Phillies Discussing Victorino Trades

The Phillies are trying to trade Shane Victorino for bullpen help, Jim Bowden of and MLB Network Radio reports (Twitter links). They realize they'll have to pay part of his $9.5MM salary to facilitate a trade. 

The Dodgers and Reds continue to talk to the Phillies, according to Bowden. The Phillies are interested in a Victorino for Logan Ondrusek swap or a Victorino for Josh Lindblom deal, Bowden reports. The Pirates and Yankees have also been linked to Victorino. The Orioles like Victorino as well, Roch Kubatkoā€¸ of reports (on Twitter).

93 Responses to Phillies Discussing Victorino Trades Leave a Reply

  1. lindblom for victorino? i prefer hunter pence

    • Tmandolfan 3 years ago

      And I’d prefer to live in a palace and be served grapes by smoking hot babes half my age. Not everybody is selling at 10 cents on the dollar like the Marlins are. There isn’t a team in baseball that couldn’t have cobbled together a better package than two stiffs with losing records for Hanley that the Dodgers landed him for.

      • nm344 3 years ago

        Nobody else wanted any part of Hanley with his full salary. Dodgers are wasting money left and right.

        • vtadave 3 years ago

          Yeah because upgrading from the great Juan Uribe is a bad thing? Fail of a post.

      • vtadave 3 years ago

        I’d settle for smoking hot babes 75% of my age, but that’s just me. I’d even live somewhere a step down from a palace if that were possible.

        • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

          The worst part about it is, he’s only 22.

          • txftw 3 years ago

            I’m glad someone made that joke, it needed to be done

    • While you’re at it, we’ll throw in Hamels and pay for 90% of his contract.

  2. TophersReds 3 years ago

    Apparently the Reds already turned down the Ondrusek for Victorino deal. We have a lot of bullpen depth, so that’s kind of weird to turn it down.

    • grant77 3 years ago

      19 walks and 25 K’s in 36 innings for Ondrusek. Amaro isn’t the sharpest tool in the shed, but I doubt he is stupid enough to go after him as anything more than a throw-in.

    • First Bleed 3 years ago

      seems like the Reds covet Ondrusek a little too much.. RP can be replaced.

    • Jacob 3 years ago

      From what John Fay said, he suspects Philly wanted Ondrusek and a prospect, which is why the Reds balked. They’d be crazy not to take Ondrusek for Victorino straight up, especially when you can bring Hoover back from Louisville and basically have the same numbers you get from Ondrusek.

    • I can see a Stubbs, Gregorius and an MLB RP for Pence and cash coming to the table at some point by July 31st.

    • RMR 3 years ago

      I believe it’s not just talent but an issue of money as well. Adding a few million bucks is no small thing for the Reds.

  3. Victorino would have to play LF because of Kemp and Ethier at CF and RF

    • thegrayrace 3 years ago

      Kemp and Ethier are both capable of playing LF. Might be a good thing for Kemp to avoid re-injuring the hamstring.

      • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

        More likely Ethier goes into left, but given what we’ve already got in LF I don’t see much point in Victorino. Better defense, yes, more speed, yes. But otherwise, not a real upgrade. Lindblom is more useful than the difference between Victorino and Rivera.

        • thegrayrace 3 years ago

          Agreed. I’m not a big fan of this trade proposal with Victorino putting up a .700 OPS. Hunter Pence would be worth Lindblom (and more), though.

    • nepp 3 years ago

      Well, Vic is a better defender than either of them so one of them would move.

  4. I would give them Lindblom and another prospect for pence.

  5. grant77 3 years ago

    Getting Victorino for a replaceable reliever would be a coup for either team.

  6. mgsports 3 years ago

    To the Nats with Mark M. coming over from the Red Sox?

    • johnsilver 3 years ago

      Might be just as well taking Matty Albers, Padilla or Mortenson. Boston would flip Victorino themselves, or then move Ellsbury though. They don’t need him.Boston ATM has too many relievers and Bailey is about to come off the DL

  7. Tacho Bill 3 years ago

    The Pirates offered my favorite RP, Jared Hughes, and a MiLB player for him. I hope we keep Jared. He’s so intense!

    • bigpat 3 years ago

      I must admit I’d be a little bummed if I have to see Hughes’ maniac expressions and excessive tongue waging in a different jersey. I would have been happy with that deal though.

      • Josh Conn 3 years ago

        Agreed… but the Pirates leadoff situation and lack of bench depth is close to desperate status. I would not at all like to lose Lincoln or Hughes… but I would get over it if Victorino comes to Pittsburgh and benefits from the change in scenery. I guess I am on the fence with this.

        • bigpat 3 years ago

          I don’t think their bench is too bad it’s just that Hurdle doesn’t use them. They have no LH bat off the bench when Presley and Jones start. Hurdle had the tendency to start a guy a few games in a row then just completely forget about him after that. Did it with Harrison, Hague, Sutton, and even Mckenry to an extent. Mercer was never given a shot.

          Not sure what they are going to do but things may have gotten a little simpler since Marte got called up. I am also on the fence with Victorino, it’s a tough call.

    • Jeff Snedden 3 years ago

      I would be very unhappy if the Bucs traded Hughes or Lincoln for Shane Victorino. Both are very intense, high quality bullpen arms that are just at the tip of their potential. Once the Phillies come to their senses and realize they are out of contention for 2012, perhaps they would make a deal for one of our major league ready AAA starters. If Hughes/Lincoln are in a deal for a Phillie, it needs to be Hunter Pence and include a bunch of cash coming with him.

      • if pirates were to get hunter a top outfielder would be in the deal no pence for crap we paid alot for him we wont sell cheap mccutchen would have to come our way sorry.

        • Jeff Snedden 3 years ago

          There isn’t 5 Phillies that I would accept in a trade for Andrew McCutchen, and that include Lee/Halladay/Hamels/Pence/Schmidt/Ashburn/anyone.

        • yeah, 3 Hunter Pence’s alone couldn’t get Cutch away from pittsburge

  8. Just say no to Victorino, especially if it costs Lindblom. LA fans do not want the cryin’ hawaiian.

    • grant77 3 years ago

      You can trade some junk prospect for a guy like Brandon Lyon and not miss a beat in the bullpen, while upgrading the outfield.

      • Or Dodgers can send some quality prospects to get Pence and really upgrade the outfield. Victorino isn’t that much of an upgrade.

        • Phillies_Aces35 3 years ago

          I don’t see a deal getting done (at least hopefully) without getting Zach Lee or Allen Webster back in a deal for Hunter Pence.

          I’m not sure I’m all that high on a lot of the Dodgers prospects. They have some good arms but they’re not that different from anything we already have in OUR system.

    • nepp 3 years ago

      Still bitter about ’08 & ’09?

      • Nope, not bitter at all. He’s a whiner. Don’t want.

        • Max Power 3 years ago

          Yeah – crazy of him to prefer to get hit in the midsection instead of the head like has been done for 100 years. What a whiner.

          By the way, Jonathan Broxton was neat. xoxoxoxo

  9. DempseyK 3 years ago

    Pirates offered hughes and a minor leaguer as a counteroffer to the phillies requesting brad lincoln. happy that we quickly said no to that deal. lincoln is the future closer in pittsbhrgh, is cheap with a few years of team control remaining and is just an absolute bulldog out of the pen. hopefully amaro comes around and does the deal for jared and a minor leaguer.

    • Josh Conn 3 years ago

      Jared Hughes has been very impressive so far this season. I like Victorino, but the Phils would be doing just fine if they were able to get Hughes in return.

      • Nick Paradise 3 years ago

        Bryan Morris? I think he has a good chance of having some stellar MLB years. And he’s young and cheap. It’s not like the Phillies have a shot at this season.

    • pence for mccutchen that sounds good what you think

  10. relievers for an outfielder? lolwut

  11. TommyL 3 years ago

    The Dodgers just added a bullpen arm (Choates) in the Hanley Ramirez trade. They can afford to trade a reliever for another bat.

    • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

      So where’s the bat? Victorino isn’t an offensive upgrade over Rivera.

      • vtadave 3 years ago

        Rivera is sub-replacement level while Victorino has a 2.1 WAR. Now I know a lot of that is due to defensive value, but I’m pretty sure Victorino would still be an offensive upgrade.

      • TommyL 3 years ago

        I disagree and I think their stats bear that out. Plus, he’s an upgrade defensively. Rivera continues to platoon with Loney, occasionally spells one of the outfielders and provides power off the bench.

        • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

          Victorino: .253/.318/.388/.706
          Rivera: .256/.294/.370/.664

          The difference is marginal at best, and isn’t worth Lindblom IMO.

          • Max Power 3 years ago

            Except one of those guys is normally better then that. And if you take a look, Victorino has heated up lately. He looks like he’s returning to “normal”.

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            Not so much. Career numbers:

            Rivera: .275/.325/.444/.769
            Victorino: .276/.342/.433/.775

          • Phillies_Aces35 3 years ago

            You’re improving your outfield defense by shifting Kemp or Either to left field (plus, removing Abreu/Rivera) and improving the lead off spot in your order.

          • Max Power 3 years ago

            If you take away the parts of the game where Victorino excels (speed, defense, switch hitting) then they look even. But….they’re not. Juan Rivera has no position, Victorino’s a gold glove defender at a premium position. Victorino is a 30 SB guy, Rivera has 17 career steals. Rivera’s got terrible postseason numbers, Victorino has excelled in the postseason compared to his regular season. I know going with a simple slash line to compare career numbers of a power hitter vs. a doubles guy suits your point, but you can’t ignore other factors.

          • BlueSkyLA 3 years ago

            I already acknowledged that he upgrades in the speed and defense departments, but that’s not really where the improvements are really needed. That was my point.

  12. The Reds will NOT make any moves.. Chemistry on this team should not be disrupted, we have the best bullpen in MLB, a top 3 pitching staff and the best defense in MLB, and an offense that is starting to get HOT, leave this team alone

    • oz10 3 years ago

      technically Washington has a better bullpen. Better ERA and a lot more holds.

      • You wanna look again.. 2.48 ERA, best in MLB..

        • oz10 3 years ago

          Sorry, meant runs per game which includes inherited runners, they are third in that which is a more telling stat.

  13. Jorden 3 years ago

    Lindblom for an unimpressive rental…No thanks.

    Lindblom + for Pence and we’re talking.

    • randyfastman 3 years ago

      unless that “+” is Zach Lee, nobody is talking

  14. Victorino seems a perfect match for the indians who have lots of relief pitching and who need a guy who can hit LH pitching.

  15. Lindblom is way to valueable to the Dodgers

  16. Dodgerbluez 3 years ago

    Lindblom for Pence. .270 avg with 17hrs would be a nice upgrade in LF. No Victorino OVERRATED always has been.

    • Hasn’t ALWAYS been, but yea, he is for sure on the decline. Young reliever would be a nice return.

      • Dodgerbluez 3 years ago

        2011 the guy batted .279 17 Hrs 60rbis 19sb and was a allstar?? and got MVP votes???.. Doesn’t make sense to me I just hope the Dodgers do not trade for him.

        • how the hell is that considered overatted. most teams would kill for an outfielder to put those numbers up with great defense

          • Dodgerbluez 3 years ago

            Yeah those are Def MVP type numbers.. lol. He got more MVP votes with those numbers then Players like. Beltran, Cargo, Holliday, Berkman, Pence.. and so on and so on.. All their numbers absolutly crushed Shanes. In all categories. . That is called being overrated..

  17. mcody28 3 years ago

    i dont see why a team wouldnt want to trade a reliever for a a 3 time gold glover and 2 time allstar if they are trying to win it. relievers are very replaceable where a quality outfielder is harder to find

    • thegrayrace 3 years ago

      Victorino’s numbers thus far on the season are not that hard to find. Actually, a reliever putting up Lindblom’s numbers is arguably harder to find than an outfielder with a .700 OPS.

      Teams would be betting on Victorino improving his performance over the final 2 months of the season. It is a gamble.

      • mcody28 3 years ago

        yes he isnt hitting great but .700 ops is league average and his defense is definetnly above average. i would take the gamble for a cost of a reliever. he also raised his ops by .036 his last 10 games. you also got choate which does make it easier to trade lindblom. you traded a pretty good young starter for the gamble ramirez hit better idk why you wouldnt risk for victorino.

        • thegrayrace 3 years ago

          Because 3B has been a far bigger weakness for us than any of the OF positions. And Hanley’s OPS is 50 points higher than Victorino’s.

      • V is a sparkplug . He is having an off year but his career record is better and his D is excellent I hate to see him go!

    • That outfielder is a free agent this offseason and having a down year. That is why. Also there is a reason teams are always looking for good relievers this time of year. Because they are harder to find than you think.

  18. 1980CHAMPS 3 years ago

    Why trade for a non prospect when your team is not getting to the playoffs? Ruben Amaro Jr is such a horrible GM.

    • Scott 3 years ago

      Because a guy like Ondrusek is still under team control through 2016. That’s so horrible.

      • not_brooks 3 years ago

        That walk rate is trending the wrong way though…

        And if you’re dealing for an uncertainty, why deal for a 27-year-old reliever instead of a 20-year-old prospect?

  19. Indians should get in on this. Surplus bullpen should interest the Phillies. Start Victorino in center, then either move Brantley to right and DH Choo or DH Brantley to improve defense all around. Bench Hafner. It’s just time to admit he’s a failure and take him out of the lineup.

  20. as much as i hate victorino lol he is an upgrade defensively over abreu and rivera plus can hit at or the near the same as them and the guy has a winning attitude. For a reliever i would make that deal they just traded for a reliever and they have tons of relief help in their farm if lindblom cant get it done trade away some of those reliever prospects.

  21. Gunner65 3 years ago

    If they are looking for a two month rental, I’d rather the Reds go for Pierre than Victorino. Better avg, better oba, a lot cheaper contract. Only issue with Juan is that he is struggling vs. LHP this season which isn’t in line with his career numbers. But that can be mitigated by letting Stubbs/Heisey start against lefties.

    • Dodgerbluez 3 years ago

      Like J.P alot only problem runners will test him cause he does have a noodle arm

      • Gunner65 3 years ago

        I’d trade that for a .340+ OBA … Stubbs is a good defender no doubt about it … but our 1-2 hole hitters have been the biggest issue on the team. I’d prefer Span over both Vic & Juan, but the package to get him away from the Twins is too much right now

    • nepp 3 years ago

      Do the Reds not value OF defense? Pierre is terrible…even in LF.

      • Gunner65 3 years ago

        His fielding metrics are on par with our current LF (Ludwick) who is league average, so I’d say that is an exaggerated statement

  22. Hoosierdaddy92 3 years ago

    I’d love the Tigers to get in on Victorino. I have a feeling he might play better hitting in front of Miguel Cabrera and Prince Fielder. Also, I’d love his defense in LF/RF as opposed to CF. Tigers could move a bullpen guy like Villarreal for him. Villareal has electric stuff. The Phils could do worse for Victorino.

    • Heliosphan 3 years ago

      The only question is, why would Detroit trade their best setup guy during the stretch run? And when Andy Dirks returns, he can arguably match Victorino’s production.

  23. formerdraftpick 3 years ago

    The Pirates just called up Marte, so they may have given up on Victorino.

  24. We have X Paul as the LH OF off the bench, we are waiting for Mesoraco to become the 4 hole hitter and we are waiting for B Hamilton for the lead off role, the Reds and Jocketty are developing and building a franchise. We upgraded the pitching staff with Latos, Marshall, Simon and Hoover, now this winter we will add another bat to the lineup. We start 3 rookies and are 17 games over .500 and in 1st place. We have the best defense and BP in MLB and are 3rd in overall pitching staff. Our prospects are climbing the ladders and we are stockpiling talent for the next few years, we are fine with what we have

  25. hamilton would be coming to philly if vic goes to reds mark my words

Leave a Reply