Yanks Could Be Shopping For Outfielder Soon

Some in the industry are already wondering if the Yankees could be in the market for outfield help soon, writes Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports

Both Randy Winn and Marcus Thames have struggled this spring, though Thames officially made the club's Opening Day roster today.  The club may find themselves uneasy with the two veterans as starting left fielder Brett Gardner is not yet an established major league hitter.  They would be especially thin in the outfield if Curtis Granderson or Nick Swisher are bitten by the injury bug.

Rosenthal writes that the Yankees figure to be more patient with Winn as he is more than four years removed from playing in the AL.  

The Yankees investment in Winn and Thames amounts to just $2MM combined.  Rosenthal writes that if one or both struggle, and Gardner also stumbles out of the gate, then the team could be seeking an outfielder quickly.

111 Responses to Yanks Could Be Shopping For Outfielder Soon Leave a Reply

  1. all this really means is that they’ll be shopping for crawford earlier. no need to mention any details

    • Guest 5 years ago

      Yes! Either that or they’ll swoop up BJ Upton once he pisses the Rays off with his “lazy” play.

  2. fightinghellfish 5 years ago

    Brandon Moss is available

  3. phil79 5 years ago

    Brandon Moss

  4. jbigman 5 years ago

    I think they’ll wait awhile and see if Gardner, Thames, Winn hit but a cheap alternative but with relatively poor defense could be Hank Blalock.

    • EdinsonPickle 5 years ago

      Are you suggesting Blalock play LF? Yikes.

      • jbigman 5 years ago

        I like Gardner to keep the starting job but like Blalock’s upside & versatility (OF,1B & 3B) over Winn & Thames.

        • EdinsonPickle 5 years ago

          He does have some upside, but he can barely play first base, so there is no way he can play left. Besides Blalock isn’t a starter anymore. He just isn’t that good. The Yanks would be better off filling the void some other way.

        • Guest 5 years ago

          Hank Blalock is not an outfielder.

        • Zack23 5 years ago

          Hank Blalock had a .277 OBP last year…. seriously.

        • Ray R 5 years ago

          Dude, what are you smoking? Blaylock in the OF? Besides, all he’s good for offensively any more is the occasional HR – and those come infrequently, these days. The Yanks would be better off with Dave Winfield coming out of retirement to play LF.

  5. ELIJAH DUKES!!!!!!!!!!!

  6. Robert Gaito 5 years ago

    A good example of east coast bias on behalf of baseball writers. “What if the Yankees lose two outfielders to injuries?” If any team loses two starting outfielders to injuries, and didn’t have viable minor league options, they would also be shopping for an outfielder.

    • Zack23 5 years ago

      Yankees camp has been too quiet for media members, they have nothing else to write about. Dont worry, if Gardner goes 0-3 tomorrow then you’ll see more people point to LF as why the Yankees wont win this year.

    • BoSoxSam 5 years ago

      But the Yankees are clearly going to have difficulty with Winn/Thames, plus Gardner needs more time. Therefore, what they’re saying is if -one- outfielder goes down, Swisher or Granderson, then they will have to scramble. If at that point, Winn and Thames are playing like they did in Spring Training, and they decide Gardner needs more seasoning (or comes up to play, and proves he needed more time by not playing well), then they are definitely going to be looking on the trade market. The reason this is news is because the Yanks are a competitive team, in fact one of (at least) the top three teams in baseball, if not the best, and they are one injury away from seeing their outfield implode. Obviously, barring injury, Granderson and Swisher’s strong production may make LF not as much of an issue even if Winn plays terribly. The point is just that if one of them -does- go down, one of the best teams in baseball will suddenly have two gaping holes in the outfield.

      • Zack23 5 years ago

        “and they are one injury away from seeing their outfield implode”

        What team isnt?

        • bebopster 5 years ago

          Seriously? Tampa Bay Rays.
          Arguably the Baltimore Orioles (because of Luke Scott/Felix Pie/Markakis/Adam Jones depth). and the Mariners.

          • Zack23 5 years ago

            Ok 3 teams arent screwed, the original statement still misrepresents the situation. Most teams are screwed if they have a major injury to a position.

        • BoSoxSam 5 years ago

          Okay, now I think you’ve begun nitpicking. My point is that their outfield is more fragile than most contenders, in that if they had an injury they would be having TWO players who are basically reserves starting. That’s not typical of every team. Plus, bebop already named some teams that wouldn’t implode, and I’d add the Rockies to that list. Maybe Red Sox, if it’s only one injury, simply because Hermida is the type of backup who could fill in and become a starter-quality player.

          • Zack23 5 years ago

            “My point is that their outfield is more fragile than most contenders”
            Gardner, Swisher and Granderson are more fragile than JD Drew and 37 year old Mike Cameron? How?
            What about BJ Upton being hurt/disappointing the last 2 years, and Desmond Jennings injuring his wrist for the 2nd straight year? (Not major injury right now but still)
            Carlos Quentin has a long history of injuries; and Alex Rios has a history of sucking
            Josh Hamilton breaks down, and Nelson Cruz never proved he can play a full season.
            So tell me how it’s “more fragile”?

          • bebopster 5 years ago

            What I was trying to point out before is that a competitor (the Rays) don’t have to worry about their outfield depth. Arguably the same with the Red Sox. Why dont they? Because they have minor leaguers that could fill in. Desmond Jennings anyone?
            I’m sure there are other teams that have better outfield depth, those are just the competitors that popped into my head. When 3 of the 4 teams in your division can suffer a loss to their outfield and you cant, that just doesnt look good.

          • bebopster 5 years ago

            Change minor leaguers to DECENT other options with upside.

  7. Guest 5 years ago

    BJ Upton!!!!!!

  8. switchhitingjesus 5 years ago

    Luke Scott could be an option.

  9. Guest 5 years ago

    I hope Gardy struggles early on. Not that I don’t like him, but that he is best suited as a super-speedy 4th OF/Pinch Runner. Also, if he struggles it becomes more and more likely that the Yankees find the need for one of my favorite players, BJ Upton.

  10. Rich_in_NJ 5 years ago

    Kind of an obvious point by Rosenthal, but they won’t be making an in season trade with the Rays.

    • Guest 5 years ago

      Usually they wouldn’t, but the Rays know that their window of opportunity is closing after this year with the probable losses of both Carlos Pena and Carl Crawford. If they start out a little slow, and the Yankees and Red Sox both jump out of the box well in April, the Rays might realize that they should just restock and get ready for another run in 2 or 3 years, while Evan Longoria is still in his prime years.

      Also, if BJ Upton does anything stupid, like gliding nonchalantly to a flyball and then dropping it, the Rays could just give up on him. They have already hinted in the past that they are quite annoyed with Upton’s attitude towards the game, and unless he starts out great, they might be done with him.

      Finally, the Yankees have some intriguing relief and catcher prospects that the Rays could really use. Players such as Austin Romine and Brackman, who are loaded with talent and are only 1-2 years away from the Bigs, could really help out the Rays in the future.

      The teams really do match up well and with the situation that the Rays are in financially, knowing this is really their last year with Crawford and/or Pena, this deal actually could get done.

      • 0bsessions 5 years ago

        What are you on? What potentially competitive team gives up and gets ready to ship out their players after April?!

        Do you know who was leading the AL East in early May last season? The Blue Jays. Last year’s World Series champion was in third place in their division at that point.

        You don’t consider restocking just over a month into the season if you’ve got the pieces to compete.

  11. I think this is all leading up to a trade for a rays outfielder, one of either Upton or Crawford. I think this also depends on how Johnson starts off the season, if both the DH spot and LF turn into easy outs by mid may, i can see them making a serious push for Upton or Crawford.

    • Guest 5 years ago

      Exactly. Thank you.

      I’ve been saying this for a while now.

    • Zack23 5 years ago

      Why would Nick Johnson turn into an easy out? He gets on base 40% of the time he gets up to bat

      • Him not necesarily becoming an easy out, but if he gets injured or something like that is more of what I meant. I meant easy out in the LF spot.

  12. Guest 5 years ago

    Rays get:


    Yankees get:


    • Yankees10 5 years ago

      No thanks.

    • Rich_in_NJ 5 years ago

      The Yankees can’t trade Romine until they know whether or not Montero can be an everyday catcher.

  13. Devern Hansack 5 years ago

    Jermaine Dye or Elijah Dukes?

  14. geolink2349 5 years ago

    Manny Ramirez by the Trading Deadline?

  15. vinnieg 5 years ago

    Wheres Montero going to play? First ? Locked up for 8 more years. DH? A-rod already needs a day off a week. What about Posada ? Maybe right field and make a switch like Willingham did a couple years back. Heres what I think they should do.

    Trade Montero and Mccalister for Grady Sizemore. Pop him 2nd in the lineup, make him your center fielder and put granderson in left.

    just remember this comment, watch it happen, just watch.

    • Jonathan Gallo 5 years ago

      Montero is a DH of the future. He is capable of hitting 40 HRs a season. So, I will not trade the 4th best prospect in baseball and one of our better pitching prospects for Sizemore, because Brett Gardner, might not be able to hit more than 5 HRs.

      • I completely agree, and I’m not trying to say Sizemore is a bad player, i think he’s one of the best OF in the game, but I don’t think that’s what the yankees would look into.

      • vinnieg 5 years ago

        glad you wont trade him, cashman will. montero has proven nothing. by the allstar break sizemore will have 1 1/2 years of control, so they will look to push him to get maximum value. And Montero to fill their DH or 1st is maximum value. You rarely see 1 for 1 deals anymore. But cleveland does have a history of them CC for Laport straight up.

    • Guest 5 years ago

      Will never happen. It is a decent trade, but the Yankees love Montero and truly believe he can succeed as a catcher. They also probably value Montero more than Grady at this point.

      • You gotta be kidding. Sizemore who is still under control and has proved himself as one of the best 5 outfielders in 2007-08 is worse than Jesus? Don’t get me wrong, I love Montero and his potential but he has not proven anything on ML level. It would problably Joba+Montero to net Sizemore.

        • Guest 5 years ago

          I wasn’t saying that Montero is better than Sizemore. It’s just that the Yankees see more potential value in Jesus than the do in Grady Sizemore, who has probably already reached most of his potential. Also, Grady Sizemore is showing some signs of decline over the past year and a half.

          That said, Grady is still a great player and probably much better and more proven than Jesus, it’s just that the Yankees love the potential of Montero.

        • vinnieg 5 years ago

          the yankees wouldnt look into the best defensive centerfielder when hes available? At the alstar break he will have 1 1/2 years left on his contract. The yanks will not be able to trade in the division for crawford. And need something now especially a bat if johnson cant stay healthy

          Personally i dont think the yankees could get crawford in free agency against boston. Boston will have Ortiz, Lowell, Varitek, possibly beckett and victor martinez contract off the books they will make a huge push for crawford.

          just wait and see. when it happens ill tell you i told you so.

          • Yankees420 5 years ago

            Beckett was extended for 4 years at 18MM per, so he gets a raise, Lowell and Ortiz will make up the DH so that will need to be replaced, the Sox probably want to re-sign Victor and he’ll get a raise, plus if Beltre underperforms they may need to get a new 3B, Oh and the most important thing is that they have no where to play Crawford, because Ellsbury, Cameron, and J.D. Drew are all under contract next year.

          • vinnieg 5 years ago

            beckett was not extended yet. They will make a push for crawford and will make cameron their 4th. or make JD their DH. and Martinez said he wont negotiate during the year so you better believe hes gonna be a free agent. And beltres option is 5 million which is so affordable that they will suck up a bad first year.

    • dizzle4 5 years ago

      I won’t dismiss that one so easily. It’s an interesting thought, a Montero for Sizemore deal. We’ll see how things are progressing at midseason, but it doesn’t seem that out there. I certainly wouldn’t be so sure of it as the poster, but it doesn’t sound crazy.

      • vinnieg 5 years ago

        how much longer of control does cleveland have over grady? 2 years right? your gonna see his name pop in trade talks alot.

        and no he will not catch for cleveland he will be their first basemen or dh after hafner

    • AZalltheway 5 years ago

      But don’t the Indians still have Lou Marson and Carlos Santana?

      • vinnieg 5 years ago

        i dont think he will catch. he will play first or dh after hafner

  16. Alldaybaseball 5 years ago

    Dye maybe, not the best defense, but could help.

    • Guest 5 years ago

      Dye is kind of similar to Marcus Thames right now. Obviously, he’s a little better offensively, but as you said, he is terrible defensively. Even though the Yankees would be trading because they feel like they need more offense, they probably would still want to get a guy that offers good offensive stats while still playing good defense. That’s why we traded for a guy like Granderson and defense (and obviously SPEED) is really the only reason Gardner is getting a chance.

      • Alldaybaseball 5 years ago

        Yeah agreed, Gardner or Winn could replace Dye late in the game though. Winn is kinda useless now to me, you? Especially if they trade or sign an outfielder.

  17. Yankees10 5 years ago

    Jermaine Dye

    • A washed up guy who can barely play the field. No thanks, I would rather have Yanks give Gardner a chance to prove himself in a full year.

      • Yankees10 5 years ago

        I never said he would replace Gardner. He would replace Marcus Thames or Randy Winn if they struggled. Also dont call him washed up based on only half a season.

        • Zack23 5 years ago

          Except Dye doesnt want to be a part time player, and he turned down ~3m from the Cubs earlier this offseason. He’s not going to be happy sitting on the bench.

  18. $2509879 5 years ago

    Gabe Kapler’s STILL PLAYING???

    I don’t see the need, unless Nick Johnson goes on the DL. With Dye and Dukes still out there as FA’s, no trade will be needed.

  19. pounder 5 years ago

    Josh Willingham.

  20. The only guys I can think of right now are Nelson Cruz and Shan Hoo Choo. It would take Montero to net Choo but Joba should be enough for Cruz.

    • Guest 5 years ago

      Nelson Cruz could be an interesting option. Although he will turn 30 in July, he really hasn’t had that much playing time before last season, so he is kind of a young 29.

      Could be a very interesting player in Yankee Stadium, hitting in a lineup with Tex, A-Rod and Jeter. Their great lineup would really give him some good pitches to hit, and he sure has shown some pop.

      The problem is that the Rangers probably would ask for Montero. There is no way the Yankees should trade Montero to get Cruz and they probably shouldn’t even trade Hughes or Joba either. If we could get him without using one of those three trade chips it would be a great solution for our lack of offense in LF.

    • Yankees10 5 years ago

      The Yankees would never trade Montero for Choo.

      • Why wouldn’t they trade Montero for a .300 AVG,489 SLG,.883 OPS player who hit 20 HR with 21 SB and is under team control?

        • Yankees10 5 years ago

          Montero is one of the best prospects in baseball and has 40 homer potential.

          • ..who doesn’t have a position in NY besides DH unless his catching improves. Choo is in his prime and is under a very team friendly deal, arguably the best player on the Indians.

          • Yankees10 5 years ago

            Ill start by saying that Grady Sizemore is the best player on the Indians not Choo. Not even close. Second the Yankees are not going to give up one of the top prospects in baseball for Choo it just isnt going to happen.

          • vinnieg 5 years ago


          • Yankees10 5 years ago

            Yeah… and?

  21. bomberj11 5 years ago

    You mean they might have to look at other options besides Crawford?! Why, that’s unheard of!

  22. This is more speculative than anything else. Gardner is an ideal 9th hitter as he is the epitome of a second lead-off guy–good OB skills, great speed, and a fantastic fielder. Let him actually “stumble out of the gate” before preemptively sending him off to the guillotine.

    • Guest 5 years ago

      Since when has Gardner had good on-base skills. The reason the Yankees could be shopping for outfield help is because they don’t believe in his ability to get ON BASE and use his great speed.

      • His .389 career OB in 1754 minor league PA’s is pretty good to me. Even his .345 OB for the Yanks last season is nothing to scoff at.

        • Guest 5 years ago

          I guess he’s not as bad as I thought. Still, he will definitely not match his .389 minor league OBP and probably won’t even get to .345. I say he stays more around .320-.330 which is not terrible but probably not good enough to satisfy the Yankees’ needs.

          • Any basis for your projection? Baseball Prospectus projects a .351 OB. I’ll take their projection over the one you pulled out of your backside.

          • Zack23 5 years ago

            “probably won’t even get to .345. I say he stays more around .320-.330 ”

            Why? Your first comment shows that you thinks he sucks and dont like him, but when presented with his stats you ignore them?

  23. godzillacub 5 years ago

    While a bit premature, with Colvin making the Cubs starting roster they could have an excess of outfielders, not quality outfielders, but outfielders nonetheless. Perhaps a trade similar to Abreu of a few years back where the Yankees take all of Fukudome’s contract and give the Cubs a middle reliever or a B level, aged prospect? If I was Hendry this would be something I’d consider.

    Fukudome in Yankee Stadium II would have increased power numbers and play stellar defense.

    • godzillacub 5 years ago

      Or just take Fukudome’s contract . . .

      • Zack23 5 years ago

        I dont like his .667 OPS v LHP

        • godzillacub 5 years ago

          Neither do the Cubs, that’s why the Yankees could have him for just the contract. He has good OBP skills that they’d need in a 9 hitter though and good to great defense in a corner spot. Spelling him against tough lefties would help too, perhaps with Thames.

  24. stl_cards16 5 years ago

    hold on here….all these comments about Montero? I thought Mauer was the future catcher for the Yanks? I’m so confused…….

    • Guest 5 years ago

      I’m taking it that you’re absolutely using great sarcasm. If so, lol. But if not you truly have been living under a rock. I really believe and hope that you are being sarcastic, but on the Internet people can sound pretty stupid when they try to be sarcastic.

  25. yankees101 5 years ago

    ok grady seizmore is a beast, however i dont see them trading montero after they just traded austin jackson. Also Brett Gardner is going to have a BREAKOUT season. let him play everyday but make a trade for someone like luke scott or jack cust as a bench play. the also need a player like gardner who can pinch run. maybe bring back freddy guzman?

    • Yankees420 5 years ago

      Jack Cust was DFA’d by the A’s so they’d just have to claim him.

  26. yankeeparrothead 5 years ago

    I know I am in the minority, but when I look at all the long term big dollar contracts the yanks have in place right now (and needing to re-sign Jeter and Mo after the season) I don’t see them adding any more for the next few years. ITs ties up too many resources and puts them in the situation they were in for a good chunk of the last decade with Giambi, Mussina, Pavano, etc. It leaves them with little flexibility if one of them gets old or injured. For that reason I don’t see a guy like Crawford being a likely addition. Upton might be more realistic, but I think they will look more for a low cost type guy.

  27. thomassnow 5 years ago

    Grady Sizemore

  28. thomassnow 5 years ago

    Grady Sizemore

  29. I doubt Kubel is available

  30. EdinsonPickle 5 years ago

    The Rockies aren’t going to be dealing Hawpe unless they struggle early and fall out of contention. He is a valuable piece to their offense and they won’t trade him unless they are sure they are out of the race.

    There is no chance Kubel goes. He is one of the more important pieces to the Twins line up, and I don’t think there is a chance in hell that the Twins would shop him, plus although he has the ability to play in the outfield he is primarily a DH.

    DeJesus is a more realistic option. I think if the Yanks needed to get something done then they could probably pry him away from the Royals.

    I don’t think the Yanks would bother with Kapler.

    I could see the Yanks going after a guy like Coco Crisp or maybe Corey Hart if Winn, Thames, and Gardner can’t hold the job.

  31. SWishers 5 years ago

    Taking Corey Hart off the Brewers hands could benefit both sides.

  32. Guest 5 years ago

    You are wrong. You are just looking at potential free agents.

  33. If they get the best offer from a team in the division, guess what… they’re going to trade him in the division.

  34. BoSoxSam 5 years ago

    I could see the Rockies trading Hawpe, for a couple reasons. One, he’s horrible in the outfield. I mean, his defense is just awful. With Seth Smith and Spilborghs both strong enough to start, they won’t drop too far by losing Hawpe. Plus, they can use the trade to either bolster another, weaker slot in the lineup, or their pitching. Not really sure on who the Yanks would offer, but I’m sure there is a possible trade there. Maybe someone like Mitre, or Chamberlain if he struggles AND Hughes doesn’t, plus…..yeah I don’t know after that. Hawpe is an important cog for the Rockies though, so it would likely take a lot. Now that I think of it though, the Rockies would be good trade candidates even if not considering Hawpe, with Smith and Spilborghs there. Having five legit outfielders is going to make them a prime target for the Yanks if they go shopping.

  35. edisonpickle, you don’t think the rockies will deal hawpe?????

    they can replace him with seth smith, who hit .293 with 15 homeruns in just 335 AB. i think the rockies wouldnt be losing sleep over the loss of hawpe.

  36. You’re wrong, what you’re saying doesn’t even make sense, if you’re getting the best deal from a team in your division, you do it, It doesn’t matter. I’m not in love with Crawford, this has nothing to do with him. If the bluejays got the best deal for Halladay inside the division, I find it hard to believe you think they would take a worse deal. Now if the deals were both equal, then yes they wouldn’t trade him to a team in their own division.

  37. Guest 5 years ago

    Dude, you’re the one with your head in the closet. If the best deal the Rays can get for either Crawford or Upton is from the Yankees (or the Red Sox, Orioles or Blue Jays, for that matter) they will surely do it. They know Crawford is gone next year and, as I said before, will not offer him arb, so why not trade him to whoever offers most. IMO that will definitely be the Yankees or Red Sox, who like him the most.

  38. BoSoxSam 5 years ago

    Never say never! But mostly I agree with you. The Rays are a very good team this year, and even with NY and Boston being FANTASTIC, they’ve got a legitimate chance of making the playoffs. I don’t think that they want to think about rebuilding quite yet. Now, yes, if they’re quickly near the basement of the division, and stick there for a month or two, they’ll have to consider it. But until then, I would be shocked to see them make an in-division trade. That team is too good to just start unloading.

  39. Guest 5 years ago

    Are you talking about Upton or Crawford. Because if its Upton, he’s not a free agent for quite a while. And if its Crawford you’re talking about, why wouldn’t they trade him if they’re struggling. There’s no way they will offer arbitration to him b/c if he accepts they are paying Crawford half of their payroll. Wouldn’t they rather trade him, instead of losing him for nothing, probably to the Yankees as well. Your basic point of never trading in the division is a decent one, but you really have to consider the circumstances in this case.


  41. EdinsonPickle 5 years ago

    I can definitely see Hawpe getting dealt after the offseason. I think he is due up for arb again, and his salary will once again rise. You bring up a good point with Smith and Spilborghs though. I don’t think Spils can start, but he is a terrific fourth outfielder and if Smith gets hot and proves he can handle Hawpe’s role everyday then sure maybe Hawpe could be dealt. The Yanks would probably throw Gardner into any deal with the Rockies.

  42. Guest 5 years ago

    No problem. That dude is absolutely insane. He thinks he knows a lot about baseball, but really he knows nothing. Maybe in a normal circumstance his comments would be relevant, but considering where the Rays are, all trades are a possibility for them. In the first month of the season they probably will not be trading within the division, but later on, if they are, say, 10 games behind in early May, any great value trade for Crawford or Upton would be accpeted, from any team.

  43. Guest 5 years ago

    You are right, he’s not. Larry is just looking at potential free agents and isn’t really thinking about whether they are available or not.

  44. Zack23 5 years ago

    Hawpe has a 10m club option for the 2011 season, if they deny it he gets a 500k buyout and he’s a free agent. He’s not due arbitration, but they can offer it to get draft picks in return.

    Except Hawpe is one of the worst defensive RFs over the last few years, so he doesnt solve anyone’s OF problem.

  45. EdinsonPickle 5 years ago

    Ah I see, Thanks mate for clearing that up for me.

    If the Yank’s left field situation doesn’t work out I’m not so sure they’ll be worried with Hawpe’s defense. Plus he’ll be slotted in left field which is an easier position to play than left.

  46. EdinsonPickle 5 years ago

    I can see why they might move him and I see what you’re saying, but I just have a feeling that if they are contending they may not want to deal him. Maybe something like a don’t fix it if it isn’t broken type of situation.

  47. true, but i doubt they will re-sign him or even give him arb, so thats why i see the rockies shopping hawpe sometime this season

  48. Zack23 5 years ago

    I disagree, Cashman’s goal is to get younger and more athletic, which means better defense too. While LF may be easier, he’d still suck out there.

  49. EdinsonPickle 5 years ago

    Is his goal to get younger? This year alone he traded for a 34 year old pitcher, a 30 year old Center fielder, signed two outfielders over 34. That doesn’t seem to be getting younger to me. Nonetheless the moves Cashman has made have been pretty damn good so far, but I don’t think they care about getting younger so much. I see see your point about getting more athletic though, and it may impede any deal that is made. In the end though I think that they will make a deal if they get a chance.

Leave a Reply