Offseason In Review: Chicago White Sox

The White Sox made an early splash by signing a powerful 27-year-old Cuban first baseman, acquired a new center fielder, swapped their closer for a third base prospect, and tinkered with small-scale free agent signings.

Major League Signings

Notable Minor League Signings

Trades and Claims

Notable Losses

Needs Addressed

White Sox GM Rick Hahn explained his plan to Paul Sullivan of the Chicago Tribune in late October: "Obviously getting better quickly is the goal, but the final determining factor is whether it's going to make us better for an extended period of time. I'm not going to keep churning this thing every two years with short-term fixes. Eventually you have to pay the piper for that and we want to set up something that's sustainable over an extended period."  Hahn also made it clear in various offseason interviews that he felt good about the team's pitching depth and aimed to add position players.


It's no surprise, then, that the key moves of Hahn's offseason involved acquiring three position players.  Jose Abreu (pictured), Adam Eaton, and Matt Davidson are all in their 20s, with Abreu the oldest at 27.  Abreu is controlled through 2019, Eaton through '18, and Davidson through '19 or later.  The newly-acquired trio is Major League ready or close to it, as is summer acquisition Avisail Garcia.

As I explained shortly before the October signing, Abreu checks all the boxes for the White Sox: long-term value, a contract that isn't monstrous by typical free agent standards, and no loss of a draft pick to sign him.  Five teams offered $60MM+ for the Cuban slugger, but the White Sox prevailed with a six-year, $68MM deal that stands as the largest ever for an international free agent and the largest in team history.  The White Sox hope Abreu can provide 30+ home runs annually as their first baseman for the next six years.

The Eaton trade was struck during baseball's Winter Meetings, in a collaboration with the Diamondbacks and Angels.  The main piece the Sox had to surrender was 26-year-old southpaw Hector Santiago, who compiled a 3.51 ERA, 8.4 K/9, 4.3 BB/9, and 1.10 HR/9 in 130 2/3 innings as a starter in 2013 and remains under team control through 2017.  With Erik Johnson and Andre Rienzo coming on, the White Sox had the depth to spare Santiago, who still has to figure out command and home run issues.

Eaton, often described as a "dirtbag" type of ballplayer, comes with questions of his own.  The former 19th round draft pick exceeded expectations in the minor leagues, earning a cup of coffee with Arizona in 2012 and becoming a popular Rookie of the Year candidate for 2013.  However, that spring he sprained the UCL in his left elbow, and didn't return to the big leagues until July.  Eaton is 25 with only one healthy month in the Majors to his name.  The White Sox are gambling that he can be the scrappy consistent on-base threat with good defense that he appeared to be one year ago.

The third major pickup was Davidson, who was also acquired from Arizona.  The Sox snagged Davidson straight-up for closer Addison Reed, a 25-year-old with four years of team control remaining.  As MLBTR's Jeff Todd noted in his D'Backs Offseason In Review, Reed is not without his flaws, and the cost of saves in arbitration may cut down his years of team control.  Davidson, 23 this month, hit .280/.350/.481 with 17 home runs in 500 Triple-A plate appearances and picked up 87 late-season plate appearances with the big club.  Ranked 88th among all prospects by ESPN's Keith Law, Davidson "should be an above-average regular at third base given a season or two there to continue to progress."  If that is the eventual outcome, the White Sox did very well in acquiring Davidson for perhaps three years of a good (and increasingly expensive) closer.

The White Sox traded Jesse Crain and Matt Thornton during the season and Reed in the offseason, so the bullpen demanded fresh arms.  Hahn kept the commitments relatively light, exercising Lindstrom's option, and signing Belisario, Downs, and Boggs for a total of $12.1MM.  Belisario and Boggs were non-tendered by their previous teams in December, and the Sox can control them beyond 2014 if it makes sense.

Belisario and Boggs will be projects for renowned pitching coach Don Cooper, as will scrap heap rotation hopeful Felipe Paulino.  The 30-year-old last had significant time in the Majors in 2011, undergoing Tommy John surgery in July 2012 and shoulder surgery in September 2013.  When he was right, Paulino whiffed about a batter per inning and consistently worked at 95 miles per hour, and the White Sox could have the bargain of the offseason if they can get 25+ starts out of him.  The White Sox did at least look into a bigger addition for the rotation, Japanese righty Masahiro Tanaka.  After an exploratory meeting with the pitcher in January, the Sox made an offer that one GM guessed was around $100MM.  It doesn't seem that the Sox came close to signing Tanaka.  As with their crosstown rivals, potentially paying him $108MM over the next four years did not make sense, even if his ability and youth were worth a bid.

In a process that dragged into December, White Sox all-time great Paul Konerko signed on for one more year at a meager $2.5MM.  It was a sentimental signing of a limited player who fits poorly onto the team's roster.  As explained by Jim Margalus of South Side Sox in an excellent reflection on the move, "Even the most ardent Konerko supporters acknowledge that he's significantly compromising the roster, but they're writing it off as a fair sacrifice because of the alleged effect he has on others."  The signing reminds me of the Mariners bringing Ken Griffey Jr. back for the 2010 season, which didn't end well.

On the coaching front, the White Sox added hitting coach Todd Steverson in October, and extended manager Robin Ventura in January to avoid him entering 2014 in lame-duck status.

Questions Remaining

Despite the positive vibes from Rick Hahn's offseason, the White Sox still have a below-average collection of 25-and-under players and a farm system that Baseball America ranks 24th and Keith Law ranks 27th in the game.  The 2014 draft will continue pushing things in the right direction, as the Sox have the third overall pick and a bonus pool near $10MM.  Still, Hahn and company want to get back to contention quickly, and the team needs a good amount of work in the short-term.

The Sox never did address their catching situation this offseason, instead deciding to give the Tyler Flowers/Josh Phegley tandem another shot.  I've heard they had significant interest in free agent Jarrod Saltalamacchia, particularly if he could have been had on a two-year deal, but Salty wound up with the Marlins on a three-year pact.  The Sox picked up Adrian Nieto in the Rule 5 draft, but keeping a Double-A type backstop on the Major League roster all season would be challenging.

The acquisition of Eaton seemingly pushed Alejandro De Aza into a fourth outfielder role, for which he may be best suited anyway.  With a $4.25MM salary, De Aza might have more value to another team, and it's likely the Sox will continue to explore trades.  Then there's 25-year-old Dayan Viciedo, who hit 25 home runs in 2012 but slumped last year.  He's controlled through 2017 and could still be a long-term piece, but I imagine the Sox will be open-minded to trade proposals.

Chicago's middle infield tandem of Gordon Beckham and Alexei Ramirez has come up in trade rumors in the last year.  The disappointing Beckham has two years of team control remaining, while Ramirez is signed through 2015 with a club option for '16.  Ramirez is guaranteed $20.5MM over the next two years, his age 32-33 seasons.  His trade value could be limited by the continued availability of free agent shortstop Stephen Drew.  Both Beckham and Ramirez figure to frequent the pages of MLBTR this summer.

The White Sox have uncertainty at the back of their bullpen after the Reed trade, with Nate Jones the current favorite to close games in 2014.  The franchise hasn't put together a particularly strong bullpen since their 2005 World Championship season.  

Deal of Note

If an MLB team wants to throw a large, unrestricted sum of money at a player in his mid-20s, players coming over from Cuba and Japan are basically the only options.  The White Sox took advantage of the opportunity by signing Abreu.  At $68MM, his contract defied my expectations by a good 25%, but it still leaves room for upside.  Accounting for the cost of a draft pick, the Mets paid a similar amount for Curtis Granderson's age 33-36 seasons, a deal that strikes me as mostly downside risk.  If Abreu can provide the White Sox with 25+ home runs per year, a .340 OBP, and average defense, he'll easily be worth $11.3MM per year compared to continually rising market prices.  And certainly, there's some chance of Abreu's power translating to a few 35-40 home run seasons in the bigs.

It should be noted that given the standard clause allowing Abreu to opt for arbitration once eligible, he might end up being paid more than $68MM over the next six years.  In particular, given good production he'll prefer arbitration over the sixth year of the contract, and possibly even the fifth.  If he's good enough to justify that, it will be worth the extra money for Chicago.


This is rebuilding, White Sox style.  Like any team trying to improve its young talent base, they've recently taken a few steps back in the name of the greater good.  But unlike the Cubs or Mets, the White Sox aren't on a four or five-year plan.  Hahn has been acquiring Major League ready talent, and while the White Sox are a long shot for 2014, don't count them out for '15.

Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.

Leave a Reply

17 Comments on "Offseason In Review: Chicago White Sox"

1 year 5 months ago

Great article. I agree that the White Sox could be contenders in 2015.

1 year 5 months ago

The Sox front office has done a great job in turning around the outlook of this franchise in relatively a short period of time, in my opinion. They didn’t have much on the farm and a lineup that was bringing them nowhere and added 3 young players along with Garcia for relatively little given up.

Puig Power
1 year 5 months ago

I freely admit I was one of the doubters, but this process with the White Sox has been fascinating. I wish them the best and I’m curious to see how this year’s team plays.

1 year 5 months ago

They’re my 2014 sleeper pick.

1 year 5 months ago

Is it possible to get the right Adam Eaton in the link? It’s ALWAYS wrong.

1 year 5 months ago

Jose Hernandez and Oscar Taveras raise their hands.

Unassisted Triple Play
1 year 5 months ago

I give their offseason an A+! I did not see all this coming but they shifted into the right direction with every move they made. It will be interesting to see how all these young new pieces gel with one another.

1 year 5 months ago

Hmmm … I think the Abreu projections are pretty optimistic. If every team thought that he would deliver 30+ HR’s year in year out his contract would have been much, much higher. It’s just as likely that he hits 250 with 20 HR’s. At that level of production you would have a $7-10M/AAV player.

Basically this remains a smart signing. His floor isn’t much lower than his contract value. A reasonable projection of 3 WAR gives you a surplus of $5M or so annually. And if he really turns out to be amazing he will be an absolute bargain. This was a solid B+ signing.

The other area that strikes me as being overly pessimistic is the portrayal of Santiago. The guy has a couple of seasons under his belt at age 25. His career ERA is 3.41 and he strikes out nearly a batter an inning. There are legitimate concerns about his control and obviously FIP/xFIP hate him because of the walks, but having a cost controlled, league average starter is pretty valuable. And Santiago could turn out to be much better than league average.

I don’t have an issue with him getting moved. It made sense for the White Sox to trade him. I just don’t buy into the idea that he’s just another arm. You don’t sport an ERA+ of 126 while playing in Chicago’s park without having some game. If he can get his BB/9 down into the 3 range the guy could be a very solid major league arm. As a result, I’m not sure that they got the best value out of him.

1 year 5 months ago

You could be right on Santiago, but Eaton a good bet to be solid CF for the Sox. I liked Santiago too, liked his K rate, but he broke down some toward the end of the year; also, from the Sox perspective, he was a bullpen piece just a year ago, so it’s not like there was a huge investment in him (not that that should necessarily matter).

1 year 5 months ago

and they also had a surplus of left-handed starters.

1 year 5 months ago

Amen about Santiago. Santiago has a lot more upside than Danks and is young yet AND a lefty…The Sox better hope that Eaton produces and Santiago does not go win 15+ games with the Angels this year.

1 year 5 months ago

Even if he does win 15 games, which is unlikely because even the halos still don’t known if he will be their 5th starter, bullpen guy or go to the minors. Bt even if he does it would still have been a smart move for the sox. The sox got a true lead off center fielder who was the odds on favorite for rookie of the year last year before his injury. And is cost controlled longer than Santiago at a position of more need then a mid rotation starter. The article is right. The whitesox had a surplus of pitchers. Sale clearly isn’t going anywhere. And Q gets better and better, and us younger and a better over all pitcher, danks couldn’t have been moved at the time, maybe this season, Johnson is going to be a very good very solid pitcher, rienzo showed signs of brilliance. And they needed right handed balance. They NEEDED a young high upside high floor centerfield who is cost so trolled and they got him.

1 year 5 months ago

Having watched Santiago for most of the past 2 seasons, I can tell you he is barely a 4th or 5th starter on a decent team, he’s certainly not going to be a better than average AL starter. He’s probably best utilized as a spot starter/long relief man in the bullpen.

Hugh Hughes
1 year 5 months ago

Abreu’s projection is not overly optimistic. At the plate, Abreu blows Puig out of the water…book it. The signing price was relatively low because he is Cuban, plain and simple.

Vandals Took The Handles
1 year 5 months ago

Excellent, excellent breakdown!

Quantifying – and putting into perspective – Abrau’s contract in the ‘Deal Of Note’ section was something seldom seen in baseball journalism today. Of course Abrau has to perform. But the “25+ home runs per year, a .340 OBP, and average defense” is something that should be attainable if the man stays relatively healthy and plays home games in the Cell.

Am extremely impressed with what Rich Hahn has done in the 8 or so months since he realized that an accelerated rebuild had to happen, and convinced the owner of it. He based off of his starting pitching and asked his top-tier pitching coach to develop some back-end starters and the bullpen – again, reasonable expectations. Most importantly, he went after a young lead-off guy to set the table (Eaton), and 3 young middle of the order run producers – Abrau, Garcia and Davidson. Genuine lead-off guys that don’t just hit foul balls and walk but rather disrupt defenses, and middle of the order run producers are is demand in MLB. Very few are traded, and those that are free agents command astronomical salaries. Hahn did the right thing by getting young payers with those abilities, and using one of MLB’s best coaching staffs to assure they reach their potential.

1 year 5 months ago

Don’t forget the good amount of very good middle infielders the whitesox have come up soon, thus forcing a trade of Ramirez and beckham. Micha Johnson is going to be a beast. Marcus semien has shown he can compete at the mlb leve and Tim Anderson should make it to the show soon and never to back down. They have a bright future.

Hugh Hughes
1 year 5 months ago

The other good thing the Sox have going is massive payroll flexibility that is only increasing. They could easily add 40-50 million a year in FA signings next off-season.