The Phillies have been connected to a number of impact position players this summer. Reportedly, the club has already expressed interest in Guardians All-Star Steven Kwan and has interest in Diamondbacks third baseman Eugenio Suarez as well. Now, Ari Alexander of KPRC2 reports another star player the Phillies have interest in: Luis Robert Jr. of the White Sox. That apparent interest in bolstering the lineup doesn’t necessarily mean Philadephia is focused on that sort of addition, however. Even with rumors connecting Philadelphia to a number of significant hitters, Matt Gelb of The Athletic writes the the club’s priority remains adding a “high-end” relief arm even after they signed David Robertson last week.
Robert, an All-Star back in 2023 who has struggled in each of the past two seasons with injury and ineffectiveness, has hit .206/.293/.343 (76 wRC+) this season. He’s hit incredibly well (.325/.426/.500 with a 159 wRC+) since coming off the injured list, however, and that performance has been enough to convince the White Sox to take a hard stance on their asking price for his services. Robert certainly won’t keep that torrid pace up, but at his best he was a 129 wRC+ hitter, with a .287/.331/.511 slash line in 311 games between 2021 and ’23. While Robert would be a massively valuable addition to the Phillies if he were able to bounce back to that form, it would be a substantial gamble for a club that is looking to patch a hole in the lineup caused by unproductive seasons by talented outfielders like Max Kepler and Johan Rojas to bring in yet another talented outfielder in the middle of an unproductive season, particularly given the White Sox’s asking price.
Perhaps those concerns are (at least in part) why the Phillies remain focused on acquiring bullpen help even after signing Robertson, a veteran of 16 MLB seasons who has pitched to a 2.82 ERA with 40 saves over the last three years. Robertson is a talented reliever, but even the most talented players can face a steep cliff at age-40. Between Robertson’s age and the fact that he missed the first half of the season, the club has no guarantee he’ll offer the sort of shutdown production in high-leverage situations that he’s been able to provide in the past. Fortunately for the Phillies, there are a large number of extremely talented high-leverage arms being dangled this summer. Ryan Helsley of the Cardinals, Mason Miller of the A’s, Jhoan Duran and Griffin Jax of the Twins, Emmanuel Clase and Cade Smith of the Guardians, and David Bednar of the Pirates are just some of the elite relief arms who have seen their names floated in the rumor mill in recent days.
While many of those controllable arms likely won’t end up moving when all is said and done, the number of teams at least willing to listen on players of that caliber affords Philadelphia (and other buyers) plenty of flexibility as they figure out how best to improve their roster this summer. The Phillies have plenty of reason to be aggressive with key pieces like Kyle Schwarber, Ranger Suarez, and J.T. Realmuto set to hit free agency, to say nothing of ace Zack Wheeler’s impending retirement after the 2027 season. Perhaps that motivation will convince the club to pay a high price for the help of a controllable relief ace, although it’s also possible that the club could benefit from spreading its prospect capital across multiple deals in order to maximize the 2025 roster as much as possible.
The pursuit of high-end bats also offers a backup plan in case the Phillies are unable to secure any of the top closing options. With Robertson already in the fold as an experienced closer, perhaps the Phillies could pivot to second-tier options like Atlanta closer Raisel Iglesias or Twins southpaw Danny Coulombe and trust the tandem of that addition and Robertson to handle high leverage duties in the bullpen. The theoretical prospect capital saved by acquiring one of those arms relative to the top options could then be used in a trade for a significant bat like Suarez or Robert, offering a solid Plan B that could have just as much impact as acquiring one of the market’s top relievers in the event that asking prices remain prohibitively high on those players.