  10. Carlos Lee just helped the Dodgers keep $9m and a b prospect.

    Can he be the next GM?

  11. Lets go thru a quick list of the Dodgers options now.

    Mark Reynolds.. maybe
    Billy Butler..elite hitter, not an elite fielder. Not sure if available
    Justin Smoak.. not sure if available
    Derrek Lee..old and not sure if he can hit NL West pitchers
    Mike Morse from the Nats?
    Mark Trumbo.. doubt he’s available
    Justin Morneau?
    Gaby Sanchez?

    I can’t really think of anyone else who is out there and is major league ready.
    I never understood though as to why they liked Carlos Lee in the first place.
    Unless, they thought he was the only one available, I find that hard to believe though.

    • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

      I think you answered your own question.

    • vtadave 3 years ago

      If Trumbo is available, then so are Trout, Harper, etc… so he’s not.

      Nats are very competitive, so they won’t be selling Morse. Butler would take a massive overpay I think.

      • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

        With Lee off the table then Butler might be the next opportunity. Under contract for the next several seasons, and much younger, he’s another situation entirely. Unless the trade market for him is very strong (and the given the level of interest in Youkilis and Lee, I’d say not) then “expensive” seems more like it. He could be a long term solution not just a stopgap and that comes at a price.

        • vtadave 3 years ago

          Given that Butller (unlike Lee/Youkilis) has upside and is cost-controllable, he’drequire significantly more in a deal than those guys.

          Lee and Gould would just be a starting point.

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            Absolutely, I agree, and he’d be appropriately more costly. But I don’t see a “massive overpay” necessarily because the market for him wouldn’t be huge. The price is going to depend on the competition and I don’t see who else is going to be in the market. All theoretical at the moment, but I hope the Dodgers are at least talking to KC.

    • thegrayrace 3 years ago

      Forget about Morse and Trumbo, they aren’t going to be moved.

      But Edwin Encarnacion might be a possibility.

      Corey Hart or Aramis Ramirez if the Brewers decide to sell.

      Josh Willingham.

      And if the Phillies decide to sell, what about Chase Utley? He’s not exactly cheap and is getting up there in age.

      And of course Alfonso Soriano, but the Cubs would have to eat a huge chunk of salary.

  12. Dodgerbluez 3 years ago

    Sad to say but I would much rather have Vernon Wells .240 avg over Lee. Went to yesterdays game wow very depressing. Other then the meet and greet with the players on the field pre game. It was pretty painful. 

  13. there not going to pay all of lees salary, read the post.

  14. monty4aloha 3 years ago

    I would trade him to someone not on his no trade list even if it meant no prospcts and pay all his salary . maybe he will retite mpay all the salafy

  15. Lunchbox45 3 years ago

    your comment is based on assumptions and lacks a personal knowledge of Lee and his family which makes it completely unfair

  16. Mike C. 3 years ago

    Where’s the Beef?  

    That’s right, just a short drive from Minute Maid Park.  That is why Lee is staying in Houston.  He has a cattle ranch and cuts his own steaks.  He is good for two or three a night…

  17. BWillie 3 years ago

    Yay!  We get…to keep……Carlos………..”sigh”

  18. BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

    Then he should know that already and not keep everyone in suspense.

  19. BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

    Check out my other posts on this topic. I am not a fan who forgets this. No matter, apparently the Dodgers have made Lee’s mind up for him.

  20. monty4aloha 3 years ago

    Yes, I will give you that point. Still if I was the Astros G.M. I would sit down with him and say
    “I am the
    Astros G.M.” And we want to start building a winning team and you will not be in the future. And we will be looking at other younger players to see if they might have a future with the Astros like Bret Wallace. I would also tell him that the Astros will 1. try to trade him to a team not on the no trade list 2. only use him for spot starts and or pinch hits 3. Or release him 4. Just ask him to retire.

  21. lefty177 3 years ago

    Yes he has a half season left but if you think about it, for that half season if he gets traded somewhere he would basically be living somewhere for a max of a few months, that’s not fun to do

Leave a Reply