Extension Candidate: Neil Walker

With Andrew McCutchen's extension completed, the Pirates will focus their attention on second baseman Neil Walker, according to Rob Biertempfel of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.  Biertempfel believes a Walker extension may be "pricier than they originally expected," but the team will still pony up.  What would be a fair deal for the 26-year-old Walker?

Icon_19095638

Walker currently has one year and 166 days of big league service, meaning he'll be arbitration eligible as a Super Two player after the 2012 season.  A direct comparable for Walker may be difficult to find, as few infielders with less than two years of service have signed extensions in recent years.  Walker is only six days shy of two years of service.  If we look at second basemen who signed extensions with between two and three years of service, we get Ben Zobrist, Dustin Pedroia, Aaron Hill, Ian Kinsler, and Robinson Cano.  Their contracts ranged from four to six years, guaranteed $12-40.5MM, and had at least one club option.  

Walker owns a .280/.338/.423 line in 1171 plate appearances across 286 games, with 24 home runs, 149 RBI, 138 runs, and 12 steals.  Kinsler's numbers through '07 are better, aside from RBI, but not wildly different.  Kinsler signed a five-year, $22MM contract that paid $13MM for his three arbitration years and $7MM for a free agent year, plus a club option on another.  The contract is four years old, however.  Zobrist seems another decent comparable.  He had much more service time than Walker, but a similar number of career plate appearances.  Zobrist trumps Walker's home run total and platform year but was similar career-wise.  But even coming off an MVP-caliber year, Zobrist signed a four-year deal worth $18MM with a pair of club options.  He received $14.5MM for his three arbitration years.

Neither Kinsler nor Zobrist was a Super Two player.  Walker must be compensated for four arbitration years, perhaps at $18-20MM total.  If the contract is to include one free agent season it'd probably be around $8MM.  A five-year, $27MM deal beginning with the 2013 season could be fair for Walker.  From the Pirates' point of view, Walker doesn't have the power or service time of Kinsler of Zobrist, perhaps justifying the inclusion of two club options for the Hendricks Sports client. 

Photo courtesy of Icon SMI.


7 Responses to Extension Candidate: Neil Walker Leave a Reply

  1. George Burns 3 years ago

     5 years 24-26 million seems like a fair deal for both sides.

  2. Lastings 3 years ago

    This guy really is a key for the Pirates and specifically their fan base. Very popular, down-to-earth local kid. Plus he could use the money to buy his own house, and not have to commute from his parents’ home. Lock him up Pittsburgh…

  3. WrigleyTerror37 3 years ago

    Get him locked up! I love watching him play, good guy and a stand up ball player!
    A piece the Pirates need for the puzzle long term

  4. ElGaupo77 3 years ago

    The implosion of Aki Iwamura and Andy LaRoche with no real backups in 2010 caused Walker to be a Super Two.   It also caused Alvarez to be brought up early which I think has really hurt him.

    • bigpat 3 years ago

       Oddly enough, I think their implosions were very vital to Walker’s success. Walker was starting to hang around in AAA for a while and wasn’t really hitting well enough to get rushed up to the big league club. He may not have gotten that shot if it weren’t for Aki getting cut. NH hasn’t shown much patience with the previous regime’s prospects, and if Walker played the whole year in AAA and was just ok, there’s a chance he may have been forgotten about.

  5. cubsfan97 3 years ago

    Yea, Id hate to have a batter have a low average of .280!  Sure, there are better 2B around, but hes 26, and has proven to be productive as a batter.  You cannot sit around and wait for the next Sandberg or Morgan.

  6. ImperialStout 3 years ago

    Not even a Bucs fan, but I’m LOVING the Pirates locking up their talent! 

Leave a Reply