Orioles’ Deal With Tyler Colvin Falls Through

JAN. 24: Jon Heyman of CBS Sports tweets that Colvin's physical revealed that he still has back issues, causing the Orioles to reduce their offer from a Major League contract to a minor league deal. As such, Colvin will not sign and remains a free agent. Heyman points out that Colvin can now seek a big league deal with a club, knowing that he can sign a minor league pact with the O's as a fallback (Twitter link).

JAN. 22: A source tells ESPN.com's Jerry Crasnick (Twitter link) that the Orioles found an issue with Colvin's physical, which could be creating an obstacle to the deal.

JAN. 15: The Orioles have agreed to terms with free agent outfielder Tyler Colvin, reports Dan Connolly of the Baltimore Sun (Twitter links). Only a physical stands in the way of the deal, Connolly says, which is believed to be a guaranteed MLB contract. Colvin, 28, is represented by Relativity Baseball.

The left-handed swinging Colvin has seen MLB action in parts of five seasons. In 2012, his first year with the Rockies, Colvin posted a promising .290/.327/.531 triple-slash in 452 plate appearances. But he took a step back last year, earning only 78 MLB plate appearances and registering a meager .160/.192/.280 line in the process. He continued to hit at the Triple-A level, however, slashing .275/.377/.480 in 269 trips to the plate for Colorado Springs.

Colvin started his career with the Cubs before heading to Colorado in the Ian Stewart trade. The 13th overall choice in the 2006 draft, Baseball America considered Colvin the game's 75th-best prospect after the 2007 season.

Colvin joins a long list of outfielders that will join the O's for Spring Training. (The Sun's Eduardo Encina counts 12, on Twitter.) Other offseason outfield additions include Delmon Young, Quintin Berry, Xavier Paul, David Lough, and Francisco Peguero.

100 Responses to Orioles’ Deal With Tyler Colvin Falls Through Leave a Reply

  1. JoeWantsPeace 1 year ago

    Quantity > Quality

    ~Orioles FO

    • FS54 1 year ago

      they do know that you can only have 25 men on roster, right?

  2. Lilstackhustla 1 year ago

    Acquire all marginal outfielders.

  3. Daniel Copans 1 year ago

    Only a physical stands in the way, huh? What could possibly go wrong?

    • $3513744 1 year ago

      my favorite comment of the day. perfect mix of humor and cynicism.

      • Daniel Copans 1 year ago

        Heh, looks like my cynicism was justified. God dammit Orioles.

        • $3513744 1 year ago

          well i guess it wasn’t cynical after all.

    • Mike1L 1 year ago

      Jeff Todd clearly has a wry sense of humor.

    • MagicalDiesel 1 year ago

      This is literally the funniest comment in the world right now. LOL

    • CG 1 year ago

      Your joke has turned into reality.

    • Rabbitov 1 year ago

      The O’s doctors are so good that they can find health problems that don’t even exist!

      • Michael 1 year ago

        They’ll discover it’s due to thumb prints on the x-rays. Then heads are going to roll.

  4. not_brooks 1 year ago

    Uh oh… Colvin doesn’t have a solid minor league OBP…

    What’s Duquette going to say about him?

    • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

      Maybe that he’s put up solid numbers in the majors when healthy?

      • not_brooks 1 year ago

        Outside of Coors Field? When?

        • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

          2010 in Chicago

          • not_brooks 1 year ago

            Oh right. Four years ago, when he hit .254 with a .316 OBP and a bunch of strikeouts.

            A guaranteed MLB deal for this guy is a joke.

          • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

            Way to overlook the .500 slugging and .246 iso

          • not_brooks 1 year ago

            Not really overlooking it. Everyone knows that Colvin can hit for power.

            The question is can he hit for enough average and get on base enough? At Age 28, after all the injuries and the horrible numbers outside of Coors last year, I don’t think so.

            And I’m not super excited to see my team throwing out guaranteed money to take a chance on a guy who shouldn’t get anything more than a minor league deal and an invite.

          • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

            It’s not like we’re in Garrett Atkins territory here.

          • not_brooks 1 year ago

            But we are in division title territory if we add the right pieces, and all we’ve added is a bunch of minor league fliers.

          • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

            Who do you want them to sign? Nelson Cruz? Kendrys Morales?

            No thanks.

          • Rabbitov 1 year ago

            I want them to sign a pitcher, a real pitcher, and ideally more than one. There are still plenty of good options out there.

          • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

            None of those guys are signing right now. They’re waiting for Tanaka to choose a team so they can shop themselves to the teams that lost out who may be hesitant to add them right now.

          • Andrew Ochs 1 year ago

            Corey Hart, Raja Davis, David Murphy, Kelly Johnson, Curtis Granderson,

            There were a bunch of guys out there that the O’s wouldn’t have to break the bank for that would of been just fine.

          • Rabbitov 1 year ago

            Atkins ::shudder::

          • jed_hoyer 1 year ago

            better than a mlb contract for you

        • Lefty_Orioles_Fan 1 year ago

          Actually, this may never happen!
          It sounds ominous about the physical!
          The word on the street is that Colvin has hang nail and dandruff!

        • calicub 1 year ago

          the problem with Colvin is that he does best when he gets regular playing time. Historically, with the Cubs, every time he lost any amount of regular playing time, his stats dipped dramatically.

    • Will Statter 1 year ago

      Has all the tools

  5. BeantownGreen 1 year ago

    The money is really starting to flow into buying quality free agents

  6. WrigleyTerror37 1 year ago

    Glad to see Colvin get another chance, he was one of my favorites. Cubs gave up on him to early. After getting the bat into his chest it would take a year or so to adjusts back to normal.

    also how many lh OF bats do the O’s have this year ?

    • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

      2 bats, but all the players have to share

    • Rabbitov 1 year ago

      I always saw Colvin as sort of a left-handed hitting Nolan Reimold, any thoughts on this?

      • OhthePossibilities 1 year ago

        Hopefully at least one of them can put their injuries behind them

      • WrigleyTerror37 1 year ago

        Never really thought about that, but that’s a great comparison that I never saw before. I’d say spot on tho id give Colvin the edge on defense.

    • Nashville_Os_Fan 1 year ago

      6 – Markakis, Lough, Borbon, Berry, Paul and now Colvin

      • Baloo 1 year ago

        I don’t think Borbon or Berry make the team.

        • Nashville_Os_Fan 1 year ago

          I would think no more than one of Borbon, Perry or Paul does. I don’t know that the choice among them is obvious.There are also RH OF Reimold and Pearce There not may be room for them if they keep Colvin and Young in addition to the three starting OF and Machado starts the season. . With Flaherty and Casilla as back-ups there would be room for 5 outfielders/DH types. Or if they keep Reimold, all three are probably gone

  7. FOmeOLS 1 year ago

    Be Still my heart…

  8. Will Statter 1 year ago

    This is so sad. I remember the Orioles when they were in the majors

    • Matt Bennett 1 year ago

      The Orioles have averaged 89 wins over the past two seasons. Yet, they aren’t even considered as “in the majors”?

  9. Kayrall 1 year ago

    Another former highly touted Cubs center-field prospect that fell out of grace that has joined Baltimore.

  10. raymondrobertkoenig 1 year ago

    Colvin’s now closer to the Hall of Fame.

  11. Rabbitov 1 year ago

    A major league contract? Why?

    • Lookouts400 1 year ago

      As much as I don’t see this as a bad signing, a major league deal is perplexing.

  12. Christian 1 year ago

    Looks like the other half to our DH platoon…Young/Reimold vs. LHP and Colvin/Urrutia against RHP…Could be worse, but I am excited to see how it shakes out during spring training. Only a few weeks to go!!!

  13. MasahiroTanaka 1 year ago

    why does this guy tank every other year?

  14. Jack Ball 1 year ago

    Come spring training it looks like the Orioles will be getting the other major league teams reserve outfielders ready for this season.

  15. Joe Valenti 1 year ago

    I think this is a solid move. He can play both corner OF spots and 1B. Might be a good bat off the bench, given his power.

  16. FrankRoo 1 year ago


  17. AlphaICaesar 1 year ago

    The Orioles found something wrong with his physical…shocking.

  18. Lefty_Orioles_Fan 1 year ago

    Any surprise here?
    Maybe the Orioles should set-up a program for all up and coming Doctors to finish their residency at Camden Yards, rather than a teaching hospital!

  19. Alpez16 1 year ago

    Not this again…

    • PittsburghPirates0022 1 year ago

      Do they find problems in every deal?

      • Manny Being Manny 1 year ago

        Angelos balks at any injury concerns after being burned on the Albert Belle deal 15 years ago.

  20. Manny Being Manny 1 year ago

    Here we go again.

  21. Jacob Viets 1 year ago

    So, Baltimore. I hear that Dylan Bundy has some arm problems and hasn’t passed your physical. We would be happy to take him off your hands for you. – Every Team in the Bigs

  22. RayHunt0917 1 year ago

    This smells of a post agreement veto.

  23. Shauntell 1 year ago

    2nd time this offseason. The probability that this will burn them down the road just went from likely to most probably…

    • not_brooks 1 year ago

      The Balfour situation already stinks due to his buddy docs talking about his shoulder and Olney later reporting that the O’s backed off due to wrist and knee concerns.

      This is completely unrelated, as it’s not at all surprising that Colvin might have some lingering issues after missing 60some games last year due to… wait for it… INJURIES.

      I don’t in any way support the way that the Orioles front office operates, but these things are being completely blown out of proportion.

      • Shauntell 1 year ago

        The problem is that they might have more trouble signing free agents. If a FA is offered the same amount of money by the Orioles and another team, this kind of thing could very well tip the balance.
        What player wants to take the risk of having everyone know he failed his physical & having to start finding another team again?

  24. AlphaICaesar 1 year ago

    Hi everybody!!!!
    Hi Dr. Nick!!

  25. DarkBob 1 year ago

    Issue should really be put in quotation marks.

    • RayHunt0917 1 year ago

      In Baltimore issue is spelled with an “A”…

  26. WazBazbo 1 year ago

    “Hi, I represent the Baltimore Orioles, and we’d like to talk about signing you!”


  27. Mike1L 1 year ago

    Why would free agents even start with these folk? Especially someone like Colvin, who has lost time finding a gig.

    • PittsburghPirates0022 1 year ago

      Maybe they will trade Chen if they find a problem likely not a serious one in his physical.

    • not_brooks 1 year ago

      He waited three months before the O’s agreed to a deal with him. I think he’ll be fine to wait another couple of weeks.

      And who says this deal is dead anyway?

      It’s not surprising that a guy who missed 60 games last year due to INJURIES might have some lingering issues. Maybe they’re just changing some language around.

      • Mike1L 1 year ago

        I can see that, but why offer in the first place? The organization seems to have an MO.

        • not_brooks 1 year ago

          They were right about Aaron Sele, as he broke down in what would have been the third year of the four year contract they offered him. Would have been nice to have him for the first two years though.

          They were right about Xavier Hernandez, who never pitched in MLB again after he failed his physical in Baltimore.

          They were right about Jeromy Burnitz, who didn’t make it through a full season in Pittsburgh after his agent didn’t like the medical terms in the proposed contract.

          They didn’t fail a notable player’s physical from 2007 through 2012, when they failed Jair Jurrjens, then restructured his contract. Jurrjens was healthy-ish during his time in Norfolk/Baltimore, but had a balky knee for most of the season.

          They failed Balfour, and his health issues or non-issues remain to be seen.

          They potentially failed Colvin, which shouldn’t come as a big surprise, considering how much time he missed last year.

          So, yeah. I guess they do have an MO. For failing players who aren’t healthy enough to live up to their proposed contracts.

          How is this a bad thing?

          • Mike1L 1 year ago

            I read an estimate that about 1/3 of all pitchers in MLB have had, at some time in their careers, Tommy John surgery. Any player has the potential for getting hurt–look at Mauer, or Brian Roberts, who was ostensibly healthy when the O’s gave him his large contract. Stuff happens. The MO seems to be that the physical is an opportunity to decide a second time whether you want the player. I’m not saying that doesn’t work for the organization–what I’m saying is that from a player perspective, it might not be terribly wise to agree with the Orioles because you have two hurdles-the physical, and the possible cold feet.

    • Meh Sheep 1 year ago

      It was a minor league deal anyway as corrected on the other story here. If he is taking a minor league deal chances are there was no real market for him anyway. Also to those saying the Orioles a failing due to second thoughts what would the purpose be if he was on a minor league deal anyway. They cut just cut him after spring training if they didn’t want him.

  28. bdiddy7 1 year ago

    Who didn’t see this coming?

    • not_brooks 1 year ago

      Right? Colvin missed, what, 60 games last year? Pretty easy to guess that he might still be experiencing some lingering issues.

  29. FS54 1 year ago

    unbelievable! why can’t they be like Reds who did not sign Grady?

  30. Tommets 1 year ago

    Tough luck for the Orioles this offseason.

  31. KINGMOJO 1 year ago

    Orioles are being the type of people that buy something from the store to only return it because they found out they don’t need it after all.

  32. Jeffy25 1 year ago

    Another back out by the o’s

  33. Jonathan T. 1 year ago

    First Balfour and now Colvin. This is getting trendy.

    • abes_seed 1 year ago

      I’m sure Colvin can get a gig with the Rays…

      • letsgogiants 1 year ago

        Sept. 18: Rays clinch a playoff spot in Baltimore as Colvin hits a go ahead grand slam in the eight, with Balfour getting the save to eliminate the O’s from the playoffs.

  34. Marky Mark 1 year ago

    I’d love to know what the Orioles physical test is like.. how come they’re the ONLY team to have two players not meet their standard on the physical?

    • PSUOrioles 1 year ago

      Don’t forget… same thing happened with Jair Jurrjins last season. He ended up signing a minor league deal

    • I Want My Bird 1 year ago

      I know what you’re saying but there was the notable Napoli situation last year with the Red Sox.

      • Marky Mark 1 year ago

        We all know it rarely happens, and the terms of that deal were way more significant.. I just know for a fact they colvin will be signed by someone to a major league deal and Balfour was already

        • snowbladerp14 1 year ago

          there seems to be a hold up with garza right after his physical was taken. They are saying its not the physical at the moment but it is rarely anything else

          • Marky Mark 1 year ago

            Looks like it wasn’t that lol all I’m saying is your not going to sign a guy on a 1 year deal cause of “back issues”?

  35. Chet Steadman 1 year ago

    i think they should give Ozzie Canseco a look.

  36. I Want My Bird 1 year ago

    I thought that agents were going to present the O’s with a physical right up front in the negotiations, so that it wouldn’t be ‘pending physical’ anymore.

  37. WhoKilledTheRallyMonkey 1 year ago

    At least the O’s are consistent

  38. pft2 1 year ago

    Any free agent would have to be nuts to consider the Orioles now. They seem to be in the business of trashing players market value. Perhaps they will be vindicated if Colvin and Balfour have physical issues this year, but for now…. I mean, I am pretty sure every player has physical issues if you look close enough.

    • Meh Sheep 1 year ago

      The Orioles didn’t even announce the deal. Someone leaked it to the media so had it not been leaked the results of the physical wouldn’t be out there.

  39. EarlyMorningBoxscore 1 year ago

    Seems like Dr. Spaceman is running the Orioles medical team these days.

  40. wadesawko 1 year ago

    Just kicking the tyres again….

  41. mas419 1 year ago

    Who’s going to want to sign with the Orioles now, seriously.

  42. DerekJeterDan 1 year ago

    This has been the worst Baltimore Orioles Offseason I can remember.
    They are definitely on my list of 2014 Offseason losers this year.
    And even putting it so bluntly is fair given how bad they have been with deals.

  43. signweety 1 year ago

    He was designated for assignment last year and nobody picked him up. If another team really believed his back was sound he would’ve landed somewhere. Does anyone really think he will get a major league contract? If the o’s should be bashed for anything it should be for signing so many fringe major league outfielders and going cheap on pitching.

Leave a Reply