Royals Sign Luke Jackson, Génesis Cabrera To Minor League Deals
The Royals announced that right-hander Luke Jackson and left-hander Génesis Cabrera have been signed to minor league deals. Jackson opted out of a deal with the Mets last week. Cabrera was with the Phillies on a minor league pact but he was released last week, per his transactions tracker at MLB.com. Presumably, both pitchers will report to Triple-A Omaha.
Jackson, 34, is really just getting his season going. He missed all of spring training, as he only signed with the Mets in the first week of April. He then made three scoreless Single-A appearances, followed by five Triple-A appearances. At that higher level, he allowed six earned runs in 4 2/3 innings before opting out.
The Royals are presumably banking more on his track record than those recent numbers. Jackson has a 4.22 earned run average in 409 1/3 career innings. Not too long ago, he was an important leverage arm in the big leagues. With Atlanta in 2021, he posted a 1.98 ERA and recorded 31 holds. He then made 11 postseason appearances to help Atlanta win that year’s World Series.
Unfortunately, Tommy John surgery wiped out his 2022 season. He was back on the mound in 2023, putting up a 2.97 ERA with the Giants. But then his ERA climbed to 5.09 in 2024. He corrected it somewhat in 2025, getting his ERA down to 4.06, but with less encouraging numbers under the hood. Though he induced grounders on 51.7% of balls in play, his 17.4% strikeout rate and 12.8% walk rate were both subpar numbers. In 2024, though his ERA was higher, he was able to punch out 25.1% of batters faced.
Cabrera, 29, just allowed 20 earned runs in 17 1/3 Triple-A innings after signing that aforementioned deal with the Phillies. That makes it fairly unsurprising that they let him go. The Royals will be hoping for a bounceback based on some potential he has shown in the past.
With upper-90s velocity from the left side, Cabrera has flashed some occasional swing-and-miss stuff along with command struggles. In 318 1/3 big league innings, he has walked 11.1% of batters faced. His career strikeout rate of 21.9% is close to average but has been erratic. He struck out 27.8% of batters he faced over the 2020 and 2021 seasons. That dropped to 16.5% in 2022, bounced back to 24.3% in 2023, but then was below 19% in the following two seasons.
For the Royals, there’s no harm in bringing in some fresh arms on minor league deals, especially guys with some major league experience. The Kansas City bullpen has not been a strength this year. The club’s relievers have a collective 4.51 ERA, putting them in the bottom third of the league in that category. Carlos Estévez, Matt Strahm and James McArthur are all on the injured list at the moment. With starters Cole Ragans and Kris Bubic also hitting the IL recently, long relievers like Bailey Falter or Luinder Avila might need to move to the rotation or at least bulk roles. If a fresh arm is needed at some point, Jackson and Cabrera could be candidates to get the call.
Photo courtesy of John Froschauer, Imagn Images
Royals Designate Elias Díaz For Assignment
The Royals announced that they have recalled outfielder Tyler Tolbert. To open a roster spot for him, catcher Elias Díaz has been designated for assignment. Kansas City’s 40-man count drops to 39.
Díaz, 35, signed a minor league deal with the Royals in the offseason. He had his contract selected to the big league roster just over a month ago. That gave the Royals a three-catcher setup, with Díaz backing up Carter Jensen and Salvador Perez. In that limited role, Díaz has done fairly well, hitting two home runs in 23 plate appearances.
Getting bumped off the roster is probably more about other players on the roster than it is about anything Díaz has done. At the time Díaz was called up, Perez was dealing with some hip soreness and was in need of some extra rest. That has seemingly helped, as Perez hit .200/.236/.350 over March and April but has a .231/.297/.400 line in May so far.
In the outfield, Lane Thomas is dealing with a sore hamstring, per Jaylon T. Thompson of The Kansas City Star. Thomas hasn’t hit the injured list but also hasn’t started a game since Tuesday. By bringing up Tolbert and cutting Díaz, the Royals have sacrificed their three-catcher arrangement in order to add some extra outfield depth.
Díaz now heads into DFA limbo, which can last as long as a week. The waiver process takes 48 hours, so the Royals could take five days to explore trade interest. As a 35-year-old backstop, he won’t have a ton of value, but they might get some calls. Atlanta just lost both Sean Murphy and Drake Baldwin to the injured list recently, so they could really use some extra catching depth. Cal Raleigh, Francisco Alvarez and Ryan Jeffers also hit the IL this month, leaving the Mariners, Mets and Twins without their starting catchers.
Thanks to his two homers, Díaz has a .227/.261/.591 line and 128 wRC+ this year, though in a tiny sample of 23 plate appearances. He has a .246/.300/.385 line and 78 wRC+ in his career. Defensively, he has received good grades for his throwing and blocking. He has mostly been graded as a poor framer but has been around average in recent years.
Photo courtesy of Jay Biggerstaff, Imagn Images
Mets Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment, Recall Jonah Tong
The Mets announced that they have recalled right-hander Jonah Tong from Triple-A Syracuse. In a corresponding move, fellow right-hander Craig Kimbrel has been designated for assignment.
Kimbrel, 38 next week, is one of the best closers of this generation but has been more of a fringe reliever in recent years. He had to settle for a minor league deal with the Mets coming into 2026, though one that would pay him $2.5MM if he had his contract selected. He was added to the roster a couple of weeks into the season. He has tossed 15 innings for the Mets since then but has allowed 10 earned runs for a flat earned run average of 6.00.
That probably overstates how poorly he has pitched this year. His 23.4% strikeout rate and 9.4% walk rate are both right around league average. His .325 batting average on balls in play and 56.2% strand rate are both to the unfortunate side, as is his 15.8% home run to fly ball ratio. Measures like his 4.90 FIP and 3.76 SIERA suggest he has deserved better in that relatively small sample.
Regardless of what he deserved, the results were enough for the Mets to move on. The club has seemingly been leaning into a youth movement of sorts lately. In the past month or so, they have let go of veteran guys like Tommy Pham, Andy Ibáñez and Austin Slater while calling up A.J. Ewing, Nick Morabito, Zach Thornton and now Tong.
Kimbrel will head into DFA limbo. The Mets could explore trade interest but it may be hard to line up a deal for a pitcher in his late 30s with an ERA of 6.00 who is making a few million, no matter the track record. It is perhaps more likely that he is placed on waivers and clears, leaving the Mets on the hook for the remainder of the money.
If that comes to pass, clubs would then become more interested. They would then be able to sign Kimbrel and would only owe him the prorated portion of the league minimum salary for any time spent on the roster. Though his ERA is high, as mentioned, some of the underlying numbers are a bit more encouraging. Between that and his career track record, perhaps some club would take a shot when the cost is so low.
As for Tong, it’s unclear what role he will play on the club. He has been starting in Triple-A this year but has a 5.68 ERA. The big league rotation just lost Clay Holmes to the injured list. A fractured fibula is going to keep him out for a few months. Tobias Myers is starting today. He has starting experience but hasn’t had an outing of longer than two innings in the past three weeks, so he surely won’t be going deep into the game. Sean Manaea is capable of working long relief but Tong could give the Mets another option in that department.
This may just be a spot start for Myers or he could perhaps earn a longer look in the rotation. Four spots are currently taken by Freddy Peralta, Nolan McLean, Christian Scott and David Peterson. Thornton came up and made his debut this week but allowed four earned runs in 4 1/3 innings. Peterson has an ERA north of 5.00 and may not be guaranteed anything going forward.
Photo courtesy of Rick Scuteri, Imagn Images
Trevor Story Undergoes Hernia Surgery
The Red Sox announced that shortstop Trevor Story has undergone surgery to address a sports hernia. He was placed on the 10-day injured list last week. The Sox didn’t announce a timeline in today’s announcement but reporting from last week indicated Story was considering a surgery that would sideline him for six to ten weeks.
Story got out to an awful start this year, hitting .206/.244/.303 through 41 games before hitting the IL. After landing on the shelf, he told reporters that he had been dealing with discomfort since spring training, which perhaps contributed to his poor results. Ideally, the surgery will correct the issue and he can get back on track in the second half of the season.
Injuries have played a huge role in his time with the Red Sox. He and the club signed a six-year, $140MM deal going into the 2022 season. He only played 163 games over the first three years of that deal, missing time due to various issues, most notably internal brace surgery on his throwing elbow.
He was able to stay healthy last year and had a mostly good season, getting into 157 games. His walk and strikeout rates weren’t strong and he got poor grades for his glovework but he hit 25 home runs and stole 31 bases. Unfortunately, he couldn’t keep it rolling into 2026. As mentioned, he got out to a poor start and is probably going to be out of action until the All-Star break, give or take.
For now, the Sox will have to cover shortstop without Story. In the past week, most of the playing time has gone to Andruw Monasterio. He is hitting .250/.294/.388 with poor defensive grades, though in a small sample of just 70 innings at short.
Second baseman Marcelo Mayer has said that he would like a shot at moving across the bag. He came up as a shortstop prospect but moved over to second in deference to Story. Manager Chad Tracy seemed open to the idea but only if Story was going to miss significant time. If Story were only going to miss a week or two, then the plan would have been to keep Mayer at second to continue getting accustomed to that position.
Now that Story is likely going to be out for a while, perhaps Mayer will get his shot at shortstop, but there are no guarantees that will be good for the club. Mayer’s second base defense has been slightly above average this year but he’s only hitting .221/.290/.313, a worse line than Monasterio. Perhaps Mayer is capable of more, since he was a notable prospect and hit .271/.347/.471 in Triple-A last year, but he hasn’t clicked in the majors yet.
If Mayer is going to cover short, the Sox would then have to have someone at second. That could be Monasterio but Nick Sogard and Isiah Kiner-Falefa would be other options. Sogard is currently taking a good amount of playing time from the struggling Caleb Durbin at third. Kiner-Falefa is only hitting .255/.314/.277 this year but has a strong defensive track record.
Photo courtesy of Rick Osentoski, Imagn Images
Pirates Promote Esmerlyn Valdez
May 22nd: The Bucs have made it official, announcing they have realled Valdez and optioned Cook.
May 21st: The Pirates are going to promote first base/outfield prospect Esmerlyn Valdez, reports Francys Romero of BeisbolFR. Fellow outfielder Billy Cook will be optioned as the corresponding active roster move, per DK Pittsburgh Sports. Valdez, who will be making his major league debut as soon as he gets into a game, is already on the 40-man roster.
Valdez was an international signing out of the Dominican Republic, securing a $130K bonus. He has since been climbing the minor league ladder with a pretty heavy three-true-outcomes approach. He can draw walks and hit the ball over the fence but can also be vulnerable to strikeouts, though he has shown improvement in terms of the punchouts.
Last year, Valdez split his time between High-A and Double-A, hitting 26 home runs in 529 plate appearances. He drew free passes in 10.6% of those trips to the plate. His 24.6% strikeout rate was a bit high but a notable decrease from the 30.6% rate he posted in Single-A the year prior. He finished 2025 with a combined .286/.376/.520 line and 155 wRC+. He got some help from a .344 batting average on balls in play but it was a strong showing regardless.
The Pirates added him to their 40-man roster in November to keep him out of the Rule 5 draft. Baseball America ranked him the #11 prospect in the system coming into this year, noting that he’s not a strong runner or defender. Here in 2026, he’s been in Triple-A and has been posting really strong results. In 194 plate appearances, he has a huge 17% walk rate and a 21.1% strikeout rate. He has already hit ten home runs. His .253/.381/.506 line leads to a 131 wRC+. BA recently bumped him to #5 in the system.
Pittsburgh opened the year with Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds in two outfield spots. With Spencer Horwitz at first base and Marcell Ozuna the designated hitter most days, Ryan O’Hearn was spending most of his time in an outfield corner. Jake Mangum and a few others also chipped in from time to time. O’Hearn hit the IL a few days ago due to a quad strain, which opened up some playing time. The Bucs already recalled Jhostynxon García and are now adding Valdez into the mix as well.
It’s unclear how the Bucs will divvy up the playing time now. Both García and Valdez are righties, so perhaps there will be some platoon situations at play. Cruz is a lefty and has notable platoon splits in his career but reverse splits in 2026. Reynolds and Mangum are switch hitters with fairly neutral career splits.
Horwitz is a lefty and is usually platooned, so perhaps Valdez will see most of his playing time at first base. The Bucs had been using O’Hearn at first base for a lot of the games starting by a left-handed opponent, with Mangum taking O’Hearn’s spot in the outfield in those instances. Perhaps García and Valdez will combine to pick up O’Hearn’s slack in that dual outfield/first base role. Infielder Jared Triolo, who hits right-handed, recently picked up a few outfield starts but that might be less necessary now.
Photo courtesy of Kim Klement Neitzel, Imagn Images
Red Sox Select Tayron Guerrero
May 22: Boston has officially announced the move. It will indeed be Crawford moving to the 60-day IL to clear a 40-man spot for Guerrero.
May 21: The Red Sox are going to select right-hander Tayron Guerrero to their roster, per reporting from Andrew Parker of SoxProspects.com. He’ll be back in the big leagues for the first time since 2019. Righty Zack Kelly has been optioned as a corresponding active roster move, per Chris Cotillo of MassLive. The Sox will need to make a corresponding move to open a 40-man roster spot. That will likely involve moving someone to the 60-day injured list, with Kutter Crawford being a logical candidate.
It’s an incredible comeback story for the 35-year-old. Guerrero was in the big leagues from 2016 to 2019, pitching for the Padres and Marlins. He logged 106 innings with a 5.77 earned run average. He lost his roster spot ahead of the 2020 season. Since then, he has alternated between minor league deals and time spent in Japan, without a ton of success. He was with the Chiba Lotte Marines in 2022 and 2025. The first stint overseas was okay, with Guerrero posting a 3.52 ERA, but he had a 6.41 ERA last year. In his minor league work from 2021 to 2024, he posted a 7.62 ERA.
He signed a minor league deal with the Sox this offseason and has been shoving in Triple-A. He has thrown 19 2/3 innings for the WooSox, allowing just two earned runs for a 0.92 ERA. His 8% walk rate is right around average, while his 29.3% strikeout rate is quite strong and his 69.6% ground ball rate is massive. His fastball is still averaging in the upper 90s, with his slider and changeup coming in around 90ish.
The Sox will take a chance on Guerrero to see if he can translate any of that to the big leagues. Given his age and his recent track record, it’s an unusual move, but there’s obvious appeal in his numbers so far this year. If the gambit doesn’t pan out, Guerrero is out of options.
Photo courtesy of Kim Klement Neitzel, Imagn Images
Orioles Outright Jose Espada
The Orioles announced that right-hander Jose Espada has cleared outright waivers and been assigned to Triple-A Norfolk. He had been designated for assignment earlier this week when the O’s claimed outfielder Michael Siani. This is Espada’s first career outright and he has less than three years of service time, so he doesn’t have the right to elect free agency. He’ll provide the Orioles with some non-roster depth for the time being.
Espada, 29, signed a minor league deal with the O’s in July of 2025. He was added to the 40-man in August and then optioned to the minors, suggesting he probably had some kind of opt-out in that deal. He was called up in September and made one appearance before getting optioned back to Norfolk. He’s had a similar experience so far this year, spending most of it in the minors. He was recalled three times but only made one appearance.
He also made one appearance with the Padres in 2023, so he has three big league appearances on his ledger. He has thrown five scoreless innings in total. A career earned run average of 0.00 is nice but it’s obviously a very small sample. His larger body of work at Triple-A is less impressive. In 65 innings at that level, he has a 4.57 ERA. He has a strong 27.5% strikeout rate in that sample but a worrisome 15.5% walk rate. He mostly throws a mid-90s fastball and mid-80s slider, with a 90ish splitter being his third pitch in terms of usage.
After the 2023 season, the Padres non-tendered Espada, sending him to free agency without needing to put him on waivers. He spent 2024 in Japan, throwing 27 innings for the Yakult Swallows with an ERA of 5.00. He re-signed with the Friars on a minor league deal ahead of 2025 but eventually was released from that pact and signed with the Orioles. Since this is his first time clearing waivers and his service time count is under three years, he has to accept the outright assignment. He will try to improve his control and earn his way back to the majors.
Photo courtesy of Jamie Sabau, Imagn Images
Paul DeJong To Undergo Hamstring Surgery
6:51pm: Jon Heyman of The New York Post reports that DeJong suffered a hamstring injury that’ll require season-ending surgery.
5:45pm: It appears that Paul DeJong, who recently signed a minor league deal with the Tigers, is done for the year. The Triple-A Toledo Mud Hens have placed him on the full-season injured list, according to his transactions tracker at MLB.com.
An injury isn’t listed but it’s likely something related to his lower body. DeJong last appeared in a game on May 12th. In that game, he was visibly limping around the bases to score a run, as seen in this clip from Tigers ML Report.
It will unfortunately be a second straight injury-marred season for DeJong. Last year, he missed over two months after a fastball hit him in the face and caused several fractures. He was limited to just 57 games with the Nationals and didn’t perform especially well when he was on the field.
He had to settle for a minor league deal with the Yankees coming into 2026. He hit well for their Triple-A club for a while. He was held back by a .167 batting average on balls in play but hit six home runs in 83 plate appearances, leading to a lopsided .203/.361/.516 line and 123 wRC+.
He opted out of that deal and was able to secure a fresh minor league deal with the Tigers, which was a pretty decent landing spot considering they had some injured infielders. But in just his sixth game with the Mud Hens, he was bitten by the injury bug himself and will apparently miss the remainder of the campaign.
Assuming he can get healthy for the 2027 season, he should be able to secure another minor league deal somewhere. DeJong strikes out a ton but hits home runs and is a solid shortstop defender, with the ability to play other positions as well. Dating back to the start of 2022, he has been punched out in 32.1% of his 1,327 plate appearances but has hit 50 homers in that time.
For the Tigers, as mentioned, they have been dealing with a number of infield injuries. Gleyber Torres, Trey Sweeney and Javier Báez are all on the IL at the moment. Due to those injuries and others, the club went out and added DeJong for extra depth. With DeJong no longer available, that could prompt them to find a way to bring in someone else.
Photo courtesy of Brad Mills, Imagn Images
Marlins Acquire Rece Hinds
The Marlins and Reds announced that they have made a trade sending outfielder Rece Hinds from Cincinnati to Miami. The Marlins optioned him to Triple-A Jacksonville and transferred left-hander Robby Snelling to the 60-day injured list to open a 40-man spot. The Reds, who designated Hinds for assignment a few days ago, receive minor league right-hander Zach McCambley in return. The Marlins also recalled infielder Graham Pauley and placed infielder Leo Jiménez on the seven-day injured list with concussion symptoms.
Hinds, 25, has shown the potential to be a masher but hasn’t yet done that in a major league setting. In 131 big league plate appearances, he has a .172/.221/.426 line. But he hit five home runs in spring training this year, leading to a ridiculous .410/.465/.949 line. In Triple-A, dating back to the start of 2025, he has 31 home runs in 540 plate appearances a .303/.371/.576 line.
There is clearly some power there but the concern is when he doesn’t connect. Hinds has generally struck out in about a third of his plate appearances throughout his minor league career. In his brief big league action, he has a massive 42% strikeout rate.
There is a small hint of optimism in that department. At Triple-A, again dating back to the start of 2025, his strikeout rate is just 26.3%. That’s still above average but not as bad as his earlier minor league numbers, as he had a 35% strikeout rate from 2021 to 2024. He’s got some wheels and a good arm for right field, so he could be a real asset if he can get the strikeouts under control.
Hinds is in his final option year. The Marlins can keep him at Jacksonville for now and get a close-up look at his offensive approach. If there’s an injury in the big league outfield or he shows notable improvement, he could be called up.
The Reds moved on from Hinds but are able to turn him into some extra pitching depth. McCambley, 27, is a reliever who has shown some promise in the minors. The Phillies grabbed him in the Rule 5 draft in November but returned him to the Marlins at the end of spring training.
McCambley has a mid-90s four-seamer but that’s only his third pitch in terms of usage. He primarily throws his high-80s cutter and mid-80s slider, throwing each of those pitches about a third of the time. Four-seamers, sinkers, curveballs and changeups make up the other third.
Between last year and this year, he has thrown 67 1/3 Triple-A innings thus far, allowing 2.94 earned runs per nine. His 11.6% walk rate in that time is too high but he has punched out 30.3% of batters faced and induced a good amount of grounders as well. He is not on the 40-man roster but the Reds could call him up at some point down the line if they need a fresh arm or want to shake up their bullpen mix.
Snelling was diagnosed with a sprain of his ulnar collateral ligament last week. It’s not yet clear if he will undergo surgery but it’s not a surprise to see him transferred to the 60-day IL. Even the non-surgical paths back from a UCL sprain require lengthy recovery periods. He will technically be eligible for reinstatement in July but time will tell what a realistic timeline is for his return.
As for Jiménez, he exited yesterday’s game with an apparent injury. As Ronald Acuña Jr. was sliding into third base, Jiménez tried to tag him and the two collided, as seen in this clip from MLB.com. As Jiménez recovers, Pauley will get another shot in the big leagues. Pauley is a strong defender at third base but his offense is more questionable. He hit .173/.225/.293 for the Fish earlier this year before getting optioned to Jacksonville. He hit three homers in nine games for the Jumbo Shrimp and will now try to produce more offense in the big leagues.
Pauley has one option year remaining. A player burns an option year once they spend 20 days on optional assignment. It was two weeks ago that Pauley was sent down, so he still has a chance to carry that option into 2027 if he stays up from here on out.
The Hinds/McCambley trade and Pauley’s recall were first reflected in the transactions tracker at MLB.com. Barry Jackson of The Miami Herald first reported that Jiménez would go on the IL. The Snelling move came from the official team announcement.
How Should The Astros Handle Their Infield This Summer?
In the offseason, there was a lot of talk about the Astros having a crowded infield. On paper, they had Christian Walker at first base, Jose Altuve at second, Jeremy Peña at short and Carlos Correa at third. With Yordan Alvarez set to be in the designated hitter spot most days, that didn’t leave a clear opening for Isaac Paredes, who would have to bounce around and cover other spots whenever someone was taking an occasional off-day.
The season quickly demonstrated that so-called surpluses can dry up quickly. A hamstring strain sent Peña to the injured list in mid-April, which allowed Correa to become the shortstop and Paredes the regular third baseman. Peña was nearing a rehab assignment a few weeks later when Correa suffered an ankle injury that required a season-ending surgery. The club used glove-first journeymen Nick Allen and Braden Shewmake to cover short until Peña got back. Once Peña was ready to be activated, Altuve hit the IL.
All of these players are still under club control for the 2027 season. The Astros could hang onto all of them. It would mean starting another season with a mildly clunky roster fit, but something would likely come along to again break up the logjam.
Regardless, the Astros might look at this summer as an opportunity to free things up a bit. Due to a mounting pile of injuries, they’re out to an awful 20-31 start. Only the Rockies and Angels have a worse record. Due to almost the entire American League underperforming so far, Houston is technically only five games back of a playoff spot, but climbing back in the race is going to be a challenge when so many of their key performers are injured or struggling.
With the league so wide open, some wacky things could happen in the coming months, but it seems like there’s a decent chance the Astros will be in seller position this summer. That would be an unfamiliar position for them, as they’ve been consistently competitive for over a decade now. They narrowly finished outside the playoff picture last year, their first miss since 2016. They haven’t finished below .500 since 2014.
Trading an infielder would mean going into 2027 with less depth than they have this year, but they may want to think about it anyway. In the past few offseasons, they have been working with limited payroll flexibility, due to owner Jim Crane’s desire to avoid the competitive balance tax. In the most recent offseason, they needed pitching and had to get creative, taking gambles on unproven arms like Tatsuya Imai, Ryan Weiss and Mike Burrows. For the most part, those bets haven’t paid off and contributed to the Astros’ current predicament. The outfield has also been a bit of an issue since they traded Kyle Tucker — another move that was motivated by financial concerns.
Moving someone from the dirt could perhaps be a way to address those parts of the roster, or at least free up some payroll space so that there’s more maneuverability this coming winter. Due to their recent string of winning, and penalties related to the sign-stealing scandal, their farm system is also considered one of the worst in the league. If they are suddenly sellers, it could be a chance to do some restocking. There are different ways they could approach things, with pros and cons to each.
Altuve and Correa aren’t worth considering. They are older veterans with big contracts, both currently on the IL. Even if they had trade value, they both have the ability to veto trades. Making Peña available is one route they could go. The 2027 season will be his final arbitration year before he hits free agency. The odds of him signing an extension are low.
For one thing, Peña is represented by the Boras Corporation. It’s not true that Boras never lets his clients sign extensions. For instance, Altuve is a Boras client who has signed multiple extensions with the Astros. But Houston has never topped $160MM on a contract, for Altuve or anyone else. Peña could be trending towards beating that, as many strong shortstops have done in recent years. Marcus Semien, Dansby Swanson, Willy Adames, Correa, Xander Bogaerts, Trea Turner and Corey Seager have all signed deals in recent years worth more than anything the Astros have ever given out.
It puts Peña in a somewhat analogous position to where Tucker was a few years back. Tucker was a homegrown star but was nearing free agency and wasn’t going to be signed, so the Astros flipped him while they still had a year of control left. Peña’s window of control will be barely over a year when this summer’s deadline rolls around. Trading Tucker allowed the Astros to get Paredes, Cam Smith and Hayden Wesneski from the Cubs. Peña could fetch a similar haul or perhaps even a better one. His offense hasn’t been as consistently strong as Tucker’s but his speed and shortstop defense make up a good chunk of the difference.
The downside is that Peña is going to be harder to replace, since he is a shortstop and Tucker is a corner outfielder. Technically, the Astros could trade Peña and move Correa over to short but that’s probably not wise. Correa has become increasingly injury-prone in recent years and will be coming off his aforementioned ankle surgery.
There also aren’t amazing options for trading Peña and then finding an external replacement. The best shortstop free agents of the 2026-27 class would be J.P. Crawford or Ha-Seong Kim. Crawford is a decent enough player but he is going into his age-32 season and his defense isn’t especially well regarded. He and the Mariners are already considering a move to third base. Kim has a better defensive reputation but hasn’t been healthy for most of the past two years. Old friend Mauricio Dubón will be out there but he’s never really been relied upon as an everyday shortstop for an extended stretch of time.
Trading Peña also wouldn’t represent massive cost savings. He is making $9.475MM this year and will be due a raise in arbitration, though it remains to be seen how much he can push his salary up. Around his injuries this year, he has a .259/.305/.333 line and 81 wRC+. He has lots of time to get healthy and get in a groove but it’s not yet a lock that he’s set for a huge raise.
Perhaps Peña being available is too much of a reach, but Walker and Paredes were both in plenty of rumors over the winter. It seems fair to expect that the Astros would be more willing to listen on these two.
Walker had a rough year in 2025 but is bouncing back with a big 2026. He has a .255/.330/.489 slash line and 128 wRC+. That’s much better than his 2025 line of .238/.297/.421 and roughly in line with his 2022-24 production in Arizona, when he hit .250/.332/.481 for a 121 wRC+.
The Astros may feel comfortable moving on from Walker and having Paredes on hand to take over at first base. Since Walker is making $20MM annually through 2027, they might also welcome the opportunity to move that deal and open up some payroll space. But that contract is also why Walker isn’t likely to have huge trade value, despite his comeback performance. Though some teams may be interested in adding his bat for the stretch run, a 36-year-old first baseman with a $20MM salary in 2027 isn’t going to be terribly attractive.
Players that age generally don’t get paid at that level. The most recent comp for a guy that age getting paid like that is the three-year, $58.5MM deal the Astros themselves gave to José Abreu. Houston fans know all too well how that one played out. Perhaps Walker can have a better age-36 season than Abreu did, but teams won’t be eager about paying to make that bet. Houston would probably have to eat some money to bring back any kind of notable return.
Paredes is in a more attractive position contractually. He is making $9.35MM in his penultimate arbitration season. His deal has a $13.35MM club option for 2027. Even if that is not picked up, he will be eligible for arbitration and could be retained at a price point roughly in that range.
He will therefore be cheaper than Walker and is also far younger, as he’ll be 28 next year. Unfortunately, he is having a bit of a down year so far. His 8.6% walk rate is down about three ticks relative to last year. His .244/.333/.378 line is above average, leading to a 105 wRC+, but it’s a big drop from last year’s .254/.352/.458 line and 128 wRC+. There’s a bit of surplus value here but not a ton. Considering that his pull swing fits perfectly with the Crawford Boxes in Daikin Park, he may be more valuable to Houston than to other clubs.
Holding all three of Peña, Walker and Paredes is also a possibility. As mentioned, that would maintain depth for 2027, as injuries will surely pop up next year. The downside to this path is that it won’t give the club much of a chance to capitalize on being sellers. Their impending free agents won’t fetch huge hauls. Lance McCullers Jr. and Weiss aren’t going to have much appeal to other clubs as things stand. Relievers Bryan Abreu, Steven Okert and Enyel De Los Santos can probably be dealt but aren’t performing up to their previous levels. Christian Vázquez is having a good season and may be moveable, but he won’t fetch much as a 35-year-old backup catcher.
In short, the Astros don’t have much to sell if they limit themselves to impending free agents. In that scenario, they wouldn’t do much to bolster the farm and wouldn’t free up any meaningful payroll space. They would go into the offseason with a similar roster, which is talented but with holes.
Trading an infielder would reduce the depth but could help in other areas. Peña would bring back a lot, either in terms of prospect capital or major-league-ready talent, but he would blow a big hole at shortstop. Moving one of Walker or Paredes wouldn’t leave such an obvious gap but neither has nearly as much trade value as Peña.
It’s an interesting fork in the road for the franchise and it’s unclear who will be picking which route to take. General manager Dana Brown is in the final year of his contract. Owner Jim Crane hasn’t been shy about making bold decisions about his front office, only offering then-GM James Click a one-year deal after the club’s World Series win in 2022 and subsequently letting him walk. Crane was uncertain enough about Brown to let him go into 2026 as a lame duck. Will he let him be in charge of a deadline sell-off? Would Brown even want to take part in a big sell-off when his job is potentially on the line?
If not Brown, who would be making the decisions? Crane briefly ran the front office between Click’s departure and Brown’s hiring, so he could do it himself. However, that didn’t go especially well. In that brief window, the Astros signed the aforementioned Abreu deal and also inked Rafael Montero to a three-year pact. Both of those deals quickly turned into big duds, so perhaps Crane realizes he shouldn’t be the one making these calls. Is there some assistant GM he would be willing to elevate this summer? Is there any possibility of finding an external front office leader midseason?
There are many lingering questions surrounding the the team, the players and the front office. How those questions are answered in the coming months will shape the club’s future, making them one of the most interesting clubs to monitor this summer.
Photo courtesy of Katie Stratman, Imagn Images